Is the Emeter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

The original Mark V meter where Hubbard claimed he discovered OT stuff, back in 1952, the PDC's, well, those emeters never had EMI suppression

So now you imagine yourself to be a superior analog electronics expert to Don Breeding and Joe Wallis ?

After consulting the circuit diagram and detailed explanation in the patent filing (US3290589A), one may see that the transistor Mark Vs do not require EMI suppression for two reasons:

(a) Signal to Noise ratio at the amplifier input is around -60db to -70db for the approximately 100 microvolts of EMI noise that may be found on a human body relative to the 6 volts @ 20 milliamps from the meter bridge circuit (which is not Wheatstone's Bridge). The amplifer circuit gives about 200 times signal gain at the maximum Sensitivity setting which is about 45db. Any EMI noise still remains very weak compared to the amplified signal.

(b) A D'Arsenval moving-coil galvanometer (microammeter 100uA max) acts as a electro-mechanical low pass filter and attenuates any frequencies over about 10Hz with such a steep fall off as to render even amplified EMI noise invisible to the operator of the meter, even at the highest Sensitivity setting.

It is the meter movement itself that acts as the EMI noise suppressor.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Mathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function.

mimsey borogrove said:
This meter [Mark I transistor meter] was patented in 1966

The patent was granted in December, 1966, but applied for in June, 1965.
And it was a revision of an earlier one, as noted in the patent. "DEVICE FOR MEASURING AND INDICATING CHANGES IN RESISTANCE OF A LIVING BODY
This is a continuation-in-part of my application Serial No. 82,100, filed Jan 11, 1961 and now abandoned, for "Resistance Measuring or Indicating Devices."

Mimsey
 
Device for Measuring and Indicating Changes in
the Resistance of a Human Body
Inventor: Lafayette R. Hubbard

at least they had to accurately list just what it does -- and only that.

and what LRH may have been given the honor of being listed as the inventor, isn't this just another case where he ended up getting credit for what was really others' work? did he even oversee specifications and testing that much?
 
I wouldn't let HH get to you, he can be a robot.

Sorry, but you're the one suffering most from robotic behaviors -- that's just what gets you in trouble here. I think you do best when you start to acknowledge it, and perhaps ask for some understanding and compassion regarding your challenges, rather than being defensive about it, and going on the offensive where you accuse others of what you yourself do -- that's Hubbardian training (perhaps another thing that attracted you, being given that strategy for dealing with your struggles) that doesn't actually serve well.
 
So in this scenario, Statpush has properly noted that the e-meter produces some "effect". It's untethered to any product or consumer/industrial value or demand in the marketplace. The e-meter needle REACTED! So he wants to study it. But even if he studies it, there is no intended use or purpose if Hubbard's Clearing and OT technologies don't result in Clears and OTs.

yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people? or try to account as fully as possible for all the cases of psychosis that resulted, and then try to determine just what caused them?

here's another of the things that i think should be obvious but somehow tends to get overlooked, probably due to a myopic focus on 'source' and old learned habits: why not try to understand the phenomenon by using better equipment, like modern biofeedback technology that say includes GSR sensing plus pulse, breathing rate, and other things including possibly even the latest in brain function detection -- exactly what Hubbard failed to do, take advantage of actual advances.
 
at least they had to accurately list just what it does -- and only that.

and what LRH may have been given the honor of being listed as the inventor, isn't this just another case where he ended up getting credit for what was really others' work? did he even oversee specifications and testing that much?
That's not uncommon - You hire a tech to make your idea a reality and sell the product as yours. While Bill Gates may have had the idea for DOS ( or was it personal computers?) he takes all the credit, yet has myriad of programers working for him who are uncredited.

I wouldn't be surprised that Don or somebody like him, wrote the patent and Hubbard put his own name on it. I think it's written a bit too technical for Hubbard. I am certain he did have a good idea of how it should work, having plenty of experience with Volney's meter. Enough to tell the tech what he wanted to achieve, and make sure it didn't run amuck in the process.

Mimsey
 
..
yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people?

..

That would be a fascinating albeit challenging project!

Particularly obstructive to acquiring incriminating evidence are factors such as:

- - THE "RELIGIOUS" PROTECTION FACTOR: This sordid money racket has been successfully developed and refined by countless numbers of preachers, ministers, priests and jumbo-jets-for-jesus televangelists.

Kenneth Copeland​
Kenneth Copeland
​
Net Worth $760 Million: Kenneth Copeland is very close to being a Billionaire even though he already claims billion dollar status. He runs Kenneth Copeland Ministries. His ministry’s 1,500-acre campus is a half-hour drive from Fort Worth includes a church, a private airstrip, a hangar for the ministry’s $17.5 million jet and other aircraft, and a $6 million church owned lakefront mansion.​
​

Bishop TD Jakes​
TD Jakes
​
Net Worth $150 Million: Bishop Jakes lives in a $1,700,000 mansion, he has been called America’s best preacher and has been featured on the cover of TIME magazine. He is a writer, preacher and movie producer. Thomas Dexter “T. D.” Jakes, Sr. is the bishop/chief pastor of The Potter’s House, a non-denominational American mega church, with 30,000 members, located in Dallas, Texas.​
​
David Oyedepo​
David-Oyedepo3.jpg
​
Net Worth $150 Million​
David Oyedepo is a Nigerian pastor who has a net worth of $150 million. Having enjoyed a reputation as the richest pastor in Nigeria, David Oyedepo is the founder and presiding bishop of Living Faith Church World Wide, aka Winners Chapel, and its affiliated international churches known as Winners Chapel International.​
​
Pat Robertson​
Pat Robertson​
Net Worth $100 Million: Pat Robertson launched the Christian Broadcasting Network in Virginia, and the network is now broadcast in 180 countries. In the late 80s, he ran for President, but was unsuccessful. He runs a number of large companies, including the Christian Coalition, a Christian Right organization that exists to raise monetary and public support for conservative political candidates.​
​
Benny Hinn​
Benny-Hinn
​
Net Worth $42 Million: Israeli televangelist, Benny Hinn is best known for his regular “Miracle Crusades” – revival meeting/faith healing summits that are usually held in large stadiums in major cities, which are later broadcast worldwide on his television program, “This Is Your Day”.​
​

Jesse Duplantis​
maxresdefault-2.jpg
​
Net Worth $50 Million: Jesse Duplantis is a prosperity gospel preacher from the Christian Evangelical Charismatic tradition based in New Orleans, Louisiana, US, and the founder of Jesse Duplantis Ministries. He is the founder of Jesse Duplantis Ministries (JDM), which maintains an international headquarters in America and branches in the United Kingdom and Australia. In 1997, he and his wife, Cathy Duplantis, founded Covenant Church, a local outreach of JDM on the International Headquarters property in Destrehan, Louisiana.​
​
Joel Osteen​
Joel-Osteen
​
Net Worth $40 Million: Joel Osteen is an author, televangelist, and pastor of Lakewood Church in Houston, Texas. He took over his father’s role as a pastor and televangelist, despite having very little formal religious training, in 1999. Since then, the Lakewood Church broadcast has grown exponentially and can be seen in 100 different countries.​
​
Creflo Dollar​
Creflo-Dollar
​
Net Worth $27 Million: Creflo Dollar brought in his net worth through his ministries. He has assembled a multi-million-dollar ministry to the message that “it is the will of God for you to prosper in every way​
Creflo Dollar has in addition the publisher of CHANGE magazine, a quarterly international publication with nearly 100,000 subscribers and The Max, a bimonthly resource newsletter for ministers and ministry leaders. His books include Understanding God’s Purpose for the Anointing (1992), Claim Your Success Today (2006) and 8 Steps to make the Life You Want (2008). He’s well known for his controversial teachings of Prosperity theology. He has been criticized for his lavish lifestyle as he owns two Rolls-Royces, a private jet, a million dollar home in Atlanta, and a 2.5 million dollar residence in Manhattan. In 2007, U.S. Senator Charles Grassley named him and other evangelists in a financial investigation, mentioning lavish lifestyles and questioning their use of cash gathered from churchgoers and viewers. He has denied any wrong doing.​

THE BYZANTINE OFFSHORE LABYRINTH OF CORPORATIONS, TRUSTS, FIDUCIARIES, MONEY MANAGEMENT ENTITIES AND ASSET PROTECTION SCHEMES THAT DENY AND/OR DERAIL DISCOVERY DUE TO SOVEREIGN FOREIGN NATION'S LEGISLATION DESIGNED FOR JUST THAT PURPOSE: In such elaborate schemes, even the possibility that assets might be "endangered", protective mechanisms are triggered and the funds, properties and investments of said entity can be instantly moved, transferred, assigned or placed under the perfected control of third party entities in yet other countries and/or banking/financial systems.

The more sophisticated organized crime rackets like the MAFIA, DRUG CARTELS and TERRORIST organizations have vast wealth (like Hubbard's cult) to retain legions of world-class lawyers to keep investigations and indictments at great distances. However, those formidable protections have a solution too when federal prosecutors are sufficiently motivated. Enter the development of new weapons of war, such as the RICO statutes, which ultimately obliterated previously untouchable crime organizations.

What's been missing in the 73 year history of Scientology is a creative and compelling way to infiltrate the crime cult or to threaten/crush cult collaborators with long prison sentences until they begin to "FLIP" on the next upper tier of thug management, until they finally have enough rats to take down "The Don" (or "The Ron", in Scientology's case).

SUMMARY: We need rat flipping technology! LOL. The Feds has the right idea and perfect strategy when back in the 1970s they were all over Scientology's ass with raids and rats that ended up sending Mary Sue Hubbard and another (appx.) ten cult criminals to prison. And they were so effective that a terrified Don Ron Corleone went into hiding, began donning dorky disguises and developing the advanced OT level known as HBMHT ("Hubbard Bluebird Motorhome Hiding Technology"). If the Feds had continued those extraordinarily successful measures, the cult would have fully imploded and "erased" before they ever came back from the grave and somehow wrangled their religious "non profit" status with the IRS. Once that was granted, Scientology became a teen horror movie where the murderous monster keeps coming back every time it's killed.

tumblr_n64pstB3wg1qz5q5lo1_400.jpg

..
 
Last edited:
So now you imagine yourself to be a superior analog electronics expert to Don Breeding and Joe Wallis ?

After consulting the circuit diagram and detailed explanation in the patent filing (US3290589A), one may see that the transistor Mark Vs do not require EMI suppression for two reasons:

(a) Signal to Noise ratio at the amplifier input is around -60db to -70db for the approximately 100 microvolts of EMI noise that may be found on a human body relative to the 6 volts @ 20 milliamps from the meter bridge circuit (which is not Wheatstone's Bridge). The amplifer circuit gives about 200 times signal gain at the maximum Sensitivity setting which is about 45db. Any EMI noise still remains very weak compared to the amplified signal.

(b) A D'Arsenval moving-coil galvanometer (microammeter 100uA max) acts as a electro-mechanical low pass filter and attenuates any frequencies over about 10Hz with such a steep fall off as to render even amplified EMI noise invisible to the operator of the meter, even at the highest Sensitivity setting.

It is the meter movement itself that acts as the EMI noise suppressor.
I read thru the patent link you provided, it never states what you said. A analog meter cannot provide EMI suppression. Additionally, I don't even think Hubbard had access to measuring db in the days of the 1950's. db's is decibels.
 
yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people? or try to account as fully as possible for all the cases of psychosis that resulted, and then try to determine just what caused them?

here's another of the things that i think should be obvious but somehow tends to get overlooked, probably due to a myopic focus on 'source' and old learned habits: why not try to understand the phenomenon by using better equipment, like modern biofeedback technology that say includes GSR sensing plus pulse, breathing rate, and other things including possibly even the latest in brain function detection -- exactly what Hubbard failed to do, take advantage of actual advances.
I already said what's the point more or less because nobody went clear or OT. It's quite interesting making a post here and see responses.
 
yeah. i mean i somewhat, or slightly, might agree with Statpush that it would be interesting to try to figure out exactly what goes on. but yeah, what's the point? why not try to figure out exactly where all the money went, a challenge in forensic accounting that would be of interest to a lot of people? or try to account as fully as possible for all the cases of psychosis that resulted, and then try to determine just what caused them?

here's another of the things that i think should be obvious but somehow tends to get overlooked, probably due to a myopic focus on 'source' and old learned habits: why not try to understand the phenomenon by using better equipment, like modern biofeedback technology that say includes GSR sensing plus pulse, breathing rate, and other things including possibly even the latest in brain function detection -- exactly what Hubbard failed to do, take advantage of actual advances.
While what you are saying may be true...its not the topic of this thread. Why post on a thread and say "this thread should really be about..."?

It obviously is not for you.
 
While what you are saying may be true...its not the topic of this thread. Why post on a thread and say "this thread should really be about..."?

It obviously is not for you.
From a strictly pragmatic point of view as I mentioned in my first post, #4, the e-meter worked as expected in auditing sessions. Thousands of auditors over the years would agree. Probably most scn and dn procedures could not even be done without using the e-meter. Take a guess at which item(s) to run? Some auditors after leaving the cherch with thousands of hours of experience might have done some freelancing without an e-meter but that's the exception rather than the rule. Scientology is not a path to Total Freedom or Nirvana but which if any parts of it are worthwhile continues to be debated.

P.S. statpush: In case you are not aware of it, Reyne is extremely well versed in things scientology but was never a scientologist. And btw when I started reading the scn blogs in 2015 and began reexamining my scn experience I found your comments on Alanzo's blog enjoyable and useful. :)

Eight years ago I was a Newbie and you were already an Old Timer. Lol
 
Last edited:
While what you are saying may be true...its not the topic of this thread. Why post on a thread and say "this thread should really be about..."?

It obviously is not for you.

it seems to me whether better technology might be useful, is in fact relevant to the topic of this thread. first, the fact that Hubbard failed to take advantage of advances in biofeedback technology, sticking with what is essentially an early 20th century if not late 19th century device, is i think a telling thought-experiment regarding his attitude and approach, as the title of the thread asks about. and, if you want to do some sort of investigation of the phenomena at work (which isn't really the topic of this thread, is it?) then wouldn't you need better tools to say try to understand things like non-sweat related subdermal reactions that could quickly change skin resistance, or even to use as diagnostic measures for the e-meter itself, and its readings?

also, if you want to quantify the phenomenon being observed, isn't a an online thread the wrong place to be doing that, as 70 years of theorizing and shooting the breeze even sitting around in person has produced nothing really conclusive in that regard? shouldn't it be at some technical conference, or in a research lab, that you would want to set up for that purpose?

i'm just trying to offer some outsider perspective, and perhaps help avoid repeating mistakes regarding this subject.
 
it seems to me whether better technology might be useful, is in fact relevant to the topic of this thread. first, the fact that Hubbard failed to take advantage of advances in biofeedback technology, sticking with what is essentially an early 20th century if not late 19th century device, is i think a telling thought-experiment regarding his attitude and approach, as the title of the thread asks about. and, if you want to do some sort of investigation of the phenomena at work (which isn't really the topic of this thread, is it?) then wouldn't you need better tools to say try to understand things like non-sweat related subdermal reactions that could quickly change skin resistance, or even to use as diagnostic measures for the e-meter itself, and its readings?

also, if you want to quantify the phenomenon being observed, isn't a an online thread the wrong place to be doing that, as 70 years of theorizing and shooting the breeze even sitting around in person has produced nothing really conclusive in that regard? shouldn't it be at some technical conference, or in a research lab, that you would want to set up for that purpose?

i'm just trying to offer some outsider perspective, and perhaps help avoid repeating mistakes regarding this subject.
There is no money to be made from researching and investigating the use of the e-meter in scn auditing so nobody will ever do it. The e-meter works as expected in auditing sessions. Keep it simple.

The wiki e-meter article (post # 29) provides some in depth discussion. Other than that a scn blog or forum might be the best place to speculate.

A treatise on the e-meter on a scn forum is noted in post # 9.
 
Last edited:
There is no money to be made from researching and investigating the use of the e-meter in scn auditing so nobody will ever do it. The e-meter works as expected in auditing sessions. Keep it simple.

The wiki e-meter article (post # 29) provides some in depth discussion. Other than that a scn blog or forum might be the best place to speculate.

A treatise on the e-meter on a scn forum is noted in post # 9.
how does the emeter work as expected as nobody went clear or OT?
 
From a strictly pragmatic point of view as I mentioned in my first post, #4, the e-meter worked as expected in auditing sessions.

that seems potentially self-referential if not circular. does that really tell us anything other than that maybe the auditor and the PC have been indoctrinated, trained and conditioned to produce the results they are expected to -- like 'remembering' past lives (and improbable infantile and prenatal traumas) that are mostly if not entirely fabrications based on implanted expectations?

Probably most scn and dn procedures could not even be done without using the e-meter.

didn't David Mayo of all people, join the others who gave up on using the meter? seems like a lot of the best people concluded that either things could be one without a meter, or what couldn't be wasn't of any real value.
 
Mathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function.



The patent was granted in December, 1966, but applied for in June, 1965.
"Mathison's electron tube meters also used the properties of the galvanometer (microammeter 50uA max) to provide the EMI filtering function. "

Just so you know, the only thing valuable in the Mathison's emeter was that they had telefunkun 12AX7 tubes. Those sell for about 100 bucks, other than that, it's a quack machine.
 
it seems to me whether better technology might be useful, is in fact relevant to the topic of this thread. first, the fact that Hubbard failed to take advantage of advances in biofeedback technology, sticking with what is essentially an early 20th century if not late 19th century device, is i think a telling thought-experiment regarding his attitude and approach, as the title of the thread asks about. and, if you want to do some sort of investigation of the phenomena at work (which isn't really the topic of this thread, is it?) then wouldn't you need better tools to say try to understand things like non-sweat related subdermal reactions that could quickly change skin resistance, or even to use as diagnostic measures for the e-meter itself, and its readings?

also, if you want to quantify the phenomenon being observed, isn't a an online thread the wrong place to be doing that, as 70 years of theorizing and shooting the breeze even sitting around in person has produced nothing really conclusive in that regard? shouldn't it be at some technical conference, or in a research lab, that you would want to set up for that purpose?

i'm just trying to offer some outsider perspective, and perhaps help avoid repeating mistakes regarding this subject.
How might it be better? The problem with E-meters and lie detectors is the same - they are unreliable. They don't work on the person who did the crime but doesn't think it was a crime, for instance. Not a peep. Crickets. Tumbleweeds.

Having a workable technology won't help - it's a chimera.

Consider this: during deep sleep the sleeping brain is pruning away unwanted memories, and for the most part, they are gone forever. Read "Why We Sleep" by Walker for a more in depth explanation.

How are you going to find what isn't there to be found?

Hubbard believed - given a certain stimulus there will be an equivalent response. If you stabbed somebody, and the auditor said "stabbing." with good tr-1 that the reactive mind would serve up a fall indicating there was a stabbing.

What proof is there that the mind works that way, all the time, in every instance? That is the fallacy of your premise. The mind doesn't always work that way. No technology, no matter how advanced can overcome that impediment.

What is more credible, is that it works that way sometimes, and sometimes it doesn't.

Was that fall connected with stabbing? Or poking a roll with a butter knife at breakfast?

:confused:

Let me give you an example: I was getting a session on my grades at NYO around 1968. The auditor was asking me about a withhold - he was trying to steer me and was following the same read he got when he asked the original question. As I floundered around trying to think what it could possible be, he said "there". I had my attention on a spot a foot or so outside my forehead when it read. Every time I put my attention on that spot, the auditor said "there". What was it reading on? Certainly not the alleged withhold.

You can't trust any meter 100% of the time. the mind is too complex.

Mimsey
 
Last edited:
Back
Top