How Ideal Orgs Are Causing Current Scientologists To Leave Scientology

I think there is another point, and that is this:

6. The scientology business model doesn't work.

The cost of going clear, let alone OT, is out of the reach of most people. I watched a video that I now wish that I had recorded. It was COB briefing org ED's, maybe dated 2013 - 2014. I think it occurred somewhere in EU, maybe at AOSH EU. In this briefing, he talked about pricing the new courses like SRD and student hat at $ 2500 USD. He said (paraphrased) "you guys told me the price that you wanted, that is where that price came from. It could be lower but YOU said that was the price that you were comfortable with." I didn't see how this could be possible, that someone didn't really noodle the pricing out to give economy of scale, or make it more attainable. I don't see how a young college graduate earning 30 - 40k in a starting position could afford to go clear in a year or two if they decided that was what they wanted to do. All other arguments aside, of course the DIV 6 line is not bringing people in in droves, the floors are not collapsing, of course again for various other reasons. But consider this my current scientologist friend, could you have afforded this when you were 20? 30? The pricing scheme is still awkward, with the sliding scale, and it is still out of reach of many.

I think we have the difference between Hubbard and DM here. Hubbard was in many ways the classic cult guru and, while he was out to get cash, he was out to spread his ideas and he was interested in expanding the reach of the CoS.

Dave I believe sees himself as a "caretaker" of scientology and long ago made the decision not to try to expand with what is an unpopular product. Rather, he is all about "managed decline" and milking the existing "customers" rather than getting new ones. And the focus is squarely on whales, not on joe shmoe. That's why existing services are expensive, donations are more important that services and things get re-written every few years. Its milking the existing customers again and again.
 
I don't know about you guys, but there was nothing an outsider, friend or family member could have said to me that would have made a difference. It took for me to watch my husband be brutally treated when he wanted to leave staff after his contract ended for me to really start to question. Then I was brutally treated for questioning the treatment he received, and all of a sudden it was personal. Once the crack appeared it widened fairly quickly, BUT then you have to overcome to awful realisation that if you leave you will lose one or more of the following - family, spouse, children, religion, belief system, friends, career, social circle, job etc. It was all of those for me in the end and probably the same for many others.

I think it comes down to where the greatest pain lies - leaving or staying. I bet there are thousands of people "in" that are only there for appearances because they just don't want to deal with all the shit. In fact I know there are many like that even in my city.
It took me receiving some pretty brutal life changing treatment before I finally said ENOUGH!!!

I didn't purposefully look at entheta, I kept towing the company line for years after I knew there were unexplained oddities. I didn't read Debbie Cook's email, but that really made me wonder, and really got my attention. That was a landmark thing in my world in spite of not reading it. There wasn't an out reach from the community of "being out of scientology". As a scientologist, we often heard "Not As Ron Intended" and that impinged. I think that there is an opening, scientology inc. still uses it.
 
I think there is another point, and that is this:

6. The scientology business model doesn't work.

The cost of going clear, let alone OT, is out of the reach of most people. I watched a video that I now wish that I had recorded. It was COB briefing org ED's, maybe dated 2013 - 2014. I think it occurred somewhere in EU, maybe at AOSH EU. In this briefing, he talked about pricing the new courses like SRD and student hat at $ 2500 USD. He said (paraphrased) "you guys told me the price that you wanted, that is where that price came from. It could be lower but YOU said that was the price that you were comfortable with." I didn't see how this could be possible, that someone didn't really noodle the pricing out to give economy of scale, or make it more attainable. I don't see how a young college graduate earning 30 - 40k in a starting position could afford to go clear in a year or two if they decided that was what they wanted to do. All other arguments aside, of course the DIV 6 line is not bringing people in in droves, the floors are not collapsing, of course again for various other reasons. But consider this my current scientologist friend, could you have afforded this when you were 20? 30? The pricing scheme is still awkward, with the sliding scale, and it is still out of reach of many.
They price it on a level that a middle-class person would have to spend his lifetime giving most of his income to Scientology. Especially the OT-7/8/L's segment.

The LAST thing they want is for people to be able to complete the Bridge in just a few years, and then have a whole bunch of people standing around asking "Is this all there is?".
 
My cracks started to really appear when I KR'd my seniors all the way up to Int Management for policy violations with GAT implementation. I was being a good Scientologist. Jeeez the fallout of that. I was dehumanised. It was about the same time everything else was falling apart, hubby being treated badly etc. Once the house of cards starts to fall it can happen quickly.
 
They price it on a level that a middle-class person would have to spend his lifetime giving most of his income to Scientology. Especially the OT-7/8/L's segment.

The LAST thing they want is for people to be able to complete the Bridge in just a few years, and then have a whole bunch of people standing around asking "Is this all there is?".
Totally!!

But you and I know that the idea of clearing the planet exists within the scientologist at all levels, and within by staff and outside of organizations by public, except not really at the apex. Seems odd.
 
My cracks started to really appear when I KR'd my seniors all the way up to Int Management for policy violations with GAT implementation. I was being a good Scientologist. Jeeez the fallout of that. I was dehumanised. It was about the same time everything else was falling apart, hubby being treated badly etc. Once the house of cards starts to fall it can happen quickly.
Boy, that didn't fit the company line. Those were tough times, keep delivery stats up and get auditors through the line up, all the while trying to sort out the oddities that auditors were running into while doing the new lineup and doing CR's. I watched auditors just give up when they saw the line up and got the idea of what they were going to have to do to get back into the chair.

I queried the logic behind the staff pay policy letter back in 1997 to INT. I am actually a numbers kinda jerk. I never heard back, I never got a KR or study assignment.
 
Dotey OT - you said, "He said (paraphrased) "you guys told me the price that you wanted, that is where that price came from. It could be lower but YOU said that was the price that you were comfortable with."

When I was in, I read in a few different books:

" WE wanted to call it a religion, it was not him."

I don't recall where I read that but I BELIEVED it.

I think Miscavige chanels Hubbard when he changes the "tech" to further gas light people. The gas lighting works because of BELIEF. No one even asks to see the "science" in Scientology. They just walk around with total certainty that everything they read is from Hubbard and it is true.

Some easy peasy mind control methods to keep the sheep dumbed down.
 
Boy, that didn't fit the company line. Those were tough times, keep delivery stats up and get auditors through the line up, all the while trying to sort out the oddities that auditors were running into while doing the new lineup and doing CR's. I watched auditors just give up when they saw the line up and got the idea of what they were going to have to do to get back into the chair.

I queried the logic behind the staff pay policy letter back in 1997 to INT. I am actually a numbers kinda jerk. I never heard back, I never got a KR or study assignment.

I think that's why a lot of "techies" come out of Scientology with the "Tech good - management bad" theory. It was always the admin people who screwed over the tech people. They'd try and recruit your brand new Div 6 PC and blow him off, or try and reg your new Student Hat student for staff and blow him off as well. Then the tech person got KRd or sent to cramming for out tech because the students/PCs had blown. It was an insane organisation. If any wog organisation did that they'd fold.
 
I think that's why a lot of "techies" come out of Scientology with the "Tech good - management bad" theory. It was always the admin people who screwed over the tech people. They'd try and recruit your brand new Div 6 PC and blow him off, or try and reg your new Student Hat student for staff and blow him off as well. Then the tech person got KRd or sent to cramming for out tech because the students/PCs had blown. It was an insane organisation. If any wog organisation did that they'd fold.
It was like there were two purposes within the company, always. Tech guys wanted to help the individual, at least that is what I saw around me. I saw some pretty damn conscientious people in the tech area. DIV 2, different story. I was in both in my illustrious career, loved tech, I fit sideways into DIV 2.
 
Totally!!

But you and I know that the idea of clearing the planet exists within the scientologist at all levels, and within by staff and outside of organizations by public, except not really at the apex. Seems odd.
The apex - Dave, Heber, Marty, Guillaume, Mike, Marc, Susan, Norman, Ray, Janet... these people had a top-down view on the whole thing. They knew that there is no OT IX or anything above that. They knew that OT VIII is mostly stuff made up by Dave. They knew it all and they ran the whole thing as one big dog and pony show.

The rest of us shmucks had an ant-view, so we didn't know.

Scientology is a game and was designed to be a game. Took me a while to figure that last part out. Luckily DM has not removed or censored Hubbard's lectures on games (I guess they were sure we are all too stupid to figure things out) and he lays it all out if you connect the dots.

DM and the executives knew scientology was a game designed to be played with broken pieces. And yet they decided to play it.
Ron was the 'game-maker'. Dave is the 'player'. Marc, Mike, Marty and the rest of executive strata were the 'assistant players'.
I was the guy tasked with braking the pieces.
 
Last edited:
If you happened to forward Debbies email or send it as a letter to a scientlogist. Would they read it do you think?
 
I understand members from OSA are supposed to monitor boards like this, is this true?

How safe is our identity and info?
 
If you happened to forward Debbies email or send it as a letter to a scientlogist. Would they read it do you think?
I am not sure someone currently in would read it. I would almost bet they wouldn't. They know it's out there, and the church hadn't come to a standstill because of it, so there isn't anything there.

I don't think that a currently-in scientologist would read her email on purpose, unless they were already on their way out. It's a great piece, and worth a read if you haven't. It is likely that there are a few that are still in that read a little before they realized what was happening. There are some that probably heard about it ad didn't read it, like us. Some still in may have read it all, but it's unlikely.
 
I understand members from OSA are supposed to monitor boards like this, is this true?

How safe is our identity and info?
If you were worried about your identity being known, that you would lose a connection to someone currently in, I wouldn't reveal anything that would let your identity be known. I have only been here several years, but have heard that in the past boards like this were monitored.
 
I understand members from OSA are supposed to monitor boards like this, is this true?

How safe is our identity and info?
Don't post in public anything you would not want OSA to have. I'm pretty sure there at least 1 sorry good being tasked with reading these baords and prolly he has a stat like: "interesting pieces of info found". :moodswing:

Nowadays they seem to be less likely to engage in risky black ops or send PIs to bother you unless you are a very high profile defector like Mark Bunker etc. I think there are simply too many critics out and OSA doesn't seem to have the resources and manpower it used to have.

Having said that, there's always a chance your dog will get poisoned, your tires being cut, your kid being harassed on his way to school or your boss getting a false tip about you being a sex offender. So better to err on the side of caution.

Oh yeah and they for certain will bother people who are still inside and who are connected with you. So best don't reveal their identity.
 
Dotey OT - you said, "He said (paraphrased) "you guys told me the price that you wanted, that is where that price came from. It could be lower but YOU said that was the price that you were comfortable with."

When I was in, I read in a few different books:

" WE wanted to call it a religion, it was not him."

I don't recall where I read that but I BELIEVED it.

I think Miscavige chanels Hubbard when he changes the "tech" to further gas light people. The gas lighting works because of BELIEF. No one even asks to see the "science" in Scientology. They just walk around with total certainty that everything they read is from Hubbard and it is true.

Some easy peasy mind control methods to keep the sheep dumbed down.
Believe me, even at that time when I was pretty amped up with koolaid, it was hard to think that ED's in any way influenced price. But I also thought who knows??
 
I queried the logic behind the staff pay policy letter back in 1997 to INT. I am actually a numbers kinda jerk. I never heard back, I never got a KR or study assignment.
I would assume you probably did get a KR, but then it got decommited and that's why you did not hear about it.
 
I am not sure someone currently in would read it. I would almost bet they wouldn't. They know it's out there, and the church hadn't come to a standstill because of it, so there isn't anything there.

I don't think that a currently-in scientologist would read her email on purpose, unless they were already on their way out. It's a great piece, and worth a read if you haven't. It is likely that there are a few that are still in that read a little before they realized what was happening. There are some that probably heard about it ad didn't read it, like us. Some still in may have read it all, but it's unlikely.

Thought that might be the case, I have read it and it's very intelligently written out. I'm pretty sure the people I know who are in won't have read it but may have known who she was.

I guess that is one benefit from those of you that were in for so long! Is that you did an insane amount of word clearing and other tech so I do envy the level of intelligence and use of language I come across on here. The letter was brilliant although parts flew right over my head.

I literally did about two/three introductory courses before quitting. So i will struggle along and pick up and learn what I can about this mad org so apologise in advance for my naivities 😂
 
I literally did about two/three introductory courses before quitting. So i will struggle along and pick up and learn what I can about this mad org so apologise in advance for my naivities 😂
Lucky you! And there's no need to apologize for being smart enough to walk away quickly.

(I'm being serious, not ironic here). Its cool to see that you are interested to see how the ex-community is going and that you've joined the forums. Most people leave and then spend their lives trying to get away.
in my book, anyone is welcome to help "fight the good fight" - old SO salts, staff long timers, short-timers, public, never-ins, ex-members of other cults. Deep down we all know that we have a dog in this fight and that we are stronger when we are connected.
 
Back
Top