Is the Emeter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

.
.

ANSWER: We are observing the prelude to a free pinch test. Once that technical action has successfully been delivered, we would be observing a secondary phenomena—where the being holding the cans is tricked into donating $500,000 for a series of advanced pinch tests that will result in magical powers (or minimally a jumbo completion certificate).
..
Okay. I specifically wanted to avoid such distractions, as it brings zero to the discussion.

My educated guess would be: electro-magnetic
 
Can it be both a marketing gimmick AND a quack machine? To me it is both. Someone here at ESMB2 was kind enough to send me their Mark 7. Before the battery pack died of old age, I spent a few minutes "on the cans". I adjusted the knobs as well as I could, based on the instructions I found in the instruction booklet and online. After I adjusted the knobs pretty well and grabbed the cans, the needle would seldom sit still for more than a fraction of a second. Whether I tried to strengthen my grip or relax my grip or even move the cans around in my hand, the needle just moved around however it wanted. I was not thinking about anything in particular.

To me it was just plain silly to say the needle could show that I was thinking about anything in particular, or experiencing guilt about a withhold.

I haven't been following this thread but it sounds like the sensitivity was too high.
 
Okay. I specifically wanted to avoid such distractions, as it brings zero to the discussion.

My educated guess would be: electro-magnetic

Do you think it's a small electric current bouncing off mental image pictures as depicted in Scientology's literature on the e-meter?

"The e-meter is a truth detector," Marty Rathbun
 
Do you think it's a small electric current bouncing off mental image pictures as depicted in Scientology's literature on the e-meter?

"The e-meter is a truth detector," Marty Rathbun
Too early to tell. I want to make sure I understand the mechanics of why this occurs.

Just a side note...

Back in the day, we messed around with hooking a house plant up to the meter. We did manage to get the needle on the dial, and were able to observe needle phenomena. Even put together a plant assessment list (e.g. Sunlight, water, food, air, etc). What was the most interesting was the needle response when we moved our hand into it's "space". We observed a reproducible fall (not duplicate) when we got within 6 or so inches of its branches or leaves.

What does this mean? Who knows. Just a weird data point.
 
With the device powered on, with no participant, we observe no changes or fluctuations in the behaviour of the needle.

actually, i've heard that some of the meters during a key period in the development of the 'tech' and policy, would in fact sometimes change and fluctuate when powered on, with no participant....

doesn't the fact that was ignored, and not compensated for in any way, itself demonstrate that the entire process of developing the meter and everything related to it, is so flawed and lacking in scientific rigor, that it all has to be questioned if not thrown out?

This is observable and reproducible.

what is your basis for those claims and assumptions? is anything really proven consistently enough reproducible?

What phenomena are we observing?

is there really any way to adequately answer that question, without rigorous and extensive research starting practically from the beginning? research that in over 70 years of Hubbard's organizations and numerous offshoots, no one has ever been able to adequately or satisfactorily perform, particularly not the point of being able to say produce a publishable paper on it?
 
actually, i've heard that some of the meters during a key period in the development of the 'tech' and policy, would in fact sometimes change and fluctuate when powered on, with no participant....

doesn't the fact that was ignored, and not compensated for in any way, itself demonstrate that the entire process of developing the meter and everything related to it, is so flawed and lacking in scientific rigor, that it all has to be questioned if not thrown out?

what is your basis for those claims and assumptions? is anything really proven consistently enough reproducible?

is there really any way to adequately answer that question, without rigorous and extensive research starting practically from the beginning? research that in over 70 years of Hubbard's organizations and numerous offshoots, no one has ever been able to adequately or satisfactorily perform, particularly not the point of being able to say produce a publishable paper on it?
Much of this is distraction, and does not advance the understanding of what is happening.

Were there anomalies during the development of the E-meter? Probably. Who cares? Besides, it not the E-meter we are all familiar with.

To note the lack of standards and practices of the "research", does not negate the fact that we have a meter that functions the way it does today.

It's not so important to understand how the meter was developed, but why it does what it does.
 
actually, i've heard that some of the meters during a key period in the development of the 'tech' and policy, would in fact sometimes change and fluctuate when powered on, with no participant....

doesn't the fact that was ignored, and not compensated for in any way, itself demonstrate that the entire process of developing the meter and everything related to it, is so flawed and lacking in scientific rigor, that it all has to be questioned if not thrown out?

The Mark VII meters when 1st released would in some cases where there was a strong radio signal in the area show needle reactions. This was not ignored and a filter was implemented to correct the problem. Everyone got their meters fixed (remarkably for free!)
 
THE ULTIMATE E-METER DEBUNKER​

Any Scientologist or Indie Scientologist who pretends to be an expert on the e-meter is hereby challenged to prove it with a simple test.

Have them go in front of a live audience of 100 people with their favorite e-meter. Then with the cameras rolling, blindfold them and have they pick just one numbered ping-pong balls out of a big barrel. When they pick one, the number on the ball is called out and the corresponding audience member stands and comes to the stage.

Next the e-meter expert does an e-meter drill that all auditors have to "pass" before they are allowed to audit. The audience secretly writes a gargantuan "wholetrack date" number down on a little scrap of paper, which is then quickly hidden from view. The auditor then begins to call out various "orders of magnitude" while watching the meter. The pc is not allowed to say anything.

AUDITOR
Is the order of magnitude years, tens of years, hundreds of years,
thousands of years, tens of thousands of years, hundreds of thousands
of years, millions of years, tens of millions of years, hundreds
of millions of years, billions of years, tens of billions of years....​

When the auditor sees the meter read (react) they stop and say: "Is it tens of billions of years?"

If yes, the auditor continues until they have narrowed it down to a single digit. (e.g. Is it 37 billion, 297 million, four-hundred and twenty-two thousand, six-hundred and thirteen?")

The Big Mythed-Withhold is that no auditor can pass this test without many different attempts and learning to interpret their particular PCs meter reactions. It is (at very best) a crude "steering" instrument, probably no better and no worse than simply ASKING THE PC A QUESTION AND LETTING THEM TELL YOU WHAT THEY "FEEL" THE ANSWER IS.

If an auditor cannot do it 100% of the time on the very first try, then the e-meter does not work as represented.

So much for Hubbard calling Dianetics and Scientology a "science".

Yet the myth of the meter's scientific precision lives on! LOL

...
 
Much of this is distraction, and does not advance the understanding of what is happening.

Were there anomalies during the development of the E-meter? Probably. Who cares? Besides, it not the E-meter we are all familiar with.

To note the lack of standards and practices of the "research", does not negate the fact that we have a meter that functions the way it does today.

It's not so important to understand how the meter was developed, but why it does what it does.


.
Can you perform a wholetrack dating drill on a random person, while being videotaped and get the answer correct on the very first try?

If not, why doesn't your meter work?

Instead of pontificating and guessing, just show it works by a live demonstration.

Otherwise, your theories and guesses are no better than anyone else.

Don't bother trying to dismiss this as another "distraction". An e-meter "expert" who can't demonstrate the scientific precision of their instrument is just pitching and spinning. That's the problem with Scientology---Scientologists can only TALK ABOUT the many miraculous phenomena, they can never DO IT.

If you can't do that e-meter experiment, we'll accept any other proof of how the tech works. Just show us how you can EXTERIORIZE or how you can LEVITATE MEST OBJECTS or "KNOCK HATS OFF AT 50 YARDS".

..
 
.
Can you perform a wholetrack dating drill on a random person, while being videotaped and get the answer correct on the very first try?

If not, why doesn't your meter work?

Instead of pontificating and guessing, just show it works by a live demonstration.

Otherwise, your theories and guesses are no better than anyone else.

Don't bother trying to dismiss this as another "distraction". An e-meter "expert" who can't demonstrate the scientific precision of their instrument is just pitching and spinning. That's the problem with Scientology---Scientologists can only TALK ABOUT the many miraculous phenomena, they can never DO IT.

If you can't do that e-meter experiment, we'll accept any other proof of how the tech works. Just show us how you can EXTERIORIZE or how you can LEVITATE MEST OBJECTS or "KNOCK HATS OFF AT 50 YARDS".

..
I'm trying to understand the science behind it.

I don't know what the fuck you're going on about.
 
I'm trying to understand the science behind it.

I don't know what the fuck you're going on about.
Isn't the science - it demonstrates on the needle dial and the ta arm changes in resistance to the current. The TA shows the gross changes in resistance, the needle shows the minor variations. Hubbard's theory is that mental mass is causing the changes in resistance, but that is also incomplete.

Take the F/N - it appears as a sine wave on an oscilloscope (if I recall correctly) so - Huston, we have a problem. If Hubbard's theory is correct, then how in hell is a F/N even possible? The mental mass can't be ping ponging on and off the body - ergo the menter shows multiple different phenomena. When you consider a theta bop always looks the same on any coach, as does the rock slam. Though I have never seen a rocket read - they are repeatable.

What is going on in all likelihood is that the meter is demonstrating various mental phenomena, the nature of which, on a nuts and bolts level, isn't fully understood.

Mimsey
 
I'm trying to understand the science behind it.

I don't know what the fuck you're going on about.


Oh, my question upset you? You don't like being asked questions? You're only here to deliver lectures?

You are concerned about the e-meter's "science". There is no point to waste time inquiring about the "science" if the e-meter doesn't produce any of the advanced "states" and "OT powers" for which it is intended.

I only asked if you can show it working before worrying about the "science". If it doesn't work then that's the answer--there is NO science. Likewise, I wouldn't waste much time studying the "science" of a mood ring since it doesn't do anything except change colors.

You are using a high powered electron microscope to attempt to repair a car that won't run. You are viewing at such wild levels of magnification that you can't even see that the car is in a junkyard and has already been flattened, LOL.

Auto_scrapyard_1.jpg
 
The Mark VII meters when 1st released would in some cases where there was a strong radio signal in the area show needle reactions. This was not ignored and a filter was implemented to correct the problem. Everyone got their meters fixed (remarkably for free!)
Thanks.

But wasn't it an earlier meter in the '60s or '70s that was noticed to 'rock slam' just when it was sitting untouched? Thus leading to the conclusion that many of those who had been subject to terrible judgments and fates for being 'rock slammers' were just victims of a defect of the meters (not that the supposed 'real' reads were valid justification, either), which i think i remember now had something to do with a carbon coil getting contaminated or wearing out.
 
It's not so important to understand how the meter was developed, but why it does what it does.

how do you even have an experimental hypothesis for what it does (other than possibly nothing at all), unless that's based in the (messy, and perhaps questionable) history?

and how do you expect to do, what has never been accomplished in the last 70 years, even when the best people from Jack Horner to David Mayo have been involved, as well as someone like "Sarge" Gerbode with an advanced degree from Stanford?

if you are to propose or design some sort of inquiry or research, isn't it relevant to consider the history of what has gone before, so you're not trying to reinvent the wheel (or the flying car)?

there's already a good bit out there, about such meters. what more is really needed? and how important is it to understand further, something that doesn't work well enough to really be useful?
 
Thanks.

But wasn't it an earlier meter in the '60s or '70s that was noticed to 'rock slam' just when it was sitting untouched? Thus leading to the conclusion that many of those who had been subject to terrible judgments and fates for being 'rock slammers' were just victims of a defect of the meters (not that the supposed 'real' reads were valid justification, either), which i think i remember now had something to do with a carbon coil getting contaminated or wearing out.
On a mark V you squirted some lighter fluid in the pots to stop that. Just unscrew the cover and have at it. Mimsey
 
how do you even have an experimental hypothesis for what it does (other than possibly nothing at all), unless that's based in the (messy, and perhaps questionable) history?

and how do you expect to do, what has never been accomplished in the last 70 years, even when the best people from Jack Horner to David Mayo have been involved, as well as someone like "Sarge" Gerbode with an advanced degree from Stanford?

if you are to propose or design some sort of inquiry or research, isn't it relevant to consider the history of what has gone before, so you're not trying to reinvent the wheel (or the flying car)?

there's already a good bit out there, about such meters. what more is really needed? and how important is it to understand further, something that doesn't work well enough to really be useful?
Don Breeding was the brains behind the modern meters ( Mk IV and V ) - he breadboarded the circuitry - nice guy - I met him back in the early '70's.
Mimsey
 
how do you even have an experimental hypothesis for what it does (other than possibly nothing at all), unless that's based in the (messy, and perhaps questionable) history?

and how do you expect to do, what has never been accomplished in the last 70 years, even when the best people from Jack Horner to David Mayo have been involved, as well as someone like "Sarge" Gerbode with an advanced degree from Stanford?

if you are to propose or design some sort of inquiry or research, isn't it relevant to consider the history of what has gone before, so you're not trying to reinvent the wheel (or the flying car)?

there's already a good bit out there, about such meters. what more is really needed? and how important is it to understand further, something that doesn't work well enough to really be useful?

.


I think we are grappling here with what I will call "REVERSE INCUBATION".

Having employed a considerable number of structural/design engineers and physicists to work on the development of devices that gained extensive IP coverage, I noticed that sometimes a brilliant engineer would design a "breakthrough" and be wildly euphoric to relay the news to me.

But, I was kind of a buzz kill since I asked WHAT IS THE MARKET SIZE AND DEMAND FOR THIS PRODUCT?

Of course they didn't know but that didn't kill their enthusiasm at how amazing it was. LOL

In short, the device they imagined produced an EFFECT. An effect in search of a customer who needs/wants that effect.

So in this scenario, Statpush has properly noted that the e-meter produces some "effect". It's untethered to any product or consumer/industrial value or demand in the marketplace. The e-meter needle REACTED! So he wants to study it. But even if he studies it, there is no intended use or purpose if Hubbard's Clearing and OT technologies don't result in Clears and OTs.

Okay, I'll end off here so that Statpush can yell and swear at me. LOL


..
 
Last edited:
The Mark VII meters when 1st released would in some cases where there was a strong radio signal in the area show needle reactions. This was not ignored and a filter was implemented to correct the problem. Everyone got their meters fixed (remarkably for free!)
yah, these are EMI suppressors, they are inculded in most electronic devices these days.

EMI Filter Basics | Astrodyne TDI

One has probably seen them, some are simple just a ferrite coil with the AC Power cord wrapped around them, they look like a circular magnet you might say.

479 Ferrite Coil Stock Photos - Free & Royalty-Free Stock Photos from Dreamstime

The original Mark V meter where Hubbard claimed he discovered OT stuff, back in 1952, the PDC's, well, those emeters never had EMI suppression, so who knows what was reading the emeter while Hubbard was discovering OT stuff, the needle movement could have come from electromagnetic noise from appliances or radios.

One may remember the Hubbard lecture with Mary Sue Hubbard, Tony O posted the lecture recording on his site one day.

Kind of makes one wonder, was Hubbard full of shit? Yep, but yet he claimed it was all science, or scientology, logos.
 
I'm trying to understand the science behind it.

I don't know what the fuck you're going on about.
I wouldn't let HH get to you, he can be a robot.
 
yah, these are EMI suppressors, they are inculded in most electronic devices these days.

EMI Filter Basics | Astrodyne TDI

One has probably seen them, some are simple just a ferrite coil with the AC Power cord wrapped around them, they look like a circular magnet you might say.

479 Ferrite Coil Stock Photos - Free & Royalty-Free Stock Photos from Dreamstime

The original Mark V meter where Hubbard claimed he discovered OT stuff, back in 1952, the PDC's, well, those emeters never had EMI suppression, so who knows what was reading the emeter while Hubbard was discovering OT stuff, the needle movement could have come from electromagnetic noise from appliances or radios.

One may remember the Hubbard lecture with Mary Sue Hubbard, Tony O posted the lecture recording on his site one day.

Kind of makes one wonder, was Hubbard full of shit? Yep, but yet he claimed it was all science, or scientology, logos.
The Mk V was not in existence in 52. He was using Voley's mains meter. I don't claim to know the whole history of the meter, but, I'm pretty sure the first transistor meters were in either the late 50's or early 60's. There were several versions floating around, that various people built. My understanding is that Hubbard wanted a standardized meter, and that's when Don Breeding got involved.
1674016866121.png

This meter was patented in 1966


1674016604532.png

1674016814260.png

1674017020035.png
Here he's checking a mk V (R) against a mk IV (L)
1674016673002.png
 
Last edited:
Back
Top