How Ideal Orgs Are Causing Current Scientologists To Leave Scientology

Thinking about this overnight, there is a factor that affected Atlanta, and maybe other ideal orgs:

The ordeal of fundraising can wreck an org.

Atlanta fundraising for the ideal org started around 2002 - 2003. The pressure brought to bear on public was huge. This went on for almost thirteen years.

S.O. missions, almost permanently placed for years, events every weekend for years. All the while, the org was housed in crazy mixed up quarters, and it was always about donations but that idea was on steroids. People were recovered and regged. Then some people went away and never came back. Not Good for those that want a new building and a shit ton of public. The delivery of services was a fourth placed idea behind:

Raising money for the building
Recruiting for the local org
Recruiting for S.O.
Servicing the public

Then the ideal org opens. Momentary crowds. Then shortly after, crickets. Atlanta has a CF that has been majorly worked over. Not a CF like LA or CW. Then Atlanta public moving elsewhere for services. The freshly recruited public are gone. CF is decimated. Popular public opinion has never been so negative for scn.

Ingredients for disaster for scn.

Service did not have priority, unless the service could help reg for ideal org income.

EDIT: At the time, it really chapped me to watch the tech quality degrade with a lack of interest from management. This bothered me. I cared.

You forgot regging for the IAS - probably #2 in your list
 
Thinking about this overnight, there is a factor that affected Atlanta, and maybe other ideal orgs:

The ordeal of fundraising can wreck an org.

Atlanta fundraising for the ideal org started around 2002 - 2003. The pressure brought to bear on public was huge. This went on for almost thirteen years.

S.O. missions, almost permanently placed for years, events every weekend for years. All the while, the org was housed in crazy mixed up quarters, and it was always about donations but that idea was on steroids. People were recovered and regged. Then some people went away and never came back. Not Good for those that want a new building and a shit ton of public. The delivery of services was a fourth placed idea behind:

Raising money for the building
Recruiting for the local org
Recruiting for S.O.
Servicing the public

Then the ideal org opens. Momentary crowds. Then shortly after, crickets. Atlanta has a CF that has been majorly worked over. Not a CF like LA or CW. Then Atlanta public moving elsewhere for services. The freshly recruited public are gone. CF is decimated. Popular public opinion has never been so negative for scn.

Ingredients for disaster for scn.

Service did not have priority, unless the service could help reg for ideal org income.

EDIT: At the time, it really chapped me to watch the tech quality degrade with a lack of interest from management. This bothered me. I cared.
Increasingly, it looks like DM recognizes that the game is almost over. He's totally focused on the quick bucks, and uninterested in anything resembling delivering service.

Don't be surprised if he grabs the money and runs in the next few years.
 
Increasingly, it looks like DM recognizes that the game is almost over. He's totally focused on the quick bucks, and uninterested in anything resembling delivering service.

Don't be surprised if he grabs the money and runs in the next few years.

He's living a nice cushy life doing what he loves - dominating and degrading others. Why would he run?
 
I saw first hand the effort it took to man an ideal org in Atl. There was a LOT of work done in order to have the appearance of having a shit ton of staff at grand opening appear in the pictures. They were mostly gone within two years. Some went off to other grand openings.

Absolutely. I know several scientologists who when I first met them were staff at one org. Then I hear x org is opening and they're on staff there now. And repeat this a couple times. When a new org is opening they will try to man it however they can. This includes ripping staff from other orgs. I am really interested to see what happens with Chicago and Austin. Some orgs might have enough of a field to get it at least mostly manned locally (like the California orgs). I don't know how big Chicago's field is but Austin's is way too small to man it locally. Will they be sea org orgs? I'm curious to find out. Might also be a reason why their opening gets delayed a ton, they don't have the staff to open it and don't want to man it with sea org personnel.

The financial industry is big on "data mining", finding patterns in transactions that can yield predictive information about people.

I would think that heavy spending on Scientology, followed by missed payments, would be very noticeable.

I think that's what happened. The big banks started to notice a correlation between large scientology donos and then missing payments. So then they went to scientology and said hey fix this or else. Or they just cut scientology off and scientology went to them and said how do we fix this.

Thinking about this overnight, there is a factor that affected Atlanta, and maybe other ideal orgs:

The ordeal of fundraising can wreck an org.

Atlanta fundraising for the ideal org started around 2002 - 2003. The pressure brought to bear on public was huge. This went on for almost thirteen years.

S.O. missions, almost permanently placed for years, events every weekend for years. All the while, the org was housed in crazy mixed up quarters, and it was always about donations but that idea was on steroids. People were recovered and regged. Then some people went away and never came back. Not Good for those that want a new building and a shit ton of public. The delivery of services was a fourth placed idea behind:

Raising money for the building
Recruiting for the local org
Recruiting for S.O.
Servicing the public

Then the ideal org opens. Momentary crowds. Then shortly after, crickets. Atlanta has a CF that has been majorly worked over. Not a CF like LA or CW. Then Atlanta public moving elsewhere for services. The freshly recruited public are gone. CF is decimated. Popular public opinion has never been so negative for scn.

Ingredients for disaster for scn.

Service did not have priority, unless the service could help reg for ideal org income.

EDIT: At the time, it really chapped me to watch the tech quality degrade with a lack of interest from management. This bothered me. I cared.

Completely agree with this. Many orgs/fields went through 10-15+ (still going on in some places) of heavy heavy regging. Events every week. I'm sure it overall had a very damaging effect on the field. Blew some people off lines completely and for many of those that stayed on lines their finances were totally ruined. Many scientologists already had destroyed finances just with how much the bridge costs. Then on top of that the ideal org regging put some of them in an irrecoverable hole. And that's before we add ias etc into the mix.
 
I don't know how big Chicago's field is but Austin's is way too small to man it locally. Will they be sea org orgs? I'm curious to find out. Might also be a reason why their opening gets delayed a ton, they don't have the staff to open it and don't want to man it with sea org personnel.
Putting a small number of Sea Org in isolated orgs is not good for control purposes. It makes it much easier for a Sea Org person to blow and disappear into the surrounding community, and there's nobody available to hunt him or her down.
 
You forgot regging for the IAS - probably #2 in your list
Actually there weren't many ias events during ideal org fundraising occurring locally. They held back, believe it or not. That was true in Atl, don't know if that applies everywhere else, but it was noticeable in Atl. In fact, there weren't many ias events, and maybe one or two asho events.
 
Increasingly, it looks like DM recognizes that the game is almost over. He's totally focused on the quick bucks, and uninterested in anything resembling delivering service.

Don't be surprised if he grabs the money and runs in the next few years.
He is most certainly running it for the money in the way that it makes sense to ask for money currently. Buildings, lrh hall, ias, then services.
 
Putting a small number of Sea Org in isolated orgs is not good for control purposes. It makes it much easier for a Sea Org person to blow and disappear into the surrounding community, and there's nobody available to hunt him or her down.
They had an S.O. member have a fling with a very young NOI staff. This was very early on. Your point is well taken, it's tough to keep in ethics.
 
Putting a small number of Sea Org in isolated orgs is not good for control purposes. It makes it much easier for a Sea Org person to blow and disappear into the surrounding community, and there's nobody available to hunt him or her down.

Well orgs are already supposed to have some number of SO members, the networks, so 3-5 SO members per org I guess? I wouldn't be shocked if in the not too distant future we see all orgs manned with a skeleton crew of SO members. Maybe around 20 per org? I think in some ways it would be easier to control 20 than 3, more SO members to police each other. I'm not sure they have enough SO members though.

Actually there weren't many ias events during ideal org fundraising occurring locally. They held back, believe it or not. That was true in Atl, don't know if that applies everywhere else, but it was noticeable in Atl. In fact, there weren't many ias events, and maybe one or two asho events.

Agreed, when Ideal org fundraising is going on they put a hold on almost everything else.


As I said, I am really curious to see what happens with Chicago and Austin. I'm sure for KC and Ohio people were told it's only temporary until they can man the org with regular Class V staff. I'm also sure that they can't man them with regular staff so those are actually more or less permanent postings. I wonder what the SO members thought when they were getting into it.
 
I used to think years ago that a nice impressive building would help Scientology's image and thus help bring in new members. That was back when I believed in all of the nonsense of Scientology. I can very well see how Scientologists can be persuaded to donate for and ideal org. A real ideal org would be an org where Scientology actually worked but that is impossible since it is a scam in the first place.

A real pity that they leave the cult AFTER they have donated to the ideal org scam but I am glad they left just the same,
 
Well orgs are already supposed to have some number of SO members, the networks, so 3-5 SO members per org I guess? I wouldn't be shocked if in the not too distant future we see all orgs manned with a skeleton crew of SO members. Maybe around 20 per org? I think in some ways it would be easier to control 20 than 3, more SO members to police each other. I'm not sure they have enough SO members though.



Agreed, when Ideal org fundraising is going on they put a hold on almost everything else.


As I said, I am really curious to see what happens with Chicago and Austin. I'm sure for KC and Ohio people were told it's only temporary until they can man the org with regular Class V staff. I'm also sure that they can't man them with regular staff so those are actually more or less permanent postings. I wonder what the SO members thought when they were getting into it.
Atlanta is now down to one network staff, and I believe his wife is in Columbus being that one network staff there.

We just saw one of the Atlanta staff, he was wearing gloves and a mask, as ordered.

It must be really odd being on staff now.
 
.

We just saw one of the Atlanta staff, he was wearing gloves and a mask, as ordered.

It must be really odd being on staff now.

.
Yes, being a Scientology staff member during quarantine is very very tough on one's stats!

However, a local Idea Org staff member near here prefers to see the glass as half-full. . .

originally posted by Billy Blowdown
Hey everyone! During the covid shutdown we are making Clears at unprecedented highest ever rates!

Once the federal mandate came down requiring that everyone wear surgical gloves, our PCs began literally flying through all the assessments, grades and rundowns and it was quite rare to find something charged and reading on their cases to run.


.
 
View attachment 2635

Anyone involved in the COS prior to 2003 can attest to the fact that the state of the buildings housing the orgs was pretty horrible. I had been to a few orgs by that time, none were impressive and most actually looked downstat and were in disrepair. LA Day & FDN, Tampa, CC Nash, Atlanta, Cincinnati, Columbus and Las Vegas were an embarrassment to any hardcore Scientologist. That’s why when the ideal org projected started, a certain excitement and hope started to enter in. Will we actually be able to throw away the folding chairs???

A concern sprung up, which was only whispered amongst friends that were old war horses, which was "this is a violation of having to have before you can do, isn't it?" One could only whisper this. Better not whisper it to the wrong person.


View attachment 2636

The excitement was pretty much drained out by the ten years plus that it took to raise the money for our org. I don't think we were the only org that took that long, and I believe there were a few others which took much longer. A testament to that fact is that it's now 2020, and there are still orgs fundraising at "full blast."

Also, during the period of time from the commencement of fund raising to the grand opening, there was an attitude of "we aren't really worrying about clearing the planet right now because we are fundraising for the new building." It most definitely wasn't business as usual. Again, the old war horses and anyone that had a concern for the production occurring in the org could see the effect that the complete attention org management had on fundraising. Us old war horses had to stifle our concern for fear of not being "with it." What happened to the "The Business of Orgs"???

Then there is the subject of construction or remodeling of buildings. Construction can be a crap shoot. Even the experienced builders/remodelers run into an expensive surprise occasionally, and the surprises that were too great caused the company to go under. The amateurs involved in ideal org projects take the cake!! Earthquake zones, incorrect drainage per NPDES protocols and mold remediation were a few of the very expensive surprises that many a dedicated public had to swallow and donate to overcome. I can't recall all the stories, but I suspect there has been a building or two which was purchased and had to be abandoned as a result of such oversights. (If you have knowledge of these sorts of things with your

orgs, chime in!!)

Value Engineering

Definition : Value engineering is an exercise that involves most of the project team as the project develops. It is about taking a wider view and looking at the selection of materials, plant, equipment and processes to see if a more cost-effective solution exists that will achieve the same project objectives.

Value engineering was non-existent in the process of ideal orgs, at least the ideal org that I was aware of. Maybe actually the opposite was the operating basis. During the fundraising, org public were made aware of the entire process by the landlord office, fundraisers, etc., more or less to make everyone a stakeholder in the process. We were told many of the more finer details of the building plans. I happened to be in the construction industry at the time, and had SCN friends in construction. The lack of attention to value engineering was staggering!! We all had many conversations about how we could speed up the process because we could build the building for way less. Another point in this fiasco, maybe the most important point, was the breaking of a sacred rule. The rule goes like this : Never fall in love with the property. One should always have a dispassionate viewpoint over property, because if you don't, it will cost you. Apparently, cost is no object.

For myself, the ideal org project for our area acted as a never ending supply of conflicting datums. Fundraising, withered orgs, people leaving (Suddenly people were missing or hard to get hold of) events, events, events took it's toll. It didn't cause me to leave at that time, but I became very wary of what was going on. I had to take the attitude of "We will See". I guess that leads to the next point.

Ideal org buildings are very, very empty. I drive past the org in my city on occasion, and there are never more that eight cars in the parking lot. If you frequent Tony Ortega or Mike Rinder, you get a feel for this. There are frequently reports of recently opened ideal orgs with no cars in the parking lots. This is a standard.

I haven't even covered the financial irregularities that I knew of during the fundraising portion. That will have to come at a later time.
Reading this post at the end of August 2021 and nodding my head...
Cap'n McNugget's 9th Dynamic Pimp Move, still happening!
The regging and SRA's will continue until there is no one left to steal from!
 
Great thread!

I think I need to structure my reply in 3 parts, because there's so much in the initial post I want to address:

1. Early 2000s and my initial feelings as a cultie.

I know what you mean about the state of the orgs in the early 2000s. Las Vegas was a joke, Pasadena was a dump once you made one one step outside the public-facing areas. I'm not even gonna describe some of the small missions.

So some repair and renovation was in order, but IMHO could be done on a cyclical no-nonsense scale using mostly bussed-in SO labor with a sprinkling of hired external professionals. But of course in Scientology no sensible act can occur and Dave had to crank it up to 11 , I guess because he likes being 'significant'.

Even when I was inside, I always felt they started from the wrong end. They should start by fixing horrible berthing like the AB before they got to fixing orgs. I'm not sure if the Anthony building has changed any, but when I last saw it in the late 2000s it was still LA's tallest dumpster.

What I did not realize at the time is that the Ideal Orgs were a way to turn liquid assets into real estate without endangering the tax-exempt status (Churches are not supposed to be banks or hoard large amounts of unused money).

2. Costs, engineering, accidents.

Well, I was not an engineer and as Ideal Orgs were the "COBs pet project", we at Inv did not (surprise surprise!) get orders to investigate if the people who planned it are SPs who want to waste money. So I cannot comment on value engineering, that was not a focus for us. We did get into some individual financial stuff (ie: "Did guy X get a bribe to order material Y specifically from company Z" or "Did all the funds raised in org X were in fact sent out, or are they keeping some for themselves?"), but it was really a sideshow with a limited number of cases like that.

Workplace accidents? Different story. We had many cases dealing with that (apparently the management thought us Ethics Gators were the best qualified for the job, rather than safety inspectors or engineers). People falling from heights, cutting themselves with carpeting knives, injuring themselves with a nailer... You name it, we had cases for it. To be honest, most of these cases I delegated to other members of my team due to internal reporting reasons (2D and financial cases got more heat from up high, so I often took these upon myself, accidents were mostly assigned to others). But I was aware of the volume and it was not a marginal thing.

Oh I'd love to hear about the financial irregularities of the fundraising, because we really did not get that many cases for it. I did not get at the time an impression that we are being politely told to look the other way, but maybe that's because I was not aware of the real scale of the problems. I'd love to hear more.

3. People leaving

The way I remember it, population appears to have been stable right up to roughly the Iraq war. Some left, some joined. The trend seems to have shifted roughly in late 2003. We saw more people leaving then before, but it was not overwhelming at first. From 2005 it was clearly the biggest "exodus" anyone seen and by 2006 it was obvious that the levee had broken and that there was a mass of people leaving the church. This would be the flood that would also take myself out, so I have no idea when it ended or reached its zenith.

But it is curious to see a correlation between the trend shift and the "Ideal Org" program.
Heh heh, the Ideal Borg Program...😉😎
The lies, the bankrupting, the screaming and shaming, the doubling down on bankrupting, the beatings, the fetishizing of the actual building materials, the interminable pimping events...What a shit show of bare-faced hustling!
"SO, WHAT DO YOU DO IN SCIENTOLOGY?"
"WELL, WE WORSHIP THE NINTH DYNAMIC. IT'S only ABOUT THE MOTHERFUCKIN' BENJAMINS, YO!"
David McSavage is one evil, greedy sociopath-just like Hubbard! The grift continues...until it doesn't...
Scientology has always just been variations on a theme of lying and stealing...
 
The Co$ has money to live off for the next 70 years or so. If nothing big will happen, then it will just continue to slowly bleed membership while disconnecting people, putting people through mental and physical abuse and getting 2nd gen kids thrown to the SO.

What the church needs is a big push that would either cause it to reform, or cause a systemic failure that makes people leave in droves as part of organized groups.
Because the "one person at a time" bleedout will be neither pretty, nor safe, nor quick nor good for those who are still inside.
Reform? As in change the shape, smell, and/or texture of a turd?
Make it a more "benign scam"?
It was shat out of Hubbard's Crowleyian, drug-addled desire to "smash his name into history"...
Just sayin'...
 
What sort of experiences did you have?
The usual...Relentless regging...Escaping long "Ideal Orgy" events via a smoke break that became an early escape...
Wondering...why all of the breathless excitement about square feet of this and millions of miles of that? Hearing about "unprecedented expansion", whilst looking around the DC metro area and thinking "Nobody gives a FOOK about scientology!" Sitting in an office with auditors and the OES and the D of T and D of P, doing fucking call-in...because the HGC barely had any pc's...Seeing a brand new, relatively empty building with an almost empty academy course room and a sporadically, moderately busy div 6 course room...Seeing people either "blow" staff or take leaves of absence because the pay was either non-existent or absolutely shitty...
Standard Scientology Cult Bullshit.
 
The usual...Relentless regging...Escaping long "Ideal Orgy" events via a smoke break that became an early escape...
Wondering...why all of the breathless excitement about square feet of this and millions of miles of that? Hearing about "unprecedented expansion", whilst looking around the DC metro area and thinking "Nobody gives a FOOK about scientology!" Sitting in an office with auditors and the OES and the D of T and D of P, doing fucking call-in...because the HGC barely had any pc's...Seeing a brand new, relatively empty building with an almost empty academy course room and a sporadically, moderately busy div 6 course room...Seeing people either "blow" staff or take leaves of absence because the pay was either non-existent or absolutely shitty...
Standard Scientology Cult Bullshit.
I doesn't make sense. But it makes dollars. I mean takes dollars.
 
Back
Top