Is the Emeter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

There is another why to fool the emeter, that is to put on a happy face and be all excited one completed the auditing. PC Indicators.
 
There is another why to fool the emeter, that is to put on a happy face and be all excited one completed the auditing. PC Indicators.

No. I controlled what I was thinking about while on the e-meter after objectives (a pleasant memory).
I wanted to stop the objectives and what I did worked for me.
 
Last edited:
I recall reading that some indy practitioner replaced the cans with proper medical grade electrodes and conductive gel (EKG) in order to eliminate the "perspiration" factor. I don't recall the results.
Anyone remember?

Also, how are different needle responses (F/N's, R/S's, TA Blow downs, etc) explained by the perspiration theory?
 
The first auditing I dd with a meter was Standard Dianetic R3R, circa 1971, at the New York Org in the Martinique Hotel. Sometimes I'd audit my pc in a hotel room a few blocks from the Org, and, after session, we'd have to take an elevator down from the hotel room, to the street, then through a near phalanx the winos and crazy people, and finally into the Martinique hotel and up the stairs into the Org, where I would take my pc to the Examiner.

At the time I was very impressed with R3R procedure, with the e-meter, with TRs, and Ruds, and with the L3RD Repair list. The e-meter would react just the way I was told it would. Everything went as predicted.

It took some years for the inadequacies of DN R3R to become apparent to me.

The first thing was that the somatics came back.

In original DN R3R, somatics were the area of address.

This is difficult to explain to someone who came after 1978, after Hubbard had a sleep-deprived tech aide change the word "somatic" to the word "consideration" in his HCOBs.

At one time, Dianetics was for the body, and Scientology was for the thetan.

If an "OT" had somatics, the he needed Dianetics.

After 1978, if an OT ran DN it was "DEADLY," according to Hubbard.

Were there refunds? No.

Apologies? No.

Hubbard did an about face on things he had stated for twenty five years.

Something very odd was occurring.
 
The first auditing I dd with a meter was Standard Dianetic R3R, circa 1971, at the New York Org in the Martinique Hotel. Sometimes I'd audit my pc in a hotel room a few blocks from the Org, and, after session, we'd have to take an elevator down from the hotel room, to the street, then through a near phalanx the winos and crazy people, and finally into the Martinique hotel and up the stairs into the Org, where I would take my pc to the Examiner.

At the time I was very impressed with R3R procedure, with the e-meter, with TRs, and Ruds, and with the L3RD Repair list. The e-meter would react just the way I was told it would. Everything went as predicted.

It took some years for the inadequacies of DN R3R to become apparent to me.

The first thing was that the somatics came back.

In original DN R3R, somatics were the area of address.

This is difficult to explain to someone who came after 1978, after Hubbard had a sleep-deprived tech aide change the word "somatic" to the word "consideration" in his HCOBs.

At one time, Dianetics was for the body, and Scientology was for the thetan.

If an "OT" had somatics, the he needed Dianetics.

After 1978, if an OT ran DN it was "DEADLY," according to Hubbard.

Were there refunds? No.

Apologies? No.

Hubbard did an about face on things he had stated for twenty five years.

Something very odd was occurring.
It sounds like I was at the Martinique before you - 68 - 69 then I went to LA for r-6, cc-3x, and the shsbc, then I returned to finish my contract in 73? (I was on staff there when the Exorcist was in the theaters)

Were you auditing in the Hadson? The bums weren't that prevalent until a hotel collapsed down town, and the city moved the welfare tenants into the Martinique. When I was back on staff to finish my contract there were a couple suicides at the Martinique.

One happened before I got to FDN post - I saw the chalk outline on the sidewalk, and when I walked into cramming the day cram off said he happened to look out the window and saw all the bums and winos started running towards the org. He thought - We've finally made it! Till he realized it was a jumper. He remarked, "As you know, nothing but nothing makes the bums move. So suicide matched their tone level and they ran to see what happened. "

:faceslap:

Mimsey

How's this for some malevolent TR 0?

The-Exorcist-HERO (Medium).jpg
 
Last edited:
I recall reading that some indy practitioner replaced the cans with proper medical grade electrodes and conductive gel (EKG) in order to eliminate the "perspiration" factor. I don't recall the results.
Anyone remember?

Also, how are different needle responses (F/N's, R/S's, TA Blow downs, etc) explained by the perspiration theory?
Also, how are different needle responses (F/N's, R/S's, TA Blow downs, etc) explained by the perspiration theory?
I kept my description very simple for the benefit of a passerby and I didn't even think about those other "reads". Some crazy stuff did happen between a person's ears and the rest of their body in auditing sessions. laughter

How about a "line charge", a period of uncontrolled laughing or crying followed by great relief. It didn't happen often but was pretty interesting when it did.

I suppose someone could write it all off to a dopamine or adrenaline rush. lol
 
Last edited:
The first auditing I dd with a meter was Standard Dianetic R3R, circa 1971, at the New York Org in the Martinique Hotel. Sometimes I'd audit my pc in a hotel room a few blocks from the Org, and, after session, we'd have to take an elevator down from the hotel room, to the street, then through a near phalanx the winos and crazy people, and finally into the Martinique hotel and up the stairs into the Org, where I would take my pc to the Examiner.

At the time I was very impressed with R3R procedure, with the e-meter, with TRs, and Ruds, and with the L3RD Repair list. The e-meter would react just the way I was told it would. Everything went as predicted.

It took some years for the inadequacies of DN R3R to become apparent to me.

The first thing was that the somatics came back.

In original DN R3R, somatics were the area of address.

This is difficult to explain to someone who came after 1978, after Hubbard had a sleep-deprived tech aide change the word "somatic" to the word "consideration" in his HCOBs.

At one time, Dianetics was for the body, and Scientology was for the thetan.

If an "OT" had somatics, the he needed Dianetics.

After 1978, if an OT ran DN it was "DEADLY," according to Hubbard.

Were there refunds? No.

Apologies? No.

Hubbard did an about face on things he had stated for twenty five years.

Something very odd was occurring.
"Dianetics is for the body" is the biggest piece of shit ever foisted on anyone who ever held the cans. Thetans, too, can have (emotional) engrams, and they need to be run out, with Dianetics. It took me decades of manuvering to finally get enough Dianetics -- and I'm still not finished! (Note the use of a profanity, for emphasis, where I normally use just asterisks.)

Helena
 
The emeter is a rather crude anxiety detector. That is much is true. It can, at times, detect if someone is getting more nervous than they were before.

Everything else they say about the emeter is propaganda, puffed-up nonsense and Hubbard's imagination running wild.
 
I recall reading that some indy practitioner replaced the cans with proper medical grade electrodes and conductive gel (EKG) in order to eliminate the "perspiration" factor. I don't recall the results.
Anyone remember?

Also, how are different needle responses (F/N's, R/S's, TA Blow downs, etc) explained by the perspiration theory?
All valid questions, and AFAIK have not been sufficiently explained.

When solo auditing I had to routinely use magnesium talc to reduce the perspiration to get the TA in range. But, wouldn't that add an extra layer of resistance thereby throwing off the "galvanic skin response"? Makes no sense.
 
I think there is more to it than galvanic skin response. Rock-slams or theta-bops are hard to explain by such a response.

i've read about it, and there is also subdermal phenomenon at work that can change resistance/impedance -- which happens instantaneously, compared to sweat production that i see critiqued as being too slow to explain some reactions.

i suspect anything else can be explained by unconscious occurrence of the same sort of mechanisms that people who have become aware of what is at work use to get the needle to 'float'.
 
I found that remembering my last orgasm would get my needle to float. Very useful.
Easiest way to get an F/N was to clear your mind of all thoughts. Good ol' Buddhist meditation technique.
Quicker and less fanciful way for me was to think about some of the objects I had in my room as a kid. A sony cassette player, a model airplane etc. I looked at these things so many times before falling asleep that thinking about them just made me go into a light sleepy trance that ended up with a F/N.

Easy ways to get a read? wiggle your big toe in your shoe hard. Or bite your inner cheek.

Getting weird reads in weird moments was better to throw off an auditor or EO than a F/N.
 
I recall reading that some indy practitioner replaced the cans with proper medical grade electrodes and conductive gel (EKG) in order to eliminate the "perspiration" factor.

haven't i read about someone trying attaching the cans, or electrodes, to their feet? it occurs to me that's the sort of thing that ought to be tried, to eliminate the effect of squeezing, consciously or not, cans held in the hands, which seems to me like such a big variable (including in how it's used to 'beat the meter' and similarly in techniques used to evade more sophisticated polygraphs) that it calls everything into question.
 
i've read about it, and there is also subdermal phenomenon at work that can change resistance/impedance -- which happens instantaneously, compared to sweat production that i see critiqued as being too slow to explain some reactions.

i suspect anything else can be explained by unconscious occurrence of the same sort of mechanisms that people who have become aware of what is at work use to get the needle to 'float'.
Heart rate and tempo of breathing has an indirect impact on the meter. Saw it happen hundreds of times.

You shout at someone or say something really threatening. Their breathing rate increases and it will read on the meter. This could be the middle of California summer with no AC and everyone is sweating like crazy before and after. But the anxiety reads on the meter, even if you both were swimming in your own sweat for many hours.
 
When Dianetic auditing was failing Volney Matheson stepped in to invent the e-meter.

don't i remember that Volney had actually been experimenting with meters before he even met Hubbard? (if 'source' was good at anything, it was creating a mythology where he gets undue credit even from people who are critical)

and after he left, didn't he decry how Hubbard used them as quackery if not worse?
 
The Emeter was supposed to give data on whether a person told the truth about past experiences one might say.

From my involvement in dianetics & scientology, I come to the conclusion that the emeter is a gimmick and quack machine.

what if like many things it's not black and white, but a shade of gray in between? can you deal with or tolerate ambiguity -- or is that one of the things Hubbard used to lure you into his cult, offering false 'certainty' rather than the reality of uncertainty?

it seems to me that the emeter does just enough to appear impressive, which is why early psychologists and psychiatrists like Jung initially were interested in psycho galvanometers -- but doesn't actually turn out to be accurate or powerful enough to really be useful, which is why they abandoned such meters, unlike Hubbard and his followers who were overcommited and unscientific....

also, to bring up a point i've made before, there's a fundamental issue that i believe Hubbard deliberately avoided like the plague, because he knew it would totally undermine his theories and teachings regarding the meter and other things: psychokinesis or telekinesis, and telepathy. actually, Hubbard touts what is effectively the same thing as 'power over MEST', but carefully avoids getting into the messy and inconvenient details of how that would work in everyday life. if it actually existed and scientology could cultivate it, then the interaction between PC, meter, and auditor, with either party possibly making the meter needle 'read' just with their psychic powers, not to mention implanting or reading thoughts in one anothers' minds.

that also creates a proof of concept test Hubbard would have dreaded like attacks in the middle of the night by SMERSH agents with hypodermics: an OT with any power at all should be able to sit in front of a meter with no electrodes, and make the highly sensitive needle swing back and forth, right?

thus i would say the meter proves conclusively that Hubbard was totally FOS, and there is nothing at all to parapsychology, either. apologies to true believers in any of that....

nyt-needle.gif
 
haven't i read about someone trying attaching the cans, or electrodes, to their feet? it occurs to me that's the sort of thing that ought to be tried, to eliminate the effect of squeezing, consciously or not, cans held in the hands, which seems to me like such a big variable (including in how it's used to 'beat the meter' and similarly in techniques used to evade more sophisticated polygraphs) that it calls everything into question.

Footplates were an alternative to cans in Scientology until the late 70's when they were forbidden by Hubbard with the claim that they would not give proper "reads".
 
Back
Top