What is Rhetoric?

It's pretty obvious no regular posters here wish to discuss rhetoric or Hubbard's use of rhetoric. So be it.


I'm ready to discuss rhetoric! :yes:

Hubbard persuaded through his rhetoric when people listened to his lectures or read books & HCO PLs, he wrote. But in the past hundred years, researchers have discovered that there are other means of persuasion besides rhetoric. I posted some stuff about that below. Do you think it's possible that for some individuals who got involved in Scientology that a couple of those listed factors were more important than rhetoric? I believe that because it was true for me. I was heavily persuaded not by Hubbard but by staff at the CoS.

I snipped out much of the post below so go to the link to read the whole thing. I only included two of the six type of persuasion as for me personally they had a big impact on my getting involved with Scientology and staying in in the early years. I don't believe the other four have much inpact.


Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion: A Simple Summary

Excerpt:

Robert Cialdini published his book “Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion” in 1984. In it, he explores factors that affect the decisions that people make, particularly in relation to sales and purchasing. <snip>
At the core of his work is the now well accepted idea that decision making is effortful, so individuals use a lot of rules of thumb and decision making shortcuts (heuristics) when deciding what to do, how to behave or what action to take in any situation. <snip>

The six key principles Cialdini identified are: reciprocity, scarcity, authority, commitment and consistency, liking and consensus (or social proof).



5 – Liking
The fifth of Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion is liking.

It might seem totally obvious, but people are much more likely to be influenced and persuaded by those that they like, than those that they don’t. Given human nature, people are much more likely to like people who pay them compliments and who cooperate with them, than those who don’t. And, unfortunately, given positive evidence in relation to certain benefits of diversity, people are also much more likely to like people who are similar to them, than those who are not.

We see this principle played out often in the world of marketing and advertising. Nearly every advertisement you see will feature individuals designed to appeal to the product’s target market. The more the consumer associates with and likes that person, the more likely they are to be influenced by them.

To use this principle in the world of work, you simply need to become liked by those around you and those you are looking to persuade or influence. You can do this by cooperating with others, by paying others genuine compliments and by identifying similarities and building relationships. They key here, though, is that you need to build these relationships and garner this “liking” before you try and influence others. If you try and become liked once you’ve started your efforts to influence, then those efforts will fail.

<snip>

6 – Consensus (social proof)
The last of Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion is consensus, or social proof.

Humans are social by nature and generally feel that it’s important to conform to the norms of a social group. This means that when it comes to decision making, we often look around us to see what others are doing, before making our mind up.

A classic example of this that many people will have seen is that of hotel towels. Signage that says “8 out of 10 hotel guests choose to reuse their towels” is far more effective at influencing and persuading than signs that simply say “reusing your towel helps to save the environment”.

Interestingly, the more socially specific communications of this type are, the more effective they are. For example signs that say “8 out of 10 hotel guests who stay in this room choose to reuse their towels” are more effective than those that simply reference generic hotel guests.

This principle of consensus or social proof is a bit hard to use from a personal perspective in the world of work, but by managing you reputation and personal brand, it may just be possible to do so.
 
I'm ready to discuss rhetoric! :yes:

Hubbard persuaded through his rhetoric when people listened to his lectures or read books & HCO PLs, he wrote. But in the past hundred years, researchers have discovered that there are other means of persuasion besides rhetoric. I posted some stuff about that below. Do you think it's possible that for some individuals who got involved in Scientology that a couple of those listed factors were more important than rhetoric? I believe that because it was true for me. I was heavily persuaded not by Hubbard but by staff at the CoS.

I snipped out much of the post below so go to the link to read the whole thing. I only included two of the six type of persuasion as for me personally they had a big impact on my getting involved with Scientology and staying in in the early years. I don't believe the other four have much inpact.


Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion: A Simple Summary

Excerpt:
Robert Cialdini published his book “Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion” in 1984. In it, he explores factors that affect the decisions that people make, particularly in relation to sales and purchasing. <snip>
At the core of his work is the now well accepted idea that decision making is effortful, so individuals use a lot of rules of thumb and decision making shortcuts (heuristics) when deciding what to do, how to behave or what action to take in any situation. <snip>

The six key principles Cialdini identified are: reciprocity, scarcity, authority, commitment and consistency, liking and consensus (or social proof).



5 – Liking
The fifth of Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion is liking.

It might seem totally obvious, but people are much more likely to be influenced and persuaded by those that they like, than those that they don’t. Given human nature, people are much more likely to like people who pay them compliments and who cooperate with them, than those who don’t. And, unfortunately, given positive evidence in relation to certain benefits of diversity, people are also much more likely to like people who are similar to them, than those who are not.

We see this principle played out often in the world of marketing and advertising. Nearly every advertisement you see will feature individuals designed to appeal to the product’s target market. The more the consumer associates with and likes that person, the more likely they are to be influenced by them.

To use this principle in the world of work, you simply need to become liked by those around you and those you are looking to persuade or influence. You can do this by cooperating with others, by paying others genuine compliments and by identifying similarities and building relationships. They key here, though, is that you need to build these relationships and garner this “liking” before you try and influence others. If you try and become liked once you’ve started your efforts to influence, then those efforts will fail.

<snip>

6 – Consensus (social proof)
The last of Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion is consensus, or social proof.

Humans are social by nature and generally feel that it’s important to conform to the norms of a social group. This means that when it comes to decision making, we often look around us to see what others are doing, before making our mind up.

A classic example of this that many people will have seen is that of hotel towels. Signage that says “8 out of 10 hotel guests choose to reuse their towels” is far more effective at influencing and persuading than signs that simply say “reusing your towel helps to save the environment”.

Interestingly, the more socially specific communications of this type are, the more effective they are. For example signs that say “8 out of 10 hotel guests who stay in this room choose to reuse their towels” are more effective than those that simply reference generic hotel guests.

This principle of consensus or social proof is a bit hard to use from a personal perspective in the world of work, but by managing you reputation and personal brand, it may just be possible to do so.


Excellent reference!

And if Riddick ever educated himself on the actual meaning of the term "rhetoric", he would eventually discover that the term rhetoric is not the same as innumerable other persuasive methods of cult recruitment, including but not limited to: LYING, FRAUD, DECEPTION, HALF-TRUTHS, WHITE LIES, FALSE ADVERTISING, PSEUDOSCIENTIFIC WOO, BIG LIES, TRICKING, PSYCHOLOGICAL MANIPULATION, GASLIGHTING, COERCION, MISREPRESENTATIONS, HYPERBOLE, INTIMIDATION, SWINDLING, RACKETEERING, BAIT & SWITCH, CON GAMES, OVERWHELM TECHNIQUES, HOAXING, LOVE BOMBING, RUIN-FINDING TERRORISM, et al.

..
 
Last edited:
And if Riddick ever educated himself on the actual meaning of the term "rhetoric", he would eventually discover that the term rhetoric is not the same as innumerable other persuasive methods of cult recruitment..."

<snip>
..

I do believe he'll eventually have that realization. Maybe he just needs to use more clay. :coolwink:
 
..

I do believe he'll eventually have that realization. Maybe he just needs to use more clay. :coolwink:
.


Yeah, but his tech estimate indicates that he may need considerable quantities.

For the sake of economy, perhaps he should invest in industrial clay excavation equipment.

1000_F_391876821_RIDWaGcVcD6dIDGzhF21AzvJVRwASfsj.jpg



..
 
I'm ready to discuss rhetoric! :yes:

Hubbard persuaded through his rhetoric when people listened to his lectures or read books & HCO PLs, he wrote. But in the past hundred years, researchers have discovered that there are other means of persuasion besides rhetoric. I posted some stuff about that below. Do you think it's possible that for some individuals who got involved in Scientology that a couple of those listed factors were more important than rhetoric? I believe that because it was true for me. I was heavily persuaded not by Hubbard but by staff at the CoS.

I snipped out much of the post below so go to the link to read the whole thing. I only included two of the six type of persuasion as for me personally they had a big impact on my getting involved with Scientology and staying in in the early years. I don't believe the other four have much inpact.


Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion: A Simple Summary

Excerpt:
Robert Cialdini published his book “Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion” in 1984. In it, he explores factors that affect the decisions that people make, particularly in relation to sales and purchasing. <snip>
At the core of his work is the now well accepted idea that decision making is effortful, so individuals use a lot of rules of thumb and decision making shortcuts (heuristics) when deciding what to do, how to behave or what action to take in any situation. <snip>

The six key principles Cialdini identified are: reciprocity, scarcity, authority, commitment and consistency, liking and consensus (or social proof).



5 – Liking
The fifth of Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion is liking.

It might seem totally obvious, but people are much more likely to be influenced and persuaded by those that they like, than those that they don’t. Given human nature, people are much more likely to like people who pay them compliments and who cooperate with them, than those who don’t. And, unfortunately, given positive evidence in relation to certain benefits of diversity, people are also much more likely to like people who are similar to them, than those who are not.

We see this principle played out often in the world of marketing and advertising. Nearly every advertisement you see will feature individuals designed to appeal to the product’s target market. The more the consumer associates with and likes that person, the more likely they are to be influenced by them.

To use this principle in the world of work, you simply need to become liked by those around you and those you are looking to persuade or influence. You can do this by cooperating with others, by paying others genuine compliments and by identifying similarities and building relationships. They key here, though, is that you need to build these relationships and garner this “liking” before you try and influence others. If you try and become liked once you’ve started your efforts to influence, then those efforts will fail.

<snip>

6 – Consensus (social proof)
The last of Cialdini’s 6 Principles of Persuasion is consensus, or social proof.

Humans are social by nature and generally feel that it’s important to conform to the norms of a social group. This means that when it comes to decision making, we often look around us to see what others are doing, before making our mind up.

A classic example of this that many people will have seen is that of hotel towels. Signage that says “8 out of 10 hotel guests choose to reuse their towels” is far more effective at influencing and persuading than signs that simply say “reusing your towel helps to save the environment”.

Interestingly, the more socially specific communications of this type are, the more effective they are. For example signs that say “8 out of 10 hotel guests who stay in this room choose to reuse their towels” are more effective than those that simply reference generic hotel guests.

This principle of consensus or social proof is a bit hard to use from a personal perspective in the world of work, but by managing you reputation and personal brand, it may just be possible to do so.
"I'm ready to discuss rhetoric! :yes:"

No you are not, you just trolled this thread to talk about something else, namely Cialdini.
 
..

"I'm ready to discuss rhetoric! :yes:"

No you are not, you just trolled this thread to talk about something else, namely Cialdini.
.

..

Unintentionally hilarious trolling by Riddick!

Someone dared to discuss the art of persuasion on the rhetoric thread—which is precisely what rhetoric is intended to do—persuade. However, they suppressively mentioned an expert on the 'Principles of Persuasion' other than Riddick. LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL LOL

In a way, I hope Riddick's clown act continues for the sheer entertainment value of it.

..
 
Last edited:
The rhetoric motto of the Sea Org is We Come Back. This is a ethos, pathos and logos appeal to persuade all in one sentence that scientology works.

From a logos point of view, well prove it. This is a question to Hubbard if he were alive today I would ask him, do people come back from dead? And can you hubbard prove it?
 
..

Here is more great info by Robert Cialdini on PERSUASION supported by scholarly research and scientific analysis.


It has simple yet profound practical value. Let me illustrate with an example. Recently I was watching the NETFLIX documentary on Bernie Madoff, the infamous multi-billion-dollar Ponzi perpetrator. He used "SCARCITY" to lure prospective investors in by rejecting some investors and otherwise making it difficult to "get approved" to become a client-investor of his financial management firm. It created a feeding frenzy of people anxious to do whatever it took to give him all their money.

Likewise, infamous Scientology ponzi crook, Reid Slatkin, played the same "scarcity" game by pretending not to need or want hopeful investors' money. Marks who got scammed into handing over the life savings to Slatkin were thrilled about how they were "accepted" by him. When the SEC began closing down his operations (ordering him to return all investors' capital!) Slatkin's clients literally begged to be allowed to leave their funds with him. And those lucky "chosen few" that he allowed to stay BRAGGED to others about their elite status that Reid wanted them to remain. Of course all of them lost their money, including the "chosen ones".

Scarcity is an extraordinary tool to pry both confidence and money from a mark that wanders into a Scientology org.

Want some more scarcity? How about donating hundreds of thousands of dollars to "the Bridge" and then hoping that you are worthy of "getting an invitation" to do the OT levels! LOL

JOKE DU JOUR: Who hasn't seen the Sea Org recruitment posters that promote signing a billion year contract with the supposedly compelling "scarcity" enticement (i.e. "few are chosen", LOL).

a1dgNk4gITnul6gH594sJ_l3jWbxnXiLRDyeggeXVNQ.jpg



MANY ARE CALLED...
FEW DON'T HAVE CALLER ID, AND THUS—
MOST AVOID THE MISTAKE OF PICKING UP


...​
 
Last edited:
..

The rhetoric motto of the Sea Org is We Come Back. This is a ethos, pathos and logos appeal to persuade all in one sentence that scientology works.

From a logos point of view, well prove it. This is a question to Hubbard if he were alive today I would ask him, do people come back from dead? And can you hubbard prove it?


If you stop endlessly repeating the same posts and read experts on the subject of persuasion like Robert Cialdini, you might learn something. Read Type4_PTS' many posts on persuasion as well on this and many other threads, and you will greatly enhance your understanding of the many ways that people can be influenced.

You are not an expert. Be humble and learn. When you realize this you will finally understand why you get so many terribly negative reactions on this message board over the years.

PRO TIP: Riddick, your "Rhetoric Lectures" are dead. Everyone moved on past that long ago. You should try to catch up by starting to learn from many other wonderfully informed sources of wisdom about the art of persuasion. Rhetoric is just one little branch on that big tree.

..

..
 
Last edited:
"I'm ready to discuss rhetoric! :yes:"

No you are not, you just trolled this thread to talk about something else, namely Cialdini.


Actually I totally AM ready to discuss rhetoric. But in order for someone to really understand the impact that Hubbard's use of rhetoric had on Scientologists they've got to be able to put it in it's proper perspective. The use of rhetoric by Hubbard was one part of the recipe used to create Scientologists but there were other parts as well.

Are you still claiming that rhetoric was the only means of persuasion and the only means of indoctrination? If that's the lesson you're trying to teach you're doing a disservice because it's not accurate.

When I first got involved with the CoS I really liked some of the staff members I came into contact with. They made a big impression on me. Seeing their attitude towards Scientology, their involvement with it, and how enthusiastic they were about the organization all had a huge impact on me. This was prior to my believing that Hubbard was "mankind's greatest friend". In the early days my impression of the Boston CoS staff was far more impactful on me than any of Hubbard's rhetoric.
 
Last edited:
.

oh, Hoaxie you have fallen down on me again. you should have said other than Riddick - or Dean Wilbur. :sneaky:


LOL!!

Dean Wilbur, who can forget!?! LOL

Riddick devoted an entire thread to the task of scientifically proving that Hubbard learned about rhetoric from Wilbur and thus was able to start the Dianetic and Scientology cult 2 decades later. Unfortunately, Riddick's thesis about the persuasive power of rhetoric was—not persuasive. Allow me to illustrate:

The first two (2) reaction comments on his Wilbur/Rhetoric thread were as follows:


.





.
LOL, they didn't seem very persuaded. Mara dozing off and Chuck J's broken record graphic both captured their utter lack of interest with a Zen yawn.

Perhaps Riddick realized he had lost his audience and his next response to them might have been far more persuasive, let's check it out:



If you read the link I provided above, lets begin. If you haven't STFU.

Let's begin with Book 1, or Dianetics the modern science of mental health.


.
Um, I guess not. LOL

But I do have to admire Riddick's discovery of an advanced form of persuasive rhetoric where you scream
STFU at your audience while lecturing them about how to expertly persuade others.

..
 
In the early days my impression of the Boston CoS staff was far more impactful on me than any of Hubbard's rhetoric.

.
I think what you said scientifically proves Riddick's point—and leads the the inescapable conclusion that Boston Org staff members must also have studied William Allen Wilbur's 1915 book on English rhetoric.

Since Wilbur was born during the American Civil War (1864) it is more than likely that many of Boston's staff members would have personally known and studied with him in a past life.

..
 
Last edited:
You are not an expert. Be humble and learn. When you realize this you will finally understand why you get so many terribly negative reactions on this message board over the years.

Actually I totally AM ready to discuss rhetoric. But in order for someone to really understand the impact that Hubbard's use of rhetoric had on Scientologists they've got to be able to put it in it's proper perspective. The use of rhetoric by Hubbard was one part of the recipe used to create Scientologists but there were other parts as well.

The rhetoric motto of the Sea Org is We Come Back. This is a ethos, pathos and logos appeal to persuade all in one sentence that scientology works.

i happened to be thinking about this all recently, and agreeing that what's not working ought to be learned from, and that one of such things is that there's more Hubbard and scientology than just rhetoric, when it does come to rhetoric i'd like to see good -- persuasive, even -- explanations of just what might be at work in that regard in a particular relevant instance.

for example in the case of the sea org motto, rather than hearing the brief, dogmatic claim that all 3 are in one sentence, I'd like to see a thorough explanation of how each are supposed to be at work there. and if the reason for not doing that is that it's been explained before, then maybe it's time to just let it go and not risk falling into Hubbard's use of repetition to manipulate and indoctrinate (another reminder that he used things other than rhetoric).

techniques include constant repetition of doctrine
Understanding Scientology / Chapter 14: Brainwashing and Thought Control in Scientology -- The Road to Rondroid
 
i happened to be thinking about this all recently, and agreeing that what's not working ought to be learned from, and that one of such things is that there's more Hubbard and scientology than just rhetoric, when it does come to rhetoric i'd like to see good -- persuasive, even -- explanations of just what might be at work in that regard in a particular relevant instance.

for example in the case of the sea org motto, rather than hearing the brief, dogmatic claim that all 3 are in one sentence, I'd like to see a thorough explanation of how each are supposed to be at work there. and if the reason for not doing that is that it's been explained before, then maybe it's time to just let it go and not risk falling into Hubbard's use of repetition to manipulate and indoctrinate (another reminder that he used things other than rhetoric).

Understanding Scientology / Chapter 14: Brainwashing and Thought Control in Scientology -- The Road to Rondroid



..
Your bullet points all hit the bullseye.

There is no practical value in standing on stage, showing a flashcard with a QUOTE by Hubbard —and then asking if anyone in the audience can state which of the 3 types of rhetoric it is.

Then when nobody in the disinterested audience responds, the presenter on stage triumphantly screams "LOGOS!", followed by a bow after which he excitedly awaits applause.

Nothing is gained.

It would be analogous to taking a painting class that consists solely of the art professor projecting famous Baroque masterpieces on a large screen, whereupon a laser is pointed at one spot on the oil painting and the university students are then supposed to shout out a color in unison (e.g. "MAGENTA!") or whatever hue in that painting the laser touches.

RED_LASER1.jpg


"ULTRAMARINE!"​

If they can correctly shout out the right color, they get a framed art degree diploma.

I wonder what Riddick's RHETORIC students get, besides a migraine.


...
 
Last edited:
Chasing your own tail. Pissing in the wind. Wasting time. Taking in your own laundry.

You guys are going to need a repair or correction after all this.

Some good posting, some great observations. However, we have a planet to clear, can we get on with it?
 
..
Type4_PTS said:

Is there an End of Endless Rhetoric Thread Correction List?
.


HUBBARD COMMUNICATIONS OFFICE
Saint Hill Manor, East Grinstead, Sussex

HCO BULLETIN OF 1 APRIL 1986

URGENT

Troll Series #666

END OF ENDLESS RHETORIC TREAD
SHORT-FORM CORRECTION LIST
​


1. Was there no need for this tread in the first place? ​
​
2. Has a tread been overrun?​
​
3. Did your INT go out after you "went out of" the tread, but then all the ​
other treads were also being derailed into rhetoric treads?​
​
4. Was the so-called "discussion" on rhetoric actually the same as an LRH lecture ​
where nobody is allowed to comment, ask questions or disagree? ​
​
5. Did the world's leading expert on rhetoric and persuasion fail to persuade anyone?​
​
6. Was your huge life-changing win invalidated when you cognited that "This troll doesn't​
know WTF he is talking about!" ​
​
​
​
L. RON HUBBARD ​
Founder​
Copyright © 1986 by L. Ron Hubbard ​
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED​
​
..​
 
Last edited:
Many of the scales Huddard wrote about were logos or logical appeals. I believe the book is called The Fundamentals of Thought.

The tone scale is a pathos appeal to persuade. The basic one in dianetics is from 0-4 tone, the scientology one is expanded to include past lives.

But yet, nobody returned from past lives using scientology.
 
Last edited:
..
Many of the scales Huddard wrote about were logos or logical appeals. I believe the book is called The Fundamentals of Thought. The tone scale is a pathos appeal to persuade. The basic one in dianetics is from 0-4 tone, the scientology one is expanded to include past lives.

But yet, nobody returned from past lives using scientology.


Jeez, Riddick, fan support for your repetitive
rhetoric lecture seems to be a bit low. . .

1661913208-GettyImages-142022486.jpg


No worries, dude. Keep outflowing on HOW TO PERSUADE
WITH RHETORIC
and eventually it'll go viral and
you'll be playing to sold out arenas!

..​


...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top