What Scientology could have been

.

Subtract certain things, and sort out the subject, and you'd have a different subject.


True!

However that might well be true for many subjects. For example, subtract sound from the music industry and you'd have a different subject.

I believe that L. Ron Hubbard already proved your subtraction thesis when he—

- - Subtracted science from "modern science" and had a different subject.​
​
- - Subtracted health from "mental health" and had a different subject.​
​
- - Subtracted the abilities attained part from both the grade chart and the​
auditing enrollment contracts that preclears were forced to sign.​
​
- - Subtracted around $650K from the bank account of each person who believed him.​
​
.​
 
Scientology was nothing but a scam from the start
Hubbard lied to the followers
He had only "postulated" the State of Clear and OT
using his hypnosis technique Dianetics

while charging money UP FRONT for the followers to obtain levels of awaremess never obtained by Homo Sap before
selling his hope on a rope with lots of traps to keep people in and from finding out the truth - that it was a scam
Hubbard was peddling snake oil and used his expert hypnosis skills and mind control tactics on unsuspecting people wanting to improve
their lives
what religion makes you sign 65 page legal docs without legal representation?

Hubbard used the followers to fund his research and elite lifestyle while making money and getting them to make money

Scientology was never a science of knowing how to know
it was a science of knowing how to NOT know
 
Scientology must be understood in terms of what Hubbard lied about, and what was actually done.

Hubbard lied about being 'source' of much, if not all of the tech. Much if not all of the tech was invented by others. At best I see Hubbard perhaps adapting older techniques, then claiming those as his own inventions. Techniques to help others which are invented by scientologists other than Hubbard are valid.

I realize it is difficult to separate scientology and Hubbard; they are so closely identified A=A=A=A (Korzybski). But it's true that they are not the same. In fact I consider as a sort of rule of thumb that if something in scientology is fucked up, it was created by Hubbard; and if something works well, it was created by others such as Sharp, Filbert, McMaster, Mayo, et al.
Ed

PS: NOTs is an adaptation of the biblical technique used by Jesus to remove 'unclean spirits'. :)
 
I realize it is difficult to separate scientology and Hubbard; they are so closely identified A=A=A=A (Korzybski). But it's true that they are not the same. In fact I consider as a sort of rule of thumb that if something in scientology is fucked up, it was created by Hubbard; and if something works well, it was created by others such as Sharp, Filbert, McMaster, Mayo, et al.
Ed

PS: NOTs is an adaptation of the biblical technique used by Jesus to remove 'unclean spirits'. :)

I wouldn't characterize it as "difficult". I would characterize it as "impossible" to separate Scientology from Hubbard. Nor do I understand why people attempted to do such.

You've got to remove so much bad stuff I don't get why those wishing to use what they believe to be good stuff wouldn't rebrand it, calling it anything but Scientology. :unsure:

Sorry to invoke Godwin's Law so early in the thread, but if I wished to extract some of what I believe to be good stuff from the Nazi cult and eliminate all the evil, I wouldn't continue to call myself a Nazi.
 
The Metaverse
"According to Mark Zuckerberg, mankind will migrate into the metaverse in the future,
leaving reality behind for a world [the MV] that we create and govern entirely. He claims
that there will come a moment when virtual worlds are so absorbing and handy that we
will not want to leave, at which point the metaverse will emerge."
​

Been there, done that.*

Didn't turn out as expected is all I can say. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


* Lived in Hubbard's "imaginary construct," his immersive simulation
of an alternative reality, for a couple decades. Instead of using computers
to create his "metaverse," he did it with very heavy books, cassette tapes,
and cheaply printed pamphlets. It was an earlier time after all. :coolwink:
H19845-L224882757.jpg
 
Last edited:
"According to Mark Zuckerberg, mankind will migrate into the metaverse in the future,
leaving reality behind for a world [the MV] that we create and govern entirely
Unspoken is WHO, exactly, will be the "we" who create and govern the Metaverse. It cannot be done by diverse and opposing intents. There must be only one Senior Will.

That is the ideal of the Left. Their whole philosophical basis is that their desire is senior to reality, that intent is senior to actual results.

Their goal is to be Gods, in a universe which they rule absolutely.
 


Klaus_Schwab2.png





RecklessBen1-e1578282770183.jpg


an-uncritical-scientology-cartoon-e4399dfc05f1-1-c4ec22.jpeg

Who would have thought that Scientology would become comedic relief compared to the real world?

Anyway...

Hypothetically...

If, for example, the ideas/influence of Hubbard's Mission Statement, in the wake of his having written Excalibur, at the birth of Scientology, in 1938, were removed, that would eliminate ruthlessness, in Scientology, and Hubbard's self-aggrandizing "real goal."

A real goal, cemented in place by convincing Scientologists that "LRH = (pleasant) Survival!"

Senior to the below chart is the Church of Spiritual Technology (COST) which owns and controls all copyrights. Its purpose is to preserve the name, and image, and words, of L. Ron Hubbard, in perpetuity.



COST

2005_05_1.jpg


Hubbard had made SURVIVE! the central pillar of his proposed psychological-political movement in 1938. "Not for what but just to survive." Very Darwinian.

He also made himself the center of this proposed movement and was determined to "smash [his] name into history." According to him, that was his "real goal."

Years later he wrote in Axiom Ten that, "The highest purpose in the universe is the creation of effect."

Any effect was better than no effect.

This was reinforced by convincing people that their futures for the next "endless trillions" depended on him or his surrogates.

Hubbard's base motivations are woven into Scientology.

Birthday19b.jpg

Scientology Inc.'s dictator is dwarfed by the giant LRH monogram.​


In 1938, Hubbard had written:

"I have high hopes of smashing my name into history so violently that it it will take a legendary form...
That goal is the real goal as far as I am concerned.
Things which stand too consistently in my way make me nervous.
It's a pretty big job.
In a hundred years Roosevelt will have been forgotten - which gives some idea of the magnitude of my attempt.

And all this boils and froths inside my head."

lronhubbard-birthday-2017-wide-panorama_07C3883.jpg

Scientologists give a standing ovation to the giant L. Ron Hubbard signature.



L-Ron-Hubbard-Birthday-2016-Scientology-Event-After-Event-Fort-Harrison_05C1005.jpg

Happy Hubbard fan(atic) club members gather beneath the giant LRH monogram.

_______________________
​


A little more from the 1938 Skipper letter:

"Living is a pretty grim joke but a joke just the same. The entire function of man is to survive. Not for 'what' but just to survive... I turned the thing up so it's up to me to survive in a big way. Personal immortality is is only to be gained through printed word, barred note or painted canvas or hard granite."


Personal immortality is different from plain immortality, in that memory would be intact.

Hubbard sold personal immortality and OT abilities to Scientologists, but he ridiculed the idea of using OT abilities in his 1973 Confidential, Intelligence, Its Role.

And nowhere in the thousands of pages of internal confidential Scientology Intelligence Tech, and related confidential cloak and dagger material, is there any mention of using OT abilities in spying, etc.

Hubbard was preoccupied with the preservation of his "name and image" in perpetuity. Why would that be so important, if he had personal - knowing - immortality, he could just "come back"?

*​

"Psychiatrists, reaching the high of the dusty desk, tell us that Alexander and Genghis Khan and Napoleon were madmen. I know they're maligning some very intelligent gentlemen... ..I can make Napoleon look like a punk..." Hubbard, 1938

"...I can make Captain Bligh look like a Sunday school teacher..." Hubbard, 1967

If Hubbard's ego - megalomania - and his ruthlessness were removed... ?

*​

(Bear with me, this is a thought experiment. :scratch: )

*
​

From Hubbard's late 1946/early 1947 Admissions/Affirmations:

"Your psychology is advanced and true and wonderful. It hypnotizes people.
It predicts their emotions, for you are their ruler."



bro-human-eval-2005.jpg

If the ideas/influence of Hubbard's Affirmations were removed from Scientology.... ?


*
​

If the ideas/influence of Hubbard's hoax "Russian" textbook on psycho-politics were removed... ?

Brainwashing-front.jpg



What would remain?

Whatever it was, it couldn't be called Scientology anymore, but what would it be?




 
Scientology must be understood in terms of what Hubbard lied about, and what was actually done.

Hubbard lied about being 'source' of much, if not all of the tech. Much if not all of the tech was invented by others. At best I see Hubbard perhaps adapting older techniques, then claiming those as his own inventions. Techniques to help others which are invented by scientologists other than Hubbard are valid. I realize it is difficult to separate scientology and Hubbard; they are so closely identified A=A=A=A (Korzybski). But it's true that they are not the same. In fact I consider as a sort of rule of thumb that if something in scientology is fucked up, it was created by Hubbard; and if something works well, it was created by others such as Sharp, Filbert, McMaster, Mayo, et al.
PS: NOTs is an adaptation of the biblical technique used by Jesus to remove 'unclean spirits'. :)


.
Interesting! You mentioned that Scientology's OT levels owe a debt of gratitude to Jesus for discovering the BT banishing technology. I am woefully unfamiliar with those JCOBs (Jesus Communications Office Bulletins. Would you mind posting what the technique and commands were?

You also alluded to the fact that many others aside from Hubbard have unfairly been denied credit for inventing the workable parts of Scientology. In that spirit, I would like acknowledge the inventor who made levels of CLEAR and OT possible in the first place.
1646450834158.jpeg​

Of course I am speaking about Peter Duran (above), who I like to call "THE MAN BEHIND THE METER!" In 1810 (a full 141 years before the original patent on the e-meter was filed) Mr. Duran invented the tin can, without which no e-meter could possibly operate.

No meter, no OTs.

No OTs, no planet.

I feel it is only right that the Church of Scientology posthumously award Mr. Duran one of those 7 foot tall bowling trophies.

.
 
Last edited:
israel-regardie.jpg



Category: Antecedents of Scientology



The book, The Middle Pillar, was written by Israel Regardie in 1936.

57617.jpg

Regardie was both a student of the writings of Carl Jung and Aleister Crowley, working for Crowley for a while.


Excerpt from The Middle Pillar:

_______________Begin quote________________​

Analysis is the logical precursor of spiritual attainment and magical experiment... Not until the mind and the emotional system have been cleansed and unified by the cathartic process... can the full spiritual benefits of magical work be reflected into the mind of man.

We should remember the parables of the archaic philosophical religions whose fundamental tenet was that within man was a spirit, a dynamic center of consciousness which, because of its contact and association with matter, had been plunged into a profound sleep, a state of somnambulism...

By endeavoring to extend the horizon of consciousness, to enlarge the field of awareness so as to embrace what previously was unconscious, is obviously a logical method. To become aware of all our actions, our thoughts and emotions and unsuspected motives, to regard them in their true light as actually they are and not as we would like them to be or as we would wish an onlooker to perceive them. It requires, to take this step, an extraordinary degree of honesty and courage... The more of this suppressed and forgotten material stored in this at one time unknown or dormant side of our nature that can be raised to the clear light of day, by exactly so much do we awake from the inert stupor into which we have in the past been plunged.


____________End quote____________


The rest of the thread



















































































































​
 
Subtract certain things, and sort out the subject, and you'd have a different subject .
What if you disregard 99.5 % of the subject and only work with the remaining 1/2%?

Well that is what Filbert claimed he did in his work Excalibur Revisited where he said that the bulk of that text is concerned about that bit. Here is quote from the book:

Of the over twenty-five million words of philosophical, technical, theoretical and religious speculation covered under various Scientology and Dianetic and Hubbard copyrights, less than one-half of a percent have any bearing or proximity to workable application of that subject. Less than 125,000 words of it are true. Approximately one-half of that quantity of information is true, with another half being dangerously close. Whether intentional, or by random accident, the bulk of this text relates to outlining the true quarter of this one percent and correcting the other quarter of that one-half percent.

Rather interesting isn't it?
 
Unspoken is WHO, exactly, will be the "we" who create and govern the Metaverse. It cannot be done by diverse and opposing intents. There must be only one Senior Will.

That is the ideal of the Left. Their whole philosophical basis is that their desire is senior to reality, that intent is senior to actual results.

Their goal is to be Gods, in a universe which they rule absolutely.

also left unspoken, is who does the actual work -- cooking, taking out the trash, etc. it's the fantasy of adolescent boys who've never really grown up, but unfortunately some of them have become multibillionaires with power and influence which rivals that of our democratic institutions, and even of nations. note also that one of their other fantasies is that once they've exploited this planet to the point of collapse they'll just jet off to another, not dissimilar to the way that Hubbard's followers believe they can just pick up a new body if they wreck or lose the one they're living in.

and once again the other extreme, on the right, has similar ideals and goals, in their case based in theocracy.

'Their goal is to be Gods, in a universe which they rule absolutely' -- that pretty much describes Mormon doctrine about the afterlife, for example.
 
Last edited:
Subtract certain things, and sort out the subject, and you'd have a different subject .



Maybe if Hubbard had subtracted certain things, like everything except the Communication Course, and added a course on Public Speaking, he could have competed with Toastmasters International which began in 1924 and is going strong still today with over a quarter-million members in 144 countries.
 
Hubbard mixed B. T. Barnum-ized abteaction, key points of Korzybski, and Crowley, and an e-meter, and the ideas of his haox "Russian tectbook."


]
 
Scientology could have been a common sense self-improvement group without the magic, supernatural powers, telepathy, conspiracy theories, and greed. Sort of a legit life coaching situation.

But who are we kidding. We are talking about Hubbard, for crying out loud.
I knew a couple people in scn who had done est (Erhard Seminars Training) before scn. From what they told me, it sounded like scn with that stuff subtracted.

Rumors abound, but I believe Erhard had done a Comm Course and was a quickie Grade IV in the late 60's before he started est. He definitely got some of it from Hubbard.
 
Back
Top