Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The original Mark V meter where Hubbard claimed he discovered OT stuff, back in 1952, the PDC's, well, those emeters never had EMI suppression
He was using Voley's mains meter.
This meter [Mark I transistor meter] was patented in 1966
And it was a revision of an earlier one, as noted in the patent. "DEVICE FOR MEASURING AND INDICATING CHANGES IN RESISTANCE OF A LIVING BODYMathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function.
mimsey borogrove said:
This meter [Mark I transistor meter] was patented in 1966
The patent was granted in December, 1966, but applied for in June, 1965.
Device for Measuring and Indicating Changes in
the Resistance of a Human Body
Inventor: Lafayette R. Hubbard
I wouldn't let HH get to you, he can be a robot.
So in this scenario, Statpush has properly noted that the e-meter produces some "effect". It's untethered to any product or consumer/industrial value or demand in the marketplace. The e-meter needle REACTED! So he wants to study it. But even if he studies it, there is no intended use or purpose if Hubbard's Clearing and OT technologies don't result in Clears and OTs.
That's not uncommon - You hire a tech to make your idea a reality and sell the product as yours. While Bill Gates may have had the idea for DOS ( or was it personal computers?) he takes all the credit, yet has myriad of programers working for him who are uncredited.at least they had to accurately list just what it does -- and only that.
and what LRH may have been given the honor of being listed as the inventor, isn't this just another case where he ended up getting credit for what was really others' work? did he even oversee specifications and testing that much?
yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people?
I read thru the patent link you provided, it never states what you said. A analog meter cannot provide EMI suppression. Additionally, I don't even think Hubbard had access to measuring db in the days of the 1950's. db's is decibels.So now you imagine yourself to be a superior analog electronics expert to Don Breeding and Joe Wallis ?
After consulting the circuit diagram and detailed explanation in the patent filing (US3290589A), one may see that the transistor Mark Vs do not require EMI suppression for two reasons:
(a) Signal to Noise ratio at the amplifier input is around -60db to -70db for the approximately 100 microvolts of EMI noise that may be found on a human body relative to the 6 volts @ 20 milliamps from the meter bridge circuit (which is not Wheatstone's Bridge). The amplifer circuit gives about 200 times signal gain at the maximum Sensitivity setting which is about 45db. Any EMI noise still remains very weak compared to the amplified signal.
(b) A D'Arsenval moving-coil galvanometer (microammeter 100uA max) acts as a electro-mechanical low pass filter and attenuates any frequencies over about 10Hz with such a steep fall off as to render even amplified EMI noise invisible to the operator of the meter, even at the highest Sensitivity setting.
It is the meter movement itself that acts as the EMI noise suppressor.
I already said what's the point more or less because nobody went clear or OT. It's quite interesting making a post here and see responses.yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people? or try to account as fully as possible for all the cases of psychosis that resulted, and then try to determine just what caused them?
here's another of the things that i think should be obvious but somehow tends to get overlooked, probably due to a myopic focus on 'source' and old learned habits: why not try to understand the phenomenon by using better equipment, like modern biofeedback technology that say includes GSR sensing plus pulse, breathing rate, and other things including possibly even the latest in brain function detection -- exactly what Hubbard failed to do, take advantage of actual advances.
While what you are saying may be true...its not the topic of this thread. Why post on a thread and say "this thread should really be about..."?yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people? or try to account as fully as possible for all the cases of psychosis that resulted, and then try to determine just what caused them?
here's another of the things that i think should be obvious but somehow tends to get overlooked, probably due to a myopic focus on 'source' and old learned habits: why not try to understand the phenomenon by using better equipment, like modern biofeedback technology that say includes GSR sensing plus pulse, breathing rate, and other things including possibly even the latest in brain function detection -- exactly what Hubbard failed to do, take advantage of actual advances.
From a strictly pragmatic point of view as I mentioned in my first post, #4, the e-meter worked as expected in auditing sessions. Thousands of auditors over the years would agree. Probably most scn and dn procedures could not even be done without using the e-meter. Take a guess at which item(s) to run? Some auditors after leaving the cherch with thousands of hours of experience might have done some freelancing without an e-meter but that's the exception rather than the rule. Scientology is not a path to Total Freedom or Nirvana but which if any parts of it are worthwhile continues to be debated.While what you are saying may be true...its not the topic of this thread. Why post on a thread and say "this thread should really be about..."?
It obviously is not for you.
While what you are saying may be true...its not the topic of this thread. Why post on a thread and say "this thread should really be about..."?
It obviously is not for you.
There is no money to be made from researching and investigating the use of the e-meter in scn auditing so nobody will ever do it. The e-meter works as expected in auditing sessions. Keep it simple.it seems to me whether better technology might be useful, is in fact relevant to the topic of this thread. first, the fact that Hubbard failed to take advantage of advances in biofeedback technology, sticking with what is essentially an early 20th century if not late 19th century device, is i think a telling thought-experiment regarding his attitude and approach, as the title of the thread asks about. and, if you want to do some sort of investigation of the phenomena at work (which isn't really the topic of this thread, is it?) then wouldn't you need better tools to say try to understand things like non-sweat related subdermal reactions that could quickly change skin resistance, or even to use as diagnostic measures for the e-meter itself, and its readings?
also, if you want to quantify the phenomenon being observed, isn't a an online thread the wrong place to be doing that, as 70 years of theorizing and shooting the breeze even sitting around in person has produced nothing really conclusive in that regard? shouldn't it be at some technical conference, or in a research lab, that you would want to set up for that purpose?
i'm just trying to offer some outsider perspective, and perhaps help avoid repeating mistakes regarding this subject.
how does the emeter work as expected as nobody went clear or OT?There is no money to be made from researching and investigating the use of the e-meter in scn auditing so nobody will ever do it. The e-meter works as expected in auditing sessions. Keep it simple.
The wiki e-meter article (post # 29) provides some in depth discussion. Other than that a scn blog or forum might be the best place to speculate.
A treatise on the e-meter on a scn forum is noted in post # 9.
From a strictly pragmatic point of view as I mentioned in my first post, #4, the e-meter worked as expected in auditing sessions.
Probably most scn and dn procedures could not even be done without using the e-meter.
"Mathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function. "Mathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function.
The patent was granted in December, 1966, but applied for in June, 1965.
How might it be better? The problem with E-meters and lie detectors is the same - they are unreliable. They don't work on the person who did the crime but doesn't think it was a crime, for instance. Not a peep. Crickets. Tumbleweeds.it seems to me whether better technology might be useful, is in fact relevant to the topic of this thread. first, the fact that Hubbard failed to take advantage of advances in biofeedback technology, sticking with what is essentially an early 20th century if not late 19th century device, is i think a telling thought-experiment regarding his attitude and approach, as the title of the thread asks about. and, if you want to do some sort of investigation of the phenomena at work (which isn't really the topic of this thread, is it?) then wouldn't you need better tools to say try to understand things like non-sweat related subdermal reactions that could quickly change skin resistance, or even to use as diagnostic measures for the e-meter itself, and its readings?
also, if you want to quantify the phenomenon being observed, isn't a an online thread the wrong place to be doing that, as 70 years of theorizing and shooting the breeze even sitting around in person has produced nothing really conclusive in that regard? shouldn't it be at some technical conference, or in a research lab, that you would want to set up for that purpose?
i'm just trying to offer some outsider perspective, and perhaps help avoid repeating mistakes regarding this subject.
