Clearwater's 3-2 final vote gives Scientology vacated street for its Vatican City

Karen#1

Well-known member
TONY ORTEGA
Excerpt:

[td width="876px"]
[/td][td]
[/td]​
[Allbritton, Mannino, and Cotton came through for Dave]

We watched live last night as Clearwater’s city council took its final vote and, with 3 council members voting yes — David Allbritton, Mike Mannino, and Ryan Cotton — Scientology will get what it wants as a portion of South Garden Avenue in downtown is “vacated” and closed off from the public right-of-way.
Scientology argued that it needed the street vacated as a safety concern as it builds L. Ron Hubbard Hall on the east side of Garden Avenue, and L. Ron Hubbard Park on the west side.
The two no votes — Mayor Bruce Rector and Lina Teixeira — as well as several members of the public pointed out that Scientology can have its future hall and future park, and it can get permits to shut down Garden Avenue for large events without vacating it as a public street.
But Allbritton, Mannino, and Cotton seemed swayed by Scientology’s security concerns, which were laid on pretty thickly by the Scientologists who had signed up to speak before the council.
Painting scary pictures of maniacs driving trucks into crowds, lunatics firing at strangers, and even Mexican home invasions as examples of why Scientologists needed to be protected from the public, speaker after speaker spoke in fairly formulaic presentations that seemed to have been if not written for them, vetted by the Office of Special Affairs.
But hearing from the public was merely a formality. Nothing had changed from an initial vote that was taken two weeks earlier.
Council member David Allbritton cited previous street vacations, a lack of traffic on Garden Avenue, and the safety concerns to conclude that he didn’t see a compelling reason not to grant Scientology’s request.
READ MORE
 
Scientologist aren't allowed to have excess spendable income when coming to Flag for training or services. They are supposed to feel guilty, especially for being handled by those with no incoming pay. The bistros on Cleveland Street won't upsale a table with wine and beer or indulgent sweets. Another vitamin store might do well.

Actually, the only time I saw customers was around 8 -9 pm on Fri and Sat nights. But, that was way back when. I supposed most day business came from those working in the offices situated inside those historic buildings.

In a way, I'm relieved. Tampa is in Hillsborough county and Clearwater is Pinellas County. Ya gotta know city planners want to merge districts and rezone for the jobs and money.

Daytona Beach and New Smyrna became unrecognizable to me. You no longer feel safe parking too long at the seafood houses. I've relatives in Treasure Island and St Pete and they con't complain. Not now, anyhow.
 
Last edited:


Despite the actions of the Clearwater City Council, Clearwater citizens have two different ways (at least) of stopping Scientology from getting this street.
The lawsuit that the ACLU is helping with, and also, there is another petition that the Save the Garden has 90 days to create and get enough signatures.
This fight isn't over yet. :D


Several days ago, I asked ChatGPT:
The ACLU filed a lawsuit a couple weeks back against the City of Clearwater, Florida. What is the status of that lawsuit presently?

ChatGPT:


I’ll verify the current docket/status rather than rely on news blurbs, since lawsuits can change quickly and “a couple weeks back” puts us in live-wire territory.

Presently, the lawsuit appears to be active and unresolved.

The case is Save the Garden v. City of Clearwater. It was filed on May 22, 2026 in Pinellas County Circuit Court by the ACLU of Florida on behalf of Save the Garden and individual Clearwater voters, challenging Clearwater’s rejection of ballot-initiative petition signatures. The complaint asks for declaratory and injunctive relief, including acceptance or recounting of disputed signatures and a corrected sufficiency certificate.

Since then, the City has removed the case to federal court. The ACLU’s case page lists the matter as “Filed,” with a latest update of June 11, 2026, and says the City removed it to the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida, where plaintiffs filed a motion for preliminary injunction. PacerMonitor identifies the federal case as 8:26-cv-01662 and shows a Notice of Removal dated June 4, 2026.

I did not find an accessible public source showing that the preliminary-injunction motion has been granted or denied, or that the case has been dismissed or settled. So the courtroom weather report is: pending in federal court, with the preliminary-injunction request as the immediate fight.

One related wrinkle: the underlying South Garden Avenue issue is still moving outside the courtroom. FOX 13 reported today, June 18, 2026, that Clearwater City Council was scheduled for a 6 p.m. final vote on the Church of Scientology street-vacation proposal.

Want me to watch for a ruling on the preliminary-injunction motion?



Type4:
Yes! Check for a ruling or meaningful docket update in Save the Garden v. City of Clearwater, including the preliminary-injunction motion. Notify me if there is a ruling, hearing, dismissal, settlement, remand, or other major status change. If there is no meaningful update, do not notify me.


ChatGPT:
Monitoring: Clearwater Lawsuit Watch
Done. I’ll check daily for a ruling or major docket update in Save the Garden v. City of Clearwater and notify you only if something meaningful changes.



Meaningful update:
the preliminary-injunction fight appears to be fully briefed and awaiting the judge.

PacerMonitor’s docket for Save the Garden et al. v. City of Clearwater, 8:26-cv-01662, shows that plaintiffs filed their reply in support of the time-sensitive motion for preliminary injunction on June 18, 2026 at 7:18 p.m. The docket does not show a ruling yet. The court’s most recent visible orders were procedural: allowing plaintiffs to file a seven-page reply by June 18, and accepting the city’s corrected response despite page-limit/timing issues.

Related outside-court development: Clearwater City Council has now approved vacating part of South Garden Avenue to the Church of Scientology in a 3-2 vote, according to Spectrum News on June 19, 2026. That report also notes the Save the Garden lawsuit remains pending.

So the current status is: no injunction ruling yet, no dismissal, no remand, no settlement found, but the PI motion is now teed up for decision.
 
Back
Top