What is Rhetoric?

My theory is that the purpose of the communication is to convince us -- and Riddick himself -- that he is more intelligent than we are, because he knows and understands the "big word" rhetoric, and the three other "big words" ethos, pathos, and logos, and we (supposedly) don't.

Behind this, of course, is the fear that he is not as intelligent as we are, so he must prove the contrary. The communication is not complete because we do not acknowledge his superior intelligence and he still feels the fear.

I don't like to lapse into scientologese so I won't mention the term "service facsimile";* instead I'll say this is a defense mechanism on Riddick's part.

Ironically, the more hostility the continued use of this mechanism creates, the more essential it becomes that he fight back (to escape domination) by demonstrating his superior intelligence, so he'll have to keep using it.

Up to now I've dealt with the rhetoric thing by ignoring it or making jokes about it. I naively hoped that Riddick would take my humbly tendered advice, above; but now since he proclaims he no longer needs our ARC, I'm saying what I really think.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
*That's a rhetorical device called apophasis: mentioning something while saying you won't mention it.

View attachment 18494
that's a nice theory, what makes you an expert in such a theory?
 
Thank you. I appreciate it.
Hey, no problem, Bill, it's not like I like you or will we ever meet. in live person. Don't care one way or the other.
 
chickencommunicationskills.jpg
 
Like I said, I don't care to be in communication with you or anybody else, just telling it like it is. Dianetics and scientology are rhetoric.

Do you still fall for Hubbard's ARC = Understanding? I don't.

Let me spell it out for you, I don't need your affinity, reality or communication to live my life. Your comments are pretty much bullshit as far as I'm concerned.
 
Last edited:
Like I said, I don't care to be in communication with you or anybody else, just telling it like it is. Dianetics and scientology are rhetoric.

Do you still fall for Hubbard's ARC = Understanding? I don't.

Let me spell it out for you, I don't need your affinity, reality or communication to live my life. Your comments are pretty much bullshit as far as I'm concerned.
If you actually "didn't care", you wouldn't keep posting on ESMBR.
If you actually "didn't care", you wouldn't keep responding to everyone who comments on your posts.
If you actually "didn't care", these comments wouldn't bother you so much.

So, obviously, all this is important to you. People's opinions are important to you. You keep trying and trying and trying to ... get our approval? Get our agreement? Get some kind of acknowledgement?

It's obvious you need something here, and you aren't getting it. You'll have to figure that out yourself.
 
Stanford University has an online searchable Encyclopedia of Philosophy . IMO, their scholarly article on Aristotle's Rhetoric is far more instructive and useful as a learning tool than a real dick's rambling rantings about it.
 
Like I said, I don't care to be in communication with you or anybody else, just telling it like it is. Dianetics and scientology are rhetoric.

Do you still fall for Hubbard's ARC = Understanding? I don't.

Let me spell it out for you, I don't need your affinity, reality or communication to live my life. Your comments are pretty much bullshit as far as I'm concerned.

Sounds like I'm doomed to hear rhetorical banjos...

1642aaf027dff8ecf2845992366fc013.gif
 
The question to ask yourself, how did Hubbard appeal to your emotions? Pathos wise.

Was it you can go clear? Was it you can go OT? Was it you can live a happy life? Was it you are a spiritual being? Was it whatever it appealed to you, what Hubbard said or wrote or lectured?
Anyways, the question I asked myself since I studied up on rhetoric, was what the pathos or emotional appeals Hubbard were used in Dianetics and scientology. I came to the conclusion that dianetics was an emotional appeal because Hubbard said once one went clear one would be a well and happy person. Scientology emotional appeal is cause on all dynamics, if you were a scientologist, you will know what that means.

There are many emotional appeals in hubbards writings and lectures, and he also presents them as logos or logic.

Pathos or emotional appeals are the tone scale, the book science of survival, and even the chart known as The Bridge to Total Freedom, but these are interlocked with logos or logic, it can be very confusing I might say.
 
Anyways, the question I asked myself since I studied up on rhetoric, was what the pathos or emotional appeals Hubbard were used in Dianetics and scientology. I came to the conclusion that dianetics was an emotional appeal because Hubbard said once one went clear one would be a well and happy person. Scientology emotional appeal is cause on all dynamics, if you were a scientologist, you will know what that means.

There are many emotional appeals in hubbards writings and lectures, and he also presents them as logos or logic.

Pathos or emotional appeals are the tone scale, the book science of survival, and even the chart known as The Bridge to Total Freedom, but these are interlocked with logos or logic, it can be very confusing I might say.
this vid which i posted sort of explains Hubbards pathos, Hubbard told many stories, and guess what success stories by people involved are the same by people who like myself got involved, we fell for the stories.

Beware of success stories on the internet and even writings, they may not be true.

What is Pathos? - YouTube
 
Last edited:
Hubbards Bridge to Total Freedom is a pathos appeal. One can take any step on the Bridge which is what Hubbard promoted or just move on up the Bridge, to total freedom, for instance ARC Straight wire, where the EP is one knows they will not get worse. Who wouldn't not to have that ability? When I did ARC SW I actually thought I wouldn't get worse.

The next step after ARC SW is Communications release, which the EP is supposedly being able to talk to anybody about anything. Who wouldn't want that ability? This is Hubbard's rhetoric and so on up the Bridge.
 
If you actually "didn't care", you wouldn't keep posting on ESMBR.
If you actually "didn't care", you wouldn't keep responding to everyone who comments on your posts.
If you actually "didn't care", these comments wouldn't bother you so much.

So, obviously, all this is important to you. People's opinions are important to you. You keep trying and trying and trying to ... get our approval? Get our agreement? Get some kind of acknowledgement?

It's obvious you need something here, and you aren't getting it. You'll have to figure that out yourself.
Sorry Bill, that's not it. I've only decided to post here and not monetize what I have to say. My work is free, and I will keep it so, unlike others.
 
.

Hubbards Bridge to Total Freedom is a pathos appeal. One can take any step on the Bridge which is what Hubbard promoted or just move on up the Bridge, to total freedom, for instance ARC Straight wire, where the EP is one knows they will not get worse. Who wouldn't not to have that ability? When I did ARC SW I actually thought I wouldn't get worse.

.

But you did, as clearly evidenced by this thread. LOL

It's actually you who do not understand rhetoric. You mightily try to squeeze and jam everything into your little imaginary three rhetoric boxes. You even admit that it's confusing to you. Here's why you are having so much trouble. . .

There is no need to pick ONE (1) of the rhetorical boxes. A statement by L. Ron Hubbard could be:

a) 99% Ethos & 1% Pathos.​
b). 2.5% Pathos & 0.9% Logos & 96.6% Ethos.​
c). 1% Logos & 99% lies.​
d) 0% Rhetoric and 100% other marketing gimmicks.​

You utterly fail to see the "rhetorical model" as a spectrum. You vainly struggle to force everything into a general model that never was intended to explain every reason that people get duped, conned, defrauded, fail to conduct adequate (or any) due diligence and/or make poor uninformed decisions. There are many other robust and informative and predictive models and spectrums on human behavior (other than rhetoric) that you are either entirely unfamiliar with or have not even understood at the most basic level.

You have taken a simple and helpful tool (rhetoric) and tried to make it the universal answer to every action/decision a Scientologists makes or fails to make. In this way you are yourself using rhetorical tricks (e.g. sophistry) much the same as L. Ron Hubbard did when he suddenly declared to the world that EVERYTHING mankind suffers from is just one (1) thing--ENGRAMS!

Ask yourself this question: If you understand rhetoric as well as you keep asserting, why is it that you are incapable of persuading others on your many rhetoric threads? Is it because all the others are "degraded" and "aberrated" homo sapiens, like Dr. Hubbard states when anyone disagrees with his far flung and provably false theories?

CONCLUSION: When you start to become a tiny bit persuasive (the purpose of rhetoric), then it might get interesting. But your claimed mastery of rhetoric is rather dismally betrayed by the obvious fact that you can't convince anyone, can you?

(Now you can respond with how you don't care what anyone says or thinks because they don't understand rhetoric and you don't give a shit if people understand or even read your posts, because you are posting on a discussion board that really should be turned into an angry sermon board so you can berate others & create a world without MUs on rhetoric)

.
 
Last edited:
l

When the only tool in one's toolbox is a hammer
then everything begins to look like a nail.
​
.

Perfect.

It might be interesting to start a thread one day where famous ADAGES & PROVERBS can be converted to Scientology. For example:

When the only tool in one's toolbox is an e-meter
then everything begins to look like an engram.

​


Or, maybe it just turns into one of those ghost town threads where there is just one lonely post and nobody's interested. Perhaps I'll just throw it on the "Stupid Thread" and see if it goes viral and saves the planet, lol.

.
 
Last edited:
<snip>
You keep trying and trying and trying to ... get our approval? Get our agreement? Get some kind of acknowledgement?

It's obvious you need something here, and you aren't getting it. You'll have to figure that out yourself.

Sorry Bill, that's not it. I've only decided to post here and not monetize what I have to say. My work is free, and I will keep it so, unlike others.
Riddick,
A wonderful response to statements I didn't make and questions I didn't ask. Well done!

Since I never mentioned money, your response is quite non-sequitur.

I hope you figure out what you want from us with your endless repetition of posts on rhetoric.
 
.


.


Riddick, since I never mentioned money, your response is quite non-sequitur.

I hope you figure out what you want from us with your endless repetition of posts on rhetoric.


.
Yeah, that was entirely bafflingly bewildering & bizarre how the word or word "monetize" was mis-used. I assume that it's simply another "crashing MU" for Riddick, like the word rhetoric.

As far as trying to figure out what (Riddick) wants from us. . .there might be an excellent clue about that. After he formally announced that he was ONLY POSTING ON THIS RHETORIC THREAD ON THE SUBJECT OF RHETORIC, a funny thing happened. For a bit, everyone stopped posting, except Riddick.

He then would write a random post about rhetoric and later he would answer his own post with another post about rhetoric.

CONCLUSION: What he wants, therefore, is to just talk to himself. It doesn't matter how many other posters talk to him about rhetoric, he doesn't want conversation. He is much happier chatting to himself. That's probably why he gets so upset when people speak to him because they're "cutting his com" to himself. LOL

.
 
Riddick,
A wonderful response to statements I didn't make and questions I didn't ask. Well done!

Since I never mentioned money, your response is quite non-sequitur.

I hope you figure out what you want from us with your endless repetition of posts on rhetoric.
I was referring to your brother Jefferson Hawkins who had at first told his story of being in scientology and it was free to read his story, Counterfeit Dreams. He then monetized it, at first it was free to read, then one had to pay for his book or reads what he had to say from his experience being involved. I quess you didn't connect the dots.
 
Back
Top