What is Rhetoric?

And didn't Socrates, Plato, and/or Aristotle invent it and popularize it way back when? :whistle:
it's not that Socrates, Plato, and/or Aristotle invented it, it more like what they were trying to communicate, that is this how people persuade. And this is what they do. That is what they were saying and trying to communicate.

It's still true to this day. If you can create ethos, pathos or ethos, or any combination of the the three, to a audience, you can persuade. It may be a one day thing, or maybe a long drawn out thing. If it is a long drawn out thing, like scientology, you better have proof in the end. That's why I have also said no clears or OT's or nobody returning from past life using scientology.
 
I'm going to attempt to keep my comments concerning rhetoric in one of the many threads here on Redux about Rhetoric rather than contributing to the derailment of other threads. There are LOTS of choices including these: :)

Anybody examine the rhetoric of the The Bridge to total Freedom?
It's too bad ABC News interview of David Miscaviage didn't ask questions of the rhetoric
The Rhetoric and Master Plan of Dianetics and Scientology
Dear Dean Wilbur and Rhetoric and the beginning of dianetics and then scientology
This is a good video on Rhetoric, you have to ask yourself, did Hubbard use this?
Dianetics and Scientology are Science Fiction based on rhetoric
What is Rhetoric?
The Rhetoric Of Hubbard and Scientology
Law as Rhetoric
Hubbard was a rhetoric writer in his books and also as a speaker in his recorded lectures
The Rhetoric of RJ67 Speech By Hubbard vs RJ2020?



Hubbard clearly DID utilize rhetoric as part of his fraudulent Dianetics and Scientology marketing campaigns. His lies about his own personal history to create ethos have been well documented here on Redux and all over the internet.

However, rhetoric from Hubbard is NOT the reason that many people (including myself) got involved with Scientology. There are other factors that contribute to people becoming involved. Aaron Levin-Smith just made a video where he reviewed one of Tampa Brad's videos. For those who don't know, Brad is a Scientologist who got in during the pandemic after reading some of Grant Cardone's books. Aaron gets asked all the time how people get involved with Scientology given all the information all over the web as well as all the books, documentaries, TV shows, podcasts, YouTube videos, etc. He used Brad as a case study to show how some people do get involved. There were major factors (besides Hubbard's rhetoric) that contributed to Brad getting involved. It started off with him reading Grant Cardone books, feeling as though he got benefit from those books, came to trust the author, and took his advice when Cardone recommended that his readers read the Dianetics book if they want to understand the mind.

This is a great video for anyone who wants to understand how people get sucked into the Scientology cult despite all the information out there.

 
Last edited:
I'm going to attempt to keep my comments concerning rhetoric in one of the many threads here on Redux about Rhetoric rather than contributing to the derailment of other threads. There are LOTS of choices including these: :)

Anybody examine the rhetoric of the The Bridge to total Freedom?
It's too bad ABC News interview of David Miscaviage didn't ask questions of the rhetoric
The Rhetoric and Master Plan of Dianetics and Scientology
Dear Dean Wilbur and Rhetoric and the beginning of dianetics and then scientology
This is a good video on Rhetoric, you have to ask yourself, did Hubbard use this?
Dianetics and Scientology are Science Fiction based on rhetoric
What is Rhetoric?
The Rhetoric Of Hubbard and Scientology
Law as Rhetoric
Hubbard was a rhetoric writer in his books and also as a speaker in his recorded lectures
The Rhetoric of RJ67 Speech By Hubbard vs RJ2020?



Hubbard clearly DID utilize rhetoric as part of his fraudulent Dianetics and Scientology marketing campaigns. His lies about his own personal history to create ethos have been well documented here on Redux and all over the internet.

However, rhetoric from Hubbard is NOT the reason that many people (including myself) got involved with Scientology. There are other factors that contribute to people becoming involved. Aaron Levin-Smith just made a video where he reviewed one of Tampa Brad's videos. For those who don't know, Brad is a Scientologist who got in during the pandemic after reading some of Grant Cardone's books. Aaron gets asked all the time how people get involved with Scientology given all the information all over the web as well as all the books, documentaries, TV shows, podcasts, YouTube videos, etc. He used Brad as a case study to show how some people do get involved. There were major factors (besides Hubbard's rhetoric) that contributed to Brad getting involved. It started off with him reading Grant Cardone books, feeling as though he got benefit from those books, came to trust the author, and took his advice when Cardone recommended that his readers read the Dianetics book if they want to understand the mind.

This is a great video for anyone who wants to understand how people get sucked into the Scientology cult despite all the information out there.

Aaron does a great job of rhetoric analysis in this vid although he doesn't know that is what he is doing. He explains all the appeals of rhetoric.
 
I'm going to attempt to keep my comments concerning rhetoric in one of the many threads here on Redux about Rhetoric rather than contributing to the derailment of other threads. There are LOTS of choices including these: :)

Anybody examine the rhetoric of the The Bridge to total Freedom?
It's too bad ABC News interview of David Miscaviage didn't ask questions of the rhetoric
The Rhetoric and Master Plan of Dianetics and Scientology
Dear Dean Wilbur and Rhetoric and the beginning of dianetics and then scientology
This is a good video on Rhetoric, you have to ask yourself, did Hubbard use this?
Dianetics and Scientology are Science Fiction based on rhetoric
What is Rhetoric?
The Rhetoric Of Hubbard and Scientology
Law as Rhetoric
Hubbard was a rhetoric writer in his books and also as a speaker in his recorded lectures
The Rhetoric of RJ67 Speech By Hubbard vs RJ2020?



Hubbard clearly DID utilize rhetoric as part of his fraudulent Dianetics and Scientology marketing campaigns. His lies about his own personal history to create ethos have been well documented here on Redux and all over the internet.

However, rhetoric from Hubbard is NOT the reason that many people (including myself) got involved with Scientology. There are other factors that contribute to people becoming involved. Aaron Levin-Smith just made a video where he reviewed one of Tampa Brad's videos. For those who don't know, Brad is a Scientologist who got in during the pandemic after reading some of Grant Cardone's books. Aaron gets asked all the time how people get involved with Scientology given all the information all over the web as well as all the books, documentaries, TV shows, podcasts, YouTube videos, etc. He used Brad as a case study to show how some people do get involved. There were major factors (besides Hubbard's rhetoric) that contributed to Brad getting involved. It started off with him reading Grant Cardone books, feeling as though he got benefit from those books, came to trust the author, and took his advice when Cardone recommended that his readers read the Dianetics book if they want to understand the mind.

This is a great video for anyone who wants to understand how people get sucked into the Scientology cult despite all the information out there.

What I might add is that the vid by Brad shows the classic dissemination formula, I'm surprised Aaron did not pick up on that. Find a ruin.
 
Aaron does a great job of rhetoric analysis in this vid although he doesn't know that is what he is doing. He explains all the appeals of rhetoric.

There are number of factors that led to Brad getting involved with Scientology, some of which have nothing to do with Hubbard's rhetoric.

He trusted Grant Cardone because he felt he benefited from Cardon's books. And Grant's promotion of Dianetics is what led Brad to check it out. And Brad's personal experience of doing some beginning Scientology services, courses and auditing was positive. And THAT'S what led him deeper and deeper into Scientology.
 
Rhetoric is this:

"
rhet·o·ric
[ˈredərik]

NOUN
  1. the art of effective or persuasive speaking or writing, especially the use of figures of speech and other compositional techniques:
    "he is using a common figure of rhetoric, hyperbole"
    synonyms:
    oratory · eloquence · power of speech · command of language · expression · way with words · delivery · diction
 
Rhetoric is this:

"
rhet·o·ric
[ˈredərik]

NOUN
  1. the art of effective or persuasive speaking or writing, especially the use of figures of speech and other compositional techniques:
    "he is using a common figure of rhetoric, hyperbole"
    synonyms:
    oratory · eloquence · power of speech · command of language · expression · way with words · delivery · diction
This is all Hubbard did to convince one they could go clear and then OT. He Hubbard did it by selling his words thru books and lectures for money. It was all rhetoric since nobody went clear or OT.
 
This is all Hubbard did to convince one they could go clear and then OT. He Hubbard did it by selling his words thru books and lectures for money. It was all rhetoric since nobody went clear or OT.
I like a few sentences from this write-up,

"Rhetoric is language that’s carefully constructed to persuade, motivate, or inform the reader or listener about the speaker or writer’s position. "

Hubbards position was that he figured out how to make people better thru his auditing and he thought this to be true And thus he attempted to persuade. He wrote many words and lectured to turn those spoken words into written words.

Rhetoric: A Definition and Rhetorical Devices Explained| Grammarly Blog
.
 
do your own google search, what is rhetoric, and read a bit.
 
There are number of factors that led to Brad getting involved with Scientology, some of which have nothing to do with Hubbard's rhetoric.

He trusted Grant Cardone because he felt he benefited from Cardon's books. And Grant's promotion of Dianetics is what led Brad to check it out. And Brad's personal experience of doing some beginning Scientology services, courses and auditing was positive. And THAT'S what led him deeper and deeper into Scientology.
What are the factors? You said he trusted Grant, that is rhetoric.
 
Only use rhetoric if you can't run faster than the other guy...

0d75505d8f8fa3282039a931791bf419.jpg
 
What are the factors? You said he trusted Grant, that is rhetoric.


Why would you like to know the factors? When I posted some in the past you ignored them, such as in this exchange earlier in this thread:

factor1.png

Do you think that abreaction therapy as developed by Freud and tweaked by Hubbard is rhetoric?

Can you list 10 non-fiction books that don't use elements of rhetoric? There are over 100 million non-fiction books that have been published so this should be easy, right?

In reality though it is NOT easy because pretty much all of those books use elements of rhetoric.
 
Rhetoric is some real dick distracting an entire forum off-topic with sophomoric specious argumentation that wouldn't pass muster in a first year college class.

Cicero did a much better job by simply ending every public speech with "Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam !"
 
Last edited:
Rhetoric is some real dick distracting an entire forum off-topic with sophomoric specious argumentation that wouldn't pass muster in a first year college class.

Cicero did a much better job by simply ending every public speech with "Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam !"
folks have complained I post on other treads about rhetoric, fair enough. So I decided to post only here. If you don't like it, well, then tough shit.

So, what this means is that I won't be posting on any other treads. If you want to post your comment here fine, if you don't, then don't, I don't care. You can listen to what I have to say or not, choice is yours.
 
Last edited:
Why would you like to know the factors? When I posted some in the past you ignored them, such as in this exchange earlier in this thread:

View attachment 18463

Do you think that abreaction therapy as developed by Freud and tweaked by Hubbard is rhetoric?

Can you list 10 non-fiction books that don't use elements of rhetoric? There are over 100 million non-fiction books that have been published so this should be easy, right?

In reality though it is NOT easy because pretty much all of those books use elements of rhetoric.
yes to your first question.

Everybody uses rhetoric one way or the other even if they don't know what it really means to persuade.
 
Back
Top