To what degree is the e-meter responding to actual mental phenomena?

TheSneakster

Well-known member
The above question was asked in a new post on the Scientology sub-reddit. My response over there follows:

The Scientology Electro-Psychometer (E-Meter) is a precision ElectroDermal Activity (EDA) instrument designed to display EDA levels and responses to stimuli (not limited to auditing questions and commands) in a standardized form useful to trained Scientology auditors. These devices are calibrated such that any two of these instruments of the identical model with identical sensitivity and other settings will display any given read identically.

The short version answer to your question is that - per the below medical science article - EDA signals primarily reflect both cognitive and emotional mental activity.

The following highly technical information about EDA comes directly from a standard university medical science encyclopedia which may be found in most university library catalogues:

====================================================================
The Concise Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology and Behavioral Science, John Wiley & Sons, 2004
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electrodermal Activity [ the article title ]

Many who record electrodermal activity (EDA) today share the basic belief expressed by Carl Jung in 1907 and by some present-day lie detector operators that verbal responses do not tell all, but that EDA does reveal the secrets of “mental life.”
The skin has a special significance because it both receives outside information and responds to signals from within. As one EDA investigator stated, “We can listen in on such signals by taking advantage of the fact that their arrival at the skin is heralded by measurable electrified changes that we call electrodermal activity.” If we think of our skin as a giant receptor separating us from the rest of the world, is it any wonder that responses obtained from it would be of interest to psychologists? Today we think of EDA as a measure of the state of the organism’s interaction with its environment. EDA reflects not only emotional responding; it is also elicited by cognitive activity.

Terminology

The terms used to describe EDA have changed over the years. The term used at the turn of the nineteenth century was psychogalvanic reflex (PGR). Later the term galvanic skin response (GSR) was used. Today most psycho-physiologists have dropped this term in favor of electrodermal activity (EDA).
The electrical activity of the skin can be measured in two ways. First, a small current can be passed through the skin from an external source, and the resistance to the passage of current is then measured. This technique was first used by Feré in 1888 and is referred to as the exosomatic method. The second method, the endosomatic technique, was first used by Tarchanoff in 1889; it measures the electrical activity at the surface of the skin, with no externally imposed current. The exosomatic method has been modified today into the measurement of skin conductance (SC), the reciprocal of skin resistance. The endosomatic method is still used to measure skin potential (SP), but skin conductance recording is used today by most researchers.

When describing EDA, one can discuss basal activity (tonic) versus the response to a stimulus (phasic). When referring to tonic electrodermal activity, the convention is to use the word level (L) and when discussing phasic activity to use the word response (R). Therefore, the four common descriptions of electrodermal activity are as follows: skin conductance level (SCL), skin conductance response (SCR), skin potential level (SPL), and skin potential response (SPR).
Psychophysiological recordings show a third type of activity in addition to tonic and phasic activity. Spontaneous electrodermal activity appears in records obtained using both the SC and SP techniques.

Physiological Basis

We still don’t know a great deal about the complex relationship of the central nervous system to EDA. Peripherally, we know that eccrine sweat glands, a special type of sweat gland, are intimately involved in EDA. Eccrine sweat glands are concentrated in the palms of the hands and soles of the feet. What makes them of particular interest to psychologists is that they respond primarily to “psychic” stimulation, whereas other sweat glands respond more to increases in temperature. The eccrine sweat glands are innervated by the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system, but the chemical transmitter at the postganglionic synapse is acetylcholine, not noradrenaline, as would be expected in the sympathetic nervous system.

The eccrine sweat glands, which can be thought of as tiny tubes with their openings at the surface of the skin, act as variable resistors wired in parallel. Depending upon the degree of sympathetic activation, sweat rises toward the surface of the skin in varying amounts and in varying numbers of sweat glands. The higher the sweat rises in a given gland, the lower the resistance in that variable resistor. In some cases, but certainly not all, sweat overflows onto the surface of the skin. This hydration of the skin with salty sweat increases SCL and SPL. Years ago, it was thought that EDA was determined solely by the amount of sweat on the surface of the skin. We now know this is not so. Even in those cases where stimulation does not result in sweat at the surface of the skin, changes in EDA are often found, because even a slight rise of the sweat in the glands will change the values of the variable resistors. If we wished to quantify the EDA at a given moment, we would sum the values of all the active resistors that are wired in parallel. The sum of resistors in parallel equals the sum of their reciprocals, or conductance. This is one reason for using skin conductance rather than skin resistance when describing exosomatic EDA. A second reason is that skin conductance, unlike skin resistance, does not have to be corrected for base level. In addition to the hydration of the skin and the number of active sweat glands, other factors that may be involved in EDA include a membrane in the sweat duct wall that affects the reabsorption of sweat, and changes in pressure in the duct that affect the opening of the pores in the skin. For skin potential, it has been demonstrated that SPL of extremely relaxed subjects is determined largely by the concentration of potassium at the surface.

Factors to Control when Recording or Interpret EDA data

The following subject variables have been found to affect EDA: age, sex, race, and stage of menstrual cycle. Environmental factors that effect EDA include temperature, humidity, time of day, day of week, and season.
=================================================================
 
The above question was asked in a new post on the Scientology sub-reddit. My response over there follows:

The Scientology Electro-Psychometer (E-Meter) is a precision ElectroDermal Activity (EDA) instrument designed to display EDA levels and responses to stimuli (not limited to auditing questions and commands) in a standardized form useful to trained Scientology auditors. These devices are calibrated such that any two of these instruments of the identical model with identical sensitivity and other settings will display any given read identically.

<snip>
=================================================================
Your logical fallacy is "Proof by Verbosity". You have presented a massive flood of "proof" to prove something that, at the end, you didn't actually come anywhere near proving. Just so you know.
 
.
Your logical fallacy is "Proof by Verbosity". You have presented a massive flood of "proof" to prove something that, at the end, you didn't actually come anywhere near proving. Just so you know.
.
.


Not so fast. Dr. Hubbard's e-meter has over the previous 70 years been subjected to untold scientific tests and academic rigors.

Additionally, there are many e-meter scholars who have participated in peer reviewed studies. One such scholar (quoted below) both peered at and reviewed the science contained in the book "E-Meter Essentials".


Originally posted by William "Billy" Blowdown
Dear Bill,

I think you just completely debunked your own argument when you openly stated (admitted in fact!) that Sneakster provided "Proof by Verbosity". That's enough proof for me!

ML, Billy
2020 Ideal Scientologist of the Year

.
 
Last edited:
Electronics in religion...yahweh!

377030e02de3013a86e6005056a9545d
 
The above question was asked in a new post on the Scientology sub-reddit. My response over there follows:
first, thanks for sharing that for discussion.

and i think Bill is spot-on that the presentation is misleading. the instrument may be precise in its way (perhaps true of meters in general, but questionable in the case of e-meters), but that doesn't mean its application or results are. the electrical equipment used for ECT (electroshock) is very precise, too (and surprisingly low power, did you know that it delivers about the same electrical charge to the body that an e-meter does slowly over a session?), but its application is still crude and no one really understands just how it zaps the brain (though it's still still better researched, and proven more effective, than anything to do with the e-meter or scientology).

my basic take is that it's a crude version of a lie detector, though it does roughly indicate mental responses that result in physiological stress. modern more sophisticated polygraphs have actually been shown to be as much as much as about 75% effective or reliable (something i had to track down, see for instance the NIST study) under normal circumstances -- but that doesn't make even them very useful, the problem being that they fail at what is most critical, detecting psychopathic criminals and security risks, both of which they do not measure or detect accurately because such individuals often don't have normal physiological responses.

the scientology e-meter is a primitive, anachronistic device that has actually resisted advances in biofeedback, and so is going to be much less useful or accurate than modern devices. and on top of that, like everything in scientology it's highly subject to operator error including unintentional leading of the subject. in scientology, its effects and relative usefulness a probably increase somewhat because it's being used on a population that believes it works, and even fears it. the critics who think it does nothing at all and is merely a prop, are also wrong and, i think, missing an important part of the picture.

i'd be very interested to hear from people who've had a chance to step away and consider objectively to what extent it really 'works' -- or doesn't it. i think it's useful to understand in terms of scientology's toolbox of lures, thought reform and control mechanisms.
 
The idea that thoughts cause the hands to sweat and "unsweat" (thereby causing reads) has been disscussed before. But the sweating/unsweating process is much too slow to account for some of the more complex reads, such as rock slams. Therefore I conclude that thoughts, passing through the brain but still basically a non-physical phenomena, are affecting the e-meter directly.

I've said this before and I'll say it again: reads, particularly those on a confessional, are mainly the attempt TO NOT THINK of something. So unless you know how to do it, the more you do NOT want something to be found out, the bigger the read will be.

Helena
 
The idea that thoughts cause the hands to sweat and "unsweat" (thereby causing reads) has been disscussed before. But the sweating/unsweating process is much too slow to account for some of the more complex reads, such as rock slams. Therefore I conclude that thoughts, passing through the brain but still basically a non-physical phenomena, are affecting the e-meter directly.
from what i have read, it's an area of complexity that turns out not to be all that well understood (perhaps because it's not particularly valuable to study), but it's been found that there are instantaneous subdermal reactions such as the initial contraction of the sweat glands that also cause changes in resistance measure across the skin, and thus could account for fast or quick 'reads'. that's real science for you, digging in to explain stuff that might have seemed mysterious at first....

and i don't think that necessarily conflicts as a functional matter of the reads, it just explains the mechanism more mundanely. you sound fairly realistic about what meter reads do and don't actually indicate.
 
Last edited:
.

--snipped--
i'd be very interested to hear from people who've had a chance to step away and consider objectively to what extent it really 'works' -- or doesn't it. i think it's useful to understand in terms of scientology's toolbox of lures, thought reform and control mechanisms.
.

I don't offer a unifying theory that ties together all facets of the e-meter's use within Scientology. However, I can place a few pieces of this big jigsaw puzzle in the right location en route towards figuring out what the big completed picture is supposed to look like. Damn, wouldn't it be easier to solve if someone hadn't lost (or hidden) the cover to the jigsaw puzzle box it came in?

PUZZLE PIECE #579: Perhaps the e-meter might be best understood to fit very nicely amongst countless other more traditional methods of "psychic reading" that engage devices, tools and or diagnostic methodologies. The general heading of "divination" is a helpful framework to consider when it is defined as "...the practice of determining the hidden significance or cause of events". Scientology is in fact drowning in a vast intergalactic ocean of "causes" for everything imaginable that does or doesn't happen in life. By way of example, one of the earliest cure-all causes for mankind's plight was prenatal engrams. The e-meter provides a conversationally fluid and friendly approach that is substantially more "trainable" than the cold-reading dexterities of a crystal ball peering Romani "psychic advisor". The meter, in that sense, sometimes helps "steer", stumble upon or otherwise locate subjects that are interesting to discuss for the credulous mark to talk about---much like treasure hunter's metal detector might react when sweeping across deserted beaches in search of the illusive diamond ring. What percentage of the time does that actually happen as compared to the times the "buried treasure" being discovered is an old rusty soft drink can? Just because it is kind of interesting, I'll copy/paste here some of the "tools" that spiritual guides use to interface with their customers long before Hubbard's electro-psychometric meters became available in well stocked Scientology bookstores near you:

Common methods used for fortune telling in Europe and the Americas include astromancy, horary astrology, pendulum reading, spirit board reading, tasseography (reading tea leaves in a cup), cartomancy (fortune telling with cards), tarot card reading, crystallomancy (reading of a crystal sphere), and chiromancy (palmistry, reading of the palms). The last three have traditional associations in the popular mind with the Roma and Sinti people.​
​
Another form of fortune telling, sometimes called "reading" or "spiritual consultation", does not rely on specific devices or methods, but rather the practitioner gives the client advice and predictions which are said to have come from spirits or in visions.​


PUZZLE PIECE #1,353: Here is a subject I can offer a professional opinion on as can others here who have been trained/accredited in the use of an e-meter, auditing preclears, case supervising preclears, training auditors and re-training and/or correcting them when they fail to maintain the "professional standards" within the Engram/BT hunting industries. What I am about to reveal can well be classified as one of Scientology's Dirtiest Little Secrets. It is a horrifically simple and quick way to debunk anyone holding any notions that the e-meter "works" as a reliable diagnostic/therapeutic tool. Strangely, all persons who have ever graduated any training level in Scientology have attested in writing that they have completed all of the "E-METER DRILLS", but all we need to do is look at just one (1) of those drills they have to "pass" before they are allowed to audit others or themselves. It is known as the "wholetrack dating drill", wherein the wanna-be meter master sits 3 feet across a lunch table with their "coach" who has written down on a hidden little scrap of paper some astronomically huge number—as if the training drill was an actual auditing session where the auditor/pc needed to precisely (down to the second!) divine that wholetrack date by use of the e-meter alone. This supposes that the preclear cannot find the magical date of the incident because there is too much "charge" that occludes it. However, by the axioms of all Scientology auditing, the only means of "erasing" harmful charge is to spot or announce the nano-precise time something happened.

Well, let's do the drill, shall we? If I am the coach, I write down the following number on my paper scrap before folding it up to the student auditor can't cheat, of course, lol. Here's the number. 484,098,216,379,421 years, 287 days, 21 hours and 42 seconds. That's right, four-hundred and eighty-four trillion, ninety-eight billion, two-hundred and sixteen million, three-hundred and seventy-nine thousand, four-hundred and twenty-one years, two-hundreds and eighty-seven.....well, you get the idea.

Now the aspiring student must begin calling off "orders of magnitude" while the coach silently holds the cans--and this continues until after many dozens of hours, weeks or months the student can FIND THE HIDDEN DATE using the emeter alone!

Of course they cannot do this. Therefore the drill takes on a Sisyphean impossibility until eventually they can find the date one time. Often this involves switching to many new "coaches" until they find the one lone student in the academy who has a peculiarly simplistic needle profile where needle-pattern anomalies are incredibly easy to notice.

Now here is where the science fact vs. science fiction comes into it. One could assemble the TOP ONE THOUSAND PROFESSIONAL AUDITORS in the entire world and ask them to demonstrate how they can put any random person on the cans and find the date the first time. They cannot.

None of them can find it the first time.

I'd venture a guess that 99.99% of them cannot even find it by the 10th time they attempt.

Yes, these are the best of the best, and preclears are in many cases paying $1,000 to $1,500 per hour for "Class XII" auditing because they are flawless, right?

All auditors know this. All course supervisors know this. All "cramming" (corrections) officers know this. Yet nobody talks about it within Scientology.

The reality is that the e-meter is so primitive as a diagnostic tool that it's a near-miracle when after dozens, hundreds or thousands of attempts they can even find a "hidden date" just one time.

When I mentioned this flim-flamming fakery some years ago on ESMB, there were some believers who really became upset. I challenged them (then) and I challenge anyone now to set up an e-meter and film themselves on ESMB doing the wholetrack dating drill and getting it right the first time.

Ain't gonna happen.

Just like nothing else magical ever happens in Scientology.

And that's why the vast majority of Scientology results and "miracles" must be hidden at all costs with claims of "confidentiality" and avoidance of "over-restimulation". The only restimulation that resides within Scientology is just the normal reaction of humiliation when one's lies are publicly exposed.

Okay all you COS and INDIE auditors! Show us now how to do the wholetrack dating drill. Keep your video cameras running, no edits allowed.

Why does no Scientologist ever show up for this challenge? Is it really because they don't want to embarrass cynics by performing miracles and/or parlor tricks? LOL.


.
 
Last edited:
.


.


I don't offer a unifying theory that ties together all facets of the e-meter's use within Scientology. However, I can place a few pieces of this big jigsaw puzzle in the right location en route towards figuring out what the big completed picture is supposed to look like. Damn, wouldn't it be easier to solve if someone hadn't lost (or hidden) the cover to the jigsaw puzzle box it came in?

PUZZLE PIECE #579: Perhaps the e-meter might be best understood to fit very nicely amongst countless other more traditional methods of "psychic reading" that engage devices, tools and or diagnostic methodologies. The general heading of "divination" is a helpful framework to consider when it is defined as "...the practice of determining the hidden significance or cause of events". Scientology is in fact drowning in a vast intergalactic ocean of "causes" for everything imaginable that does or doesn't happen in life. By way of example, one of the earliest cure-all causes for mankind's plight was prenatal engrams. The e-meter provides a conversationally fluid and friendly approach that is substantially more "trainable" than the cold-reading dexterities of a crystal ball peering Romani "psychic advisor". The meter, in that sense, sometimes helps "steer", stumble upon or otherwise locate subjects that are interesting to discuss for the credulous mark to talk about---much like treasure hunter's metal detector might react when sweeping across deserted beaches in search of the illusive diamond ring. What percentage of the time does that actually happen as compared to the times the "buried treasure" being discovered is an old rusty soft drink can? Just because it is kind of interesting, I'll copy/paste here some of the "tools" that spiritual guides use to interface with their customers long before Hubbard's electro-psychometric meters became available in well stocked Scientology bookstores near you:

Common methods used for fortune telling in Europe and the Americas include astromancy, horary astrology, pendulum reading, spirit board reading, tasseography (reading tea leaves in a cup), cartomancy (fortune telling with cards), tarot card reading, crystallomancy (reading of a crystal sphere), and chiromancy (palmistry, reading of the palms). The last three have traditional associations in the popular mind with the Roma and Sinti people.​
​
Another form of fortune telling, sometimes called "reading" or "spiritual consultation", does not rely on specific devices or methods, but rather the practitioner gives the client advice and predictions which are said to have come from spirits or in visions.​


PUZZLE PIECE #1,353: Here is a subject I can offer a professional opinion on as can others here who have been trained/accredited in the use of an e-meter, auditing preclears, case supervising preclears, training auditors and re-training and/or correcting them when they fail to maintain the "professional standards" within the Engram/BT hunting industries. What I am about to reveal can well be classified as one of Scientology's Dirtiest Little Secrets. It is a horrifically simple and quick way to debunk anyone holding any notions that the e-meter "works" as a reliable diagnostic/therapeutic tool. Strangely, all persons who have ever graduated any training level in Scientology have attested in writing that they have completed all of the "E-METER DRILLS", but all we need to do is look at just one (1) of those drills they have to "pass" before they are allowed to audit others or themselves. It is known as the "wholetrack dating drill", wherein the wanna-be meter master sits 3 feet across a lunch table with their "coach" who has written down on a hidden little scrap of paper some astronomically huge number—as if the training drill was an actual auditing session where the auditor/pc needed to precisely (down to the second!) divine that wholetrack date by use of the e-meter alone. This supposes that the preclear cannot find the magical date of the incident because there is too much "charge" that occludes it. However, by the axioms of all Scientology auditing, the only means of "erasing" harmful charge is to spot or announce the nano-precise time something happened.

Well, let's do the drill, shall we? If I am the coach, I write down the following number on my paper scrap before folding it up to the student auditor can't cheat, of course, lol. Here's the number. 484,098,216,379,421 years, 287 days, 21 hours and 42 seconds. That's right, four-hundred and eighty-four trillion, ninety-eight billion, two-hundred and sixteen million, three-hundred and seventy-nine thousand, four-hundred and twenty-one years, two-hundreds and eighty-seven.....well, you get the idea.

Now the aspiring student must begin calling off "orders of magnitude" while the coach silently holds the cans--and this continues until after many dozens of hours, weeks or months the student can FIND THE HIDDEN DATE using the emeter alone!

Of course they cannot do this. Therefore the drill takes on a Sisyphean impossibility until eventually they can find the date one time. Often this involves switching to many new "coaches" until they find the one lone student in the academy who has a peculiarly simplistic needle profile where needle-pattern anomalies are incredibly easy to notice.

Now here is where the science fact vs. science fiction comes into it. One could assemble the TOP ONE THOUSAND PROFESSIONAL AUDITORS in the entire world and ask them to demonstrate how they can put any random person on the cans and find the date the first time. They cannot.

None of them can find it the first time.

I'd venture a guess that 99.99% of them cannot even find it by the 10th time they attempt.

Yes, these are the best of the best, and preclears are in many cases paying $1,000 to $1,500 per hour for "Class XII" auditing because they are flawless, right?

All auditors know this. All course supervisors know this. All "cramming" (corrections) officers know this. Yet nobody talks about it within Scientology.

The reality is that the e-meter is so primitive as a diagnostic tool that it's a near-miracle when after dozens, hundreds or thousands of attempts they can even find a "hidden date" just one time.

When I mentioned this flim-flamming fakery some years ago on ESMB, there were some believers who really became upset. I challenged them (then) and I challenge anyone now to set up an e-meter and film themselves on ESMB doing the wholetrack dating drill and getting it right the first time.

Ain't gonna happen.

Just like nothing else magical every happens in Scientology.

And that's why the vast majority of Scientology results and "miracles" must be hidden at all costs with claims of "confidentiality" and avoidance of "over-restimulation". The only restimulation that resides within Scientology is just the normal reaction of humiliation when one's lies are publicly exposed.

Okay all you COS and INDIE auditors! Show us now how to do the wholetrack dating drill. Keep your video cameras running, no edits allowed.

Why does no Scientologist ever show up for this challenge? Is it really because they don't want to embarrass cynics by performing miracles and/or parlor tricks? LOL.


.

.

Another thing to consider about the professional skills and drills that must be mastered before a Scientologist is certified as proficient with an e-meter.

There is no test in fact. There is only the student signing off their own checksheet. If there was a real test where the student auditor had to perform with live judges inspecting their meter accuracy, nobody would ever pass that test if they had to do it correctly on the FIRST TRY.

Also, even more significantly, how is the meter supposed to be reacting when it's just a fictional date being written on a scrap of paper in a course room? It's not a date which has any "charge" connected to it, so what in hell is causing all those alleged meter reads?

If a fictitious date is supposed to reliably react on an emeter, what is the reaction caused by? My best guess on this is it's simply reacting on "an excited feeling" and/or "the anticipation of an excited reaction". Fake dates don't have any "charge". So, doesn't that end the debate right there that an e-meter is locating areas of charge that must be addressed so that the preclear can regain their godlike miraculous powers?

In my experience, the meter will react for the most part to what the preclear thinks it's supposed to react on. If you are auditing someone in the early 1950, I'll bet your preclear's needle is reacting to pre-natal engrams. But a few years later, they magically won't find any prenatals because the needle will be reacting on "wholetrack implants".

When is the last time a Scientology preclear ran a pre-natal engram? LOL!!!

.
 
Your logical fallacy is "Proof by Verbosity". You have presented a massive flood of "proof" to prove something that, at the end, you didn't actually come anywhere near proving. Just so you know.
yah, Hubbard;s rhetoric is powerful. Logical fallacies are part of Hubbard's rhetoric.

Logical Fallacies - Rhetorical Argument - Research Guides at Lone Star College – University Park Library

As HH said "When is the last time a Scientology preclear ran a pre-natal engram? LOL!!! "

But, I'd add when did anybody ever run a pre-natal engram? With actual proof?

This is why I say dianetics and scientology are rhetoric. Dianetics and scientology are a complete logical fallacy which is a subset of rhetoric.
 
@Riddick

Scientology is a mixture of Hubbard's pseudo-science in training/classes and the creation of various brain neuro-transmitter effects in auditing.
I partially agree with you but not 100%.
 
like everything in scientology it's highly subject to operator error including unintentional leading of the subject

discussion elsewhere of people learning to deliberately 'beat' the meter brought to mind, i also wonder to what extent those who spend large amounts of time with the device may unconsciously learn to produce the desired result, or avoid undesirable results, without being aware of it.

it seems to me that there are just too many variables. that points to why in real science, you do double blind experiments.
 
discussion elsewhere of people learning to deliberately 'beat' the meter brought to mind, i also wonder to what extent those who spend large amounts of time with the device may unconsciously learn to produce the desired result, or avoid undesirable results, without being aware of it.


@Reyne Mayer, I'm not ignoring you, but I have repeatedly put off crafting a defensible response. This is only going to be a partial response, because I have to go through my collection of Electro-Dermal Activity (EDA) science publications to give a full one.

But here I will say this: not one person has ever "beat" or "fooled" any E-Meter, psychogalvanometer, or polygraph. Not Ever.

Why do I say this? Because these instruments are inanimate objects that are not in any sort of games condition with any subject attached to one. They display particular bio-signals. That's all they do or can do. Some designs are better or poorer at displaying those signals, of course.

The operator of one of these instruments might, perhaps, be deceived - especially, if they are poorly trained, unobservant, and/or negligent or inept in their operation. The actual bio-signals the instrument displays fall within the province of a field called psychophysiology (the study of the influence of mental activity upon the human body).

For EDA the standard university text is Electrodermal Activity by Wolfram Boucsein. The first edition was published in 2002 and was the first course textbook on this particular subject. I have linked to the 2nd Edition publish in 2012, of which I possess a full electronic copy in PDF I use for reference.

Like most university textbooks, it is dreadfully expensive at over USD $140. Persons who are seriously interested in this subject, but can't afford that kind of money would have to make use of the medical science library at their closest university. In Los Angeles, USC has it and I believe UCLA has it (check their online catalogs).
 
Last edited:
Science publications I
The psychogalvanic reflex: a review by E. Prideaux (Brain Vol. 43 Issue 1 Page 50)

This particular paper passed peer-review and is cited in virtually every scientific
publication concerning the psychogalvanic reflex in all the years from then to the
present. It is also cited in the academic text referenced above:
Electrodermal Activity by Wolfram Boucsein (published by Springer-Verlag, 2012).

It is a summary review of most of the experimental and theoretical publications on this
phenomenon published from 1878-1919. Unfortunately, most of those are in German
or French. Citations are in the bibliography at the end of the PDF version of the full
paper.

As I could not upload the Google Books copy of this important paper, I have
linked it above. It may be downloaded free of charge and really belongs in the
reference library of anyone concerned with EDA and E-Meters.

The following excerpt is a detailed description of the phenomenon and point (1)
specifically deals with the detection of mental activity.

Prideaux said:
The psychogalvanic reflex [1]: a review
by E. Prideaux
(from work carried out at Cambridge for the Medical Research Committee)
Brain, the Journal of Neurology (Vol.43 Issue 1 - May 1920)

[ The following section starts on Page 52]

PHENOMENA OF THE REFLEX.

The only fact about which there is general agreement amongst the
investigators on this subject is that the phenomena of the reflex have
been definitely established, both with and without the use of an external
current.

(1) Galvanometric deflections due to psychical [2] causes.—Any stimulus
giving rise to an emotion, such as the unexpected ringing of a bell,
flashing a light, a pin-prick or a burn, after a certain latent period will
cause a deflection which is proportional to the subjective state aroused.
An actual stimulus is not necessary, the expectation of the stimulus is
sufficient, and it is only necessary for the experimenter to walk behind
the chair of the subject for a deflection to be produced. The threat of
a stimulus often provokes a greater reaction than the stimulus itself.
Also calling up memories of painful experiences, or referring to questions
concerning which the subject may have pin-pricks of conscience, will
give a deflection.

(2) Galvanometric deflections due to physical causes.—Alterations in
contact between the skin and the electrodes will cause deflections, but
these are easily recognized. When using liquid electrodes, this deflection
is always in an opposite direction, due to withdrawal of the hands or feet
from the solution : when using metal electrodes, firm pressure on them
^ can produce a very slight deflection in the direction of the emotional
reaction, but muscular movement causing diminution of contact will
produce a deflection in an opposite direction. These deflections can be
distinguished by the fact that they take place immediately, and are not
characterized by a long latent period.

(3) Galvanometric deflections due to physiological causes.—A deep
inspiration, cough, yawn or sigh will produce a large deflection, whilst
ordinary respiratory movements will not visibly affect the galvanometer.
These deflections have a latent period of the same order as the
emotive deflections.

(4) Latent period.—The latent period varies in different people, and
in the same people at different times. It is of an average duration of
two to three seconds. The periods recorded by different observers vary
slightly, as some—Veraguth [43], Knauer [19] —make it longer, having
measured the time from the commencement of the stimulus to the
summit of the reaction, instead of to the commencement of the reaction,
as is now generally done.-

(5) After-discharge effect.—The reaction provoked by the excitation
persists for some time. This time varies considerably in different
persons ; it may last only ten to twenty seconds, or it may persist for
a few minutes.

(6) Fatigue of reflex.—After a stimulus has been repeated a few
times it begins to lose its emotive effect, and very little reaction then
occurs. It cannot be regarded as a true reflex fatigue. After a subject
has been experimented upon for some time and has become familiar
with the procedure, he may give no reactions until some new and
unexpected stimulus catches him unawares.

(7) Diminution of reflex as result of fatigue.—The same subject
will react differently to the same stimuli at different times of the day,
and at the same times on different days, according as he feels in good
or bad health. Physical or psychical fatigue diminishes the reflex.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Definitions added by me.
[1] psychogalvanic reflex - later incorrectly called "galvanic skin
response" and now called "electrodermal activity" in the psycho-
physiology community
[2] psychical - having to do with the psyche or mind
 
Last edited:
I've mentioned this before, but in my experience the meter at its very best can "measure/show" only one specific mental state which is anxiety. And that's it, you can never see any other reactions or "thoughts" and it never gets very precises or detailed.

To use a specific interrogation example: An innocent's "omfg I'm being framed!" reaction and a guilty party's "damn, I'm being exposed!" reaction - both show up in exactly the same way on the meter. That is as an increase in anxiety.

Relying on the meter as an infallible lie-detecting tool for interrogations is pure foolishness. Everyone with enough ethics experience knows this, regardless if they admit it openly or not.
 
Relying on the meter as an infallible lie-detecting tool for interrogations is pure foolishness. Everyone with enough ethics experience knows this, regardless if they admit it openly or not.

So you were only trained to use the E-Meter as an interrogation tool, correct ?

Like you didn't complete a Professional TRs and Metering course?

Did you train to at least Auditor Class II ? That is the minimum requirement specified by Ron Hubbard for HCO personnel to run Search & Discovery on suspected PTS persons in order to technically (not politically) determine whether a PTS person is Type I (suppressed in present time) or Type II (currently restimulated by some past Suppressive Person in their life).

Have you every received Method 4 (metered) Word Clearing from a competent, trained auditor ? I have.

As an example, on one occasion I had failed a checkout on an HCO Bulletin and was sent to the Word Clearer. The Word Clearer said we were going to do Method 4 and placed the first page of a 4 page legal-sized HCOB in front of me. "Put your attention on the page." (I actually felt a sort of tiny little thud) ... "What is that ?" .... "That" ... "that" as I keep looking around on that page until I zeroed in on a word that actually appeared darker to me than the rest of the page. I told her which word. Sure enough, I could not correctly define it.

We went through the word clearing drill: dictionaries, use different definitions in sentences, yada-yada. Go back to page, that page was no longer reading, continued with next page.
 
Last edited:
So you were only trained to use the E-Meter as an interrogation tool, correct ?

Like you didn't complete a Professional TRs and Metering course?

Did you train to at least Auditor Class II ? That is the minimum requirement specified by Ron Hubbard for HCO personnel to run Search & Discovery on suspected PTS persons in order to technically (not politically) determine whether a PTS person is Type I (suppressed in present time) or Type II (currently restimulated by some past Suppressive Person in their life).

Have you every received Method 4 (metered) Word Clearing from a competent, trained auditor ? I have.

As an example, on one occasion, I had failed a checkout on an HCO Bulletin and was sent to the Word Clearer. The Word Clearer said we were going to do Method 4 and place the first page of a 4 page legal-sized HCOB in front of me. "Put your attention on the page." (I actually felt a sort of tiny little thud) ... "What is that ?" .... "That" ... "that" as I keep looking around on that page until I zeroed in on a word that actually appeared darker to me than the rest of the page. I told her which word. Sure enough, I could not correctly define it.

We went through the word clearing drill: dictionaries, use different definitions in sentences, yada-yada. Go back to page, that page was no longer reading, continued with next page.

I had some training as an auditor. But I ended up doing very little actual auditing So yes, my auditing experience is very slim. My ethics experience in contrast is very substantial. I mean there were some individuals on whom I must have spent well north of 100 hours of metered interrogations. Fun stuff, let me tell you that.

Have you every received Method 4 (metered) Word Clearing from a competent, trained auditor ? I have.
I have received method 4 word clearning, even as a kid. Hated every minute of it (just as I hated most in-depth word clearing when I felt like I understand all the words to begin with.)
So your guess is as good as mine if said person was "competent".
 
I had some training as an auditor. But I ended up doing very little actual auditing and a whole ton of interrogations. So yes, my actual auditing experience is very slim.

BTW, my question was not intended to be in any way critical of yourself.

But did you actually do the Professional TRs and Metering Course ? I'm asking because E-Meter Drill 20, done standardly, teaches how the Auditor's TR's can dirty the needle and how to clean it.

As Course Admin for the SHSBC, I sometimes played PC for a student or two on various E-Meter Drills. On EM20, I get all GRR (dirty needle) from the deliberately messed up comm cycle - despite knowing about the phenomenon - I would tell the student auditor *EXACTLY* which part of the comm cycle they were violating and in what way, then laugh and they would call an F/N. "You're TR1 sort of went over my left shoulder", etc.

I could reliably produce a Theta Bop read upon demand by simply recalling a particular Near Death OOB experience when I was 4 1/2. This was before we had those E-Meter Read push button drill machines.
 
BTW, my question was not intended to be in any way critical of yourself.
Nah, I know that. And you are correct that you could wipe the floor with my auditing experience, yours is certainly far greater.

On the other hand, I'm sure I could wipe the floor with your interrogation experience. What I'm saying is that we both have a lot of experience with the meter, just using it for different purposes. I don't think it invalidates either.

I don't feel like revealing my specific training and processing info. But what I can say (and I mentioned it before) is that I was clear and I had roughly the equivalent level of training. I never got to OT I though.
 
Back
Top