TheSneakster
Well-known member
The above question was asked in a new post on the Scientology sub-reddit. My response over there follows:
The Scientology Electro-Psychometer (E-Meter) is a precision ElectroDermal Activity (EDA) instrument designed to display EDA levels and responses to stimuli (not limited to auditing questions and commands) in a standardized form useful to trained Scientology auditors. These devices are calibrated such that any two of these instruments of the identical model with identical sensitivity and other settings will display any given read identically.
The short version answer to your question is that - per the below medical science article - EDA signals primarily reflect both cognitive and emotional mental activity.
The following highly technical information about EDA comes directly from a standard university medical science encyclopedia which may be found in most university library catalogues:
====================================================================
The Concise Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology and Behavioral Science, John Wiley & Sons, 2004
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electrodermal Activity [ the article title ]
Many who record electrodermal activity (EDA) today share the basic belief expressed by Carl Jung in 1907 and by some present-day lie detector operators that verbal responses do not tell all, but that EDA does reveal the secrets of “mental life.”
The skin has a special significance because it both receives outside information and responds to signals from within. As one EDA investigator stated, “We can listen in on such signals by taking advantage of the fact that their arrival at the skin is heralded by measurable electrified changes that we call electrodermal activity.” If we think of our skin as a giant receptor separating us from the rest of the world, is it any wonder that responses obtained from it would be of interest to psychologists? Today we think of EDA as a measure of the state of the organism’s interaction with its environment. EDA reflects not only emotional responding; it is also elicited by cognitive activity.
Terminology
The terms used to describe EDA have changed over the years. The term used at the turn of the nineteenth century was psychogalvanic reflex (PGR). Later the term galvanic skin response (GSR) was used. Today most psycho-physiologists have dropped this term in favor of electrodermal activity (EDA).
The electrical activity of the skin can be measured in two ways. First, a small current can be passed through the skin from an external source, and the resistance to the passage of current is then measured. This technique was first used by Feré in 1888 and is referred to as the exosomatic method. The second method, the endosomatic technique, was first used by Tarchanoff in 1889; it measures the electrical activity at the surface of the skin, with no externally imposed current. The exosomatic method has been modified today into the measurement of skin conductance (SC), the reciprocal of skin resistance. The endosomatic method is still used to measure skin potential (SP), but skin conductance recording is used today by most researchers.
When describing EDA, one can discuss basal activity (tonic) versus the response to a stimulus (phasic). When referring to tonic electrodermal activity, the convention is to use the word level (L) and when discussing phasic activity to use the word response (R). Therefore, the four common descriptions of electrodermal activity are as follows: skin conductance level (SCL), skin conductance response (SCR), skin potential level (SPL), and skin potential response (SPR).
Psychophysiological recordings show a third type of activity in addition to tonic and phasic activity. Spontaneous electrodermal activity appears in records obtained using both the SC and SP techniques.
Physiological Basis
We still don’t know a great deal about the complex relationship of the central nervous system to EDA. Peripherally, we know that eccrine sweat glands, a special type of sweat gland, are intimately involved in EDA. Eccrine sweat glands are concentrated in the palms of the hands and soles of the feet. What makes them of particular interest to psychologists is that they respond primarily to “psychic” stimulation, whereas other sweat glands respond more to increases in temperature. The eccrine sweat glands are innervated by the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system, but the chemical transmitter at the postganglionic synapse is acetylcholine, not noradrenaline, as would be expected in the sympathetic nervous system.
The eccrine sweat glands, which can be thought of as tiny tubes with their openings at the surface of the skin, act as variable resistors wired in parallel. Depending upon the degree of sympathetic activation, sweat rises toward the surface of the skin in varying amounts and in varying numbers of sweat glands. The higher the sweat rises in a given gland, the lower the resistance in that variable resistor. In some cases, but certainly not all, sweat overflows onto the surface of the skin. This hydration of the skin with salty sweat increases SCL and SPL. Years ago, it was thought that EDA was determined solely by the amount of sweat on the surface of the skin. We now know this is not so. Even in those cases where stimulation does not result in sweat at the surface of the skin, changes in EDA are often found, because even a slight rise of the sweat in the glands will change the values of the variable resistors. If we wished to quantify the EDA at a given moment, we would sum the values of all the active resistors that are wired in parallel. The sum of resistors in parallel equals the sum of their reciprocals, or conductance. This is one reason for using skin conductance rather than skin resistance when describing exosomatic EDA. A second reason is that skin conductance, unlike skin resistance, does not have to be corrected for base level. In addition to the hydration of the skin and the number of active sweat glands, other factors that may be involved in EDA include a membrane in the sweat duct wall that affects the reabsorption of sweat, and changes in pressure in the duct that affect the opening of the pores in the skin. For skin potential, it has been demonstrated that SPL of extremely relaxed subjects is determined largely by the concentration of potassium at the surface.
Factors to Control when Recording or Interpret EDA data
The following subject variables have been found to affect EDA: age, sex, race, and stage of menstrual cycle. Environmental factors that effect EDA include temperature, humidity, time of day, day of week, and season.
=================================================================
The Scientology Electro-Psychometer (E-Meter) is a precision ElectroDermal Activity (EDA) instrument designed to display EDA levels and responses to stimuli (not limited to auditing questions and commands) in a standardized form useful to trained Scientology auditors. These devices are calibrated such that any two of these instruments of the identical model with identical sensitivity and other settings will display any given read identically.
The short version answer to your question is that - per the below medical science article - EDA signals primarily reflect both cognitive and emotional mental activity.
The following highly technical information about EDA comes directly from a standard university medical science encyclopedia which may be found in most university library catalogues:
====================================================================
The Concise Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology and Behavioral Science, John Wiley & Sons, 2004
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Electrodermal Activity [ the article title ]
Many who record electrodermal activity (EDA) today share the basic belief expressed by Carl Jung in 1907 and by some present-day lie detector operators that verbal responses do not tell all, but that EDA does reveal the secrets of “mental life.”
The skin has a special significance because it both receives outside information and responds to signals from within. As one EDA investigator stated, “We can listen in on such signals by taking advantage of the fact that their arrival at the skin is heralded by measurable electrified changes that we call electrodermal activity.” If we think of our skin as a giant receptor separating us from the rest of the world, is it any wonder that responses obtained from it would be of interest to psychologists? Today we think of EDA as a measure of the state of the organism’s interaction with its environment. EDA reflects not only emotional responding; it is also elicited by cognitive activity.
Terminology
The terms used to describe EDA have changed over the years. The term used at the turn of the nineteenth century was psychogalvanic reflex (PGR). Later the term galvanic skin response (GSR) was used. Today most psycho-physiologists have dropped this term in favor of electrodermal activity (EDA).
The electrical activity of the skin can be measured in two ways. First, a small current can be passed through the skin from an external source, and the resistance to the passage of current is then measured. This technique was first used by Feré in 1888 and is referred to as the exosomatic method. The second method, the endosomatic technique, was first used by Tarchanoff in 1889; it measures the electrical activity at the surface of the skin, with no externally imposed current. The exosomatic method has been modified today into the measurement of skin conductance (SC), the reciprocal of skin resistance. The endosomatic method is still used to measure skin potential (SP), but skin conductance recording is used today by most researchers.
When describing EDA, one can discuss basal activity (tonic) versus the response to a stimulus (phasic). When referring to tonic electrodermal activity, the convention is to use the word level (L) and when discussing phasic activity to use the word response (R). Therefore, the four common descriptions of electrodermal activity are as follows: skin conductance level (SCL), skin conductance response (SCR), skin potential level (SPL), and skin potential response (SPR).
Psychophysiological recordings show a third type of activity in addition to tonic and phasic activity. Spontaneous electrodermal activity appears in records obtained using both the SC and SP techniques.
Physiological Basis
We still don’t know a great deal about the complex relationship of the central nervous system to EDA. Peripherally, we know that eccrine sweat glands, a special type of sweat gland, are intimately involved in EDA. Eccrine sweat glands are concentrated in the palms of the hands and soles of the feet. What makes them of particular interest to psychologists is that they respond primarily to “psychic” stimulation, whereas other sweat glands respond more to increases in temperature. The eccrine sweat glands are innervated by the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system, but the chemical transmitter at the postganglionic synapse is acetylcholine, not noradrenaline, as would be expected in the sympathetic nervous system.
The eccrine sweat glands, which can be thought of as tiny tubes with their openings at the surface of the skin, act as variable resistors wired in parallel. Depending upon the degree of sympathetic activation, sweat rises toward the surface of the skin in varying amounts and in varying numbers of sweat glands. The higher the sweat rises in a given gland, the lower the resistance in that variable resistor. In some cases, but certainly not all, sweat overflows onto the surface of the skin. This hydration of the skin with salty sweat increases SCL and SPL. Years ago, it was thought that EDA was determined solely by the amount of sweat on the surface of the skin. We now know this is not so. Even in those cases where stimulation does not result in sweat at the surface of the skin, changes in EDA are often found, because even a slight rise of the sweat in the glands will change the values of the variable resistors. If we wished to quantify the EDA at a given moment, we would sum the values of all the active resistors that are wired in parallel. The sum of resistors in parallel equals the sum of their reciprocals, or conductance. This is one reason for using skin conductance rather than skin resistance when describing exosomatic EDA. A second reason is that skin conductance, unlike skin resistance, does not have to be corrected for base level. In addition to the hydration of the skin and the number of active sweat glands, other factors that may be involved in EDA include a membrane in the sweat duct wall that affects the reabsorption of sweat, and changes in pressure in the duct that affect the opening of the pores in the skin. For skin potential, it has been demonstrated that SPL of extremely relaxed subjects is determined largely by the concentration of potassium at the surface.
Factors to Control when Recording or Interpret EDA data
The following subject variables have been found to affect EDA: age, sex, race, and stage of menstrual cycle. Environmental factors that effect EDA include temperature, humidity, time of day, day of week, and season.
=================================================================