The NOTs Scholars Home Page (Scientology)

That was put together by Dave Touretzky, a research professor at Carnegie Mellon University.

There is an amusing post he wrote back in 1998:

Scientology Pickets Carnegie Mellon

1648825739927.png

This is Wean Hall, home of the CMU Computer Science Department. Scientologists are on the left; CMU counter-picketers on the right.
click for whole image or a blown-up version
Date: December 17, 1998. My university was picketed by Scientologists today. The Friends of Religious Liberty (not a real organization, just a silly name the Scientologists picked for themselves), no doubt having important business elsewhere on the east coast, appear to have made a side trip to Pittsburgh to picket me in front of my building here at Carnegie Mellon.

Their timing was off. Exams were over last week, so most of the undergrads were gone. The campus newspaper had already put out its final issue until next term. And worst of all, they showed up at 11:00 AM; I am never on campus that early. So I missed my own picket. On the other hand, just the day before, I had made a posting to an internal university newsgroup mentioning that I was shown on the A&E Scientology special picketing next to Xenu the space alien. So it was kind of cool to have real live Scientologists show up on campus the very next day. Several colleagues sent me congratulatory email. Pity the picketers couldn't stay longer; I would have liked to have met them.

​
The university sent over a police officer to make sure everyone played nicely together. (Sorry his photo came out so poorly; he was in shadow.) Picketers are allowed on campus, and the Scientologists could even go into the building to use the bathroom, but they weren't allowed anywhere near my office.

There were six of them, reportedly well-behaved. They look normal in the photographs. My secretary went down and talked to them for a while, but when she asked them what Scientologists believe in, they wouldn't give her a straight answer. She was too polite to bring up the subject of Xenu, which she already knew about from helping me put together a poster presentation on Scientology's belief system that I gave at the Society for Neuroscience meeting last month.

The FRL's signs reportedly said "Dave Touretzky is a Religious Bigot" and "Your Neighbor Dave Touretzky Protects Pornography". Also something about a list of aliases I supposedly use, but nobody bothered to write those down.

Some of our grad students, bored and looking for amusement, decided to have fun with the picketers. They made up picket signs of their own and joined in. Several candidate slogans were discussed, including "Unix is not Xenu", but in the end they went with:

​
``Mom Send Money''
``Open Source Tibet``
``Xenu, Warrior Princess``
``Will Protest for Food``
``Ceci N'est Pas Une Pipe``
``Remember Byron``
``Legalize (maple leaf) Canada''
 
That was put together by Dave Touretzky, a research professor at Carnegie Mellon University.

There is an amusing post he wrote back in 1998:

Scientology Pickets Carnegie Mellon

View attachment 17689

This is Wean Hall, home of the CMU Computer Science Department. Scientologists are on the left; CMU counter-picketers on the right.
click for whole image or a blown-up version
Date: December 17, 1998. My university was picketed by Scientologists today. The Friends of Religious Liberty (not a real organization, just a silly name the Scientologists picked for themselves), no doubt having important business elsewhere on the east coast, appear to have made a side trip to Pittsburgh to picket me in front of my building here at Carnegie Mellon.

Their timing was off. Exams were over last week, so most of the undergrads were gone. The campus newspaper had already put out its final issue until next term. And worst of all, they showed up at 11:00 AM; I am never on campus that early. So I missed my own picket. On the other hand, just the day before, I had made a posting to an internal university newsgroup mentioning that I was shown on the A&E Scientology special picketing next to Xenu the space alien. So it was kind of cool to have real live Scientologists show up on campus the very next day. Several colleagues sent me congratulatory email. Pity the picketers couldn't stay longer; I would have liked to have met them.


The university sent over a police officer to make sure everyone played nicely together. (Sorry his photo came out so poorly; he was in shadow.) Picketers are allowed on campus, and the Scientologists could even go into the building to use the bathroom, but they weren't allowed anywhere near my office.

There were six of them, reportedly well-behaved. They look normal in the photographs. My secretary went down and talked to them for a while, but when she asked them what Scientologists believe in, they wouldn't give her a straight answer. She was too polite to bring up the subject of Xenu, which she already knew about from helping me put together a poster presentation on Scientology's belief system that I gave at the Society for Neuroscience meeting last month.

The FRL's signs reportedly said "Dave Touretzky is a Religious Bigot" and "Your Neighbor Dave Touretzky Protects Pornography". Also something about a list of aliases I supposedly use, but nobody bothered to write those down.

Some of our grad students, bored and looking for amusement, decided to have fun with the picketers. They made up picket signs of their own and joined in. Several candidate slogans were discussed, including "Unix is not Xenu", but in the end they went with:


``Mom Send Money''
``Open Source Tibet``
``Xenu, Warrior Princess``
``Will Protest for Food``
``Ceci N'est Pas Une Pipe``
``Remember Byron``
``Legalize (maple leaf) Canada''

.

.
My favorite part about the Scientology protesters was this:

"There were six of them, reportedly well-behaved. They look normal in the photographs. My secretary went down and talked to them for a while, but when she asked them what Scientologists believe in, they wouldn't give her a straight answer."​

The sheer paradoxical stupidity of Scientologists showing up to give the Scientology perspective, but then refusing to answer questions about what the Scientology perspective is! LOL

.
 
This probably isn't news to a number of people here, but I only came across it today and thought it was worth posting. It seems to be an attempt to set up an online body of scholars to examine the NOTS data and technology in a rigorous and academic fashion;

Well, that's just not going to happen. No one has examined, scholarly, scientifically, ANY of Hubbard's hypotheses.

Do "engrams" exist? "Locks"? "Secondaries"? "Reactive mind"? "GPMs"? Yes, obviously, people have problems, traumas, compulsions, etc. but are they what Hubbard said they were?

To be, well, accurate, it requires using what Hubbard said "works" to test his claims. Investigators would have to be trained Scientologists, and they would have to believe as Scientologists. At that point, disinterested investigation is just not going to happen. Never has. Never will.
 
Well, that's just not going to happen. No one has examined, scholarly, scientifically, ANY of Hubbard's hypotheses.

Do "engrams" exist? "Locks"? "Secondaries"? "Reactive mind"? "GPMs"? Yes, obviously, people have problems, traumas, compulsions, etc. but are they what Hubbard said they were?

To be, well, accurate, it requires using what Hubbard said "works" to test his claims. Investigators would have to be trained Scientologists, and they would have to believe as Scientologists. At that point, disinterested investigation is just not going to happen. Never has. Never will.

I agree about the training ( because you have to be tech trained to know what all the concepts mean, or are supposed to mean, and how they relate to each other), but not necessarily about the belief. I don't see why someone can't approach the investigation of how much truth there is in the concepts Scn uses, in a spirit of scepticism, even if they know about those concepts; that's what scientists do all the time in other fields.
 
I agree about the training ( because you have to be tech trained to know what all the concepts mean, or are supposed to mean, and how they relate to each other), but not necessarily about the belief. I don't see why someone can't approach the investigation of how much truth there is in the concepts Scn uses, in a spirit of scepticism, even if they know about those concepts; that's what scientists do all the time in other fields.
It may be theoretically possible, but it has never happened in the entire history of Scientology.
 
I agree about the training ( because you have to be tech trained to know what all the concepts mean, or are supposed to mean, and how they relate to each other), but not necessarily about the belief. I don't see why someone can't approach the investigation of how much truth there is in the concepts Scn uses, in a spirit of scepticism, even if they know about those concepts; that's what scientists do all the time in other fields.

Today's science has evolved to something that is more of a religion like: "Some Scientists Believe".

In order to test Scientology with standard scientific methods, one would not have to "believe", but share a baseline of similar memories of what happened and when. Even Scientologists who "believed" didn't get to experience real OT awareness because the common experiences of, Literally be behind the body, whole track realizations etc... didn't really happen beyond a mental exercise. Others have experienced these things and could make use of the Scientology tools for more awareness. Only those with common reality (not belief), could be in a position to apply scientific methods to verify Scientology claims.
 
I haven't been to the NOTs Scholars link in a while. Didn't it used to be a chapter of Wise Old Goat's site by Michel Snoeck.


We live in an age where established identities (with their established past to back them up) can be cancelled or gaslighted out of existence. New narratives are written for our life units and applied 'gang bang' style. I think the whole world could use a weekend course in taking apart unknowingly assumed hats. Make it cost like 50 bucks.
 
It may be theoretically possible, but it has never happened in the entire history of Scientology.

The aim I'm considering here is to simply look at the concepts Scn uses (engram, reactive mind etc.) and how much validity they have, not what can be obtained through the methods (real OT awareness, etc.). I don't see why that can't be done outwith the blessing of the CofS.

I regard the two things (the validity of the concepts, and the workability of the Tech) as independent of each other. Just for the sake of an example, it could be that we have a reactive mind but it can't be removed through auditing or any other means.
 
Last edited:
The aim I'm considering here is to simply look at the concepts Scn uses (engram, reactive mind etc.) and how much validity they have, not what can be obtained through the methods (real OT awareness, etc.). I don't see why that can't be done outwith the blessing of the CofS.

I regard the two things (the validity of the concepts, and the workability of the Tech) as independent of each other. Just for the sake of an example, it could be that we have a reactive mind but it can't be removed through auditing or any other means.
I think someone should revisit and validate Hubbard's theories. In a post, I said
"Some believers might ask, “If people are being helped, what difference does it make?”​
​
"All the difference in the world. If someone is only imagining they are being helped, that isn’t much actual help, is it? Also, if you don’t know how Dianetics and Scientology actually help (when it does), you won’t know why it doesn’t work, you won’t know how to make it more effective and you won’t have a clue where to go next.​
​
"What is the goal of Scientology processing when there is no “Reactive Mind” and there is no “State of Clear”? What is the need for “engram processing” when there are no engrams? What value is there in Scientology when its very foundations have been disproven?"​
 
I think someone should revisit and validate Hubbard's theories. In a post, I said
"Some believers might ask, “If people are being helped, what difference does it make?”​
​
"All the difference in the world. If someone is only imagining they are being helped, that isn’t much actual help, is it? Also, if you don’t know how Dianetics and Scientology actually help (when it does), you won’t know why it doesn’t work, you won’t know how to make it more effective and you won’t have a clue where to go next.​
​
"What is the goal of Scientology processing when there is no “Reactive Mind” and there is no “State of Clear”? What is the need for “engram processing” when there are no engrams? What value is there in Scientology when its very foundations have been disproven?"​
​
​
True as far as it goes, but if you're going to be as absolutist as that how could anyone prove they've been helped, to the satisfaction of another person, in anything else never mind Scn?​
​
What you've said about people imagining they're being helped could be the nullification of any kind of psychotherapeutic methodology at all, not just Scientology. Mental concepts are never going to be as visible as physical ones, so Sigmund Freud could have been making it all up when he talked about the ego, superego and id (in fact some people believe exactly that). The same with Eric Berne and transactional analysis (TA, incidentally one of the very first things I looked into). Are any of Rudolf Steiner's concepts strictly provable according to the same rubric? Or Jung's, or Assagioli's?​
​
People aren't as p'ed off with those guys (for understandable reasons) as they are with Hubbard, so there's less inclination to put them under the same microscope; but I suspect they wouldn't fare any better if you did.​
​
One has to be careful to not throw the baby out with the bathwater, IMO. You know as well as I do that there are people on here who think the whole thing's a load of rubbish and never helps anyone ever. So, when someone like me comes along and says they believe they've had some benefits from Scn processing, they're going to run into a problem.​
​
One of the reasons I posted this is to make some kind of a start on determining how you resolve that. One answer is to just accept that that's the way it is and there's never going to be any common ground, but I have to admit I'd prefer it if that didn't happen.​
 
Last edited:
​
​
But how could anyone prove they've been helped, to the satisfaction of another person? What you've said could be the nullificatuion of any kind of therap[uutic methodology at all, noit just Sciehntolo0gy. Mental concepts are never going to be as visib;le as physicqal ones, so Sigmund Freud coupd have been makoing oit all up when he ta;lked about the ego, superego and id 9in fact asome peipokle believe exactly that).​
​
One has to be careful to knot throw the bably out with the bathwater, IMO .​
​
You know as well as I do that there are people on there who think the wjole thing 's a crock of shit and never helps anypone ever. Spo, when someone like me comes along and says they believe theyve hasd some benefots from Scn provcessimng, they're going to run into a proiblem.​
As I said, if you don't know HOW something produces a result, you can't know how to fix it when it doesn't nor how to make it faster, better, easier, etc.

Proving the existence of an "engram" (as described by Hubbard) would be straightforward but the only attempt to validate Hubbard's theory about it failed completely. And Hubbard's entire structure of the mind depends on the engram.

Hubbard's "tech" is just a black box. You just follow his directions. Sometimes something happens, sometimes not. None of his promised miracles happens. Why not? No one knows. No one investigates.

Being very afraid to investigate, prove or disprove, Hubbard's bestiary pervades all of Scientology, in or out of the church. It isn't about "throwing the baby out with the bathwater". It's about knocking out the foundations of Hubbard's theories. If you do that, you've got to start all over.
 
I'll give you an example, from my own life and with another discipline. Within a couple of months of starting TM, my Gran told me I was becoming more placid (in her own words, like I used to be) and I was able to throw away the tranquiliser tablets I'd been taking. Nevertheless there are still meditation sceptics who don't believe it helps anyone.

For me, a better way of looking at it is to say, people feel better and people around them have noticed an improvement; but we don't know why at this stage.
 
As I said, if you don't know HOW something produces a result, you can't know how to fix it when it doesn't nor how to make it faster, better, easier, etc.

Proving the existence of an "engram" (as described by Hubbard) would be straightforward but the only attempt to validate Hubbard's theory about it failed completely. And Hubbard's entire structure of the mind depends on the engram.

Hubbard's "tech" is just a black box. You just follow his directions. Sometimes something happens, sometimes not. None of his promised miracles happens. Why not? No one knows. No one investigates.

Being very afraid to investigate, prove or disprove, Hubbard's bestiary pervades all of Scientology, in or out of the church. It isn't about "throwing the baby out with the bathwater". It's about knocking out the foundations of Hubbard's theories. If you do that, you've got to start all over.

We're probably going to have to agree to disagree here, because my understanding is that whereas Dianetics depends on the engram, Scientology depends on the recognition of oneself as a spiritual being which can postulate (and other things besides, such as perceive and solve problems). Beyond that, I tend to get into arguments with other people here; but that is the absolute basic of the subject, as far as I understand it.
 
Last edited:
We're probably going to have to agree to disagree here, because my understanding is that whereas Dianetics depends on the engram, Scientology depends on the recognition of oneself as a spiritual being which can postulate (and other things besides, such as perceive and solve problems). Beyond that, I tend to get into arguments with other people here; but that is the absolute basic of the subject, as far as I understand it.
Well, if you are going more in the direction of COHA, I'd agree. But that should still be tested and verified or you still run into the problem of fixing, improving, expanding when you don't know what's actually happening.
 
.

I think someone should revisit and validate Hubbard's theories. In a post, I said
"Some believers might ask, “If people are being helped, what difference does it make?”​
​
"All the difference in the world. If someone is only imagining they are being helped, that isn’t much actual help, is it? Also, if you don’t know how Dianetics and Scientology actually help (when it does), you won’t know why it doesn’t work, you won’t know how to make it more effective and you won’t have a clue where to go next.​
​
"What is the goal of Scientology processing when there is no “Reactive Mind” and there is no “State of Clear”? What is the need for “engram processing” when there are no engrams? What value is there in Scientology when its very foundations have been disproven?"​


Interesting subject! I hope I can shed some light on the matter. . .

When I was on my OT levels, I had a huge win that involved supernatural powers. At that time I was not entirely sure if it was a REAL OT event or just a SUBJECTIVE (internal) feeling I was experiencing—and not necessarily reality.

The next day I was driving around for quite a while looking to park my car. Don't anyone laugh here, just because you think this is going to be one of those stupid "I FOUND A PARKING SPACE" wins. It's not that. It's much bigger than that.

Anyways I could not seem to find a space to park and decided to see if any of my (alleged) OT powers would help the situation. So I postulated finding a parking space within 30 seconds. And within 30 seconds someone pulled out of their space and I couldn't believe it. Again, this win is not about me finding a parking space, so don't anyone get all uppity and start laughing that I had one of those delusionally cliched "WOW I FOUND A PARKING SPACE" wins.

As I was starting to pull into the space another car quickly backed up and zoomed into the parking space first and I had no chance at all and I lost the parking spot! Maybe it was my com lag or maybe my postulate was not strong enough, I am not sure. But it really bothered me that I did not really have any OT powers like I imagined. That was really depressing.

Later that night I was so stressed out about what happened that I experienced insomnia. I was still tossing and turning when the sun came up the next day and adding to my anxiety was the thought that maybe the OT levels were fake.

But then it hit me. An incredible cognition!

I realized that the OT levels actually HAD worked! What happened, quite apparently, was the OT win was so big that I moved up scale as a being from "OTHER DETERMINISM" so quickly that I soared right thru "SELF DETERMINISM" and landed all the way atop the scale in "PAN DETERMINISM". In other words the tech worked with blinding speed and I did not even realize that I had attained PAN DETERMINISM, which fully explains why someone else got my parking space!!!

For those of you who are interested in exploring your own spiritual powers, I will be giving a workshop at the AO this coming weekend called "REHABILITATING YOUR OT POWERS & RESPONSIBILITY LEVELS ACROSS THE DYNAMICS SO EVERYONE WINS!" There will be free refreshments (bottled water) so get there early while supplies last! We'll also be doing some free group auditing to bring up your havingness so you can have your own OT powers!



/
 
Last edited:
Well, if you are going more in the direction of COHA, I'd agree. But that should still be tested and verified or you still run into the problem of fixing, improving, expanding when you don't know what's actually happening.

Getting dangerously close to Scientologese here, but what the heck :0 My guess is that you could probably do it that way if you were dealing with your own case and nothing else, but most Scns want to make their postulates stick in the outer world in order to make things happen out there and to get what they want, and I suspect that's where any attempt to establish replicability would run into problems.

There's apparently an old saying in Texas that "there's a lot of dogs out there after them bones", and those other dogs can postulate too (including parking spaces, to take up HH's example)! So, to continue with that example, any attempt to prove the workability of Scn by seeing how easy it becomes to get a parking space where you want one is going to run into the problem of other people also wanting a parking space near to where they want to get to.
 
Last edited:
Getting dangerously close to Scientologese here, but what the heck :0 My guess is that you could probably do it that way if you were dealing with your own case and nothing else, but most Scns want to make their postulates stick in the outer world in order to make things happen out there and to get what they want, and I suspect that's where any attempt to establish replicability would run into problems.

There's apparently an old saying in Texas that "there's a lot of dogs out there after them bones", and those other dogs can postulate too (including parking spaces, to take up HH's example)! So, to continue with that example, any attempt to prove the workability of Scn by seeing how easy it becomes to get a parking space where you want one is going to run into the problem of other people also wanting a parking space near to where they want to get to.


Yeah but that was the whole deal with OT. It was Cause over Matter, Energy, Space and Time. What you're describing is a fixed resource of MEST and that makes one Effect. The OT definition of Cause means that one can create the MEST as wanted/needed. Therefore there would be no fixed amount of parking space availability. One could merely postulate one into existence. Anything short of that violates the "Cause over" definition.
 
Getting dangerously close to Scientologese here, but what the heck :0 My guess is that you could probably do it that way if you were dealing with your own case and nothing else, but most Scns want to make their postulates stick in the outer world in order to make things happen out there and to get what they want, and I suspect that's where any attempt to establish replicability would run into problems.

There's apparently an old saying in Texas that "there's a lot of dogs out there after them bones", and those other dogs can postulate too (including parking spaces, to take up HH's example)! So, to continue with that example, any attempt to prove the workability of Scn by seeing how easy it becomes to get a parking space where you want one is going to run into the problem of other people also wanting a parking space near to where they want to get to.
No. The problem with Scientology "results" is that, if they occur, they are indistinguishable from placebo effect. If you really, really BELIEVE, you just might get some kind of result.

It's indistinguishable from faith healing, aroma therapy, lucky rabbit's foot, et. al. That's the problem. Without actual scientific grade research and validation of the theories and methods, the "tech" has absolutely no validity.

"I had auditing and I found a $20 bill shortly afterwards" has no meaning. It's silly. And, as far as I can see, Scientology's "results" are all just like that.
 
"I had auditing and I found a $20 bill shortly afterwards" has no meaning. It's silly. And, as far as I can see, Scientology's "results" are all just like that.

.

That happened to me too! I once had auditing and I found a $20 bill shortly afterwards.

I found the bill in my mail which the org sent me after I attended an event where they did a FREE GROUP AUDITING session. The sent me a bill for $20 to "cover the cost of the paper for the blank Success Story form" they handed me after the session.

They cared enough about me to ensure that I didn't go out-exchange with Ron and become a criminal. Surely that should count as an OT win.

.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top