Are Independent Scnists Hated?

.

There is a difference between quoting Hubbard to show that he was internally inconsistent, (i.e., HH's Hubbard's Law of Commotion) and quoting Hubbard assuming that he was substantively correct as the part or premise of an argument.I actually agree that everything Hubbard said was not complete and total shit. I just doubt that is a discussion that you want to have with a Scientologist. Otherwise, the Scientologist quickly turns the discussion into getting you to list the Hubbard and Scientology data that you agree with.
/


LOL!

Yes, there is always that liability--that an ex-scientologist goes into a Hubbardite's home to do an intervention--and stumbles out 17 hours later, introverted, badly shaken and frantically trying to borrow money from everyone to handle their "ruin".

.

.
 
Last edited:
.

Also, just because we may think that somebody using Scn tech is misled or deluded, does not mean we "hate" her.

.
Thanks for spotlighting the straw man title for the thread, albeit formulated as a question. Admittedly, it's a good conversation starter. But it's consistent with the victimhood claim of the Independent Scientologist's video that is being discussed.

The propaganda-promo video seemed like it was dripping and oozing the chronic millennial gimmick of victimhood and inferring that others are "Haters!" if they don't agree.

I do, however, fully understand and appreciate that a true-believing cult member will say just about anything to "handle" DBs on this slave planet. It's unfortunate that the producers of that video pimped out and wasted their marketing skills in an altogether flakey effort to sell the non-existent "miracles" of a pathological liar--Hubbard.

They should have invested a little bit of that time and energy, instead, into committing the Scientology HIGH CRIME known as due diligence.

.
 
Last edited:
.

The Indie's video promises to answer its title's burning question. . .

WHY I'M HATED
​
However, the "why finding" never mentions that people don't like being lied to by Hubbard or his sales representatives. Especially when the pitchman cannot get through a simple sales presentation without resorting to infallibly imperious condescension and nasty jabs at anyone who dares to disagree. (see proof in the earlier visits by that same Indie to this discussion forum, that showcases how badly Hubbard's tech fails in the real world where people are allowed to have their own opinions)

These things are hallmarks from Hubbard's hat writeup. On the positive side, however, at least staff members are finally studying, drilling and really duplicating their hat. LOL.

.
 
Last edited:
Interesting thread topic.

The original exscn has gone back and forth on the subject of FZers. I think exscn2 is far more clear. Generally, discussion is fine but selling or promoting Scn services on here isn’t. Actually, that’s probably true for anyone selling anything on here.

At least, that’s how it seems to me. What do I know.

I like FZers the most when they haven’t lost touch with reality and can shift gears, treating the FZ stuff like a hobby, daydream or entertainment. Then I don’t mind it a bit because they’re not stuck in it to the exclusion of normal life.That’s completely different from my cult experience with COS.

I was never a public or FZer. After leaving the SO, I didn’t see any value in any of it. If they do, that’s their thing I guess, just keep off the false claims and don’t ostracize those who disagree. If you keep the cult aspects out, it’s more like soft porn compared to Hubbard’s S&M. Nobody should ever have to get overboarded or disconnect from their kids or mortgage their homes to keep their church happy.

 
.

AFTER VIEWING THIS THREAD, BE SURE
TO VISIT THE BOOKSTORE WHERE WE
ARE OFFERING JUMBO DISCOUNTS ON

SIGNED LIMITED EDITION BOOKS!




* * * DEALS OF THE DAY * * *

WHY I'M HATED
-Bernie Madoff

WHY I'M HATED
-Reid Slatkin

WHY I'M HATED -Charles Ponzi

WHY I'M HATED -David Miscavige

WHY I'M HATED -L. Ron Hubbard

.​
 
.
Thanks for spotlighting the straw man title for the thread, albeit formulated as a question.

-snip-

You're too quick for me. You caught me again.

Not everything that LRH said was crap. There are a few cherries mixed in. However, diving into the pile of crap, looking for the cherries, seems like a bad use of time.

Those familiar with subject have already dove. It's done. No diving - present tense - is required. If there's a cherry mixed in, and someone is fascinated or enchanted with Scientology because of that cherry, calmly showing the person that one has familiarity with it, and, then, explaining that the cherry - hey, it's your allegory :), but bear with me - is not representative of the rest of the subject, that there are hidden hooks and booby traps in the subject, sometimes can loosen the glue that sticks a person to Scientology.

Also, just because we may think that somebody using Scn tech is misled or deluded, does not mean we "hate" her.

....

-snip-

Interesting that both Scientology Inc. and Independent Scientology are seeking to create the narrative that they are targets of "hate."

-snip-

Has anyone noticed any actual "hate," directed at Scientologirl, from this MB? I can't find any.

Is this a new dissemination technique?

Is the word "hate" being used as a "button"?

"We belong to a minority religion that teaches love, and we are hated." :dramaqueen:

?
 
Last edited:
.

Has anyone noticed any actual "hate," directed at Scientologirl, from this MB? I can't find any.

Is this a new dissemination technique? Is the word "hate" is being used as a "button"?

"We belong to a minority religion that teaches love, and we are hated." :dramaqueen:

.

Good point.

"Hate" is a millennial-milieu-marketing gimmick. It's quite popular right now, used by such successful religions as BLM, ANTIFA and other hate-crime victims such as those victimized by islamophobia, homophobia, transphobia, misogyny, xenophobia, racism and religious bigotry.

In Scientology's case, the hate manifests in a psychological pathology called PhiloScienoPhobia (i.e. "fear of loving Scientologists"). No one knows why people fear/hate Scientologists, they have done nothing wrong. Assuredly it is the haters' horrid cases which generates all this entheta---which Scientology ministers would very happily help them handle and erase!

.
 
Has anyone noticed any actual "hate," directed at Scientologirl, from this MB? I can't find any.

Is this a new dissemination technique?

Is the word "hate" is being used as a "button"?

"We belong to a minority religion that teaches love, and we are hated."
It's a Leftist technique. Any disagreement is "hate". Anything except full submission is "hate"
 
Yes, Hubbard was trained in rhetoric. But as others here have said, there's more to scn than just rhetoric. Where's the rhetoric in doing TR-0?

Where's the rhetoric in the hundreds of grade processes? In the rudiments? A session is not a rhetorical device.

So, while Hubb's rhetorical writing certainly had it's effects it is far from the complete picture.
One has to look at the whole picture of Hubbard's creation, from his dianetics to scientology, from dianetics groups/centers to scientology missions/orgs, then sea org. And look at logos, pathos and ethos. One can divide the whole picture into it's parts, and still one has to look at logos, pathos and ethos. But, one needs to get a grasp of logos, pathos and ethos, and then look(read his books, listen to his lectures, do auditing, receive auditing. etc.) at the dianetics and scientology and hubbard.

One has to be somewhat versed in having read his policy letters and HCOB's.

One can think there is no rhetoric in TR-0, but it's actually OT TR-0. (OT means Operating Thetan).

One can think doing the hundreds of process's has no rhetoric because they are questions to ask of a pc, but one has to consider that the EP of each process has a result, and guess what, it is rhetoric. This applies more to the whole grade chart. Each grade is to produce a result. For instance Grade 0 is one now has the ability to talk to anybody about anything. And grade 1 the ability to solve problems, the EP's are rhetoric. Just as the EP's of Clear and OT are. One has become persuaded by thinking they attained a EP.

For, nobody has really attained the EP's. They think they have (persuaded), but not really. The problem with looking at dianetics and scientology from a critical thinking POV and even hypnotized POV doesn't explain people who have been involved for a long time and haven't received much auditing.

Hubbard said he just a writer and said it would be hard to figure it all out. I have, so I'll keep toot'in me horn.
 
One has to look at the whole picture of Hubbard's creation, from his dianetics to scientology, from dianetics groups/centers to scientology missions/orgs, then sea org. And look at logos, pathos and ethos. One can divide the whole picture into it's parts, and still one has to look at logos, pathos and ethos. But, one needs to get a grasp of logos, pathos and ethos, and then look(read his books, listen to his lectures, do auditing, receive auditing. etc.) at the dianetics and scientology and hubbard.

One has to be somewhat versed in having read his policy letters and HCOB's.

One can think there is no rhetoric in TR-0, but it's actually OT TR-0. (OT means Operating Thetan).

One can think doing the hundreds of process's has no rhetoric because they are questions to ask of a pc, but one has to consider that the EP of each process has a result, and guess what, it is rhetoric. This applies more to the whole grade chart. Each grade is to produce a result. For instance Grade 0 is one now has the ability to talk to anybody about anything. And grade 1 the ability to solve problems, the EP's are rhetoric. Just as the EP's of Clear and OT are. One has become persuaded by thinking they attained a EP.

For, nobody has really attained the EP's. They think they have (persuaded), but not really. The problem with looking at dianetics and scientology from a critical thinking POV and even hypnotized POV doesn't explain people who have been involved for a long time and haven't received much auditing.

Hubbard said he just a writer and said it would be hard to figure it all out. I have, so I'll keep toot'in me horn.
let's examine this:


"Ethos (Credibility), or ethical appeal, means convincing by the character of the author. We tend to believe people whom we respect. One of the central problems of argumentation is to project an impression to the reader that you are someone worth listening to, in other words making yourself as author into an authority on the subject of the paper, as well as someone who is likable and worthy of respect."

That's the first book Dianetics, hubbard presents hisself as a authority. Also in scientology, probably the best example is Hubbard's "My Philosophy". You can google search that rhetoric speech.

"Pathos (Emotional) means persuading by appealing to the reader’s emotions. We can look at texts ranging from classic essays to contemporary advertisements to see how pathos, emotional appeals, are used to persuade. Language choice affects the audience’s emotional response, and emotional appeal can effectively be used to enhance an argument. "

How do I explain this, well, each EP of a process or grade chart action is pathos. Also Hubbard's emotional chart of emotions from below death to free being, or OT. Wow, what emotions.

"Logos (Logical) means persuading by the use of reasoning. This will be the most important technique we will study, and Aristotle’s favorite. We’ll look at deductive and inductive reasoning, and discuss what makes an effective, persuasive reason to back up your claims. Giving reasons is the heart of argumentation, and cannot be emphasized enough. We’ll study the types of support you can use to substantiate your thesis, and look at some of the common logical fallacies, in order to avoid them in your writing. "

oh boy, this complicated to explain, Hubbard used many technigues in Dianetics, but went really into with the PDC's and later logic series of the OEC's/FEBC's.
 
let's examine this:


"Ethos (Credibility), or ethical appeal, means convincing by the character of the author. We tend to believe people whom we respect. One of the central problems of argumentation is to project an impression to the reader that you are someone worth listening to, in other words making yourself as author into an authority on the subject of the paper, as well as someone who is likable and worthy of respect."

That's the first book Dianetics, hubbard presents hisself as a authority. Also in scientology, probably the best example is Hubbard's "My Philosophy". You can google search that rhetoric speech.

"Pathos (Emotional) means persuading by appealing to the reader’s emotions. We can look at texts ranging from classic essays to contemporary advertisements to see how pathos, emotional appeals, are used to persuade. Language choice affects the audience’s emotional response, and emotional appeal can effectively be used to enhance an argument. "

How do I explain this, well, each EP of a process or grade chart action is pathos. Also Hubbard's emotional chart of emotions from below death to free being, or OT. Wow, what emotions.

"Logos (Logical) means persuading by the use of reasoning. This will be the most important technique we will study, and Aristotle’s favorite. We’ll look at deductive and inductive reasoning, and discuss what makes an effective, persuasive reason to back up your claims. Giving reasons is the heart of argumentation, and cannot be emphasized enough. We’ll study the types of support you can use to substantiate your thesis, and look at some of the common logical fallacies, in order to avoid them in your writing. "

oh boy, this complicated to explain, Hubbard used many technigues in Dianetics, but went really into with the PDC's and later logic series of the OEC's/FEBC's.
so here's the thing, nobody went clear, nobody is OT. It's all rhetoric. Can you see the big picture of the whole thing?
 
so here's the thing, nobody went clear, nobody is OT. It's all rhetoric. Can you see the big picture of the whole thing?

To play devil's advocate, I have had people do TR0 (there was no OT TRO at the time) who had no idea what Scientology was.

I've audited people who never heard of Scientology.

When I audited someone on Grade 0, it continued until the person was happy, and had a floating Tone Arm.

The person was done with 0.

Hubbard placed heavy emphasis on his words, no doubt, but also believed the sound of his voice was hypnotic.

The Dynamic principle of SURVIVE! does exist in objective reality.

SURVIVE is a real urge.

And it goes on.
 
Last edited:
To play devil's advocate, I have had people do TR0 (there was OT TRO at the time) who had no idea what Scientology was.

I've audited people who never heard of Scientology.

When I audited someone on Grade 0, it continued until the person was happy, and had a floating Tone Arm.

The person was done with 0.

Hubbard placed heavy emphasis on his words, no doubt, but also believed the sound of his voice was hypnotic.

The Dynamic principle of SURVIVE! does exist in objective reality.

SURVIVE is a real urge.

And it goes on.

"To play devil's advocate, I have had people do TR0 (there was OT TRO at the time) who had no idea what Scientology was."
OK, so what happened? Are they still involved?

"I've audited people who never heard of Scientology."

OK, so what happened, are they still involved?

"When I audited someone on Grade 0, it continued until the person was happy, and had a floating Tone Arm.

The person was done with 0."

OK, are they still involved? Did the person actually attain Grade 0? Did the person move on up to Grade 1 after attaining Grade 0, and why not? Or maybe you don't know, and why not?
 
Last edited:
"To play devil's advocate, I have had people do TR0 (there was OT TRO at the time) who had no idea what Scientology was."
OK, so what happened? Are they still involved?

"I've audited people who never heard of Scientology."

OK, so what happened, are they still involved?

"When I audited someone on Grade 0, it continued until the person was happy, and had a floating Tone Arm.

The person was done with 0."

OK, are they still involved? Did the person actually attain Grade 0? Did the person move on up to Grade 1 after attaining Grade 0, and why not? Or maybe you don't know, and why not?

They were done with Grade Zero. What was to be gained had been gained. Yes the person moved on to Grade1.

The point is, that without rhetoric, there are some processes that still produce some results.
 
Last edited:
Rhetoric is a study of words and language. From www.dictionary.com

rhetoric
[ ret-er-ik ]SHOW IPA

See synonyms for rhetoric on Thesaurus.com
noun
(in writing or speech) the undue use of exaggeration or display; bombast.
the art or science of all specialized literary uses of language in prose or verse, including the figures of speech.
the study of the effective use of language.
the ability to use language effectively.
the art of prose in general as opposed to verse.
the art of making persuasive speeches; oratory.
(in classical oratory) the art of influencing the thought and conduct of an audience.
(in older use) a work on rhetoric.
......................................................................................

Rhetoric can be used to create things like emotion or sensation, but the emotion or sensation is a thing of itself without worded description. Pets experience emotion without worded description and the temperature of something is what it is without a worded description like warm or cool.

Look at that bottle.
Walk over to it.
Pick it up.
What is it's color?
What is it's temperature?
What is it's weight?
Put it down in exactly the same place.

Maybe whoever came up with that process was trying to bust you loose from explaining everything in words.
 
Last edited:
They were done with Grade Zero. What was to be gained had been gained. Yes the person moved on to Grade1.

The point is, that without rhetoric, there are some processes that still produce some results.
I understand your coffee shop auditing of what 1 person?

The point is actually, it's hubbard's rhetoric that got people to stay involved and keep going being involved. And it's also the rhetoric of his marketing series and PR series of how to get people involved, get auditing, join staff, etc.

You have to look at the big picture and not a narrowed minded POV of Crowley, and simple processes of auditing and whatever else you think.
 
I understand your coffee shop auditing of what 1 person?

The point is actually, it's hubbard's rhetoric that got people to stay involved and keep going being involved. And it's also the rhetoric of his marketing series and PR series of how to get people involved, get auditing, join staff, etc.

-snip-

Read the Quit Fast thread. It's about people - in Scientology Inc. as public - who were briefly involved, got something out of it, were happy, then left. They weren't hooked.

During the time while auditing outside the Organization, in defiance of the Organization, I and others knew Hubbard had been exposed as an inveterate prevaricator, P. T. Barnum-esque promoter, and that the confidential "upper" levels led into the Scientology labyrinth.

Hubbard's manipulation bubble had burst, and some people were simply curious about some parts of Scientology.

People explored all sorts of things. Scientology was one of those things.

They didn't join staff, or join the Sea Org, or become Rondroids.

Just as people were subjected to Hubbard's (1955) "blueprint" for Scientology to different extents, so people were exposed to varying amounts of his hyperbole.

Each person's experience is different.
 
Back
Top