Is the Emeter true or a marketing gimmick or quack machine?

Riddick

I clap to no man
The Emeter was supposed to give data on whether a person told the truth about past experiences one might say.

From my involvement in dianetics & scientology, I come to the conclusion that the emeter is a gimmick and quack machine.
 
The e-meter measures electronic skin responses affected by various activities in the brain.
Some of it is correct and some of it is not and some of it is a mixture of both.

When Dianetic auditing was failing Volney Matheson stepped in to invent the e-meter.
 
The Emeter was supposed to give data on whether a person told the truth about past experiences one might say.

From my involvement in dianetics & scientology, I come to the conclusion that the emeter is a gimmick and quack machine.
Not really - while I think Hubbard and his followers believe in it, it has a few frailties .

A) it reads on belief. If you believe you committed a crime and are withholding an overt it very well could read accurately
B) if you did the crime, but think happy thoughts, or are thinking of something else, it's likely to not read, but possibly F/N
C) if you did the crime but don't consider you did anything wrong - it may not read.
D) if you did no crime but are worried, you may go down an expensive rabbit hole
E) Some of the phenomena you drill on the meter drills are pretty accurate but some are not, for example, the favorite fruit drill. One would think it would read on your same favorite fruit every time, but it doesn't.
F) It is possible to do the dating drills and get the correct date, without the coach unduly influencing the meter. However, that drill is a perfect example of it reading on belief - the coach believes in the date he /she wrote on the paper, which is why this drill works.
G) Hubbard saying it reads just below the PC's level of awareness, is a misdirection to give the meter more validity than it actually has.
H) calling it a crude lie detector as some do, only shows their lack of understanding how it actually works and it's frailties
Mimsey
 
Last edited:
For myself my trusty MarkV e-meter worked as expected in auditing sessions.

In dianetic auditing when you give the command, "Locate an incident of . . . . " the person looks, the meter reads (the needle on the e-meter drops or falls to the right) and then two or three seconds later it is obvious that the person is into and looking at an incident.

When the person gives a list, for example a list of drugs they have taken, some of the drugs will read in various degrees like small fall, fall or long fall. Running items which read works while running items which don't read causes problems.

When a person has a cognition (realization) and good indicators the e-meter needle does in fact "float" or swing lazily back and forth.

If the person I audited got to the Examiner with an F/N, Cog, VGIs (floating needle, cognition, very good indicators) I assumed the person had learned something about themself. Good enuff

The above descriptions and others were repeated probably hundreds of thousands of times in auditing sessions. My two cents.
 
Last edited:
During the years I ran R3R, I had the same experiences as Zertel did. I was a U.S. Navy trained Sonar Technician prior to getting into Scientology, so I understood how a wheatstone bridge worked. A fall on the e-meter would indicate a lowering of the body's resistance.

The reads I obtained were instantaneous, which would be due to a reduction in the body's resistance, whether that be skin, muscle or even blood. What I don't believe is that my PC's could hear my command, send a nerve response to the brain, evaluate the command, and then send another nerve response from the brain to the skin which would instantaneously cause the skin to reduce it's resistance.

There were times during some sessions where I could tell the room was getting slightly darker as the PC ran through a particularly tough incident. There has to be something about mental mass being physical.
 
During the years I ran R3R, I had the same experiences as Zertel did. I was a U.S. Navy trained Sonar Technician prior to getting into Scientology, so I understood how a wheatstone bridge worked. A fall on the e-meter would indicate a lowering of the body's resistance.

The reads I obtained were instantaneous, which would be due to a reduction in the body's resistance, whether that be skin, muscle or even blood. What I don't believe is that my PC's could hear my command, send a nerve response to the brain, evaluate the command, and then send another nerve response from the brain to the skin which would instantaneously cause the skin to reduce it's resistance.

There were times during some sessions where I could tell the room was getting slightly darker as the PC ran through a particularly tough incident. There has to be something about mental mass being physical.
That's my point - Hubbard and his followers believe in it implicitly, and you and Zertel illustrate why they believe the meter's reads. It seems to give the responses Hubbard said there would be. That said, it isn't perfect for the reasons I mentioned, so it's a tool of dubious worth. Hubbard wrote about having to prove a read, such as putting buttons in on it, so he was aware of the problem, but didn't think it was enough of a problem to ditch using it.
Mimsey
 
I agree with what Mimsey said above (in post #3). I would like to add my own observations:

IMHO what the meter reads on is the attempt to not think of something. Especially if the PC thinks the meter can read minds and can expose his trespasses (to steal a word from Christianity), he will try to not think about it in an attempt to avoid being "discovered" -- and the harder he tries the more the meter will read.

I've been in a number of sessions where I would be asked a question, and if I were to honestly answer in the affirmative, the auditor would just want to "handle" it and burn up precious auditing hours needlessly. So I developed this technique -- when asked such a question, I would scream inside my head the word YES!! and at the same time calmly say no. It worked every time.

I've never actually used the above to escape punishment or avoid confronting a highly-charged area of my case.

Helena
 
I agree with what Mimsey said above (in post #3). I would like to add my own observations:

IMHO what the meter reads on is the attempt to not think of something. Especially if the PC thinks the meter can read minds and can expose his trespasses (to steal a word from Christianity), he will try to not think about it in an attempt to avoid being "discovered" -- and the harder he tries the more the meter will read.

I've been in a number of sessions where I would be asked a question, and if I were to honestly answer in the affirmative, the auditor would just want to "handle" it and burn up precious auditing hours needlessly. So I developed this technique -- when asked such a question, I would scream inside my head the word YES!! and at the same time calmly say no. It worked every time.

I've never actually used the above to escape punishment or avoid confronting a highly-charged area of my case.

Helena
But have you thought beautiful thoughts either at the examiner, or the success officer on your routing out routing form? When you are about to leave comping your 6 mos check - or after session the last thing you want is to not f/n. Stress is not something you need or want waiting for the ok to book your flight.

Mimsey
 
The e-meter measures electronic skin responses affected by various activities in the brain.
Some of it is correct and some of it is not and some of it is a mixture of both.

When Dianetic auditing was failing Volney Matheson stepped in to invent the e-meter.
The emeter measures the galvanic skinresponse like galvanometers have done for 100 years. Jung experimented with galvanometers already in 1906.

The galvanic skinresponse is science, the interpretion of the skinresponses can be quackery.



The E-meter is just one of many psychogalvanometers.
 
The emeter measures the galvanic skinresponse like galvanometers have done for 100 years. Jung experimented with galvanometers already in 1906.

The galvanic skinresponse is science, the interpretion of the skinresponses can be quackery.



The E-meter is just one of many psychogalvanometers.
This paragraph from "A Brief History . . . " kind of answers my question about how skin changes can occur so rapidly as to allow "reads" to appear on the e-meter.
.........................................

Eccrine sweat glands are especially dense on the palms of the hands and the soles of the feet. Of interest to our discussion is the fact that the eccrine sweat glands in the palms of the hands and the soles of our feet sweat primarily in response to psychological stress. If you’ve ever been extremely nervous or stressed, you likely experienced sweaty palms and sweaty feet. This happens because the sympathetic nervous system triggers these sweat glands in response to stress. These stress-triggered “sweat events” trigger changes the electrical resistance of your skin. For this reason, the electrodes of psychogalvanometer work best when attached the hands or the soles of the feet where the eccrine sweat glands are more heavily concentrated.
 
Last edited:
The emeter measures the galvanic skinresponse like galvanometers have done for 100 years. Jung experimented with galvanometers already in 1906.

The galvanic skinresponse is science, the interpretion of the skinresponses can be quackery.



The E-meter is just one of many psychogalvanometers.
Sort of off topic but this section caught my interest. I hadn't previously seen this description of Hubbard's involvement and experimentation at the Oak Knoll Naval Hospital.
..................................................................

Having established the scientific and psychological background of the psychogalvanometer in our previous article, in this installment we weave together several strands as we inexorably head toward the moment in which the paths of L. Ron Hubbard and the e-meter collided.

As a prelude to that collision, we find the fingerprints of L. Ron Hubbard all over the psychiatric literature at Oak Knoll Naval Hospital. During the many months Hubbard spent malingering there in the latter half of 1945, he pretended to be a medical doctor. This allowed him access to the medical library where he devoted his extensive free time to consuming psychiatric texts. He read Wundt, Freud, and even the very current works on systematic trauma reduction by William Sargant. Hubbard was very busy educating himself.

Hubbard experimented on other patients at Oak Knoll and tried out his various proto-Dianetics techniques on them. Hubbard’s “experiments” on patients at the Navy hospital were unauthorized, illegal, and foreshadowed the Dianetics Research Foundation of Elizabeth, New Jersey being criminally charged in January 1951 for operating a medical school without a license.

During his pre-Dianetics years from 1945-1949, Hubbard was so consumed by Freudian psychotherapy, narcosynthesis, hypnotic techniques, Aleister Crowley’s Thelema, and his own personal drama that he never made the connection between what he was doing and the psychogalvanometer. Someone else would have to make that connection for him at a later date by literally shoving a meter into his hands.
 
But have you thought beautiful thoughts either at the examiner, or the success officer on your routing out routing form? When you are about to leave comping your 6 mos check - or after session the last thing you want is to not f/n. Stress is not something you need or want waiting for the ok to book your flight.

Mimsey
What stress? With my method, there is no stress.

Helena
 
The emeter measures the galvanic skinresponse like galvanometers have done for 100 years. Jung experimented with galvanometers already in 1906.

The galvanic skinresponse is science, the interpretion of the skinresponses can be quackery.



The E-meter is just one of many psychogalvanometers.
"The galvanic skinresponse is science, the interpretion of the skinresponses can be quackery."

Well, there you go. Hubbard said reading the emeter was sort of a art, if I recall correctly.
 
Not really - while I think Hubbard and his followers believe in it, it has a few frailties .

A) it reads on belief. If you believe you committed a crime and are withholding an overt it very well could read accurately
B) if you did the crime, but think happy thoughts, or are thinking of something else, it's likely to not read, but possibly F/N
C) if you did the crime but don't consider you did anything wrong - it may not read.
D) if you did no crime but are worried, you may go down an expensive rabbit hole
E) Some of the phenomena you drill on the meter drills are pretty accurate but some are not, for example, the favorite fruit drill. One would think it would read on your same favorite fruit every time, but it doesn't.
F) It is possible to do the dating drills and get the correct date, without the coach unduly influencing the meter. However, that drill is a perfect example of it reading on belief - the coach believes in the date he /she wrote on the paper, which is why this drill works.
G) Hubbard saying it reads just below the PC's level of awareness, is a misdirection to give the meter more validity than it actually has.
H) calling it a crude lie detector as some do, only shows their lack of understanding how it actually works and it's frailties
Mimsey
let me ask you, have you done studies on the emeter and their results to create a clear or OT? You know, scientific studies to confirm.
 
If there was no stress, why scream "yes" with your internal monologue? Why not simply be there confronting the auditor with nothing, in total waste of whether it read or not? Mimsey
It's the effort to not think of something that causes the stress that makes the meter read. Screaming yes while saying no is how you eliminate the stress.

And if you don't answer at all, the auditor will just TR-3 it.

Helena
 
It's the effort to not think of something that causes the stress that makes the meter read. Screaming yes while saying no is how you eliminate the stress.

And if you don't answer at all, the auditor will just TR-3 it.

Helena
The procedure is ask the question and see if it reads, and if so, look expectantly at the pc. What you are doing is non-standard. If you are answering the question No when the auditor is looking at you expectantly, while thinking yes, the auditor is going to then prove the read with buttons like false, suppress etc.

If you are answering the question before he / she looks up, the auditor needs to re-hat you on proper procedure. If Hubbard's theory that the reads are instant is valid, then you are thinking your answer too late. It's difficult to think "No" at the precise instant of the end of the last syllable of the spoken question uttered by the auditor.

If your auditor is repeatedly letting you respond verbally before he / she looks up, that auditor needs to be crammed.

Mimsey

"Have your meter in a position (line of sight) so you can see the list and the needle or you can see the needle and the pc. The meter position is important.

Hold the mimeoed list close beside the meter. Have your worksheet more to the right. Keep record on your worksheet. Mark the pc’s name and date on it. Mark what list it is on the worksheet with time. It remains in the folder stapled to the worksheet.

Read the question on the list, note if it reads. Do NOT read it while looking at the pc, do NOT read it to yourself and then say it while looking at the pc. These are the L10 actions and are called Method 6, not Method 3. It is more important to see the pc’s cans than his face as can fiddle can fake or upset reads.

TR 1 must be good so the pc clearly hears it.

You are looking for an INSTANT READ that occurs at the end of the exact last syllable of the question.

If it does not read, mark the list X. If the list is being done through an F/N and the F/N just continues, mark the question F/N.

If the question reads, do not say, “That reads.” Mark the read at once (tick, sF, F, LF, LFBD, R/S), transfer the number of the question to the worksheet and look expectantly at the pc. You can repeat the question by just saying it again if pc doesn’t begin to talk. He has probably already begun to answer as the question was live in his bank, as noted by the meter.

Take down the pc’s remarks in shortened form on the worksheet. Note any TA changes on the worksheet."

 
Last edited:
The procedure is ask the question and see if it reads, and if so, look expectantly at the pc. What you are doing is non-standard. If you are answering the question No when the auditor is looking at you expectantly, while thinking yes, the auditor is going to then prove the read with buttons like false, suppress etc.

If you are answering the question before he / she looks up, the auditor needs to re-hat you on proper procedure. If Hubbard's theory that the reads are instant is valid, then you are thinking your answer too late. It's difficult to think "No" at the precise instant of the end of the last syllable of the spoken question uttered by the auditor.

If your auditor is repeatedly letting you respond verbally before he / she looks up, that auditor needs to be crammed.

Mimsey

"Have your meter in a position (line of sight) so you can see the list and the needle or you can see the needle and the pc. The meter position is important.

Hold the mimeoed list close beside the meter. Have your worksheet more to the right. Keep record on your worksheet. Mark the pc’s name and date on it. Mark what list it is on the worksheet with time. It remains in the folder stapled to the worksheet.

Read the question on the list, note if it reads. Do NOT read it while looking at the pc, do NOT read it to yourself and then say it while looking at the pc. These are the L10 actions and are called Method 6, not Method 3. It is more important to see the pc’s cans than his face as can fiddle can fake or upset reads.

TR 1 must be good so the pc clearly hears it.

You are looking for an INSTANT READ that occurs at the end of the exact last syllable of the question.

If it does not read, mark the list X. If the list is being done through an F/N and the F/N just continues, mark the question F/N.

If the question reads, do not say, “That reads.” Mark the read at once (tick, sF, F, LF, LFBD, R/S), transfer the number of the question to the worksheet and look expectantly at the pc. You can repeat the question by just saying it again if pc doesn’t begin to talk. He has probably already begun to answer as the question was live in his bank, as noted by the meter.

Take down the pc’s remarks in shortened form on the worksheet. Note any TA changes on the worksheet."

I never responded too soon. And if you shout yes to yourself inside your head, you are not lying or suppressing the thought, so it will F/N.

And this entire procedure -- fooling the e-meter -- is nonstandard.

Helena
 
Back
Top