How Ideal Orgs Are Causing Current Scientologists To Leave Scientology

Thought that might be the case, I have read it and it's very intelligently written out. I'm pretty sure the people I know who are in won't have read it but may have known who she was.

I guess that is one benefit from those of you that were in for so long! Is that you did an insane amount of word clearing and other tech so I do envy the level of intelligence and use of language I come across on here. The letter was brilliant although parts flew right over my head.

I literally did about two/three introductory courses before quitting. So i will struggle along and pick up and learn what I can about this mad org so apologise in advance for my naivities 😂
Can I ask what turned you off to not continue?
 
Someone mentioned "personal attack..."

That is what did it for me.

This is a bit different from "abuse..."

Abuse could go on for years....or even decades. You can blame it on the "system" or other reasons.....

But personal attack....well.....its personal. Directly at one.

That to me is the final straw....and makes people leave.
 
Can I ask what turned you off to not continue?

Long time ago now, I can't quite remember. Whilst doing the course over 15 years ago I did bombard them with questions. It was just certain things that struck me. Telling me how great it was yet I knew staff didn't get paid well and if the tech was so great, why was their success in marketing it so woeful! I was always strong in sales and i thought the pricing model made no sense, no carrots or discounts etc.

If you want to clear the planet then do the first set of courses dirt cheap surely????

Don't get me wrong some of it sounded appealing but I'm not an avid reader and that kept talking about all the wonderful books lol hahaha

It wasn't a match made in heaven, they told me not to read the negative stuff but I did. I think I may have been slightly sceptical when I went in, I do recall a very nice girl who was supervising me (fancied her a little) told me that she was joining staff or the sea org and I remember thinking she had been duped so I must have had doubts. I also thought Tom Cruise was abit quirky and previous to that when I went to East Grinstead DM was doing some event and it was a full on cheese fest and thought DM was abit of a cock! That made me raise an eyebrow anyway.

They have co-incidently tried getting me to consider courses again, very recently infact via the people I know. I'd share it but I'm paranoid it could point a finger at me.
 
Lucky you! And there's no need to apologize for being smart enough to walk away quickly.

(I'm being serious, not ironic here). Its cool to see that you are interested to see how the ex-community is going and that you've joined the forums. Most people leave and then spend their lives trying to get away.
in my book, anyone is welcome to help "fight the good fight" - old SO salts, staff long timers, short-timers, public, never-ins, ex-members of other cults. Deep down we all know that we have a dog in this fight and that we are stronger when we are connected.

Thanks and your very right

I've remained interested as I know people who are still in which I've mentioned. I don't think they will come out anytime soon. If anything they are more full on than ever unfortunately. I play along though and respect their choices but just help them should they come out as that will be one bitter pill.

I'd love to be able to find that magic seed that can be sewn and wake them up.
 
Long time ago now, I can't quite remember. Whilst doing the course over 15 years ago I did bombard them with questions. It was just certain things that struck me. Telling me how great it was yet I knew staff didn't get paid well and if the tech was so great, why was their success in marketing it so woeful! I was always strong in sales and i thought the pricing model made no sense, no carrots or discounts etc.

If you want to clear the planet then do the first set of courses dirt cheap surely????

Don't get me wrong some of it sounded appealing but I'm not an avid reader and that kept talking about all the wonderful books lol hahaha

It wasn't a match made in heaven, they told me not to read the negative stuff but I did. I think I may have been slightly sceptical when I went in, I do recall a very nice girl who was supervising me (fancied her a little) told me that she was joining staff or the sea org and I remember thinking she had been duped so I must have had doubts. I also thought Tom Cruise was abit quirky and previous to that when I went to East Grinstead DM was doing some event and it was a full on cheese fest and thought DM was abit of a cock! That made me raise an eyebrow anyway.

They have co-incidently tried getting me to consider courses again, very recently infact via the people I know. I'd share it but I'm paranoid it could point a finger at me.
They are persistent, and your name shows up on the lists because you bought something a long time ago. They have gone through those lists many, many times. It is desperation that drives them to try to get you back in, not coincidence. I know this because I was once someone that would call or write to people that hadn't been to an org for thirty years.

They believe that everything that lrh wrote or said is magnificent or magic almost. Sad, isn't it, when you look at it that way, that they no longer need to think for themselves, yet tell you that you don't need to listen to someone else, or shouldn't. Just listen to them. Don't listen to anyone else. Should be a red flag, shouldn't it? It was to you, that's smart.
 
Our house mortgage principal was just over 60k from being paid off. Ideal org loans changed that.

We are a status that I can't say because it could give us away. We aren't new civilization builders, but we are more than humanitarians.

Right now, after cranking it back up to around 150k, we are at about 95k on the house. A wonder what a 15 year mortgage will do!! We both work but I can see a day in the future where we can take the foot off the gas a little, or a lot.

I know people older than us by a bit deeper in debt than us, and they are on a fixed income.

I was talking to a guy that's on the edge of leaving the cult the other day, and I asked him how many scientologists that he knew that had a mountain of debt. It was every one of them.
 
Our house mortgage principal was just over 60k from being paid off. Ideal org loans changed that.

We are a status that I can't say because it could give us away. We aren't new civilization builders, but we are more than humanitarians.

Right now, after cranking it back up to around 150k, we are at about 95k on the house. A wonder what a 15 year mortgage will do!! We both work but I can see a day in the future where we can take the foot off the gas a little, or a lot.

I know people older than us by a bit deeper in debt than us, and they are on a fixed income.

I was talking to a guy that's on the edge of leaving the cult the other day, and I asked him how many scientologists that he knew that had a mountain of debt. It was every one of them.

That is one of the few elements that makes it better being in the SO than public - you don't have the resources to build up a mountain of debt that will pursue you for the rest of your life.
As for the freeloader bill, it is useless... well, one can use it as toilet paper during the pandemic I guess.
 
That is one of the few elements that makes it better being in the SO than public - you don't have the resources to build up a mountain of debt that will pursue you for the rest of your life.
As for the freeloader bill, it is useless... well, one can use it as toilet paper during the pandemic I guess.
One thing I did when I was public, was to bring discipline my finances with respect to Scientology. Particularly after I had a wife and kids to consider.

I refused to go into debt for Scientology. Any Scientology stuff had to be paid for out of current gross income. Moreover (and I didn't tell reges this) I limited my Scn payments to just the increase in my income, current year minus prior year. It still resulted in me getting through much of the OT levels.

I also adopted the practice of being a "submarine Scientologist", where I would surface, do a bunch of things in one visit, then dive off their radar until I had accumulated enough funds to do more services. I adopted this practice after the madness I saw during the early 1980's when the Int Finance Police were ravaging through the Scn community. I very deliberately chose to live far from any org.

I think, starting in the early 80's, I was developing the opinion "The tech may be good, but we have a bunch of lunatics in management positions", and not dwelling on the implications of that opinion.
 
We didn't get "in" financial policy until it was past a good point. We were both on staff for a brief time, and income was god awful, just afetr the ideal opening. At this point we found Aldi's, and began eating economically, and for a couple of "foodies", we did pretty well.

We got out if it, and are surviving this time pretty well, I am proud of us. My income has remained constant, and her's has dipped for good reason, not that we entirely agree.

BTW, our financial policy before was dictated by the regges. It's a wonder we aren't utterly insane!!!
 
The one thing I can never wrap my head around is who's benefiting
from all this financial scamming for decades. Usually in financial scams,
there's a bunch of people "wetting their beaks" and they all have vested
interests in keeping the scams going. In this particular one, all I see is:
  • David Miscavige
  • his teams of lawyers and outside accounting consultants
  • outside PIs and surveillance people
  • outside suppliers
  • some exes: millions to Debbie Cook, Marty Rathbun and a few more over the years
But mostly and singularly David Miscavige, through control of assets and corporations.

Am I missing something?

For the benefit of mostly one person? How can this be?
 
Last edited:
One thing I did when I was public, was to bring discipline my finances with respect to Scientology. Particularly after I had a wife and kids to consider.

I refused to go into debt for Scientology. Any Scientology stuff had to be paid for out of current gross income. Moreover (and I didn't tell reges this) I limited my Scn payments to just the increase in my income, current year minus prior year. It still resulted in me getting through much of the OT levels.

I also adopted the practice of being a "submarine Scientologist", where I would surface, do a bunch of things in one visit, then dive off their radar until I had accumulated enough funds to do more services. I adopted this practice after the madness I saw during the early 1980's when the Int Finance Police were ravaging through the Scn community. I very deliberately chose to live far from any org.

I think, starting in the early 80's, I was developing the opinion "The tech may be good, but we have a bunch of lunatics in management positions", and not dwelling on the implications of that opinion.
After looking over the thread a few comments.

I can only go from around 1990 on but there has been a dramatic change on emphasis from doing services to donated "for the greater good of the planet" I really think Scn has been in decline for this whole time. I mark the basics as the start of milking those in and really giving up on new raw meat. The ideal orgs started as an experiment it must have succeeded but now it is very long in the tooth. I am not sure this current lock down might not be an excuse for DM to do another basic realignment of Scn. All these orgs are costing much with little coming in. The trick is how to convince the Scn sheeple.

The last few Ideal orgs I have knowledge of did not make their fund raising goals, I am sure of it. They were only completed to keep up the facade .
There may be a time coming that all pretense is abandoned. I have been privy to a few private FB pages that seemed to indicate that with this Corona virus situation that the 4 th dynamic is psychotic and unable to be audited . Only rank and file staff members but it does show a change of attitude. I have long said Scn will pull back first to the upper orgs and lastly probably to FLAG. The big question on how this will proceed is if DM is a believer or just in it to shear the whales.

For me the basics was more of a red flag than the ideal orgs. The coming out of having to redo the purif and student hat sealed the deal for me.

Finally on the money. the week after 9/11 the ED called and said he needed 5k that night to save the planet. He didn't get it. The reason i bring this up is that I reminded him of that around 2012 when he needed 50k for the ideal org. I told him he saved the planet w/o me then and he will do it with out me now. i am forced to remain associated with Scn and under the radar but have been fairly successful in limiting money spent to the traditional tithe levels given to a religion. At least that is how I justify it to the regges.
 
The one thing I can never wrap my head around is who's benefiting
from all this financial scamming for decades. Usually in financial scams
there's a bunch of people "wetting their beaks" and they all have vested
interests in keeping the scams going. In this particular one, all I see is:
  • David Miscavige
  • his teams of lawyers and outside accounting consultants
  • outside PIs and surveillance people
  • outside suppliers
  • some exes: millions to Debbie Cook, Marty Rathbun and a few more over the years
But mostly and singularly David Miscavige, through control of assets and corporations.

Am I missing something? How can this be?
Hubbard wanted to be comfortably off, but I feel that was 10% of his focus. 90% was being a guru, a game-maker and having more and more followers to order around.

Dave... I think in some misguided way Dave thinks of himself as a "caretaker" of scientology. He's just doing "managed, long-term decline" and avoids rocking the boat either way. Debbie and Marty gave him a scare, because they appealed to believers. Oh and of course living the life of a millionaire playing polo with Cruise seems to keep his spirits up.
 
Last edited:
The one thing I can never wrap my head around is who's benefiting
from all this financial scamming for decades. Usually in financial scams
there's a bunch of people "wetting their beaks" and they all have vested
interests in keeping the scams going. In this particular one, all I see is:
  • David Miscavige
  • his teams of lawyers and outside accounting consultants
  • outside PIs and surveillance people
  • outside suppliers
  • some exes: millions to Debbie Cook, Marty Rathbun and a few more over the years
But mostly and singularly David Miscavige, through control of assets and corporations.

Am I missing something? How can this be?

I think it has a lot to do with commissions being paid for IAS (do they pay them for Ideal Org fundraisers?) All those freedom medal winners and full-time IAS regs (non-SO) going around regging for cash are making a living from the 10% skim off the top.

As far as payments for services, of course the orgs benefit. No GI no pay, no heat, lights or phones. The stats system also puts a lot of pressure on staff. The main benefit is not getting screamed at, not becoming ethic bait.

If you're talking Slatkin type scamming - that's a different kettle of fish - pure criminal greed.
 
For me the basics was more of a red flag than the ideal orgs. The coming out of having to redo the purif and student hat sealed the deal for me.
The way I head people interpret it (in hush-hush voices no less) was that Ideal Orgs were a way of keeping the IRS off our backs and also bringing back OT VIII whales back into the game. GAT and related changes... I have no idea what was its purpose. Limit damage after L.McPherson? Rip people off by re-releasing a few books? Was that worth it?

I have long said Scn will pull back first to the upper orgs and lastly probably to FLAG.
Maybe its my skewed point of view, but I think it would contract to PAC, Gold and Flag. I'm somewhat suspecting that PAC would outlast both Flag and even Gold. Maybe long, long into the future the last living scientologist will be found living off stockpiled funds in big blue. Alone in the endless corridors, with no one left to audit.

That would be a creepy movie: "Left behind IV - the Last Scientologist"
 
The one thing I can never wrap my head around is who's benefiting
from all this financial scamming for decades. Usually in financial scams,
there's a bunch of people "wetting their beaks" and they all have vested
interests in keeping the scams going. In this particular one, all I see is:
  • David Miscavige
  • his teams of lawyers and outside accounting consultants
  • outside PIs and surveillance people
  • outside suppliers
  • some exes: millions to Debbie Cook, Marty Rathbun and a few more over the years
But mostly and singularly David Miscavige, through control of assets and corporations.

Am I missing something?

For the benefit of mostly one person? How can this be?

I don't know, but when you are talking about large amounts of money, and large amounts of abuse, you are likely to need to pay off a number of people, both in and outside government, to get away with it for long amounts of time.
 
I think it has a lot to do with commissions being paid for IAS (do they pay them for Ideal Org fundraisers?) All those freedom medal winners and full-time IAS regs (non-SO) going around regging for cash are making a living from the 10% skim off the top.

As far as payments for services, of course the orgs benefit. No GI no pay, no heat, lights or phones. The stats system also puts a lot of pressure on staff. The main benefit is not getting screamed at, not becoming ethic bait.

If you're talking Slatkin type scamming - that's a different kettle of fish - pure criminal greed.
The were paying commissions for ideal org fundraisers, I think it may have been around 10%. But then I heard at some point (2012ish?) that they stopped paying commissions. Guys like Bill Bertineau, after his ASHO days were over, showed up in Columbus to make a living from that. Peggy Crawford was running around making commissions. They also had Charmaine Roger doing a bunch of regging, but since she was SO, she probably got other perks, like maybe gift cards, I am not sure.
 
The one thing I can never wrap my head around is who's benefiting
from all this financial scamming for decades. Usually in financial scams,
there's a bunch of people "wetting their beaks" and they all have vested
interests in keeping the scams going. In this particular one, all I see is:
  • David Miscavige
  • his teams of lawyers and outside accounting consultants
  • outside PIs and surveillance people
  • outside suppliers
  • some exes: millions to Debbie Cook, Marty Rathbun and a few more over the years
But mostly and singularly David Miscavige, through control of assets and corporations.

Am I missing something?

For the benefit of mostly one person? How can this be?


I can't imagine DM not having squirreled some money away someplace, if not lots of places...IMO.

A Billion Dollars just doesn't go as far as it use to..... :D
 
Back
Top