What is Rhetoric?

.

Sure, I recall.

When I was a young teen, I did not know that adults, best selling authors, war heroes, doctors & nuclear scientists could lie, trick, cheat, steal and defraud.

Public schools don't teach children about pathological liars, con men & sociopaths.


.
And public schools probably did not teach about rhetoric. The liars and conman use rhetoric because it is innate, the sociopaths are just truly nuts and nobody knows.
 
One should google research these questions:

What does ethos mean?

What does pathos mean?

What does logos mean?

After doing that, ask yourself the question, did Hubbard do that? Ask yourself the question did anybody else do that to you, using one or two or all three means of persuasion.
 
folks have complained I post on other treads about rhetoric, fair enough. So I decided to post only here. If you don't like it, well, then tough shit.

So, what this means is that I won't be posting on any other treads. If you want to post your comment here fine, if you don't, then don't, I don't care. You can listen to what I have to say or not, choice is yours.
Thank you. I appreciate it.
 
@Riddick, for years you have been saying "rhetoric, rhetoric, rhetoric," over and over and over again.

It should be obvious to you from the responses you're getting that we are pretty tired of it.

No one here denies that Hubbard used rhetoric. No one contests this. We're cool with it.

Yet you go on and on and on, yammering about rhetoric and ethos, pathos, and logos. Why? What are you trying to prove? What point are you trying to make? We accepted the point that rhetoric is important, long ago.

Are you angry at us? Are you trying to punish us for something?

Are you deliberately trying to be annoying? Because deliberate or not, that is the effect you are creating.

Do you want us to dislike you? Because that's where this is heading.

Your first impulse, I'm sure, is to say you don't give a shit if we dislike you, but what's going to happen then?

I'm sure you remember the ARC triangle. (I think this is one thing from scn that actually has a little bit of truth in it.) If you damage one corner of the triangle you damage the whole thing. So what''s going to happen if you make us dislike you? If Affinity goes, Communication and Reality go too. If Affinity goes, we'll just stop paying attention to your posts completely.

And that'll be the end of your crusade to convince us of whatever it is you're trying to convince us of about rhetoric.

I suggest you take a page from LRH. In 1952 he realized that dianetics was a flop and switched from dianetics to scn. He shifted from talking about running incidents and clear to talking about exteriorization and OT. He left dianetics alone, mostly, for about 15 years, until the late 60's.

He didn't keep going "dianetics, dianetics, dianetics," 'cause he knew it wouldn't work.

I suggest you imitate LRH, a master rhetorician, and stop hammering on this one topic before you lose our attention completely.

That's my advice, humbly tendered as a gift to Riddick, 8 July, AD 72.
 
Last edited:
Since it's not a high priority for me I have a simple mnemonic (memory aid) to remember the three elements of rhetoric plus a fourth called kairos mentioned in a previously posted article. post #144

ethos as ethical - convincing the audience you are a good person

pathos as pathetic - mentioning the trials, tribulations and work you have done to gain sympathy or empathy.

logos as logical - facts to back up your proposition

kairos as chronos or timing - proper timing if you want the audience to act

So be ethical, pathetic and logical and be aware of chronos. Works for me - lol
 
Last edited:
Since it's not a high priority for me I have a simple mnemonic (memory aid) to remember the three elements of rhetoric plus a fourth called kairos mentioned in a previously posted article. post #144

ethos as ethical - convincing the audience you are a good person

pathos as pathetic - mentioning the trials, tribulations and work you have done to gain "sympathy"

logos as logical - facts to back up your proposition

kairos as chronos or timing - proper timing if you want the audience to act

So be ethical, pathetic and logical and be aware of chronos. Works for me - lol
Nice. I'm glad you mentioned kairos, timing.

Note what I said above about Hubbard switching emphasis in 1952 from dianetics to scn and leaving dianetics alone for about 15 years.

Hint, hint. :eyeroll:
 
@Riddick, for years you have been saying "rhetoric, rhetoric, rhetoric," over and over and over again.

It should be obvious to you from the responses you're getting that we are pretty tired of it.

No one here denies that Hubbard used rhetoric. No one contests this. We're cool with it.

Yet you go on and on and on, yammering about rhetoric and ethos, pathos, and logos. Why? What are you trying to prove? What point are you trying to make? We accepted the point that rhetoric is important, long ago.

Are you angry at us? Are you trying to punish us for something?

Are you deliberately trying to be annoying? Because deliberate or not, that is the effect you are creating.

Do you want us to dislike you? Because that's where this is heading.

Your first impulse, I'm sure, is to say you don't give a shit if we dislike you, but what's going to happen then?

I'm sure you remember the ARC triangle. (I think this is one thing from scn that actually has a little bit of truth in it.) If you damage one corner of the triangle you damage the whole thing. So what''s going to happen if you make us dislike you? If Affinity goes, Communication and Reality go too. If Affinity goes, we'll just stop paying attention to your posts completely.

And that'll be the end of your crusade to convince us of whatever it is you're trying to convince us of about rhetoric.

I suggest you take a page from LRH. In 1952 he realized that dianetics was a flop and switched from dianetics to scn. He shifted from talking about running incidents and clear to talking about exteriorization and OT. He left dianetics alone, mostly, for about 15 years, until the late 60's.

He didn't keep going "dianetics, dianetics, dianetics," 'cause he knew it wouldn't work.

I suggest you imitate LRH, a master rhetorician, and stop hammering on this one topic before you lose our attention completely.

That's my advice, humbly tendered as a gift to Riddick, 8 July, AD 72.
you can listen to what I have to say or not in the past or future, the choice is yours. I don't need nor want your approval or anybody else's.

BTW, in Hubbard parlance this would be ARC, I don't need your ARC.
 
Last edited:
you can listen to what I have to say or not in the past or future, the choice is yours. I don't need nor want your approval or anybody else's.

We already listened to what you have to say the first time. A thousand repetitions later and we're still waiting for an actual message. Your words are a looped beat with no melody.
 
While I really do appreciate that you are keeping your "rhetoric" stuff here, I still don't understand why you continue on the subject.

I have a Scientology blog where I put my realizations, observations and suggestions about Scientology. I have the idea I wish to express, I write the idea up carefully, then I publish it --- and I'm done with that idea-->communication action. I don't have to write another blog article on that idea unless I have a correction or addition.

The thought is complete and I've communicated it.

What I don't get with you and this "rhetoric" things is why you aren't done. Is it because you haven't finished figuring it out? Is it that you don't think you've expressed it correctly? How is this communication not complete?

Really, serious question.
 
.


you can listen to what I have to say or not in the past or future, the choice is yours.
I don't need nor want your approval or anybody else's.



That assertion above is a ridiculous and painfully obvious lie.

Because, otherwise you would not have spent the last two years repeating yourself hundreds of times like a broken record whilst desperately trying to get others to agree with you on the subject of rhetoric.

To make matters worse, you understand so little about the subject of rhetoric that you are not only not able to persuade others (the entire purpose of rhetoric!) you actually have been so dogmatically obnoxious, rude and disrespectful on the subject that you did the exact opposite of persuasion. Instead, you created skepticism, cynicism, enemies and open hostility towards you and your theories on rhetoric.

Pretending you don't care if others agree with you is like a fire and brimstone preacher who gives the identical sermon every day about how everyone is going to hell if they don't submit to his every instruction and admonition about reading and understanding the Bible. Then each day (after delivering an hours-long hysterical rant about how nobody understands the Bible), he concludes by saying that he "doesn't care" if anyone agrees with him or understands the Bible.

What a fail-inducing and sordid debating tactic! LOL.

.
 
Last edited:
.

you can listen to what I have to say or not in the
past or future,
the choice is yours.


.
Nice introductory lecture and r-factor!

Reminds me of something. . .

OYJW6JWMWUI6TIJOIBWI6S7HAY.jpg

"If you leave this room after seeing this film, and walk out and never mention Scientology again, you are perfectly free to do so. It would be stupid, but you can do it. You can also dive off a bridge or blow your brains out. That is your choice. But, if you don't walk out that way, if you continue with Scientology, we will be very happy with you. And, you will be very happy with you. You will have proven that you are a friend of yours."​
​

If we "continue with Rhetoric" will you "be very happy with us"? . :giggle:
​
.​
 
Last edited:
What I don't get with you and this "rhetoric" things is why you aren't done. Is it because you haven't finished figuring it out? Is it that you don't think you've expressed it correctly? How is this communication not complete?

Really, serious question.
My theory is that the purpose of the communication is to convince us -- and Riddick himself -- that he is more intelligent than we are, because he knows and understands the "big word" rhetoric, and the three other "big words" ethos, pathos, and logos, and we (supposedly) don't.

Behind this, of course, is the fear that he is not as intelligent as we are, so he must prove the contrary. The communication is not complete because we do not acknowledge his superior intelligence and he still feels the fear.

I don't like to lapse into scientologese so I won't mention the term "service facsimile";* instead I'll say this is a defense mechanism on Riddick's part.

Ironically, the more hostility the continued use of this mechanism creates, the more essential it becomes that he fight back (to escape domination) by demonstrating his superior intelligence, so he'll have to keep using it.

Up to now I've dealt with the rhetoric thing by ignoring it or making jokes about it. I naively hoped that Riddick would take my humbly tendered advice, above; but now since he proclaims he no longer needs our ARC, I'm saying what I really think.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
*That's a rhetorical device called apophasis: mentioning something while saying you won't mention it.

1657402963714.png
 
Last edited:
In researching ethos, there can be many definitions or explanations. I like this one:

SAGE Research Methods - The SAGE Encyclopedia of Communication Research Methods (sagepub.com)

"The term ethos is one of the three appeals in persuasive speech described by Aristotle in his book Rhetoric. According to Aristotle, a persuasive speech has three appeals: logos (logical arguments), pathos (emotional appeals), and ethos (good character of the speaker). Aristotle described ethos as persuasion through character, as to make a speaker worthy of credence. Ethos is an important concept for analyzing human communication because it gives scholars a way to identify strategies in persuasive speeches.
Ethos is an appeal in persuasive speeches like, “Believe my words because I am a credible person.” Through ethos a speaker persuades an audience to believe that he or she is a fair-minded and knowledgeable person. For example, a speaker attempts to persuade an audience that ..."

As far as Hubbard's use of ethos, it can be found in the dianetics book where he says he was a nuclear engineer and told stories and such. Of course that story continued on with scientology.

Back when I read dianetics I believe he had ethos or was of a ethical good character. And even so when I was switched over to scientology. Of course, I might add I did not know about rhetoric back them.

Hubbard certainly got people involved with his book dianetics, some famous people during the time (and scientology), so they fell for his ethos as well. And even now in present time there are people whether on staff or public or indie who fall for Hubbard's ethos.

There have been thousands of posts by many exposing Hubbard's false ethos and some well-known ones as jerry armstrong, arnie lerma, and many others telling their stories of personnel contact with Hubbard.
 
In researching ethos, there can be many definitions or explanations. I like this one:

SAGE Research Methods - The SAGE Encyclopedia of Communication Research Methods (sagepub.com)

"The term ethos is one of the three appeals in persuasive speech described by Aristotle in his book Rhetoric. According to Aristotle, a persuasive speech has three appeals: logos (logical arguments), pathos (emotional appeals), and ethos (good character of the speaker). Aristotle described ethos as persuasion through character, as to make a speaker worthy of credence. Ethos is an important concept for analyzing human communication because it gives scholars a way to identify strategies in persuasive speeches.
Ethos is an appeal in persuasive speeches like, “Believe my words because I am a credible person.” Through ethos a speaker persuades an audience to believe that he or she is a fair-minded and knowledgeable person. For example, a speaker attempts to persuade an audience that ..."

As far as Hubbard's use of ethos, it can be found in the dianetics book where he says he was a nuclear engineer and told stories and such. Of course that story continued on with scientology.

Back when I read dianetics I believe he had ethos or was of a ethical good character. And even so when I was switched over to scientology. Of course, I might add I did not know about rhetoric back them.

Hubbard certainly got people involved with his book dianetics, some famous people during the time (and scientology), so they fell for his ethos as well. And even now in present time there are people whether on staff or public or indie who fall for Hubbard's ethos.

There have been thousands of posts by many exposing Hubbard's false ethos and some well-known ones as jerry armstrong, arnie lerma, and many others telling their stories of personnel contact with Hubbard.
One may ask what Hubbard's persuasive speeches were. They were all his books and lectures, which we paid for.

This is just the ethos appeal.
 
.

folks have complained I post on other treads about rhetoric, fair enough. So I decided to post only here. If you don't like it, well, then tough shit.

So, what this means is that I won't be posting on any other treads. If you want to post your comment here fine, if you don't, then don't, I don't care. You can listen to what I have to say or not, choice is yours.

.

I just noticed your promise to not post about rhetoric on any other threads than this one--which you named "WHAT IS RHETORIC".

Awesome!

This would seem like an excellent moment for everyone to stand, cheer and repetitively scream "THE WAR IS OVER!!!" while balloons are released from the ceiling! LOL


.
.
 
Last edited:
There are many examples of Hubbard's ethos appeal such as he saying he was a nuclear engineer. Oh, he even tried it by saying he was a doctor. Of course, his My Philosophy and KSW are also examples. there are many, like when he told the story that when was a kid and he got rid of bullies. Also, his Explorer Club membership, his being a pilot, his being a camera expert, music expert etc. These and many more are his ethos appeals to show he was of good character, mankind's greatest friend as he called himself.

Hubbard also created ethos in his scientology organization, top of them all was the Sea Org where the Sea Org were the most ethical people on the planet, or ethos. And even in Org's and Mission for they had ethical departments, these are ethos appeals, to join the winning team.
 
Pathos is another part of rhetoric; it has to do with emotions. I think this guy has a good grasp of what Hubbard did thru his lectures and writings.

Hubbard used emotional appeal to get people involved and think they can go clear and then OT. It was all rhetoric.

What is Pathos? - YouTube

You'll have to watch from the beginning.
 
Last edited:
The question to ask yourself, how did Hubbard appeal to your emotions? Pathos wise.

Was it you can go clear? Was it you can go OT? Was it you can live a happy life? Was it you are a spiritual being? Was it whatever it appealed to you, what Hubbard said or wrote or lectured?
 
Here is Hubbard's RJ67, a rhetoric lecture addressed to all staff & students of scientology: One could say Hubbard hypnotized people with this lecture, but it is rhetoric.

Scientology L Ron Hubbard RJ 67 - YouTube
 
.



.


I just noticed your promise to not post about rhetoric on any other threads than this one--which you named "WHAT IS RHETORIC".

Awesome!

This would seem like an excellent moment for everyone to stand, cheer and repetitively scream "THE WAR IS OVER!!!" while balloons are released from the ceiling! LOL


.
.
glad you finally read something, not like I care, lol.
 
Back
Top