catharsis covers various levels of emotional relief or release, and from the reports of various altered states including auditing 'high' being experienced, it seems to me that it or something like it is relatively common during auditing. but as you point to, it is a complex subject.
Preamble: It's a fine point, but, these days, with the spirit of totalitarianism sweeping society, and greater "top down control" by the government-corporate complex (the name for which is "fascism") being asserted, and the possibility of a "social credit system" and electronic monitoring of speech, commerce, movement and, conceivably, even thoughts, no longer being far fetched ideas from a dystopian paperback novel, I have to express my support for (unauthorized) "altered states." That may sound silly, but there's a nuance. I recognize the danger of "altered states" inside a (destructive) cult milieu, such as Scientology, but reject those who seek to assert control over our minds - often with the pretext of "protecting" us, and "safety," etc. - and I reject that control just as I reject something like Scientology.
The difference is that Scientology is small, and society and the government, etc. is large and encompassing.
I mention this because there seem to be some who oppose the totalitarian system of Scientology who seem entirely too comfortable with the trend toward totalitarianism in society. But, of course, I could be mistaken in that perception, and I hope I am.
Anyway, that's the end of the preamble.
i think the "
Long strings of psychotics" thread points to some of the various evidence that scientology has had an unusually high incidence of psychosis, even if it's not exactly common.
Footnote on Hubbard's use of the term "psychotics." He sometimes used it to describe people who were not really psychotic. A person might disagree with Hubbard and Hubbard would call him "psychotic," etc. So, while no doubt there were some actual "psychotics," Hubbard sometimes classified people who didn't like him as "psychotic." He also classified those who didn't like Dianetics as "low" on his "Tone Scale," and thus not sane.
And ex wife Sara was described as having been PDHed, etc.
Anyway, during that period - early to mid 1950s - Hubbard was trying out - testing - many ideas that he would implement, with gusto, beginning during the early 1960s.
So it became even worse.
and look at the violent incidents scientology engenders. it seems that about every other year there's a major incident or a death at an org. and yet the entirety of scientology worldwide is only about as large as a medium sized megachurch; what megachurch has regular violence and killings every couple of years? it's not always members themselves but sometimes family; regardless, it's part of some dynamic that happens often enough it's not just coincidence among a small group.
There are many things in Scientology that can lead to delusion, confusion, paranoia, obsession, depression, guilt, shame, suicidal tendencies, suicide, violence, and even murder.
1952
Mary Sue Hubbard reading about her last sixty trillion years
Scientology messes with people's minds. After all, "mental healing" was the entry point for both Dianetics and Scientology, and both emphasized that the person's SURVIVAL depended on how well the person progressed in its system of "mental healing."
(Cutting and pasting of other old posts begins here. Hope it's not too sloppy.)
"Advanced Courses are the most valuable services on the planet. Life insurance, houses, cars, stocks, bonds, college savings all are transitory and impermanent... There is nothing to compare with Advanced Courses. They are infinitely valuable and transcend time itself."
L, Ron Hubbard, during the late 1960s, writing of his confidential "upper levels," from Mission Order 375,
from Scientology's Hard Sell pack for training Scientology sales people or registrars.
Scientology was becoming increasingly more secretive before the "Advanced Courses" appeared.
Secrecy, deception, "implanting," authoritarianism, "brainwashing," being punitive, were mentioned, by Hubbard, to unsuspecting Scientologists, as things done by the bad guys - as "enemy tactics" - and then Hubbard would turn around and use those same ideas and actions on his own defenseless followers, who knew - with "total certainty" - that "Mankind's Greatest Friend" would never do such a thing.
This pattern was commented upon as early as October 1950, in the book,
A Doctor's Report on Dianetics, by Joseph Winter, who had written the introduction for
Dianetics, the Modern Science of Mental Health. Winter had noticed that Hubbard liked to lecture about the evils of authoritarianism while being authoritarian himself:
"There was a difference in the ideals inherent in the Dianetic hypothesis and the actions of the Foundation in its ostensible efforts to carry out those ideals... as I saw them, included non-authoritarianism and flexibility of approach... These ideals... continued to be given lip-service, but I could see a definite disparity between ideals and actualities..."
Scientologists might say this was simply the result of working in an imperfect environment, where "We build a world with broken straws," etc., but, in 1954, Volney Mathison - whose electro-pyschometer, based on the much earlier Wheatstone bridge of the 1800s, and popularized, to some extent, by Carl Jung in the early 1900s - made this observation, referring to Hubbard:
_________________________________Begin quote________________________________
...
a certain type of sick patient is referred to as being vampire-like in behavior. But such a patient is not really aware of why he acts as he does, a far more despicable vampire-like personality is that of a vicious type of fraudulent cult therapist who operates in the two following phases:
First, he denounces or "exposes"... Then he USES THE VERY POWER HE HAS DENOUNCED [sic]... but the techniques he employs are of a covert type...
The victim is caught completely off guard. He has just heard all about the evils... so he believes that here is this kind and honest person whom one can TRUST...
_________________________________End quote________________________________
A virtual compendium of ideas and methods used by Hubbard on others, including his own followers, can be compiled by listing the things he denounced, or about which he warned.
The cover of Hubbard's hoax "Russian" manual of 1955 - which depicted Dianetics and, in a 1968 printing, "the Church of Scientology," as under attack by Russian communists - aptly describes the Scientology operation, in its definition of psychopolitics.
The original manual
Remarkably, this booklet was spotted as the "blueprint" for the Scientology movement as early as 1965
The pattern of Hubbard warning people about the bad guys doing something, and then turning around and doing the same thing, was repeated over and over.
In the above manual, Hubbard was warning about "brainwashing."
Scientology presents itself as the antithesis of "brainwashing," while advising people to think for themselves.
Scientologists would soon be reading the super-hyped secret materials where Hubbard would tell them what's wrong with them.
And applauding his giant photograph in gratitude.
At the "upper levels" Hubbard authoritatively TELLS Scientologists the contents of their own minds and spaces.
And if they don't agree, or are not delighted with the results, that means there's something very wrong with them.
*
Also, at its core, Scientology is a violent subject.
Link to
Lightness of organization thread.
Link to
Scientology: The Higher OT Levels Begin After You Commit Suicide thread.
Link to
LRH Dead. Scientologists react thread.
Link to
Scientology & Jim Jonesthread.
and you're right that Flag in particular started really vetting people carefully. as i understand it, they'll 69 anyone with any sort of 'bad indicators'. they no longer serve the same clientele they once did, and that's indeed a way of restricting delivery. plus it also seems to me that GAT really reduced and watered down the auditing delivered at local orgs (much less at missions, and by virtually extinct field auditors), which had a similar sort of effect, and accelerated the long trend toward shifting auditing to upper level orgs -- where it can be more carefully controlled, limited, and restricted including by its just becoming harder and more expensive to access.
if you turn away anyone with any hint of possibile instability you're just catering to the 'worried well' for exhorbitant amounts of money -- exactly what Hubbard accused Freudian analysts of the era of doing, and not without justification,
p.s. thanks for the couple of responses.
Link to
Scientology exploits catharsis thread.
IMO, it's unlikely that this person - below - was a casualty of catharsis, except, possibly, that he was provided with some relief, early on, by catharsis of some degree or type, which encouraged him to pursue Scientology further.
It's more likely that he found himself in the unpleasant position of being INSIDE Scientology and being regarded as a "Suppressive Person" or a "Degraded Being." The guilt and shame and sense of worthlessness would be agonizing.
He possibly thought he was going to "end cycle" (as Scientology call it), "drop his body," and then start over.
That image is gonna haunt me for a bit. The frontman for Scn's whole "Felicidad" commits suicide.
It is just profoundly sad and disturbing. My sincere condolences to all his family members and friends, if any of you might be reading this.
....
Hubbard, when interest in Scientology - and income - started to wane, in the mid 1970s, announced that there were 15 additional unreleased OT levels. However, OT 8, as "total cause" (See link below), continued to be sold. (This continued until after NOTs - "cause of Life"- was announced and released in 1978.)
....
There was speculation, at the time, that these were OT abilities used in other universes beyond the MEST universe.
Subsequently, over the years, there were other statements.
Despite these modifications. the super human state of "OT" continue to be sold.
In truth there were no more OT levels, and Hubbard knew it, and lied.
Link to the 1970 Grade Chart. This is the chart that was prominently displayed on walls and in magazines throughout Scientology's period of greatest expansion, and the beginning of "big league" money-getting.
To paraphrase Hubbard from the OEC volumes: "We can demand total discipline because we can deliver total freedom."
People were recruited into Scientology, and the Sea Org, and some even sent their children to be servants for L. Ron Hubbard, because they believed what this Grade Chart, and what Hubbard, over many years, told them.
The top level, under ability gained, was:
"Ability to be at cause knowingly and at will over thought, life, form, matter, energy, space, and time, subjective and objective."
Under ability lost was:
"Freedom from inability to be totally free and at total cause as a being."
This was not presented as a hypothetical. It was sold as fact. This was when Scientology established itself.
.....
What was Frank Suarez told by Scientology Inc. that, ultimately, drove him to suicide?
Did Scientology Inc. tell him: "Well, Scientology worked on us, and we're OT. If you're not, it wasn't the tech that failed. You failed."
Did Frank Suarez throw himself off the balcony to his death believing he was a Degraded Being, or even a Suppressive Person?
Will we ever know?