Tony Ortega's site is too political, reducing its effectiveness

I
I don't doubt the sincerity of your proposal and I know that it was offered in good faith. Unfortunately, it won't work for at least two reasons.

First, any Scientologists (almost certainly Indie Scientologists these days) can't and won't be limited to any designated "safe" threads. They are going to respond to other threads and create their own threads.

Second, I think we both known that any Scientologists (again, almost certainly Indie Scientologists these days) who post here will likely start with a superior, condescending, "know best" attitude of Total Certainty. (In this context, at least, I believe it is useful to think of that attitude as a symptom roughly akin to a psychiatric patient who is suffering from delusions of grandeur.) The quite understandable and *almost* inevitable response is to blast them with an avalanche of truth and perhaps mock them in responses that are perfectly, albeit certainly inadvertently, crafted such that they will not be received, much less be persuasive to the (Indie) Scientologist.

Again, such response would be quite understandable. People who post with a superior, condescending, "know best" attitude of Total Certainty really can't expect anything different. To post a response that is best calculated to be received, and eventually be persuasive, would require great self-restraint, thought and hard work.

/

You can be pretty darn insightful sometimes.
Good post. Nailed it.
 
I don't doubt the sincerity of your proposal and I know that it was offered in good faith. Unfortunately, it won't work for at least two reasons.

First, any Scientologists (almost certainly Indie Scientologists these days) can't and won't be limited to any designated "safe" threads. They are going to respond to other threads and create their own threads.

Second, I think we both known that any Scientologists (again, almost certainly Indie Scientologists these days) who post here will likely start with a superior, condescending, "know best" attitude of Total Certainty. (In this context, at least, I believe it is useful to think of that attitude as a symptom roughly akin to a psychiatric patient who is suffering from delusions of grandeur.) The quite understandable and *almost* inevitable response is to blast them with an avalanche of truth and perhaps mock them in responses that are perfectly, albeit certainly inadvertently, crafted such that they will not be received, much less be persuasive to the (Indie) Scientologist.

Again, such response would be quite understandable. People who post with a superior, condescending, "know best" attitude of Total Certainty really can't expect anything different. To post a response that is best calculated to be received, and eventually be persuasive, would require great self-restraint, thought and hard work.

/

But why do you even want to persuade Indies from scientology? They are never going to be anything but fringe cult dwellers, if they were not into scientology it would just be something else that is equally silly ... hubbard got lucky for various reasons when he was busily creating his cult following but in this century I suspect he would be under the watchful eye of a psychiatrist (at best) due to his known mental issues.

My objection has only ever been based on them coming here and trying to 'handle' us or even worse ... trying to promote their brand of madness to people ridding themselves of it who are still vulnerable (that, admittedly makes my hair stand on end) ... the rest of it is none of my business.

The cofs is a very different thing.
 
I don't doubt the sincerity of your proposal and I know that it was offered in good faith. Unfortunately, it won't work for at least two reasons.

First, any Scientologists (almost certainly Indie Scientologists these days) can't and won't be limited to any designated "safe" threads. They are going to respond to other threads and create their own threads.

Second, I think we both known that any Scientologists (again, almost certainly Indie Scientologists these days) who post here will likely start with a superior, condescending, "know best" attitude of Total Certainty. (In this context, at least, I believe it is useful to think of that attitude as a symptom roughly akin to a psychiatric patient who is suffering from delusions of grandeur.) The quite understandable and *almost* inevitable response is to blast them with an avalanche of truth and perhaps mock them in responses that are perfectly, albeit certainly inadvertently, crafted such that they will not be received, much less be persuasive to the (Indie) Scientologist.

Again, such response would be quite understandable. People who post with a superior, condescending, "know best" attitude of Total Certainty really can't expect anything different. To post a response that is best calculated to be received, and eventually be persuasive, would require great self-restraint, thought and hard work.

/

I suspect that most Scientologists who have come here and to ESMB with a genuine intent to learn something came as lurkers, and only rarely do they post. I recall a couple of people who acknowledge that they did just that when they were CoS Scientologists still in.

For Scientologists to show up here and post on what is labeled an "Ex Scientologist Message Board" more often than not it seems that it is for purposes other than to learn something. Sometimes it is to handle us or to troll the board, and when they are here for that purpose it would be exceedingly difficult to persuade them about anything.

I try to give newbies the benefit of the doubt when they arrive, but if it becomes obvious that they're here just to promote how wonderful the tech is or to troll the board that whole self-restraint thing gets pretty difficult. :coolwink:
 
But why do you even want to persuade Indies from scientology? They are never going to be anything but fringe cult dwellers, if they were not into scientology it would just be something else that is equally silly ...

We got out of a cult and are no longer fringe cult dwellers. :no:

It seems that many who left the CoS temporarily stopped in with the Indies but eventually left for good. Once they leave the CoS and have more freedom of speech and freedom of thought they can explore the true information all over the internet about Hubbard and Scientology, and many of them will completely leave the subject in time.
 
We got out of a cult and are no longer fringe cult dwellers. :no:

It seems that many who left the CoS temporarily stopped in with the Indies but eventually left for good. Once they leave the CoS and have more freedom of speech and freedom of thought they can explore the true information all over the internet about Hubbard and Scientology, and many of them will completely leave the subject in time.

I know I got out of a cult ... and I don't think of the cofs as a fringe cult, I see it as a 'proper' cult and I would love to see it shut down ... I don't have any issue with people leaving the cofs and joining the indies if that is what they want to do, it is none of my business at all. I'm not here to try and control other peoples lives ... I do get a bit crabby when I see others (ie indies) trying to control people around here by attempting to recruit and/or confuse.

:confused:
 
I know I got out of a cult ... and I don't think of the cofs as a fringe cult, I see it as a 'proper' cult and I would love to see it shut down ... I don't have any issue with people leaving the cofs and joining the indies if that is what they want to do, it is none of my business at all. I'm not here to try and control other peoples lives ... I do get a bit crabby when I see others (ie indies) trying to control people around here by attempting to recruit and/or confuse.

:confused:


My only point, maybe one I didn't express well, was that those who are Indie's sometimes are just Ex-churchies who are using Indy Scientology as a stepping stone and many of them eventually leave completely.

I also don't care what they do either, as long as they're not hurting others. But when some continue the fraudulent marketing and false claims as made by CoS then I do have an issue with it, especially when it is done on an Ex Scientologist Message Board.
 
I think Tony is trying to expand his visitor base. Let's face it, scn is not a topic that interests very many people.

Half his content is now on poking fun at the absurdities of QAnon. Click-bait stuff. He has nothing cogent to say other than to repost the inanities of a small fringe. I don't think it is useful and consider it pandering.
Yeah, I pretty much quit reading Tony's blog. Having run my own blog for a while, I know how very tough it is to have something new -- I can't imagine how tough it is to try to do that every single day.

In my opinion, doing it every day means Tony has to make up stuff, blow things out of proportion and so on. I understand how that works, but it really isn't very useful to me. If someone references something good on Tony's blog, I'll go look... but read "comments"? Forget it.
 
William Burroughs is a pretty well publicized example of the different states of mind.

First he was curious about Scientology and suspicious of it.

Then he became involved and, while involved, was treated as an eccentric celebrity, and accepted, but, while in Scientology, he was a little bit of a rebel.

While still a member but, away from Scientology, and encountering people who criticized Scientology, he would defend Scientology, and it's embarrassing to read some of these defenses.

Several years passed.

Becoming more deeply involved, he went to Saint Hill and the Advanced Org, and finally resigned his membership in the "so called Church of Scientology," as he called it in a 1970 article. He still thought parts of the subject had something to offer, but disagreed with the organization and the group-think of Scientology.

While the Organization of Scientology eventually becomes intolerable to most, some saw the subject of Scientology as thousands of little pieces, which can be disassembled, rearranged, or discarded.

Others see the subject as a giant poisonous blob that must be discarded in its entirety.

As for Scientologirl, she encountered Scientology Inc. and rejected it, and became involved in the Advanced Organization of the Great Planes, with the Director becoming her fiance. He offered her the "Bridge" at no cost.

How many of us have been in love? How tolerant shall one be?



Edit: typo
 
Last edited:
As for Scientologirl, she encountered Scientology Inc. and rejected it, and became involved in the Advanced Organization of the Great Planes, with the Director becoming her fiance. He offered her the "Bridge" at no cost.

How many of us have been in love? How tolerant shall one be?
I don't have a problem with people who think they can pick out the parts of Scientology that "work". Good luck to them. Some seems to have some (unproven, unverified) usefulness. Go for it.

But, as I've said before about "Indies", if they still promise "Release", "Clear", "OT", "homo novis", "curing", and all that crap from Hubbard, then they are committing the same damn crimes as the Church of Scientology.

Promise "You might feel better"? OK. Promise "You might gain new insights"? Yeah, OK. Promise "The Bridge to Total Freedom"? Anyone doing that should be thrown in jail for fraud.
 
Please elaborate.

I knew him well back in the day.

He was the ideal cult personality. A true believer and adherent to Scientology. Beyond that, there was no getting to know the man as himself. Not then.

Apparently not now, either. He’s still a huge believer.

IMO, Scientologirl would be in love with the idea of being with someone who could give her back the confidence that Scientology was still okay. Enter TM.

I’m holding my tongue a bit. He’s not a bad or mean guy, that’s not it. He’s just an extreme believer. I guess that’s attractive to someone who was doubtful.
 
I don't have a problem with people who think they can pick out the parts of Scientology that "work". Good luck to them. Some seems to have some (unproven, unverified) usefulness. Go for it.

But, as I've said before about "Indies", if they still promise "Release", "Clear", "OT", "homo novis", "curing", and all that crap from Hubbard, then they are committing the same damn crimes as the Church of Scientology.

Promise "You might feel better"? OK. Promise "You might gain new insights"? Yeah, OK. Promise "The Bridge to Total Freedom"? Anyone doing that should be thrown in jail for fraud.

I say let the true believers and even the con men come here and comminicate. We know more than they do. We can deal with it.
 
Last edited:
I knew him well back in the day.

He was the ideal cult personality. A true believer and adherent to Scientology. Beyond that, there was no getting to know the man as himself. Not then.

Apparently not now, either. He’s still a huge believer.

IMO, Scientologirl would be in love with the idea of being with someone who could give her back the confidence that Scientology was still okay. Enter TM.

I’m holding my tongue a bit. He’s not a bad or mean guy, that’s not it. He’s just an extreme believer. I guess that’s attractive to someone who was doubtful.

?

Jonathan Burke is the ED of the AO of the Great Plains, and the fiance.

In any event, it's likely a phase. I recommend tolerance.
 
?

Jonathan Burke is the ED of the AO of the Great Plains, and the fiance.

In any event, it's likely a phase. I recommend tolerance.
Ah, okay. I must have mixed him up with that other FZ group of Tom M’s. He married a former Messenger. What was the name of his group?
 
Milestone 2?

:LOL: Good one! Or that could have been the name. Gosh, that’s so lame but so FZ I can’t even tell if you’re joking.
Yeh, it was like that! He was hardcore. Sea Org Flag Orders and everything. He had like three different names for his group and kept moving around. Haven’t heard anything about it in about ten years though.
 
But, as I've said before about "Indies", if they still promise "Release", "Clear", "OT", "homo novis", "curing", and all that crap from Hubbard, then they are committing the same damn crimes as the Church of Scientology.

Well, it IS true they are releasing you...,
from your MEST currency.
 
I don't have a problem with people who think they can pick out the parts of Scientology that "work". Good luck to them. Some seems to have some (unproven, unverified) usefulness. Go for it.

But, as I've said before about "Indies", if they still promise "Release", "Clear", "OT", "homo novis", "curing", and all that crap from Hubbard, then they are committing the same damn crimes as the Church of Scientology.

Promise "You might feel better"? OK. Promise "You might gain new insights"? Yeah, OK. Promise "The Bridge to Total Freedom"? Anyone doing that should be thrown in jail for fraud.


Good points!

I remember when former "King of the Indies" Marty Rathbun made an ever-so-brief appearance on ESMB to promote his auditing services and OT levels. He didn't like the reaction he got and split moments later. I guess he was expecting the same glowing reception and standing ovations he used to receive when he was in RTC and wearing a fancy military uniform.

Whenever I have seen people trying to use ESMB to recruit paying preclears/students, it doesn't end well. Because their activities, by the very nature of their representations and promised "abilities" and "powers" are nothing less than a complete fraud.

And they do not want to hear any facts. They're not in the fact business. They're in the business of R-Factoring others and Handling others and trying to jam Hubbard's version of reality into people so that they will (minimally) agree or ideally buy the fraudulent magical course or miraculous auditing.

Have I mentioned recently that Scientology is a fraud? LOL


.
 
Good points!

I remember when former "King of the Indies" Marty Rathbun made an ever-so-brief appearance on ESMB to promote his auditing services and OT levels. He didn't like the reaction he got and split moments later. I guess he was expecting the same glowing reception and standing ovations he used to receive when he was in RTC and wearing a fancy military uniform.

Yes, that was years ago. That was when Marty Rathbun and Mike Rinder were like peas in a pod.

Starting with the time when they were subordinates of Miscavige.

Bio2.png


Then they left Scientology Inc. and criticized Miscavge, while promoting Independent Scientology, and working diligently to discourage the besmirching of L. Ron Hubbard.


This was around 2011

Link to 2014: Marty spots one of Hubbard's main M.O.s before being crushed by Scientology Inc.


Link to Mike Rinder from 2012, and then, after changing, from 2014


​
They were both changing.

People sometimes change.

June 1982, at 9:50, Robert Vaughn Young,
then official Hubbard biographer, and Scientology Inc./OSA spokesman.



At 2:09, Robert Vaughn Young, interviewed during 1997

​
Whenever I have seen people trying to use ESMB to recruit paying preclears/students, it doesn't end well. Because their activities, by the very nature of their representations and promised "abilities" and "powers" are nothing less than a complete fraud.

And they do not want to hear any facts. They're not in the fact business.

People sometimes change.

They're in the business of R-Factoring others and Handling others and trying to jam Hubbard's version of reality into people so that they will (minimally) agree or ideally buy the fraudulent magical course or miraculous auditing.

Have I mentioned recently that Scientology is a fraud? LOL
 
Back
Top