Why Annie Broeker, famous inside Scientology, had to die in secret

Karen#1

Well-known member
TONY ORTEGA
Excerpt:






[Annie Tidman and Jim Logan]
This story was first published at The Village Voice on January 30, 2012. We consider it one of our most important stories ever about Scientology, and we decided to find room for it here at our Substack so it will have an ad-free archival home. — T.O.



Last June, a 55-year-old woman named Ann Tidman died in an apartment in Hollywood.

Her own sisters, who suspected that she was ill, did not learn about Tidman’s death until just a few weeks ago. They had tried to get information about her, but Tidman herself — and the church she belonged to — wanted as few people as possible to know about her fight with lung cancer.

And that’s why we’re only finding out now, months after her death, that Ann Tidman died on June 14 in apartment 336 at a complex owned by the Church of Scientology at 1830 N. Bronson Avenue, a block over from the famous Hollywood Celebrity Centre.

For those not in the church, or among its ex-members, Tidman’s name may mean little, and her death will probably not be noticed by the mainstream press. But to Scientologists, who tend to call her by another name — Annie Broeker — she was a powerful symbol for where their movement had been and where it was going.

On January 14, former Scientology executive Marty Rathbun announced on his blog that a record of Tidman’s death had been found online. Then, yesterday, he published her death certificate, along with an analysis of its details. Since his first announcement, we’ve been verifying information about her final years as well as interviewing people who knew her.

Janet Reitman, in her excellent history of the church, last year’s Inside Scientology, explained what made Tidman such an important figure in the history of the organization. After 1980, when Scientology’s founder, L. Ron Hubbard, went into seclusion, it was Annie — then married to Pat Broeker — who cared for the aging writer:

READ MORE

 
Annie Broeker had to be sequestered (isolated and hidden away) because she was the only person still alive from Ron Hubbard's final years at Creston Ranch who knew for an absolute fact that Davie McSavage was absolutely not left in charge of Scientology by Hubbard. She knew he was and had been lying about that to everyone in Official Corporate Scientology, both staff and public members, since he finished his house Coup d'Etat in mid-1988.

Pat Broeker was a declared Suppressive Person outside the C of $ at that point under constant P.I. surveillance. We have it from Steve "Sarge" Pfauth that Hubbard did not actually want him around at Creston during the last year or so because he and Miscavige never did obtain the necessary security All Clear (all legal threats to Ron Hubbard personally handled) so that Hubbard could return to Winter HQ and oversee the completion of the Technical Training Films. They were supposed to get that done within a few months after he went fabian on Jan 15th, 1980.

Annie Broeker was his CMO Watch Messenger the entire time at Creston. She personally transcribed all his outbound communications from dictation recordings to typewritten despatches and therefore absolutely would have known whether or not Hubbard had appointed Dave the Grifter to his current Pope of Scientology status.

Annie was spiritually and mentally beaten down with abusive black Scientology techniques and then sequestered to keep the Scientology public (particularly the Whale donors) from ever finding out that he had scammed them for at least USD $1 billion in donations for the IAS and Ideal Orgs Program that were strictly forbidden to even exist by Ron Hubbard himself.

"Follow the money" - Deep Throat to Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of The Washington Post during their Watergate investigation.
 
Last edited:
Annie Broeker had to be sequestered (isolated and hidden away) because she was the only person still alive from Ron Hubbard's final years at Creston Ranch who knew for an absolute fact that Davie McSavage was absolutely not left in charge of Scientology by Hubbard. She knew he was and had been lying about that to everyone in Official Corporate Scientology, both staff and public members, since he finished his house Coup d'Etat in mid-1988.

Pat Broeker was a declared Suppressive Person outside the C of $ at that point under constant P.I. surveillance. We have it from Steve "Sarge" Pfauth that Hubbard did not actually want him around at Creston during the last year or so because he and Miscavige never did obtain the necessary security All Clear (all legal threats to Ron Hubbard personally handled) so that Hubbard could return to Winter HQ and oversee the completion of the Technical Training Films. They were supposed to get that done within a few months after he went fabian on Jan 15th, 1980.

Annie Broeker was his CMO Watch Messenger the entire time at Creston. She personally transcribed all his outbound communications from dictation recordings to typewritten despatches and therefore absolutely would have known whether or not Hubbard had appointed Dave the Grifter to his current Pope of Scientology status.

Annie was spiritually and mentally beaten down with abusive black Scientology techniques and then sequestered to keep the Scientology public (particularly the Whale donors) from ever finding out that he had scammed them for at least USD $1 billion in donations for the IAS and Ideal Orgs Program that were strictly forbidden to even exist by Ron Hubbard himself.

"Follow the money" - Deep Throat to Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein of The Washington Post during their Watergate investigation.
I know you're very focused on separating documented fact from claimed fact, I wasn't aware that DM claimed to have been appointed by Hubbard to take charge, can you give the particulars of DM making that claim?
 
I know you're very focused on separating documented fact from claimed fact, I wasn't aware that DM claimed to have been appointed by Hubbard to take charge, can you give the particulars of DM making that claim?

You may consult his official biography ( link to Scientology.Org).

Mike Rinder published a blog article which is a rebuttal to that biography dated July 18, 2023 and titled David Miscavige was NOT Anointed by Hubbard
 
Last edited:
Ron adored being adored. That's CMO messenger Annie under his hand. He said they all had a past as his Loyal Officers. That stuck like glue.


images
 
Last edited:
Excuse me, but I've never seen that claim before. Can you please cite your source for that? I'll go have a look.
I'm repeating a line from one of the youtube commentaries about David Miscavige and the ardent followers. I DO remember this coming from an ex Sea Orger who now has a channel. Sorry, I made a note of those words but cannot remember if it was Aaron or Mike Rinder or Marc Headley. Outside of drawings sanctioned by LRH, depicting Loyal Officers rescuing in Incident 2.....

Drawing cued to 53.37 min. An OT VIII claims Loyal Officers are Ron's Sea Org.
The 54 minute marker, commentary

I'm confident there are tapes of staff briefings where Ron is addressing and thanking loyal officers. Off the bat, I don't recall a special tape where Ron said Sea Org members were all 'loyal officers'. He sure did infer it.

Ron was most correct when he said the days of groups of OTs or free and wild ones, had come to a finish.. There is nobody else but ourselves to carry out the goals. Mostly, those recalling their final OT hero adventures will also sense how singularly alone they felt if they persevered. There was no more GROUP......and there hadn't been for a long time.
 
Last edited:
Excuse me, but I've never seen that claim before. Can you please cite your source for that? I'll go have a look.
OK, not a correct item for every single person there. But, Annie and Pat Broeker, Hanna Eltringham, Captain Bill, and probably Marty and Mike, felt individually validated for that 'track' and remaining loyal to their purpose.
 
Hatshepsut said:
He [Hubbard] said they [his Commodore's Messengers] all had a past as his Loyal Officers.

OK, I just now checked with Janis Gillham Grady and she says that Hubbard indeed used to say that about his Messengers and other Apollo crew. Janis gave me permission to source her for this.

I'm sorry, if my hyperfocus on verification has offended you.
 
Annie Broeker had to be sequestered (isolated and hidden away) because she was the only person still alive from Ron Hubbard's final years at Creston Ranch who knew for an absolute fact that Davie McSavage was absolutely not left in charge of Scientology by Hubbard. She knew he was and had been lying about that to everyone in Official Corporate Scientology, both staff and public....

In my opinion, I think he also wanted to make sure she would not reveal to anybody the severe physical and mental deterioration of Hubbard, years prior to his death; especially regarding his mental illness and loss of reality.
 
Back
Top