Is the Emeter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

that seems potentially self-referential if not circular. does that really tell us anything other than that maybe the auditor and the PC have been indoctrinated, trained and conditioned to produce the results they are expected to -- like 'remembering' past lives (and improbable infantile and prenatal traumas) that are mostly if not entirely fabrications based on implanted expectations?



didn't David Mayo of all people, join the others who gave up on using the meter? seems like a lot of the best people concluded that either things could be one without a meter, or what couldn't be wasn't of any real value.
Thousands of auditors over the years observed millions of e-meter "reads". Not all of them can be attributed to imagination or leading by the auditor. It branches off into a discussion of the multitude of scn processes and what caused the reads.

Freezoners may be getting reads on who knows what.

Mayo's group offered the OT levels so I assume they used e-meters. "Auditing" BTs without an e-meter would be an adventure. I didn't do the OT levels so somebody else might suggest what that would be like. :dizzy:
 
Thousands of auditors over the years observed millions of e-meter "reads". Not all of them can be attributed to imagination or leading by the auditor. It branches off into a discussion of the multitude of scn processes and what caused the reads.

Freezoners may be getting reads on who knows what.

Mayo's group offered the OT levels so I assume they used e-meters. "Auditing" BTs without an e-meter would be an adventure. I didn't do the OT levels so somebody else might suggest what that would be like. :dizzy:
On the clearing course, and OT 2, you have lists (platens) of reliable items (RI) taken from whole track implants. You are holding the solo cans in one hand, pen in the other. You look at the first item and note the read, you look at it again until it goes flat, then go to the next item.
example:

You take the out the platten (list) of RIs from the Woke GPM and uncover the first one and look at it:

RI: # 11 to be very woke

You put you attention on it, then write a slash for each read, and an x when it stops reading, so your w/s looks like this:

#11 //////X

Then you go to #12, which is: to not be very woke

#12 //X

Etc.

You don't write the RIs on the w/s so you don't restim the c/s. Just the #s

All the RIs are opposing pairs, as above. The different implants don't all have the same # of RIs one to another.

Mimsey
 
Last edited:
On the clearing course, and OT 2, you have lists (platens) of reliable items (RI) taken from whole track implants. You are holding the solo cans in one hand, pen in the other. You look at the first item and note the read, you look at it again until it goes flat, then go to the next item.
example:

You take the out the platten (list) of RIs from the Woke GPM and uncover the first one and look at it:

RI: # 11 to be very woke

You put you attention on it, then write a slash for each read, and an x when it stops reading, so your w/s looks like this:

#11 //////X

Then you go to #12, which is: to not be very woke

#12 //X

Etc.

You don't write the RIs on the w/s so you don't restim the c/s. Just the #s

All the RIs are opposing pairs, as above. The different implants don't all have the same # of RIs one to another.

Mimsey
By the time one reaches the OT levels they have developed a belief in past lives and theoreticals like whole track implants might be considered. Additionally, and this is just my two cents, in the process of auditing one develops the ability to quickly access an unfiltered and uncensored part of the the mind. Maybe call it stream of consciousness or some would call it vivid imagination. This would allow other past track items to be considered by some people to be subjective reality.

That said millions or billions of people over time give credence to things generally considered paranormal or supernatural.

While I'm at it here is an interpretation of BTs. I might consider I start out with a Basic Personality. Over time an unlimited number of interactions with other people like parents, siblings, teachers and even just people in general might cause "impressions" and cause me to assume parts of their personality. Book and movie heroes or villains and other personalities might also enter the equation.
 
Last edited:
On the clearing course, and OT 2, you have lists (platens) of reliable items (RI) taken from whole track implants. You are holding the solo cans in one hand, pen in the other. You look at the first item and note the read, you look at it again until it goes flat, then go to the next item.
example:

You take the out the platten (list) of RIs from the Woke GPM and uncover the first one and look at it:

RI: # 11 to be very woke

You put you attention on it, then write a slash for each read, and an x when it stops reading, so your w/s looks like this:

#11 //////X

Then you go to #12, which is: to not be very woke

#12 //X

Etc.

You don't write the RIs on the w/s so you don't restim the c/s. Just the #s

All the RIs are opposing pairs, as above. The different implants don't all have the same # of RIs one to another.

Mimsey

Sorry but I
 
On the clearing course, and OT 2, you have lists (platens) of reliable items (RI) taken from whole track implants. You are holding the solo cans in one hand, pen in the other. You look at the first item and note the read, you look at it again until it goes flat, then go to the next item.
example:

You take the out the platten (list) of RIs from the Woke GPM and uncover the first one and look at it:

RI: # 11 to be very woke

You put you attention on it, then write a slash for each read, and an x when it stops reading, so your w/s looks like this:

#11 //////X

Then you go to #12, which is: to not be very woke

#12 //X

Etc.

You don't write the RIs on the w/s so you don't restim the c/s. Just the #s

All the RIs are opposing pairs, as above. The different implants don't all have the same # of RIs one to another.

Mimsey
Since you mentioned GPMs, goals, problems and mass are just common King's English words. Go ahead and post some real GPMs from the platens and I'll see if they read.


Joke - I don't own an e-meter. Probably like a lot of processes some people got some benefit while some didn't.
 
Last edited:
How might it be better? The problem with E-meters and lie detectors is the same - they are unreliable. They don't work on the person who did the crime but doesn't think it was a crime, for instance. Not a peep. Crickets. Tumbleweeds.

modern polygraphs (not to mention biofeedback equipment) would at least likely be more reliable and useful than a simple, unscientific, single-input e-meter. i've read that polygraphs for example are 70-80% effective with most people - it's just that as you point out, they are not effective at finding the small percentage you really want to ferret out in applications like like criminology and security, and thus almost worthless for those particular applications (just as for example your car would be no good on a race track, but pretty reliable for a cross-country highway trip).

i don't know that other equipment would be enough more indicative or reliable to really be useful, but it would be interesting -- and arguably a necessary part of any really rigorous inquiry into the e-meter -- to at least try it. there are at least some claims that modern biofeedback equipment has a worthwhile level of therapeutic effectiveness, and i suspect ultimately when it comes to things like MRI, CAT and PET technology that some turn out to truly be useful (they already provide insightful research information about brain functions, just not individual therapy).

You can't trust any meter 100% of the time. the mind is too complex.

yes, i think that's one of the problems, it certainly can't be treated as completely reliable -- and also, as pathological criminals point to, can't be counted on to work the same on all people (modern brain research equipment is also shedding light on how individuals' brains work differently) just as for example some medicines are great for some people but ineffective or even dangerous for others, LRH's attempt to impose uniformity and black-and-white answers is fundamentally flawed.

i'm actually sort of in the middle on this, i think it's wrong to say the e-meter does nothing, but also to say that it's really a useful therapeutic tool either.
 
Thousands of auditors over the years observed millions of e-meter "reads". Not all of them can be attributed to imagination or leading by the auditor. It branches off into a discussion of the multitude of scn processes and what caused the reads.

i agree there's some of that going on -- but from all indications of historical results (or lack of) and every attempt, not enough to be that useful, partly because there is too much of the other (spurious phenomenon).

Mayo's group offered the OT levels so I assume they used e-meters.

I'd love to hear from someone who knows the answer to that, i've only heard that Mayo (who may even have said it himself during one of the conference segments i once listed to) gave up on the meter, at least for most things.

Mayo candidly told me that he had spent very little time attending to Hubbard’s “body thetans” – the little spirits exorcised on every OT level from III-VII – but rather had concentrated on ‘“misownership.”
....
I spoke to David again in 1988, by which time Gerbode wanted to cut him loose. Gerbode’s deputy, Gerry French, was complaining that David had become autocratic. I had heard David giving him a dressing down. Gerbode followed my suggestion that he put Mayo on a sabbatical, then quietly sever their connection.

I think by this time David was in an agony about the workability of Scientology. Julia can tell us if this was really so. But, I had pestered Gerbode and Mayo to drop OT III back in 1986 – I’d dealt with several cases of damage caused on that level, and found that the mental asylum nearest to Saint Hill expected about two cases of acute psychosis a year caused by OT III (I advised them not to use any drugs, and allow the psychosis to die down – they were surprisingly receptive and very concerned, contrary to Hubbard’s position about “psychs”). To my relief, by 1988 the OT levels were gone, and Traumatic Incident Reduction (aka New Era Dianetics) was the center of the new Institute for Research into Metapsychology’s “bridge.”
Atack: What David Mayo told me about L. Ron Hubbard, Scientology, and the upper levels | The Underground Bunker

also, Gerbode is an example that it's a false assumption, that there's never been money to study this sort of stuff. besides bailing out Mayo's AAC, he must have spent a good bit of his wealth on the research into TIR, which required stripping out everything that couldn't actually be proven reliably -- the e-meter and much of the rest.
 
Last edited:
"Mathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function. "

Just so you know, the only thing valuable in the Mathison's emeter was that they had telefunkun 12AX7 tubes. Those sell for about 100 bucks, other than that, it's a quack machine.
Quackery: A Brief History of Quack Medicines & Peddlers (historyonthenet.com)

The emeter is a quack machine.

On a laughing note, thank god DM has secured the future of mankind by building a underground bunker having all of Hubbard's writings secured underground in case of a nuclear war. It's amazing to me that DM got people to donate to that. And even the IAS.

LOL

Nobody went clear or OT using the emeter.
 
I'm still waiting for any past life person using dianetics tech or scientology tech to return from past life.
 
I'm still waiting for any past life person using dianetics tech or scientology tech to return from past life.
If they went into the past and didn't return - perhaps they are trying to tell you something. Kidding aside - how many people have you asked? I had a good discussion with a redhead IAS reg at Flag who was a former Scientologist in a previous life which is why she joined the SO this life. Was what she said true? Dunno, but she believed it was.

Mimsey
 
Since you mentioned GPMs, goals, problems and mass are just common King's English words. Go ahead and post some real GPMs from the platens and I'll see if they read.


Joke - I don't own an e-meter. Probably like a lot of processes some people got some benefit while some didn't.
Possibly there's some OT 2 or CC materials on the interweb, or you can look up the tech volumes from the early 60's - there's a couple bulletins with line plots in them. A goals problem mass is, in Scientology, a specific thing in the mind:

1. the goal has been balked for eons by opposing forces. The goal pointed one way, the opposing forces point exactly opposite and against it. If you took two fire hoses and pointed them at each other, their streams would not reach each other’s nozzles, but would splatter against one another in midair. If this splatter were to hang there, it would be a ball of messed up water. Call hose A the force the pc has used to execute his goal. Call hose B the force other dynamics have used to oppose that goal. Where these two forces have perpetually met, a mental mass is created. This is the picture of any problem-force opposing force with resultant mass. Where the pc’s goal meets constant opposition, you have in the reactive mind the resultant mass caused by the two forces- Goal=force of getting it done, Opposition=force opposing it getting done. This is the goal problem mass. (HCOB 20 Nov 61)

2. is fundamentally founded on a goal. They’re a conglomeration of identities which are counter-opposed, and these identities are hung up on the postulate-counter- postulate of a problem. (SH Spec 243, 6302C26)

3. constituted of items, beingnesses, that the person has been and has fought. (SH Spec 137, 6204C24)

4. the problem created by two or more opposing ideas which being opposed, balanced, and unresolved, make a mass. It’s a mental energy mass. (SH Spec 83, 6612C06)

5. items (valences) in opposition to one another. Any pair of these items, in opposition to each other, constitute a specific problem. (HCOB 23 Nov 62)

Goals-Problem-Mass
 
Since you mentioned GPMs, goals, problems and mass are just common King's English words. Go ahead and post some real GPMs from the platens and I'll see if they read.


Joke - I don't own an e-meter. Probably like a lot of processes some people got some benefit while some didn't.
OT II Course, summary and comments
In OT 2, OT COURSE - SECTION TWO - INSTRUCTIONS

Hubbard gives instructions for the 'whole track tables', that is: the timeline of trillions of years of memory Scientologists claim to have. There are supposedly ten of them. In the following I will try to summarize it, because my lawyer, after having finally having seen evidence handed over to him on behalf of RTC, has advised me that including the full text is at this time against my interests. So be it. I therefore will give you this summary, taken from Michael Robinson's article Oparating Thetan Summary and Analysis.Your comments are kindly invited. Please correct any errors and tell me about any information that I may have missed.
According to Hubbard, there are ten of these 'whole track' tables or time lines. Each time line contains only one GPM or 'Goals Problems Mass' (according to Martin Hunt's dictionary: "a supposed mass which develops when one is thwarted from reaching a Goal by a Problem or stop.") Each set should be run separately:
The GPM found in each set are as follows: ELECTRICAL, TOCKY, BIG BEING, HOUSE, PSYCHO, BANKY, FORERUNNER, BASIC-BASIC, BASIC, THE COMMAND, LOWER LP, LP, and BODY GPM. In addition to these GPM, there are a number of Implant Incidents which have no line plot, as follows: THE ARROW, DOUBLE ROD, WOMAN, WHITE BLACK SPHERE, HOT COLD, LAUGHTER CALM, and DANCE MOB.
The GPM in these "whole track tables" are supposedly the residual mass of incidents that happened untold numbers of lifetimes ago to the individual's immortal "thetan". Approximate dates for each of the incidents are provided, although some, such as "about trillions 214th Power years ago" for the BASIC BASIC GPM, challenge credulity regardless.

More at link:

 
By the time one reaches the OT levels they have developed a belief in past lives and theoreticals like whole track implants might be considered. Additionally, and this is just my two cents, in the process of auditing one develops the ability to quickly access an unfiltered and uncensored part of the the mind. Maybe call it stream of consciousness or some would call it vivid imagination. This would allow other past track items to be considered by some people to be subjective reality.

That said millions or billions of people over time give credence to things generally considered paranormal or supernatural.

While I'm at it here is an interpretation of BTs. I might consider I start out with a Basic Personality. Over time an unlimited number of interactions with other people like parents, siblings, teachers and even just people in general might cause "impressions" and cause me to assume parts of their personality. Book and movie heroes or villains and other personalities might also enter the equation.
There's something like that in Robert Monroe's work where you have a collection of your past life identities you carry with you. When you die, your Zertel identity will be added the collection as you ( the spirit) assume another life and a new identity.

Mimsey
 
But I what?

Sorry about that Mimsey.

I can't remember what I was going to say now. I suspect I was going to say something along the lines of OT2 being a load of rubbish to put it politely), then I held back because I didn't want to be taken to task for it by people who did believe there was something in it and forgot that I'd posted anything at all.

But yes, I wouldn't bet 2 British pennies (and that's not a lot of money) on there being any truth in the story as revealed by LRH in the OT 2 materials. I don't put much store in OT 3 either.
 
By the time one reaches the OT levels they have developed a belief in past lives and theoreticals like whole track implants might be considered. Additionally, and this is just my two cents, in the process of auditing one develops the ability to quickly access an unfiltered and uncensored part of the the mind. Maybe call it stream of consciousness or some would call it vivid imagination. This would allow other past track items to be considered by some people to be subjective reality.

That said millions or billions of people over time give credence to things generally considered paranormal or supernatural.

While I'm at it here is an interpretation of BTs. I might consider I start out with a Basic Personality. Over time an unlimited number of interactions with other people like parents, siblings, teachers and even just people in general might cause "impressions" and cause me to assume parts of their personality. Book and movie heroes or villains and other personalities might also enter the equation.


Uhhh no. You are the strongest personality to be with the body. You beat out all the other beings so that you are top dog to run the body. The other beings, you label BT's are mostly asleep, but they seem to get the top dogs to also believe they are bodies.
Just because THEY believe they are the body, doesn't make it true.
 
Last edited:
OT II Course, summary and comments
In OT 2, OT COURSE - SECTION TWO - INSTRUCTIONS

Hubbard gives instructions for the 'whole track tables', that is: the timeline of trillions of years of memory Scientologists claim to have. There are supposedly ten of them. In the following I will try to summarize it, because my lawyer, after having finally having seen evidence handed over to him on behalf of RTC, has advised me that including the full text is at this time against my interests. So be it. I therefore will give you this summary, taken from Michael Robinson's article Oparating Thetan Summary and Analysis.Your comments are kindly invited. Please correct any errors and tell me about any information that I may have missed.
According to Hubbard, there are ten of these 'whole track' tables or time lines. Each time line contains only one GPM or 'Goals Problems Mass' (according to Martin Hunt's dictionary: "a supposed mass which develops when one is thwarted from reaching a Goal by a Problem or stop.") Each set should be run separately:
The GPM found in each set are as follows: ELECTRICAL, TOCKY, BIG BEING, HOUSE, PSYCHO, BANKY, FORERUNNER, BASIC-BASIC, BASIC, THE COMMAND, LOWER LP, LP, and BODY GPM. In addition to these GPM, there are a number of Implant Incidents which have no line plot, as follows: THE ARROW, DOUBLE ROD, WOMAN, WHITE BLACK SPHERE, HOT COLD, LAUGHTER CALM, and DANCE MOB.
The GPM in these "whole track tables" are supposedly the residual mass of incidents that happened untold numbers of lifetimes ago to the individual's immortal "thetan". Approximate dates for each of the incidents are provided, although some, such as "about trillions 214th Power years ago" for the BASIC BASIC GPM, challenge credulity regardless.

More at link:

ELECTRICAL, TOCKY, BIG BEING, HOUSE, PSYCHO, BANKY, . . . . etc.
Laughter - I can see Hubbard sitting down while on the cans with Mary Sue or another auditor saying, "That! That! That!" and listing out these "GPMs". Imagination has no limit. Whoever was doing the auditing obviously wouldn't contradict the Big Guy, just write them down and keep going.
 
Last edited:
Possibly there's some OT 2 or CC materials on the interweb, or you can look up the tech volumes from the early 60's - there's a couple bulletins with line plots in them. A goals problem mass is, in Scientology, a specific thing in the mind:

1. the goal has been balked for eons by opposing forces. The goal pointed one way, the opposing forces point exactly opposite and against it. If you took two fire hoses and pointed them at each other, their streams would not reach each other’s nozzles, but would splatter against one another in midair. If this splatter were to hang there, it would be a ball of messed up water. Call hose A the force the pc has used to execute his goal. Call hose B the force other dynamics have used to oppose that goal. Where these two forces have perpetually met, a mental mass is created. This is the picture of any problem-force opposing force with resultant mass. Where the pc’s goal meets constant opposition, you have in the reactive mind the resultant mass caused by the two forces- Goal=force of getting it done, Opposition=force opposing it getting done. This is the goal problem mass. (HCOB 20 Nov 61)

2. is fundamentally founded on a goal. They’re a conglomeration of identities which are counter-opposed, and these identities are hung up on the postulate-counter- postulate of a problem. (SH Spec 243, 6302C26)

3. constituted of items, beingnesses, that the person has been and has fought. (SH Spec 137, 6204C24)

4. the problem created by two or more opposing ideas which being opposed, balanced, and unresolved, make a mass. It’s a mental energy mass. (SH Spec 83, 6612C06)

5. items (valences) in opposition to one another. Any pair of these items, in opposition to each other, constitute a specific problem. (HCOB 23 Nov 62)

Goals-Problem-Mass
As usual with a lot of processes at a quick glance they might seem to make some sense. Opposing forces thwarting your goals or something like that. Digging deeper it goes to extremes. On the lower levels maybe up to and including dianetic clear it wasn't necessary to accept as factual all of Hubbard's fantastical notions. Doing the Clearing Course which included GPMs would require greater acceptance.
 
Last edited:
Laughter - I can see Hubbard sitting down while on the cans with Mary Sue or another auditor saying, "That! That! That!" and listing out these "GPMs". Imagination has no bounds. Whoever was doing the auditing obviously wouldn't contradict the Big Guy, just write them down and keep going.
He researched it solo when he was in Rhodesia. Some years later, Otto Roos was FESing Ron's folders, and Ron (violating the ivory tower rule) read them and blew up at MSH and made her recant all the R/S reads she found on him.

Mimsey
 
He researched it solo when he was in Rhodesia. Some years later, Otto Roos was FESing Ron's folders, and Ron (violating the ivory tower rule) read them and blew up at MSH and made her recant all the R/S reads she found on him.

Mimsey
I had to look up FES. Folder Error Summary

While I'm here for the benefit of never-ins or passersby,

R/S is a Rock Slam, an e-meter read supposedly indicating an evil purpose or evil intention

ivory tower rule without looking it up is never look at what your auditors or case supervisors are saying about your "case" (the case supervisor lives in an ivory tower)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top