What is Rhetoric?

Hubbard's logos appeal is to make it sound scientific. This is evident in his first book called Dianetics the Modern Science of Mental Health. Back when it was published, many well-known people of the day fell for it, for it sounded logical, or logos in rhetoric terms. Once Scientology started, this is the same more or less for scientology means science plus ology or study of science or knowledge, a logos appeal. This is a twist of words by Hubbard, it is actually a logos appeal to persuade by using logos.

There are many examples of Hubbard's use of logos, first and foremost would be his use of scales, and that includes survival of the 4 dynamics in Dianetics and then later in scientology the dynamics to survive thru 8 dynamics. The Bridge to Total Freedom is one big rhetoric scale to just do the next step on moving up the bridge.

Seems very logical, but nobody went clear or OT.
 
Last edited:
.

..

Hubbard's logos appeal is to make it sound scientific. This is evident in his first book called Dianetics the Modern Science of Mental Health. Back when it was published, many well-known people of the day fell for it, for it sounded logical, or logos in rhetoric terms. Once Scientology started, this is the same more or less for scientology means science plus ology or study of science or knowledge, a logos appeal. This is a twist of words by Hubbard, it is actually a logos appeal to persuade by using logos. There are many examples of Hubbard's use of logos, first and foremost ........

.

I think i finally understand what you are waiting for (and demanding) others do.

You need them to use the word LOGOS (or "rhetoric" or "ethos" or "pathos") an incredible number of times (like you do).

EXAMPLE: You need them to stop saying that Hubbard was a LIAR or that Hubbard LIED.

You desperately need them to say Ron was a "logos liar" or that he "logos lied".

It's such a huge and ultra-significant difference, right? LOL


ps: Legit question. Is English not your native language? I notice that grammatically you often use the word RHETORIC incorrectly. And there are other odd "tells" too. Like the fact that you often use the word thread but you never spell it correctly. I am wondering if you have a language handicap and might not be understanding the English language very well, which might account for why you are always trying to get people to construct sentences like you do--referring to or including one or more of these words; rhetoric, logos, pathos and ethos.

.

/
 
Last edited:
.

I dropped a box of Legos on the patio and my mom sent me to ethics. The ethos officer told me I was pathetic and that I'd better donate my Legos to the Org. Should I?

lol lol lol



.
 
Last edited:
If one were to think of persuasion meaning ethos, pathos and logos, or just one or a combination of two or three, then one can get it.

A couple of Hubbard's main persuasions were KSW and My Philosophy. Both use all 3 of the ethos, pathos and logos. In fact, if one were to read Hubbard's policy letters and HCOB's, they all use the same more or less. Hubbard even gave the janitor ethos, pathos and logos by calling him the Estate's Executive, or whatever he called him in the org board, which is just a rhetoric org board, with titles and such.
 
If one were to think of persuasion meaning ethos, pathos and logos, or just one or a combination of two or three, then one can get it.

A couple of Hubbard's main persuasions were KSW and My Philosophy. Both use all 3 of the ethos, pathos and logos. In fact, if one were to read Hubbard's policy letters and HCOB's, they all use the same more or less. Hubbard even gave the janitor ethos, pathos and logos by calling him the Estate's Executive, or whatever he called him in the org board, which is just a rhetoric org board, with titles and such.


Are there other means of persuasion besides using rhetoric?

Anyone feel free to answer my question. I suspect Riddick may possibly have me on the ignore list. :unsure:

If I put a gun to someone's head and threaten their life if they don't hand over their wallet that certainly would generate an emotional response in the person, but would this really be considered a use of rhetoric?

Similarly, if an Ethic's Officer threatens your eternity if you don't comply with his demands would that be considered a use of rhetoric?

I asked this question of Riddick previously in another thread and all I heard was <crickets>. He ignored me even prior to putting me on the ignore list.
 
Are there other means of persuasion besides using rhetoric?

Anyone feel free to answer my question. I suspect Riddick may possibly have me on the ignore list. :unsure:

If I put a gun to someone's head and threaten their life if they don't hand over their wallet that certainly would generate an emotional response in the person, but would this really be considered a use of rhetoric?

Similarly, if an Ethic's Officer threatens your eternity if you don't comply with his demands would that be considered a use of rhetoric?

I asked this question of Riddick previously in another thread and all I heard was <crickets>. He ignored me even prior to putting me on the ignore list.
Riddick is confused and makes the subject overly complicated.

There is a pretty good articls on Wikipedia that is worth reading. Rhetoric refers to speaking and writing.

If you investigate something, and make a decision based on the facts you have found, that is not rhetoric. If you choose based on your beliefs, upbringing, culture, etc. that is not rhetoric. And, to your question, threats are not rhetoric.

For politicians and lawyers, rhetoric is a good thing. Otherwise, its moral value is questionable.
 
The whole purpose, one might ask, is of rhetoric? That purpose is to persuade another of ones' ideas. Hubbard's ideas were that one could go clear using dianetic procedures when that book first came out. Later on, his purpose or rhetoric was to persuade that scientology was the answer.

Rhetoric: A Definition and Rhetorical Devices Explained| Grammarly Blog

"Rhetoric is language that’s carefully constructed to persuade, motivate, or inform the reader or listener about the speaker or writer’s position."

Hubbard's position was one could go clear and then OT.

Of course, this is all false, for nobody went clear or OT or returned from past life.
 
,

The whole purpose, one might ask, is of rhetoric? That purpose is to persuade another of ones' ideas. Hubbard's ideas were that one could go clear using dianetic procedures when that book first came out. Later on, his purpose or rhetoric was to persuade that scientology was the answer.

"Rhetoric is language that’s carefully constructed to persuade..."


.
I am not persuaded that the first line of your post is a sentence.

.
 
.

If one were to think of persuasion meaning ethos, pathos and logos, or just one or a combination of two or three, then one can get it. A couple of Hubbard's main persuasions were KSW and My Philosophy. Both use all 3 of the ethos, pathos and logos. In fact, if one were to read Hubbard's policy letters and HCOB's, they all use the same more or less. Hubbard even gave the janitor ethos, pathos and logos by calling him the Estate's Executive, or whatever he called him in the org board, which is just a rhetoric org board, with titles and such.
.


There are three (3) possible ways that rhetoric can persuade:
  • ethos
  • pathos
  • logos
There are also three (3) possible reasons that you have endlessly repeated the same exact sentences about rhetoric many hundreds of times over the years:
  • idiocy
  • trolling
  • the mindlessly compulsive repetition of phrases/sentences due to OCD
Right now I am slightly favoring "trolling", although a compelling case can be made for both of the other two.

.
 
And on and on it goes.

All it takes are the 3 Musetotears: Pathos, Asshos and Aratroll.

All for 1 and 1 for all!


2fe86080e283013ab656005056a9545d
 
Last edited:
In the beginning, that would be dianetics book, Hubbard endlessly talks about how if one did dianetics auditing why their tone level will improve and they can become clear. This is a pathos or emotional appeal to persuade one to do dianetics auditing. Hubbard said one was in a tone scale of 1-4, which is a logos or logical appeal. This is Hubbard's emotional tone scale to persuade, just get more auditing and your tone will improve so you can live a happy life. It's a combination of the rhetoric pathos, ethos and logos.

I did many hours of dianetics auditing and I did not go clear doing so. But at the time I did all this dianetics auditing, I was persuaded by reading the book dianetics, I could go clear.
 
Last edited:
.

Hubbard's logos appeal is to make it sound scientific. This is evident in his first book called Dianetics the Modern Science of Mental Health. Back when it was published, many well-known people of the day fell for it, for it sounded logical, or logos in rhetoric terms. Once Scientology started, this is the same more or less for scientology means science plus ology or study of science or knowledge, a logos appeal. This is a twist of words by Hubbard, it is actually a logos appeal to persuade by using logos. There are many examples of Hubbard's use of logos, first and foremost would be his use of scales, and that includes survival of the 4 dynamics in Dianetics and then later in scientology the dynamics to survive thru 8 dynamics. The Bridge to Total Freedom is one big rhetoric scale to just do the next step on moving up the bridge.


In the beginning, that would be dianetics book, Hubbard endlessly talks about how if one did dianetics auditing why their tone level will improve and they can become clear. This is a pathos or emotional appeal to persuade one to do dianetics auditing. Hubbard said one was in a tone scale of 1-4, which is a logos or logical appeal. This is Hubbard's emotional tone scale to persuade, just get more auditing and your tone will improve so you can live a happy life. It's a combination of the rhetoric pathos, ethos and logos. I did many hours of dianetics auditing and I did not go clear doing so. But at the time I did all this dianetics auditing, I was persuaded by reading the book dianetics, I could go clear.

.

.

You may legally be entitled to a REFUND of whatever you paid for your Dianetic auditing.

Because apparently you received the "quickie" version which omitted the handling of "bouncers", "deniers" and other compulsively repetitive behaviors, phrases or words (i.e. rhetoric, logos, ethos, pathos) that endlessly keep popping up. Dr. Hubbard's discoveries included "The Repeater Technique" which helps the auditor and PC contact and erase heavily charged engrams that hypnotically trigger repeating dramatizations.





.
 
Last edited:
.

This thread is kind of entertaining, but not in the way a discussion thread normally is.

It's focused 100% on RHETORIC. The technology of influential & persuasive speech/writing.

However, quite ironically nobody is persuaded. Further, and paradoxically, the originator and host of this thread has blocked the handful of readers who are participating in the discussion. In other words, it's a discussion thread that refuses to discuss. And it's a rhetoric thread that fails to persuade---and the thread's rhetoric expert then exclaims on multiple occasions that they don't give a shit what anyone else thinks or if anyone else is persuaded.

So then, what would be the purpose of such a thread that has NO DISCUSSION and on which the thread originator refuses to even read what anyone else has to say? That sounds more like Riddick came to lecture or more accurately--sermonize! But, in that case, even priests change their Sunday sermons and don't simply read the identical prompter verbatim every single week.

Perhaps the name of the thread ("What is Rhetoric") needs to be changed to more accurately reflect what the thread is actually about? Maybe something closer to "WHAT ISN'T RHETORIC" due to the observable fact that it is the least persuasive thread on the discussion board.

Or possibly (in recognition of the random and frequent spewing/blurting of the words logos, ethos & pathos) the thread's name could be shortened to "RTC". (Rhetorical Tourettes Center).


.
 
Last edited:
The Data Series is another one of Hubbard's logos appeals.
 
Hubbard's KTL/LOC course are for the most part emotional or pathos appeals of persuasion. Key to Life sounds great, wow, if one had the key to life one could become successful. LOC or Life Orientation Course sounds great, discover your hat in life or your purpose, who wouldn't want that, sounds great, if one knew their purpose(hat) in life, why one could become successful. The little trick Hubbard and his cohorts did, was that these courses were ultimately designed for one to be a scientologists, it is hidden rhetoric.

The same could be said for the FEBC's, an executive doing this course, could boom a org. More rhetoric by Hubbard.
 
.

The Data Series is another one of Hubbard's logos appeals.

.
The Rhetoric Series is another one of Riddick's trollos appeals. LOL


.
 
Perhaps the name of the thread ("What is Rhetoric") needs to be changed to more accurately reflect what the thread is actually about? Maybe something closer to "WHAT ISN'T RHETORIC" due to the observable fact that it is the least persuasive thread on the discussion board.

Or possibly (in recognition of the random and frequent spewing/blurting of the words logos, ethos & pathos) the thread's name could be shortened to "RTC". (Rhetorical Tourettes Center).
How about "What Is Irony?"

Irony (from Ancient Greek εἰρωνεία eirōneía 'dissimulation, feigned ignorance'[1]), in its broadest sense, is a characterization of a situation which discloses that what on the surface appears to be the case contrasts consequentially with what is actually the case. Irony is an important rhetorical device and literary technique.
 
How about "What Is Irony?"

Irony (from Ancient Greek εἰρωνεία eirōneía 'dissimulation, feigned ignorance'[1]), in its broadest sense, is a characterization of a situation which discloses that what on the surface appears to be the case contrasts consequentially with what is actually the case. Irony is an important rhetorical device and literary technique.

Irony...such as a strong proponent of Rhetoric lacks the ability to persuade anyone?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top