Is the Emeter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

i've read about it, and there is also subdermal phenomenon at work that can change resistance/impedance -- which happens instantaneously, compared to sweat production that i see critiqued as being too slow to explain some reactions.

i suspect anything else can be explained by unconscious occurrence of the same sort of mechanisms that people who have become aware of what is at work use to get the needle to 'float'.
I don't know why some people can not accept there might be a mental aspect to how the meter reads. There are some very specific reads that are really hard to attribute to subdermal, physical movements, and sweat. The problem with the people making these claims is many have little or no hands on experience with a meter.

My question to you Reyne - have you used an emeter? If not, why not borrow or buy a used one, get a book of emeter drills and get a friend to hold the cans. You might have some interesting results.

For instance, you ask your coach "consider the events of the day". In this drill you watch the meter, looking for a read. It could be a minute rise, a double tick, doesn't matter what read you choose, but when you see one, you say "That. What was that thought?" The person holding the cans starts thinking of other things. Then at a random time later, he/she recalls what it was he/she thought of. It should produce the exact read you saw previously. If so, you say "there - that was the same thought." if so the coach say yes, if not he says flunk.

If you look at what is going on - a thought like "I said hi to Mindy at starbucks this morning" is related to this specific needle reaction, and revisiting it results in the same reaction, where is the cause? Let's say it was a subdermal reaction that caused the read. But what triggered the subdermal reaction? A thought.

Mimsey
 
Last edited:
Footplates were an alternative to cans in Scientology until the late 70's when they were forbidden by Hubbard with the claim that they would not give proper "reads".
My wife has consistent sweaty palms, I made some wrist straps for her out of copper mesh I got from McMaster Carr. The sweat could evaporate through the mesh, and ended her false ta problems.

Mimsey
 
Heart rate and tempo of breathing has an indirect impact on the meter. Saw it happen hundreds of times.

You shout at someone or say something really threatening. Their breathing rate increases and it will read on the meter. This could be the middle of California summer with no AC and everyone is sweating like crazy before and after. But the anxiety reads on the meter, even if you both were swimming in your own sweat for many hours.
On a MK VII, sometimes when I would put my hand near the Tone Arm, the needle would move - most likely it was static electricity.
It makes me wonder how many reads the auditor saw were not the pc's, but the auditors?

Mimsey
 
Last edited:
I don't know why some people can not accept there might be a mental aspect to how the meter reads. There are some very specific reads that are really hard to attribute to subdermal, physical movements, and sweat. The problem with the people making these claims is many have little or no hands on experience with a meter.

My question to you Reyne - have you used an emeter? If not, why not borrow or buy a used one, get a book of emeter drills and get a friend to hold the cans. You might have some interesting results.

well, i did write at one point that i think what the emeter does is a mix -- of some real results, and some quackery. and i do think it's a mistake to dismiss it entirely -- it intially impressed some of the great pioneers of medicine and science back in the early 20th century (and, actually, in the 19th as well), for good reasons that still apply to laypeople today.

yes, i've spent a bit of time on a meter, and i've read up enough on how subdermal activity besides movement or sweat can cause changes in resistance/impedance -- have you familiarized yourself with those phenomenon? -- that it seems to me that anything treated as a 'read' in scientology could be attributed to other things, and thus faked or misattributed, though yes at best there are probably 'real' reads as well.

are there any of those sorts of specific reads you're referring to, that are close to 100% reliable -- or useful?
 
well, i did write at one point that i think what the emeter does is a mix -- of some real results, and some quackery. and i do think it's a mistake to dismiss it entirely -- it intially impressed some of the great pioneers of medicine and science back in the early 20th century (and, actually, in the 19th as well), for good reasons that still apply to laypeople today.

yes, i've spent a bit of time on a meter, and i've read up enough on how subdermal activity besides movement or sweat can cause changes in resistance/impedance -- have you familiarized yourself with those phenomenon? -- that it seems to me that anything treated as a 'read' in scientology could be attributed to other things, and thus faked or misattributed, though yes at best there are probably 'real' reads as well.

are there any of those sorts of specific reads you're referring to, that are close to 100% reliable -- or useful?
The problem with faking reads is they don't look real. There's a distinct difference. For instance the needle's slowly rising - looks like it's flowing, and you ask "Do you have and ARC X?" and at the precise end of the last syllable, there is a small fall, and the needle resumes its slow rise. The fall is a clean drop of the needle and it returns to the same position, at the same speed, then returns to rising. On a body read, such as lifting a finger slightly off the can, moving your foot, squeezing the cans, it rarely looks smooth, it looks jerky, doesn't often return to the place it was. The correct read may also take only a split second, and the body read may take longer. It's quite a trick to time a finger movement to occur at the preise end of the last syllable. Not early or late. No doubt you could practice faking reads and get good at it, but why? What is there to gain?

in a sec check, you don't want it to read - what body motion is going to stifle a read? The answer is think happy thoughts and produce a F/N to evade the question.

Mimsey
 
..

The emeter is a rather crude anxiety detector. That is much is true. It can, at times, detect if someone is getting more nervous than they were before.

Everything else they say about the emeter is propaganda, puffed-up nonsense and Hubbard's imagination running wild.

..

You've got part of the puzzle there, but perhaps only about 20% of it.

I'd suggest that a more accurate description of the meter is that it detects the involuntary reaction to and/or cognitive recognition of something meaningful. The meaning might be something that produces anxiety--or anything else within the vast spectrum of human experience (e.g. joy, beauty, appreciation, surprise, love, humor, hope, excitement, passion, admiration, gratitude, resolution, relief, et al)

It need not be related to anxiety. It might be something funny, ironic or revelatory. Here is a simple proof of that. Just hook up audience members to the cans during a stand-up comedian's routine or during a funny movie. Or have a rabid sports fan hold the cans during the final moments of a championship game when their favorite team and player scores the winning points as the game clock expires and victory is at long last seized. Or, how about monitoring someone's e-meter reaction when they win the lottery or upon encountering their future lifelong spouse and experiencing "love at first sight".

There is another part of the enigmatic e-meter that is also fascinating. It can react to creative insight, too. Consider the "Long Fall Blow Down" at the moment a homicide detective finally connects the dots and solves a 30 year old "cold case". Or the moment (after years of study and experiments) a Chinese restoration master finally figures out how to repair and reglaze a fragile 4000 year old vase that was shattered during an earthquake--so that it has the appropriately aged and matching patina.

Or, the meter reaction at the precise moment a musical artist somehow creatively discovered the melodic/rhythmic hook of any tune on the list of "500 BEST SONGS OF ALL TIME".


..
 
Last edited:
Is the E-meter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

Can it be both a marketing gimmick AND a quack machine? To me it is both. Someone here at ESMB2 was kind enough to send me their Mark 7. Before the battery pack died of old age, I spent a few minutes "on the cans". I adjusted the knobs as well as I could, based on the instructions I found in the instruction booklet and online. After I adjusted the knobs pretty well and grabbed the cans, the needle would seldom sit still for more than a fraction of a second. Whether I tried to strengthen my grip or relax my grip or even move the cans around in my hand, the needle just moved around however it wanted. I was not thinking about anything in particular.

To me it was just plain silly to say the needle could show that I was thinking about anything in particular, or experiencing guilt about a withhold.
 
..

Can it be both a marketing gimmick AND a quack machine? To me it is both. Someone here at ESMB2 was kind enough to send me their Mark 7. Before the battery pack died of old age, I spent a few minutes "on the cans". I adjusted the knobs as well as I could, based on the instructions I found in the instruction booklet and online. After I adjusted the knobs pretty well and grabbed the cans, the needle would seldom sit still for more than a fraction of a second. Whether I tried to strengthen my grip or relax my grip or even move the cans around in my hand, the needle just moved around however it wanted. I was not thinking about anything in particular.To me it was just plain silly to say the needle could show that I was thinking about anything in particular, or experiencing guilt about a withhold.


Same conclusion I reached. It might work sometimes but at the same time it is both a gimmick and a quack device. The law of averages plays a role. But if technology only works "sometimes", it would be like a book promoting "WIN IN LAS VEGAS 100% OF THE TIME" which very soon bankrupts 100% of those who apply that gambling tech.

It's the same for all of Scientology. For example:

Q: Did Hubbard believe the tech worked or was it his personal money racket? ​
A: Both​
​
Q: Was Fair Game canceled along with "tricking and lying"? ​
A: Yes and No. The "tricking and lying" part only keys in when Scientology has​
to handle an SP—or in moments when someone asks if the policy is really canceled.​

The "Hubbard Law of Commotion" helps explain it. ("In Scientology for each and every code, creed, policy and piece of tech, there is an equal and opposite code, creed, policy and piece of tech")

Ergo, as regards the e-meter, if something quacks like a duck and blows down like a duck and F/Ns like a duck, it's quackery. LOL

...
 
Last edited:
Even if the emeter shows a reaction, and now one needs to determine what it means based on what Hubbard said and others, after all these years nobody has really gone clear or OT.
 
after all these years nobody has really gone clear or OT.
Inquiring minds want to know: How do you know that? Have you interviewed every person that did scn and determine this by test. What is this test?

I've heard you assert this countless times, but it seems to just be YOUR rhetoric at work on us.
 
Inquiring minds want to know: How do you know that? Have you interviewed every person that did scn and determine this by test. What is this test?

I've heard you assert this countless times, but it seems to just be YOUR rhetoric at work on us.
I can only by all the people throughout my scientology involvement, first off my wife, then there are many others, I wish I could name names, I have in some of my posts. Believe me, I have known and met a lot people who supposedly went clear and made it up to OT8 and did the L's. If I disclose myself, it won't matter really, nobody knows my name in the scientology world, except OSA. If I were single thru divorce, I would really name names.
 
I'd suggest that a more accurate description of the meter is that it detects the involuntary reaction to and/or cognitive recognition of something meaningful. The meaning might be anxiety--or anything else the vast spectrum of human experience (e.g. joy, beauty, appreciation, surprise, love, humor, hope, excitement, passion, admiration, gratitude, resolution, relief, et al)

that reminds me of what i would expect would be one of the problems -- one that Hubbard with his desire to find (and sell) universal solutions wouldn't have wanted to recognize or acknowledge -- that different people could react quite differently, or not react at all to certain things, more than Hubbard's attempts to 'calibrate' could compensate for.

at the extreme, one of the reasons EDA meters and polygraphs are not very useful investigatory tools, is that while they are moderately effective at detecting whether normal people are being honest or not -- though still not reliable enough to really serve as say evidence in a courtroom -- the big problem is that pathological liars, psychopaths and those who don't believe what they did was wrong, as well as those who have figured out or been trained (like spies) to 'beat the meter', are likely to escape detection, while those are the people you really want to catch...not say honest ones who are just nervous about being under suspicion....
 
Can it be both a marketing gimmick AND a quack machine? To me it is both. Someone here at ESMB2 was kind enough to send me their Mark 7. Before the battery pack died of old age, I spent a few minutes "on the cans". I adjusted the knobs as well as I could, based on the instructions I found in the instruction booklet and online. After I adjusted the knobs pretty well and grabbed the cans, the needle would seldom sit still for more than a fraction of a second. Whether I tried to strengthen my grip or relax my grip or even move the cans around in my hand, the needle just moved around however it wanted. I was not thinking about anything in particular.

To me it was just plain silly to say the needle could show that I was thinking about anything in particular, or experiencing guilt about a withhold.
totally agree.
 
Inquiring minds want to know: How do you know that? Have you interviewed every person that did scn and determine this by test. What is this test? I've heard you assert this countless times, but it seems to just be YOUR rhetoric at work on us.


I believe Riddick is using the same technological testing methods as Dr. Hubbard when he stated that:

"SCIENTOLOGY IS THE ONLY GAME IN THE
UNIVERSE WHERE EVERYONE WINS"

—L. Ron Hubbard​

In that example, Ron's personally conducted surveys on all beings in all parts of the universe! I cannot even imagine how many times the airlines lost his luggage or scheduling glitches caused Ron to miss his connecting flights!

..

..
 
I believe Riddick is using the same technological testing methods as Dr. Hubbard when he stated that:

"SCIENTOLOGY IS THE ONLY GAME IN THE
UNIVERSE WHERE EVERYONE WINS"

—L. Ron Hubbard​

In that example, Ron's personally conducted surveys on all beings in all parts of the universe! I cannot even imagine how many times the airlines lost his luggage or scheduling glitches caused Ron to miss his connecting flights!

..

..
no HH, I wish you would stop trolling me, I've mentioned this before.
 
..

no HH, I wish you would stop trolling me, I've mentioned this before.

.

PRO TIP: It has always been incredibly easy for YOU to prevent being trolled by others. Look around the message board and you'll notice that everyone else already knows how.

I don't have authorization to reveal confidential upper-level data, but I did get permission to give you a little clue.


CLUE
What you're missing is the same exact tech that Glinda had to teach Dorothy
when she interminably complained that she was prevented from going
home and being trolled
by the Wicked Witch of the West.

GLINDA.jpg


...​
 
Last edited:
..



.


PRO TIP: It has always been incredibly easy for YOU to prevent being trolled by others. Look around the message board and you'll notice that everyone else already knows how.

I don't have authorization to reveal confidential upper-level data, but I did get permission to give you a little clue.


CLUE
What you're missing is the same exact tech that Glinda had to teach Dorothy
when she interminably complained that she was prevented from going
home and being trolled
by the Wicked Witch of the West.

GLINDA.jpg


...​


Hey Riddick, if you are serious about trying to solve your problem (that you have received untold numbers of terribly negative reactions to your posts over the last years), I am sure that people will cheerfully give you more free clues. Just ask. How hard is that?

But, if you just want to play victim and blame others for how they react to YOUR posts, then that's the same gimmick Hubbard tried to use on PCs when his tech didn't work. Blame THEM.

They've got overts, out ethics and evil purposes. They're SPs, right?

If you don't change your approach, I don't think your engram is going to erase. LOL

.
 
Last edited:
In the effort to strip this back, let's disregard any theology, ideology or ideas of quackery. At this stage, it is not important whether the states of Clear and OT are real.

We have a device called the E-meter.
It is an electrical device.
A human can interact with this device two different ways. One, as a participant, and two, as an observer.
As a participant, the being interfaces with the device by holding two metallic electrodes in the palm of their hands.
We can see that the electrodes are plugged into the device.
With the device powered on, with no participant, we observe no changes or fluctuations in the behaviour of the needle.
Add a participant, and immediately the behaviour of the needle changes.
This occurs without the need for calibration, or instruction or belief of the participant or observer.
This is observable and reproducible.

What phenomena are we observing?
 
..


..


We have a device called the E-meter.
It is an electrical device. We can see that the electrodes are plugged into the device.
With the device powered on, with no participant, we observe no changes or fluctuations in the behaviour of the needle.
Add a participant, and immediately the behaviour of the needle changes.
What phenomena are we observing?

..
ANSWER: We are observing the prelude to a free pinch test. Once that technical action has successfully been delivered, we would be observing a secondary phenomena—where the being holding the cans is tricked into donating $500,000 for a series of advanced pinch tests that will result in magical powers (or minimally a jumbo completion certificate).

..
 
Last edited:
Back
Top