Are Independent Scnists Hated?

nope, not gonna do it, it's the truth bud, just persuasive writing. Unless you can prove that anybody has returned from past life using scientology or indie scientology or freezone, has anybody returned from past life? Think about it.

Rhetoric is the art of persuasion, which along with grammar and logic (or dialectic – see Martianus Capella), is one of the three ancient arts of discourse. Rhetoric aims to study the techniques writers or speakers utilize to inform, persuade, or motivate particular audiences in specific situations. Aristotle defines rhetoric as "the faculty of observing in any given case the available means of persuasion" and since mastery of the art was necessary for victory in a case at law, for passage of proposals in the assembly, or for fame as a speaker in civic ceremonies; he calls it "a combination of the science of logic and of the ethical branch of politics". Rhetoric typically provides heuristics for understanding, discovering, and developing arguments for particular situations, such as Aristotle's three persuasive audience appeals: logos, pathos, and ethos. The five canons of rhetoric or phases of developing a persuasive speech were first codified in classical Rome: invention, arrangement, style, memory, and delivery.

Yes, Hubbard was trained in rhetoric. But as others here have said, there's more to scn than just rhetoric. Where's the rhetoric in doing TR-0?

Where's the rhetoric in the hundreds of grade processes? In the rudiments? A session is not a rhetorical device.

So, while Hubb's rhetorical writing certainly had it's effects it is far from the complete picture.
 
:scratch: Calling things "crap" is not my speed. You must not be paying attention.
I was was paying attention. I used the word "crap" to crudely, but accurately and succinctly, summarize your assessment of Scientology tech.

The fact that I used the word "crap" doesn't detract from the fact that the reasoning of your particular attack on Scientologirl was defective.

Seriously, you are going ro use a Hubbard doctine to attack a Hubbard follower not on the ground that she doesn't know what she is talking about, nor on the ground that she she was being inconsistent, but instead based on the premise that Hubbard is... right? Based on the assumption that Hubbard's observation is... valid?

Yeah, that is a great way to prove a Scientologist wrong.

/
/
 
I was was paying attention. I used the word "crap" to crudely, but accurately and succinctly, summarize your assessment of Scientology tech.

The fact that I used the word "crap" doesn't detract from the fact that the reasoning of your particular attack on Scientologirl was defective.

Seriously, you are going ro use a Hubbard doctine to attack a Hubbard follower not on the ground that she doesn't know what she is talking about, nor on the ground that she she was being inconsistent, but instead based on the premise that Hubbard is... right? Based on the assumption that Hubbard's observation is... valid?

Yeah, that is a great way to prove a Scientologist wrong.

/
/

Well, it might be a very good way to get a wedge in. If the person is gaga over Hubbard and you can use Hubbard to pierce a hole then perhaps it might be a useful approach.
 
Well, it might be a very good way to get a wedge in. If the person is gaga over Hubbard and you can use Hubbard to pierce a hole then perhaps it might be a useful approach.

Finding out the truth about Hubbard helped me to see things more clearly. I didn’t know.
 
Well, it might be a very good way to get a wedge in. If the person is gaga over Hubbard and you can use Hubbard to pierce a hole then perhaps it might be a useful approach.
Logically, but less diplomatically, it is akin to arguing:

"I'm not admtmitting that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit, but assuming for the sake of argument that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit, then...."

The practical problem is that people don't consider such hypothetical arguments in the real world. If you use a Hubbard datum against a Scientologist, they quite reasonably take that as a concession that you agree that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit.

/
 
"From the war school of life - What does not kill me, makes me stronger."

more like
Out of life's school of war, -What does not destroy me, makes me stronger.

the context was war..
more champagne, anyone?
 
Logically, but less diplomatically, it is akin to arguing:

"I'm not admtmitting that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit, but assuming for the sake of argument that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit, then...."

The practical problem is that people don't consider such hypothetical arguments in the real world. If you use a Hubbard datum against a Scientologist, they quite reasonably take that as a concession that you agree that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit.

/

It’s a gradual realization, though, first realizing that Hubbard had a shady background and then that all he said wasn’t exactly right and moving on from there.

Some FZers never give Scn up no matter what, but it is because they got something out of it. Maybe some can’t easily change the way Scientology reorganized their thinking, either. I wish they’d differentiate enough from the cult to stop using the word Scientology altogether. Why in the world would an FZer still want to be associated with a vicious cult after leaving it? Maybe you know. That part always puzzled me.
 
It’s a gradual realization, though, first realizing that Hubbard had a shady background and then that all he said wasn’t exactly right and moving on from there.

Some FZers never give Scn up no matter what, but it is because they got something out of it. Maybe some can’t easily change the way Scientology reorganized their thinking, either. I wish they’d differentiate enough from the cult to stop using the word Scientology altogether. Why in the world would an FZer still want to be associated with a vicious cult after leaving it? Maybe you know. That part always puzzled me.
I think they continue to use the word Scientology and refer to Hubbard because they pretty much have to. The words "Scientology" and "Hubbard" are plastered all over the written materials that they are using and the recordings that they are listening to. What are they going to do, do a search for "Scientology" in all of the docs and replace them with "SomethingElseology?" Delete Hubbard's name from everything?

Plus, the overwhelming majority of their customers are ex-corporate Scientologists who WANT Scientology -- just without the abuse, crush regging, etc., and believe that they can get it in the FZ. They don't want something else.

/
 
I think they continue to use the word Scientology and refer to Hubbard because they pretty much have to. The words "Scientology" and "Hubbard" are plastered all over the written materials that they are using and the recordings that they are listening to. What are they going to do, do a search for "Scientology" in all of the docs and replace them with "SomethingElseology?" Delete Hubbard's name from everything?

Plus, the overwhelming majority of their customers are ex-corporate Scientologists who WANT Scientology -- just without the abuse, crush regging, etc., and believe that they can get it in the FZ. They don't want something else.

/

Ah, okay. It’s the partial disconnect because my customers are Scientologists and I’d rather believe than disbelieve thing. :coolwink:

I kind of understand the part in the vid about how fragile goals and dreams can be. They are, especially to the shy or introverted types. Somehow we need to address that so that it’s not a rule for every odd thing a Scn believes. Do you follow? It makes any disagreement with Hubbard “Entheta” when it really is about protecting a person’s right to have a dream and believe they can achieve it.
 
Why in the world would an FZer still want to be associated with a vicious cult after leaving it?
my guess:
they feel they are the breakaway society that saved the original work, and one day, they will be recognized as the legit heirs.
isn't that the way of all breakaway religions?
 
Last edited:
.

ah.... memories.... a toast!
“Was mich nicht umbringt, macht mich stärker”

.
I tried to get a good translation of that, but unfortunately I don't speak German.

Is this right?

"Whatever does not handle or audit me makes me stronger"

.
 
.

One hopes they will just go away and perhaps do something useful with their lives ... ideally something that doesn't involve sanctimonious preaching and pretending to be something they are not.


Yeah, exactly.

I just watched that slick propaganda propaga-aslighting video.

I never knew that there was such a tone level---Serenity of Scolding!

.
 
.



.

I tried to get a good translation of that, but unfortunately I don't speak German.

Is this right?

"Whatever does not handle or audit me makes me stronger"

.
no, scroll up a few posts.... but yours is good too
 
.
--snipped--
The practical problem is that people don't consider such hypothetical arguments in the real world. If you use a Hubbard datum against a Scientologist, they quite reasonably take that as a concession that you agree that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit.

That's my experience as well.

Trying to validate Hubbard's hoax as a way of extricating them from it is tricky business and involves an inordinate level of lying skills and disregard for the truth--in order to get a result.

example of expediently saying whatever you thinks another wants you to say...


Bank robbers realize the bank is surrounded by SWAT teams, so they take all the bank customers hostage. After 17 exhausting hours of negotiations, the Hostage Negotiator finally calls them back and says: "Okay, the Mayor finally approved your helicopter and we just loaded it with the 10,000,000 cash in unmarked twenty-dollar bills. We just need you to release the hostages and you can tell the pilot wherever you want to go." Meanwhile rooftop Swat specialists are zero-ing in their sniper rifle's scope, windage and elevation calculations---for the first moment the bank robber walks outside towards the landed helicopter.

If I was a dentist and Scientologist came to me with a very painful and impacted wisdom tooth, I wouldn't mess around chatting about some anecdotal stories in which a rotten tooth was supposedly and miraculously saved. I also wouldn't wiggle the tooth around a lot and tug on it gently, again and again--because I was applying Dr. Hubbard's tech on "gradients". I'd just pull the screwed up tooth out and quickly treat the area with an antibiotic and then wad it up to stop any bleeding.

I don't doubt that there have been rare occasions where pretending to agree with some of Hubbard's tech might have (later) helped the Scientologist to look at mild "disagreement" or even (gasp!) "entheta"! lol
But, if "the truth shall set you free" is accurate, I don't much see the point in delaying the process of putting truth on the line.

There are an infinite number of ways to convey TRUTH without being a meanie. It can be done with stories, humor or countless other methods and can be quite fun for all. Hey, bring the whole family!! LOL



.
 
Logically, but less diplomatically, it is akin to arguing:

"I'm not admtmitting that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit, but assuming for the sake of argument that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit, then...."

The practical problem is that people don't consider such hypothetical arguments in the real world. If you use a Hubbard datum against a Scientologist, they quite reasonably take that as a concession that you agree that everything that Hubbard said wasn't complete and total shit.

/

Everything Hubbard said was not complete and total shit. There may be some that do express that opinion, but I'm sure if engaged in discussion they would admit that they were engaging in hyperbole.

Using Hubbard to counter Hubbard is a good ploy. I'm sure you're familiar with HH's Hubbard's Law of Commotion.
 
Everything Hubbard said was not complete and total shit. There may be some that do express that opinion, but I'm sure if engaged in discussion they would admit that they were engaging in hyperbole.

Thank you. :)

Link to Hubbard used "aberrative mechanisms" and "enemy tactics" on his own followers thread.

Using Hubbard to counter Hubbard is a good ploy. I'm sure you're familiar with HH's Hubbard's Law of Commotion.
 
Everything Hubbard said was not complete and total shit. There may be some that do express that opinion, but I'm sure if engaged in discussion they would admit that they were engaging in hyperbole.

Using Hubbard to counter Hubbard is a good ploy. I'm sure you're familiar with HH's Hubbard's Law of Commotion.
There is a difference between quoting Hubbard to show that he was internally inconsistent, (i.e., HH's Hubbard's Law of Commotion) and quoting Hubbard assuming that he was substantively correct as the part or premise of an argument.

I actually agree that everything Hubbard said was not complete and total shit. I just doubt that is a discussion that you want to have with a Scientologist. Otherwise, the Scientologist quickly turns the discussion into getting you to list the Hubbard and Scientology data that you agree with.

/
 
Not everything that LRH said was crap. There are a few cherries mixed in. However, diving into the pile of crap, looking for the cherries, seems like a bad use of time.

Also, just because we may think that somebody using Scn tech is misled or deluded, does not mean we "hate" her.

It's more like dealing with a drug addict: we try to tell them that smoking crack is a bad idea, and he screams that we hate him because we try to tell him that smoking crack is a bad idea, even though he loves it.
 
-snip-

I actually agree that everything Hubbard said was not complete and total shit.

Link to the Scientology exploits catharsis thread.

I just doubt that is a discussion that you want to have with a Scientologist. Otherwise, the Scientologist quickly turns the discussion into getting you to list the Hubbard and Scientology data that you agree with.

Maybe, you need to be more assertive during your IRL interaction with others.


Each situation is different. Especially when the person is alone and there are not other Scientologists around.

And even when there are other Scientologists around, seeds of questioning and doubt can be planted, which the person may consider at a later time.

Telling the person that it's all crap just shuts this all down.

Apparently, many people are hardwired to say, "It's all crap," but it's not an effective method of extricating people from Scientology.
 
Back
Top