i don't see that as necessarily better. i suspect Erhard had in mind some sort of genius for putting together techniques and courses that moved people, rather than as a philosopher, though from the perspective of close to half a century later he'd likely be much more critical about the actual results produced (or not) and the means used. as i understand it even back then in the 70s, 'est' was partly inspired by Erhard seeing what Hubbard was doing as too limited, expensive, and encumbered by culty organization, when he'd already worked with others who could produce impressive (seeming) results in more efficient group training sessions.
Back in the 1970s I had an apartment, in midtown Manhattan, a half block away from Madison Square Garden. Just going to the subway, under the Garden, could be an interesting experience. Events, conventions, and assorted gatherings would occur and it was impossible to take the subway from that location without seeing and interacting with the attendees. From across the street, I would see the crowd waiting to enter Madison Square Garden and then guess who they might be.
The crowd for Professional Wrestling and Hockey was easily identifiable, and particularly the hockey people (often inebriated) were to be avoided.
A few blocks down Eighth Avenue was the old New Yorker building, which had been purchased by the Unification Church. Pale, thin young men, with white dress shirts and skinny black ties, would stand around with walkie-talkies.
Then there were the Lyndon LaRouche people - their official title was the National Caucus of Labor Committees - and they would set up a big folding table, also nearby on Eighth Avenue, in front of big central post office to sell and distribute literature.
At a distance of a block or so I couldn't discern the pale thin Moonies from the pale thin LaRouche people. They dressed identically. It occurred to me that some Scientologists - particularly staff members - dressed the same way and had the same appearance and mannerisms.
Then one day there was an EST convention at the Garden, and
they looked just like typical Scientologists, complete with the blinkless stare.
It's anecdotal of course, but from my experiences with them, I noticed many similarities between EST and Scientology. They had adopted the Scientology practice of Hard Sell, being "unreasonable," and using "8-C" control.
Amongst other things, Werner Erhard had adopted the Scientology Lower Grades and made them what, in Scientology, would be called Group Processing.
Around the same time, for a while, there was an EST center in San Francisco, across the street from the Eductivism center run by notorious "squirrel" Jack Horner. It must have driven Hubbard, who was hyper-possessive and punitive, crazy.
i do point out even to bitter critics that the old man, and DM after him, have a certain genius even if it's just for creating a lucrative organization offer power over others that has to be acknowledged, even an evil genius if you will.
There are some who think MK-Ultra, the IRS, or at least a bunch of lawyers, are secretly running Scientology.