How Ideal Orgs Are Causing Current Scientologists To Leave Scientology

Reform? As in change the shape, smell, and/or texture of a turd?
Make it a more "benign scam"?

If they get rid of the abusive practices, then I couldn't care less if they continue to believe that postulates are real or that OTs can use telepathy to find a parking spot.

There are many religions and philosophies that believe crazy things or plain falsehoods. Christianity believes that a jewish carpenter that's been dead for 2000 years will come back to save the world. That doesn't make them a cult.

Its not like I would go back to scientology or recommend it to anyone, even if they get rid of the abuse. But at that point I would consider riding away into the sunset.

But as long as this nonsense goes on, I feel I should try to push back. Even if its just posting on a forum and giving interviews.
 
Last edited:
When the cherch received religious recognition, part of me felt this was "the beginning of the end". I'm not sure why, maybe it was because it felt undeserved or dishonest. We were told "get ready for the boom". The boom never happened.

Then, the Ideal Org strategy was launched. I believe Buffalo was the first Ideal Org. I recall, seeing the CGI walkthroughs, the opulent fixtures and exotic materials, and the staff dressed in monkey suits. We were told "get ready for the boom". Yeah.

On one level, it was all very impressive. On another it felt like a lie. I had left staff by then, but I felt for the current org staff. Most of them were dead broke or heavily in debt. Yet, they are now going to have to go to work everyday at some faux palace dressed as a bell hop. And they are going to have pretend how successful Scn is and how its made their lives better, while many could not afford to eat. This puts the staff on a continuous missed withhold from the public. Horrible.

This tells me something about DM. He does not know or understand the Scn public and how Class V orgs and staff work. He does not know what drives or motivates the people that actively pursue Scn (the "true" Scnists). He does not have the "spirit of Scientology". He has become a Wall Street huckster, flogging anti-aging treatments for the soul.

He knows there are things in Scn which can produce a positive gain (Grades, TRs), but is also aware that the Big Picture is a lie. So what do you do? Keep the majority of your public in the lower/middle part of the Bridge for as long as possible. Make the upper levels expensive and difficult to attain, knowing that probably 50% of those who reach the end will wake-up and blow.

The final phase of this evolution was the regging of straight donations. The mask is off. Its now an institutional machine designed to extract maximum wealth and return as little as possible.
 
When the cherch received religious recognition, part of me felt this was "the beginning of the end". I'm not sure why, maybe it was because it felt undeserved or dishonest. We were told "get ready for the boom". The boom never happened.

Then, the Ideal Org strategy was launched. I believe Buffalo was the first Ideal Org. I recall, seeing the CGI walkthroughs, the opulent fixtures and exotic materials, and the staff dressed in monkey suits. We were told "get ready for the boom". Yeah.

On one level, it was all very impressive. On another it felt like a lie. I had left staff by then, but I felt for the current org staff. Most of them were dead broke or heavily in debt. Yet, they are now going to have to go to work everyday at some faux palace dressed as a bell hop. And they are going to have pretend how successful Scn is and how its made their lives better, while many could not afford to eat. This puts the staff on a continuous missed withhold from the public. Horrible.

This tells me something about DM. He does not know or understand the Scn public and how Class V orgs and staff work. He does not know what drives or motivates the people that actively pursue Scn (the "true" Scnists). He does not have the "spirit of Scientology". He has become a Wall Street huckster, flogging anti-aging treatments for the soul.

He knows there are things in Scn which can produce a positive gain (Grades, TRs), but is also aware that the Big Picture is a lie. So what do you do? Keep the majority of your public in the lower/middle part of the Bridge for as long as possible. Make the upper levels expensive and difficult to attain, knowing that probably 50% of those who reach the end will wake-up and blow.

The final phase of this evolution was the regging of straight donations. The mask is off. Its now an institutional machine designed to extract maximum wealth and return as little as possible.
And in the midst of each ideal org opening is the regging of staff. Now that the recruiters pulled strings, arranged for apts., jobs, gave false promises of daycare, etc., the regges can then reg everyone including staff. Lots of newly opened credit cards suddenly maxed out. Staff that make no money, now having to make the credit card payments on little pay.
 
What happens in an org that regges equally, staff and public? They will try to get staff in session during their post time, inevitably. Then much more.
 
one of the comments in this -- which i'm expecting Karen is likely to post a new thread -- says:

It was a HUGE mistake to move from Nicollet, over burdening public, no new public, bad PR, and dedicated public dying, the internet. It is actually impossible for that Org in that location to survive let alone thrive. Oh, not to mention OTs in that area finally figuring out that the whole thing is bull shit, I know some of them. Yeah


onceuponatime could be right that say this was just the smaller day/fdn org staff, most of whom are away at Flag for GAA training, and thus the staff is much larger, and maybe there are a lot of active members who just weren't seen when the org was visited, and so we're underestimating the size of the co$ and can't give too much weight to an account like this.

and sort of like with Finnish snipers, there could be a whole lot of members invisible in their social media postings like this:

Capture.jpg
 
one of the comments in this -- which i'm expecting Karen is likely to post a new thread -- says:




onceuponatime could be right that say this was just the smaller day/fdn org staff, most of whom are away at Flag for GAA training, and thus the staff is much larger, and maybe there are a lot of active members who just weren't seen when the org was visited, and so we're underestimating the size of the co$ and can't give too much weight to an account like this.

and sort of like with Finnish snipers, there could be a whole lot of members invisible in their social media postings like this:

View attachment 20339

What? I thought our overall estimates were more or less in line as far as the overall size of scientology. I just don't put as much weight in staff/event pictures as you do. Fwiw if I had to guess I'd say TC has 30ish staff at best, wouldn't be shocked if they were down to less than 20 though. I don't really know much about TC, just things I've heard from people second or third hand. They are ideal but they were still a smaller org, even after going ideal. Yes, I think some orgs are quite a bit bigger than what you see in places like TC (I do have hard numbers about some orgs, nothing I'm going to share though, it isn't all guesswork). I haven't seen anything that contradicts my guesses about the overall numbers.
 
What? I thought our overall estimates were more or less in line as far as the overall size of scientology. I just don't put as much weight in staff/event pictures as you do. Fwiw if I had to guess I'd say TC has 30ish staff at best, wouldn't be shocked if they were down to less than 20 though.

ok, i agree we're not too far off, but i had to give you grief about your eternal optimism on the side of the CoS being bigger :sneaky:

i could see one or even a couple local event photos being questionable, but when at least the CoS' photography teams are known for going to incredible lengths to try to make photos appear to show more people than are actually in attendance (and who are actually public), i find it a stretch to imagine that dozens of the event photos posted to social media somehow all represent the active local memberships being significantly smaller than they actually are. or that complete failure to posted to social media (TC has just that one picture outside the org) doesn't like point to them really being struggling, even if it's not absolutely conclusive. and when i have seen more specific information about orgs, like St. Louis, it does seem to line up more less with what the event photos show.

“Based on my ex-Scientologist sources who worked in that building, they said there’s probably 25 or so members in this church,” Joey Peters, a reporter for Sahan Journal, said.

how do they possibly even have 20 staff, then? we've heard from Chris Shelton that they were doing terribly, even before.

(i think of Plymouth in the UK, where they're reportedly down to as few as 10 remaining members after the pandemic - and that they are only actually open limited hours now)
 
Last edited:
We were told "get ready for the boom".

We were told "get ready for the boom". Yeah.

This tells me something about DM.

The mask is off.
Golden age of tek phase 1.

Golden age of tek for ots.

Ideal orgs.

Basics.

Golden age of tek phase 2.

Superpower.

Scn media productions.

Church of janitology (pandemic joke).


You would think, after all of this and then some, you would think.

I'm still finding people that left the cult that do not search scn and the internet.

My original fsm is out, never going to do another action, but still believes.
 
interesting to hear. i'm guessing it's too much for some people to confront, how they were taken and how mistaken they were.
It is the damnedest thing. I've spoken with several friends, that are not in after thirty plus years in. But no faintest knowledge of basic data, such as Alistair Crowley, Jack Parsons, Sarah Northrup, BlueBird motor homes, vistaril. They are out. The chide me for looking at entheta.

You guys that are out are my only contacts that I can speak with. Oh, and JustSheila, as we developed a friendship, but she is gone and I have to call her to talk. She's been out for so long, she doesn't have the ideal org stories.

EDIT: they are more of that brand of the "good" scnist. They just got fed up with whatever aspect they got fed up with, such as doing everything over and over again, or never ending ideal org regging.
 
ok, i agree we're not too far off, but i had to give you grief about your eternal optimism on the side of the CoS being bigger :sneaky:

i could see one or even a couple local event photos being questionable, but when at least the CoS' photography teams are known for going to incredible lengths to try to make photos appear to show more people than are actually in attendance (and who are actually public), i find it a stretch to imagine that dozens of the event photos posted to social media somehow all represent the active local memberships being significantly smaller than they actually are. or that complete failure to posted to social media (TC has just that one picture outside the org) doesn't like point to them really being struggling, even if it's not absolutely conclusive. and when i have seen more specific information about orgs, like St. Louis, it does seem to line up more less with what the event photos show.



how do they possibly even have 20 staff, then? we've heard from Chris Shelton that they were doing terribly, even before.

(i think of Plymouth in the UK, where they're reportedly down to as few as 10 remaining members after the pandemic - and that they are only actually open limited hours now)

Lol, if I'm the voice of optimism then things really aren't looking good for them, no matter how you look at it. I do try to take a more conservative approach.

It isn't a team from gold taking and posting those pictures at a class v level. It's some poor staff member who got assigned go take photos on the wqsb. They aren't doing any manipulation to make the crowds look bigger, outside of trying to get a good angle. And another thing you have to think with, not all scientologists go to events, even the big international ones. Not even all staff members make it to every event.

25 people at a time in the org, half public half staff still leaves you with 25 staff. You have to account for day and foundation. Most of the time when you here a number like 10 staff you have to double it, unless the org doesn't have day and foundation or the person specifically says they're counting both. St. Louis is another small struggling org. 25-30 staff is the best I'd think they could do.

I'll say this much. I know of several orgs that are in the 60-80 staff range and I have confirmed numbers within the recent past. If anything they've grown since I last had hard numbers, scientology is doing a massive recruitment pitch right now, backed by this ideal management stuff. These are orgs that haven't been posted about anywhere, at least not actual stats.

I wish we'd get numbers from some of the orgs that I think are on the bigger size.
 
It is the damnedest thing. I've spoken with several friends, that are not in after thirty plus years in. But no faintest knowledge of basic data, such as Alistair Crowley, Jack Parsons, Sarah Northrup, BlueBird motor homes, vistaril. They are out. The chide me for looking at entheta.

with scn considered an extreme cult, a lot of people who've been through it could probably be considered to have something akin to PTSD -- and so like WW2 vets, may just put it at the back of their mind and try to move on, not wanting to talk about it.

i also suspect that while joining such a group or cult is generally talked up to being at a vulnerable point in life, quite a number of people who stay in such a group for a long time may be below average in things like critical thinking. i'm impressed at someone like you who seems able to step away and view it pretty objectively.

EDIT: they are more of that brand of the "good" scnist. They just got fed up with whatever aspect they got fed up with, such as doing everything over and over again, or never ending ideal org regging.

that sounds similar to the phenomenon i've noticed, it seems that accounts of exploitation and abuses or even witnessing them doesn't get people to quit, just when it finally happens to them.
 
with scn considered an extreme cult, a lot of people who've been through it could probably be considered to have something akin to PTSD -- and so like WW2 vets, may just put it at the back of their mind and try to move on, not wanting to talk about it.

i also suspect that while joining such a group or cult is generally talked up to being at a vulnerable point in life, quite a number of people who stay in such a group for a long time may be below average in things like critical thinking. i'm impressed at someone like you who seems able to step away and view it pretty objectively.



that sounds similar to the phenomenon i've noticed, it seems that accounts of exploitation and abuses or even witnessing them doesn't get people to quit, just when it finally happens to them.
There were several times during my twenty seven years in where I had just about had enough, and found myself recovering myself, or someone reaching out to pull me back in. Each time was a little different. I saw through the ideal org thing but could only complain to a few, or off with my head! When I put myself deeply back in on staff, it was the high octane routing out ethics cycle that finally did the trick.

The personal experience that I now have is quite strange. Being both sides, with reality on each. It wouldn't be worth much without inspection, and I have had some time to go over it.

And a special thanks to Victor Frankl to help me find its value in my wild life.
 
Most of the time when you here a number like 10 staff you have to double it, unless the org doesn't have day and foundation or the person specifically says they're counting both. St. Louis is another small struggling org. 25-30 staff is the best I'd think they could do.

over at Mike Rinder's, there are a number of people who have posted pretty detailed historical information about STL, but have more recently been watching the parking lot and still know which cars belong to who. there seem to be pretty reliable counts that staff are down to 12-15 total, if that. i had some kinda insider info on Orlando at one point several years before they went ideal (and apparently got sea org staffing) and they had been right around that size too, i was reasonably certain. so it seems to me the evidence points to the smaller orgs are really not doing that well, and have staff more of the size you'd expect to be serving a couple dozen members.

also, from one org i did get to observe directly a couple of times close to a decade ago now, an org in a good sized metro area that had 25-30 staff was one that got 50-60 people participating regularly, and 100-120 people at say the big New Year's and LRH birthday events. that was also one that got its ideal org done in just a few years, with only one false start. and that was before the tsunami of bad publicity really hit; that org no longer has any social media presence that i can find.

i think it's expected that Tampa is probably the biggest org -- and you can see it in the staff photos they post to social media. i hadn't picked up on San Francisco, but wasn't surprised to hear they are also larger -- and there are some staff pictures in their social media that are certainly much larger than what you see for almost all orgs, if still not showing their full size.

ultimately what always frustrates and even surprises me, is that we don't have better information from people leaving scn, about the status of things like staff counts and active membership. i don't quite get it, but i can only figure that either orgs keep such things shrouded, or members had blinders on or just weren't the sort of people to do quantitative reality checks (which would go with how they get sold on 'expansion' and 'ideal orgs' when all the orgs are so empty).
 
over at Mike Rinder's, there are a number of people who have posted pretty detailed historical information about STL, but have more recently been watching the parking lot and still know which cars belong to who. there seem to be pretty reliable counts that staff are down to 12-15 total, if that. i had some kinda insider info on Orlando at one point several years before they went ideal (and apparently got sea org staffing) and they had been right around that size too, i was reasonably certain. so it seems to me the evidence points to the smaller orgs are really not doing that well, and have staff more of the size you'd expect to be serving a couple dozen members.

also, from one org i did get to observe directly a couple of times close to a decade ago now, an org in a good sized metro area that had 25-30 staff was one that got 50-60 people participating regularly, and 100-120 people at say the big New Year's and LRH birthday events. that was also one that got its ideal org done in just a few years, with only one false start. and that was before the tsunami of bad publicity really hit; that org no longer has any social media presence that i can find.

i think it's expected that Tampa is probably the biggest org -- and you can see it in the staff photos they post to social media. i hadn't picked up on San Francisco, but wasn't surprised to hear they are also larger -- and there are some staff pictures in their social media that are certainly much larger than what you see for almost all orgs, if still not showing their full size.

ultimately what always frustrates and even surprises me, is that we don't have better information from people leaving scn, about the status of things like staff counts and active membership. i don't quite get it, but i can only figure that either orgs keep such things shrouded, or members had blinders on or just weren't the sort of people to do quantitative reality checks (which would go with how they get sold on 'expansion' and 'ideal orgs' when all the orgs are so empty).
I think that what we should do is to start a thread with org data by people in the area. If they wanted to post in private so as not to give away their locale, they could message P&B with pics and data (if it was ok with him). I am in Atlanta, as I have said I have some degree of knowledge of what is going on there, but not the inside skinny to be sure.

It should be called "Another Day in the Lie of Scientology." Numbers do not lie. They can hire people to show up, they can rent cars for the parking lots. That would be funny, they could do a casting call for org extras. People to walk in and out of the building simultaneously carrying empty e-meter cases or pc folders like it's no big deal, like it's a gold shoot.
 
I think that what we should do is to start a thread with org data by people in the area.

one had been started, but never got that sort of traction. though i've wondered if it wouldn't help if everything related to orgs, wasn't organized with maybe even a renaming of 'Org Watch and Protests' into something more obviously focused on both org history and current status information -- aren't protests pretty much a thing of the past?

i just posted a car count from an org there. while you may have told us this before, i'd be very interested to see what the Atlanta car count is compared to how many total staff (days, evenings and weekends, even if they're not formally split into day and fdn org) and active members you think the org has at this point.

 
I think that what we should do is to start a thread with org data by people in the area. If they wanted to post in private so as not to give away their locale, they could message P&B with pics and data (if it was ok with him). I am in Atlanta, as I have said I have some degree of knowledge of what is going on there, but not the inside skinny to be sure.

Fine by me.
 
Back
Top