.
In a metered auditing session I was auditing a middle aged man on the self analysis lists. The auditing "command" (scientology lingo) was, "Recall a time when someone had just given you something." He started waving his hands in the air saying, "No! No! No!" He was reliving a time when he was dropped off at an orphanage as a child and someone was trying to give him an ice cream cone to calm him down.
If that session allowed that man to "discharge" or lay to rest that longstanding painful memory he would say that the auditing was beneficial.
Perhaps! Could be!
Or not.
I did plenty of auditing and C/Sing so I am quite familiar with in-session phenomena. Here is my takeaway about all those huge resurgent wins.
WHAT HAPPENS IN A SESSION IS WHAT HAPPENED.
This is related to the e-meter datum that goes something like this: "When the meter reads you know that the meter has read" (i.e. that's
all you know, not whether that needle reaction is in any way connected to the PC being audited).
So a PC has a monumental win. They're exterior! They just realized that they were Marilyn Monroe in a past life! Their car was reposessed that morning because 380,048,483,227 years ago they pulled the air cover off a planet named "Repo" and their bank did an A=A and that caused them to pull in the motivator of getting fired from their job, so that resulted in missing the monthly car payments. Now they totally cognited on what happened and they are totally certain that they will never get their car towed away again!"
Sorry. It's just that I don't know what any of those breathless PC originations mean in session. Maybe something happened, maybe nothing happened. I don't trust what Scientology Preclears say, because I know for a fact that Scientologists are often wildly and delusionally making shit up.
Am I too cynical? I don't think so, I am on my best behavior here. LOL
So maybe your PC did or did not get put up for adoption, Maybe or maybe not there was an ice-cream cone incident. How would anyone really know unless they were there.
NOW...if the guy dreamed this up (unintentionally) and believed it was true..and if that moment of creative storytelling somehow helped him, well cool!
But, what if making up stuff and believing it is actually harming him because it feeds some element of mental illness or cult overwhelm?
When I have spoken to Scientologists, ex-Scientologists they can get offended that I am "invalidating" their whatever. I don't see it that way. I don't have any emotional investment or stake in what is or isn't true, I am just blithely commenting that I DO NOT KNOW.
Taken out of the milieu and put into another context, let's say that I took one of my motorcycles back to the custom shop that worked on it because it developed a funky rattle when i stopped or started. So I left it for a week and they callled to say it was fixed. I ubered in and drove home. but it was still making the same sound. So, I I took it back and left it again.
Next time they called, they said they found the reason it was rattling and replace a part in the front fork with a new silicone one and that was the problem.
So, another couple weeks had passed but i was happy and ubered back. Then I took the bike and paid for the work...but I told the owner: "Hey I believe you but I want to take it for a test drive around the block" . No problem.
Noise was still happening when I stopped the bike, handlebar/fork assembly was vibrating or something. Left the bike again.
It got fixed the next time.
So was I cynical to doubt it was fixed the 2nd, 3rd and 4th time? Or was I a realist?
Same way I approach anything remotely connected to Scientology.