What Scientology could have been

I knew a couple people in scn who had done est (Erhard Seminars Training) before scn. From what they told me, it sounded like scn with that stuff subtracted.

Rumors abound, but I believe Erhard had done a Comm Course and was a quickie Grade IV in the late 60's before he started est. He definitely got some of it from Hubbard.

I never did est but I read a couple of books about it and before I knew anything about scientology. I think the emphasis is different - est tries to get you, and very early on, to see how you are responsible for creating your experience instead of seeing life as something that is "done to" you. There is also a lot of emphasis (or used to be) on putting you into situations you will find uncomfortable - getting a very masculine type such as a pro football player to go on stage in a dress and act like a woman, for example.

When I was in the freezone I knew a girl (Greek family, brought up in London) who had been an assistant with est and went on to do her Life Repair at our centre; she got a lot out of it, which for me suggests that est isn't a replacement for scn. (I also did some comm course drills with her, which was an experience.)
 
Last edited:
est tries to get you, and very early on, to see how you are responsible for creating your experience imnstead of seeing life as something that is "done to" you.
Doesn't scn do this too? The idea that "you are responsible for your own condition" entered very early for me.
There is also a lot of emphasis (or used to be) on putting you into situatioins you will find uncomfortable - getting a very masculine type such as a pro football player to go on stage in a dress and act like a woman, for example.
We didn't have any men go on stage in a dress, but as for situations you will find uncomfortable, bullbaiting could certainly do that.
When I was in the freezone I knew a girl (Greek family, brought up in London) who had been an assistant with est and went on to do her Life Repair at our centre; she got a lot out of it, which for me suggests that est isn't a replacement for scn. (I also did some comm course drills with her, which was an experience.)
I'm not suggesting that est was a "replacement for scn," only that many of the ideas were similar. A big difference between the two is that est lacked one-on-one therapy, which is fundamental to dns and scn.

What would be a replacement for scn? Orwell's 1984, perhaps.
 
Chickens peck at horse manure to find seeds they can eat. One could, in theory, dissect horse manure to extract the seeds. It is far easier to just get the seeds elsewhere.

I simply don't understand this 'lets identify what was good in Scientology' thing. Hubbard had no insights or techniques that cannot be found elsewhere, and the OT stuff is total nonsense.
 
Chickens peck at horse manure to find seeds they can eat. One could, in theory, dissect horse manure to extract the seeds. It is far easier to just get the seeds elsewhere.





I simply don't understand this 'lets identify what was good in Scientology' thing. Hubbard had no insights or techniques that cannot be found elsewhere, and the OT stuff is total nonsense.

I certainly remember watching a documentary years ago and seeing an elderly "untouchable" Indian woman in the fields squatting down and picking out seeds and oats out of cow patties and eating them on the spot. It wasn't a pleasant sight and it was one of a series of few other options for food. I feel quite lucky that my life does not lead me to making those choices.

Your analogy is certainly apt as far as I'm concerned, Dissecting scientology for what is right seems to be fairly pointless.

It also contributes to the extreme hostility that exists between the far left and right belief systems. The incessant pin point researching that I think Hubbard fell victim to is a big part of creating all sorts of problems. So many people are searching for answers, but only end up looking for their own confirmation biases. Even senior academics are guilty of this, in reference to race and gender studies.

I think that Hubbard believed strongly in what he was doing, it was his mental conditions and delusions was the problem.

Those are what ended up creating a "subject" that was full of fallacies and plagiarised items that fitted into his rabbit hole thinking. In a number of ways I would guess that he was quite unaware (consciously) that he had actually done so. His delusional thinking may well have twisted his thoughts on that. Or perhaps not.
 
I simply don't understand this 'lets identify what was good in Scientology' thing. Hubbard had no insights or techniques that cannot be found elsewhere, and the OT stuff is total nonsense.
I think it's only natural that you would look back on something you devoted years of your life to, decades perhaps, and maybe a good deal of money, before you realized it wasn't working out, and ask yourself, "What went wrong? How could it be changed so it might have worked out better?" I think that sort of questioning is normal.
 
The CofS doesn't allow people to come and go as they please and that is one of the worst aspects of it. If an organisation truly wanted to help people it would allow them to do the services that suited them and let them make decisions as to what to do next. But Hubbard decided that people need to be told what to do and must be controlled and forced to do what the organisation wants them to do.

If the CofS was to become something useful to mankind it would have to scrap so much of its in-built structure, such as sea org, ethics, management by statistics, that it wouldn't be the same organisation. To keep anything useful would be pointless because those things can be found in other, normal, organisations.
 
Last edited:
It would be interesting to see what was left if you took everything bad out of it. No desperation, no long hours, no billion years contracts, no one size fits all grade charts, no long hours of word chains, no KSW, no Xenu, no dogs arse incidents, no blinkless TR0, no RPF, no ethics abuse, no sleepless nights, no files garnished with mouse shit, no diet of beans and rice, no disconnection, no birthday game, no ideal orgs, no IAS, no lies, no making a victim take the blame, no personality tests, no use of the word 'wog' to describe non scienTologists. No idea what that leaves and even if anyone would want it. The one thing left is the phrase 'if it isn't fun it isn't Scientology'.
 
Church of Scientology, the family predator...

7983ec48732193dfb75ede79fe91f7dfa99cb3c8.jpg
 
I agree it is natural and understandable. I just maintain as long as an ex is searching for truths in what is called the ‘tech’, they are still a little bit of a Scientologist.

I think it's only natural that you would look back on something you devoted years of your life to, decades perhaps, and maybe a good deal of money, before you realized it wasn't working out, and ask yourself, "What went wrong? How could it be changed so it might have worked out better?" I think that sort of questioning is normal.
 
The Scientific Method is, roughly:
  1. Observe
  2. Ask question
  3. Propose hypothesis
  4. Test hypothesis
  5. Observe results
  6. Modify hypothesis based on results
  7. Repeat 4, etc.
What would Scientology been if that had happened?

Hubbard started out with declaring his hypothesis to be TRUE, TESTED and VERIFIED. This blocked any attempt at #6.

Splinter groups DID attempt 4, 5, 6, 7 but the results promised by Hubbard never appeared. So, step #6 by "squirrels" never resulted in a workable version. And some DID try, for years.

So, the inevitable conclusion is that Scientology, even if allowed to change and grow, would NEVER have resulted in any workable tech. The indie field proves that.
 
I agree it is natural and understandable. I just maintain as long as an ex is searching for truths in what is called the ‘tech’, they are still a little bit of a Scientologist.
I agree with you. I gave up searching for answers in the tech long ago. But I still find speculating about it interesting.
 
The merging of parts of Crowley's Magick ("The Method of Science, the Aim of Religion"); Korzybski's Science of Sanity); psychological abreaction (catharsis); the e-meter (simple bio-feedback) ; hypnosis; and "brainwashing," is a curiosity.

If all the negativeness were subtracted what would remain would be a tiny fraction s of the subject.

Extricating someone from Scientology by telling him it's all bad has a poor success rate.


daisy-on-railroad-track.jpg
 
You would have the tech on how to clean windows using newspaper, vinegar, and water.
Yes I did that for years after I left smearing ink all over my windows and leaving greasy lines. But where in a good scintOlogist household do you find newspapers? I had to take them out of my neighbor's bin!
 
The Scientific Method is, roughly:
  1. Observe
  2. Ask question
  3. Propose hypothesis
  4. Test hypothesis
  5. Observe results
  6. Modify hypothesis based on results
  7. Repeat 4, etc.
What would Scientology been if that had happened?

Hubbard started out with declaring his hypothesis to be TRUE, TESTED and VERIFIED. This blocked any attempt at #6.

Splinter groups DID attempt 4, 5, 6, 7 but the results promised by Hubbard never appeared. So, step #6 by "squirrels" never resulted in a workable version. And some DID try, for years.

So, the inevitable conclusion is that Scientology, even if allowed to change and grow, would NEVER have resulted in any workable tech. The indie field proves that.
You just would not be able to use this method in scientology. And not even for perfecting a technology point. This is not part of the paradigm, as well as narrative. Mankind, left to it's own devices, came up with lobotomy, etc. as the "reason" that would not work.
 
The merging of parts of Crowley's Magick ("The Method of Science, the Aim of Religion"); Korzybski's Science of Sanity); psychological abreaction (catharsis); the e-meter (simple bio-feedback) ; hypnosis; and "brainwashing," is a curiosity.

If all the negativeness were subtracted what would remain would be a tiny fraction s of the subject.

Extricating someone from Scientology by telling him it's all bad has a poor success rate.


daisy-on-railroad-track.jpg
No one exists that would be able to specifically say why certain parts made it into the mix with any certainity. No one exists that would be able to say why other things did not. No one exists that can speak with certainty about these things. Telling people how to think about their experience is not a good idea, as you may not be able to know their experience compared to yours and others that you know of.

There are two things here, interestingly. One is "what parts work and what parts don't work" (this thought definitely does not align with the basic points ascribed to scientology, which is that it all works) and the other is how people decide about things that they are involved in.

It is quite the puzzle.
 
Yes I did that for years after I left smearing ink all over my windows and leaving greasy lines. But where in a good scintOlogist household do you find newspapers? I had to take them out of my neighbor's bin!


Someone posted something online about cleaning windows with this method.

How to clean windows with Vinegar and Newspaper


He wrote:

Most newspapers are now printed with soy-based ink. This will not come off whilst using the newspaper to clean your windows. A simple test to see if the paper is printed with soy-based ink is to firstly look for the stamp on the paper " Printed with soy ink " and secondly. Rub the paper in between your fingers for a minute if the ink comes off then it's petroleum-based ink which isn't good for cleaning windows. If however, it does not come off then it's soy-based and good for windows.
 
You just would not be able to use this method in scientology. And not even for perfecting a technology point. This is not part of the paradigm, as well as narrative. Mankind, left to it's own devices, came up with lobotomy, etc. as the "reason" that would not work.
Hubbard created an hypothesis that there were engrams and such beasties and those made up a "Reactive Mind" and that this Reactive Mind was the source of all man's problems. Of course that could have been tested. Of course the results of such testing could have been observed. If Hubbard hadn't been in charge, the failures could have been seen and the hypothesis modified.

The reason the scientific method couldn't be used in Scientology was because Hubbard blocked any attempts but it could have been easily used.
 
Hubbard created an hypothesis that there were engrams and such beasties and those made up a "Reactive Mind" and that this Reactive Mind was the source of all man's problems. Of course that could have been tested. Of course the results of such testing could have been observed. If Hubbard hadn't been in charge, the failures could have been seen and the hypothesis modified.

The reason the scientific method couldn't be used in Scientology was because Hubbard blocked any attempts but it could have been easily used.
It could still be used on this subject by those wanting it to work.

Big pharma knows their way around these obstacles pretty well.
 
It could still be used on this subject by those wanting it to work.

Big pharma knows their way around these obstacles pretty well.
Here is a little slice of big pharma: Findings In this cross-sectional study of 116 drug approvals and 228 cost-effectiveness studies and 254 analyses, a drug was 40 times more likely to be deemed cost-effective when the study was funded by pharmaceutical companies compared with no funding.



 
Back
Top