Tony Ortega's site is too political, reducing its effectiveness

Veda

Well-known member
Rule number 2 from Leah Remini's Facebook group: "No Politics. This is not the forum to debate Trump, Hillary Clinton, Politics. This only leads to heated arguments and warfare. There are other groups to go to for political debate."





​
 
I don't read his political stuff anyway. I think he has them compartmentalized better than Chris Shelton (Who, for the record, I really like, even though I don't agree with his political views).
It is harder with podcasts.
 
Last edited:
I think Tony is trying to expand his visitor base. Let's face it, scn is not a topic that interests very many people.

Half his content is now on poking fun at the absurdities of QAnon. Click-bait stuff. He has nothing cogent to say other than to repost the inanities of a small fringe. I don't think it is useful and consider it pandering.
 
Let's face it, scn is not a topic that interests very many people.
I think people's attention has shifted to real survival issues -- all the stuff we talk
about on the off-topic threads. Real life and death, financial and career worries,
the cold civil war in America, a 1917-style revolution and drift to socialism, this
pandemic, vaccine deaths, another pandemic, etc.

The Hubbard fantasy drops to about 30th on the list of attention grabbers. He was
totally revealed and laid out about ten years ago.
 
Last edited:
I think people's attention has shifted to real survival issues -- all the stuff we talk
about on the off-topic threads. Real life and death, financial and career worries,
the cold civil war in America, a 1917-style revolution and drift to socialism, this
pandemic, vaccine deaths, another pandemic, etc.

The Hubbard fantasy drops to about 30th on the list of attention grabbers. He was
totally revealed and laid out about ten years ago.

I agree. But Tony shows his National Enquirer tabloid tastes when he chooses to devote half his blog to tabloidian junk. There is not a shred of journalism in what he is doing. It's on the Harold level.
 
I think Tony is trying to expand his visitor base. Let's face it, scn is not a topic that interests very many people.

Half his content is now on poking fun at the absurdities of QAnon. Click-bait stuff. He has nothing cogent to say other than to repost the inanities of a small fringe. I don't think it is useful and consider it pandering.
Tony has managed to gather a group of far left extremists, about a third of which are internationals obsessed with far right conspiracy theories. It wasn’t so bad when he wrote about animals and pollution. This stuff is ridiculous.
 
I think people's attention has shifted to real survival issues -- all the stuff we talk
about on the off-topic threads. Real life and death, financial and career worries,
the cold civil war in America, a 1917-style revolution and drift to socialism, this
pandemic, vaccine deaths, another pandemic, etc.

"Build Back Better" is the slogan of the Neo Feudalists. Last time I looked, The Underground Bunker is onboard with their program. The two politicians seen below are just puppets.

5ecf8398d78e4d109b7cb0e8d814da6b.jpg



This transcends politics.

Big corporations have been bowing deep at the waist to be on good terms with the new Boss.
The government of totalitarian China wants the USA weakened so that it can ascend to world hegemony without the need of a hot war.
TELEMMGLPICT000249456204_trans_NvBQzQNjv4BqfmWw8ZtkYoKgUQYLfpqhYmUSkFEhWYX_IRyyo-k5toA.jpeg




A bunch of James Bond movie villains are making a power play.
Klaus-Schwab.png


This would be a bad movie script if it wasn't really happening.​


The Hubbard fantasy drops to about 30th on the list of attention grabbers. He was
totally revealed and laid out about ten years ago.

The Hubbard fantasy was obvious from the start. It was always only a tiny percentage who couldn't see it.

As far as being totally revealed and laid out, that was done decades ago.

This is supposed to be an ex-Scientology Message Board. There are still many thousands of people who need help on that topic.

Despite the mass lunacy around us, the purpose of this Message Board is still valid, and still needed.
 
I've often wondered about the effectiveness of the anti-scn blogosphere, specifically, the idea of the 'echo chamber effect'. The uninitiated would be reading something about cats or watching cat videos for the most part, those that believe wouldn't read any of it at all, for concern their next session will be wasted pulling w/h's, those on the cusp may briefly tune in, just for bias confirmation, and the screwed, blued and tattooed already know. the echo chamber is filled with preaching to the choir, as in many other segments, 'thou shalt not be infringed' and the like. I do think Remini and clan had it right with the reality tv approach, giving the casual consumer of stories a basic background about something they should be concerned about, should 'free personality tests' come knocking at their door, and she deserves the most credit for effectively reaching the vulnerable or naive. TBH, I've probably watched an hour or two at most of that show... ya know, because I already knew what happens when you weaponize 'followers' with a control weapon: they do enjoy power, having little of their own. As crazy as it all is and turned out to be, you really can't dismiss the finger on the trigger as the source of a good part of the problem. I think that by failing to acknowledge and discuss this aspect of culpability, the logic just gets a bit fuzzy. I'll just see myself to the door.
 
I've often wondered about the effectiveness of the anti-scn blogosphere, specifically, the idea of the 'echo chamber effect'.

The old formula for glue might be applicable.

The usual pattern is, first comes some hope, freedom, wins - the good stuff, which includes good (but naive) people.

That's the solvent.

Then comes the lacquer, and that mixes with the solvent ever so gradually.

As the solvent evaporates, the lacquer hardens.

Thoroughly describing Scientology Inc. requires mentioning that the solvent can, in and of itself, sometimes be good.

This goes against many people's "hard wiring," thus the subject is seldom thoroughly described, which means that vulnerable people are not being adequately warned.

It's one of those things.

The uninitiated would be reading something about cats or watching cat videos for the most part, those that believe wouldn't read any of it at all, for concern their next session will be wasted pulling w/h's, those on the cusp may briefly tune in, just for bias confirmation, and the screwed, blued and tattooed already know. the echo chamber is filled with preaching to the choir, as in many other segments, 'thou shalt not be infringed' and the like. I do think Remini and clan had it right with the reality tv approach, giving the casual consumer of stories a basic background about something they should be concerned about, should 'free personality tests' come knocking at their door, and she deserves the most credit for effectively reaching the vulnerable or naive. TBH, I've probably watched an hour or two at most of that show... ya know, because I already knew what happens when you weaponize 'followers' with a control weapon: they do enjoy power, having little of their own. As crazy as it all is and turned out to be, you really can't dismiss the finger on the trigger as the source of a good part of the problem. I think that by failing to acknowledge and discuss this aspect of culpability, the logic just gets a bit fuzzy. I'll just see myself to the door.



 
Rule number 2 from Leah Remini's Facebook group: "No Politics. This is not the forum to debate Trump, Hillary Clinton, Politics. This only leads to heated arguments and warfare. There are other groups to go to for political debate."





​
Ortega clearly recognizes that he has a problem. The rough history is as follows.

-- Some Trump supporters, Republicans and other right wing people complained about political bias in Ortega's stories, and especially being gang-bang vilified in the comment section. Some quit commenting and reading his blog as a result. I've communicated with some of them and they simply don't feel comfortable there and are tired of being ganged up on. (I quit commenting on Ortega's blog for other reasons.)

-- In response, Ortega posted a comment asking people to not make political comments on the Scientology stories of the day unless the comment was relevant to the those stories or to Scientology generally, and to make their political comments under the daily Q Anon post.

-- As time passed, people stopped complying with Ortega's request and began taking shots at Trump and other Republicans and conservatives again. There was a period of time when Ortega really didn't enforce the rule.

-- After more pushback from Trump supporters Republicans and other right wing people, Ortega restated his "no-politics" request and started to enforce the rule. Ortega had generally been enforcing the rule ever since, though sometimes a snide comment slips through.

*****************

As indicated above, sometimes there is legitimate overlap between Scientology and politics, as when Scientology Patron Meritorious Joy Villa formed a Congressional exploratory committee or later testified before Congress, or when other Scientologists ran for office, or when Scientology billionaires Robert and Patricia Duggan separately made political contributions in the millions. I've posted such stories myself, but have tried to be non-partisan. I've always honestly said that I would post precisely the same stories if Villa was supporting Biden, or if the Duggans had donated to elect Biden. What is important to me, and I believe is important to the subject of Scientology, is Scientology's and Scientologists' involvement in politics generally, and not their particular political positions.

*****************

Finally, your observation that "Ortega's site is too political, reducing its effectiveness" could also be said of this board. ESMBR. I've sometimes had to ask people not to inject partisan politics into my Scientology threads, though thankfully that has been rare and it has been a while since I've had to do that. More generally, this board is pretty much dominated by right-wing Trump supporters who tend to jump on liberals the same way thay Ortega's commentators jump on Trump supporters. The result is that liberal ex-Scientologists and others may be uncomfortable here for the same reasons conservatives may be uncomfortable commenting on Ortega's blog -- i.e., they don't like to eat shit.

But, hey, I understand. It is not like there is anywhere else on the internet where one can discuss partisan politics. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

/
 
Last edited:
Tony has managed to gather a group of far left extremists, about a third of which are internationals obsessed with far right conspiracy theories. It wasn’t so bad when he wrote about animals and pollution. This stuff is ridiculous.
That is not an entirely unfair description.

You guys know me - I'm the last person in the world to accept and believe in BS conspiracy theories. But I think at this point more Qanon bashing is just beating a dead horse. That ship had sailed, sank and fallen apart on the bottom.

More generally, this board is pretty much dominated by right-wing Trump supporters who tend to jump on liberals the same way thay Ortega's commentators jump on Trump supporters.
That I believe is also a fair description. The majority of people here have not even pro-conservative, but rather just pro-Trump pro-populist sympathies.

Which is not an accusation, just an observation. In most parts of the internet I end up being called a conservative, fascist and whatnot. This is one of the very few places where anyone accused me of being too liberal or too woke.
 
Last edited:
Ortega clearly recognizes that he has a problem. The rough history is as follows.

-- Some Trump supporters, Republicans and other right wing people complained about political bias in Ortega's stories, and especially being gang-bang vilified in the comment section. Some quit commenting and reading his blog as a result. I've communicated with some of them and they simply don't feel comfortable there and are tired of being ganged up on. (I quit commenting on Ortega's blog for other reasons.)

-- In response, Ortega posted a comment asking people to not make political comments on the Scientology stories of the day unless the comment was relevant to the those stories or to Scientology generally, and to make their political comments under the daily Q Anon post.

-- As time passed, people stopped complying with Ortega's request and began taking shots at Trump and other Republicans and conservatives again. There was a period of time when Ortega really didn't enforce the rule.

-- After more pushback from Trump supporters Republicans and other right wing people, Ortega restated his "no-politics" request and started to enforce the rule. Ortega had generally been enforcing the rule ever since, though sometimes a snide comment slips through.

*****************

As indicated above, sometimes there is legitimate overlap between Scientology and politics, as when Scientology Patron Meritorious Joy Villa formed a Congressional exploratory committee or later testified before Congress, or when other Scientologists run for office, or when Scientology billionaires Robert and Patricia Duggan separately made political contributions in the millions. I've posted such stories myself, but have tried to be non-partisan. I've always honestly said that I would post precisely the same stories if Villa was supporting Biden, or if the Duggans had donated to elect Biden. What is important to me, and I believe is important to the subject of Scientology, is Scientology's and Scientologists' involvement in politics generally, and not their particular political positions.

*****************

Finally, your observation that "Ortega's site is too political, reducing its effectiveness" could also be said of this board. ESMBR. I've sometimes had to ask people not to inject partisan politics into my Scientology threads, though thankfully that has been rare and it has been awhile since I've had to do that. More generally, this board is pretty much dominated by right-wing Trump supporters who tend to jump on liberals the same way thay Ortega's commentators jump on Trump supporters. The result is that liberal ex-Scientologists and others may be uncomfortable here for the same reasons conservatives may be uncomfortable commenting on Ortega's blog -- i.e.. they don't like to eat shit.

But, hey, I understand. It is not like there is anywhere else on the internet where one can discuss partisan politics. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

/


The "Lowdown" section, prominently at the top of The Underground Bunker, attempts to identify any idea that conflicts with the preferred narrative of what, in the old days, was called the "establishment" - the establishment being a collection of bureaucrats and big corporations, that were opposed by publications such as the Village Voice, which I read for years, along with the East Village Other, Paul Krassner's The Realist, I. F. Stone's weekly, etc.

Now the control-freak busy-body bureaucrats are the good guys, and the invasive nature of the bureaucracy is beyond anything that was imagined years ago - except in works of fiction such as 1984 - and anyone, and everyone, is supposed to be happy with this state of affairs, or be labeled a "right winger" or be identified with "Q" - whatever the hell that is - or have some other label attached.

Not my cup of tea, and it has nothing to do with politics.
 
Finally, your observation that "Ortega's site is too political, reducing its effectiveness" could also be said of this board. ESMBR. I've sometimes had to ask people not to inject partisan politics into my Scientology threads, though thankfully that has been rare and it has been a while since I've had to do that. More generally, this board is pretty much dominated by right-wing Trump supporters who tend to jump on liberals the same way thay Ortega's commentators jump on Trump supporters. The result is that liberal ex-Scientologists and others may be uncomfortable here for the same reasons conservatives may be uncomfortable commenting on Ortega's blog -- i.e., they don't like to eat shit.

But, hey, I understand. It is not like there is anywhere else on the internet where one can discuss partisan politics. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Regardless of whether or not there is any truth to this, we're not journalists here and this isn't a news site, we're a discussion forum, so the purpose of the two sites is completely different.

And while it's true that some discussion forums do ban discussion of politics because it can be divisive, some of the most important things going on in the world these days concern politics in some way. I would respect whatever decision that P&B made as board owner, but I don't believe the banning of political discussions would serve the membership.
 
The "Lowdown" section, prominently at the top of The Underground Bunker, attempts to identify any idea that conflicts with the preferred narrative of what, in the old days, was called the "establishment" - the establishment being a collection of bureaucrats and big corporations,

Well, that one thing has somewhat changed over the years.

As an employee of a "Big corporation", I can tell you that they want as little to do with bureaucrats as humanely possible. Administration, American or otherwise, is seen as a necessary evil at best.
 
Last edited:
Tony has managed to gather a group of far left extremists, about a third of which are internationals obsessed with far right conspiracy theories. It wasn’t so bad when he wrote about animals and pollution. This stuff is ridiculous.

Tony did come from....was it The New York Post? Or Village Voice? Not exactly a paragon outlet of Journalism. He found favor among ex's and has done a great job on the $cn. cult. But otherwise? Don't hate me if I say he's a tabloid journalist.


Just my opinion. That and $5.45 will buy you a Latte.
 
Last edited:
.

It's on the Harold level.

.
.

I never looked at anything on the UNDERGROUND BUNKER other than the Scientology articles, which I find thoroughly illuminating & entertaining.

However, holy hell! As far as Harold's level, it's impossible to imagine anyone on this planet replacing him as the GOAT (Greatest Of All Time)!

Harold's the Michael Jordan of CPT!!!

1625861602013.jpeg​


* CPT: .Cut & Paste Technology. In his spare time Harold is also the Executive Director of the COS (Church of Stickum) as well as the COB of RTC (Religious Technology of Cutting). Although his limited time is at a premium, Harold can be booked as paid guest speaker and world's leading expert on the rapidly expanding industry of CGT (Critical Glue Theory).


.
 
Last edited:
Regardless of whether or not there is any truth to this, we're not journalists here and this isn't a news site, we're a discussion forum, so the purpose of the two sites is completely different.

And while it's true that some discussion forums do ban discussion of politics because it can be divisive, some of the most important things going on in the world these days concern politics in some way. I would respect whatever decision that P&B made as board owner, but I don't believe the banning of political discussions would serve the membership.
At least originally, I honestly didn't think that the propose of Ortega's site and this forum were "completely different." I thought that at the very least they both had a focus on Scientology in common -- e.g., news (provided here by members), history, analysis, etc. Both to help people who were in and to educate and warn the public. To provide resources to educate people about Scientology.

Now, when I click "What's new" and see the "Latest posts," the top tends to be dominated by posts about everything except Scientology.

I'm not complaining. Nor would I ever suggest that political posts be banned. People are entitled to post about what actually interests them. It is what it is.

I would never suggest censorship, though I have sometimes wished -- both on this board and on Ortega's comment section (when I posted there) -- that people would consider exercising some self-restraint and have some concern about driving people away. Alas, those are not the times that we are living in. Being snarky, being hurtful, mocking people -- driving them away -- is often the point.

/
 
Last edited:
At least originally, I honestly didn't think that the propose of Ortega's site and this forum were "completely different." I thought that at the very least they both had a focus on Scientology in common -- e.g., news (provided here by members), history, analysis, etc. Both to help people who were in and to educate and warn the public. To provide resources to educate people about Scientology.

Now, when I click "What's new" and see the "Latest posts," the top tends to be dominated by posts about everything except Scientology.

I'm not complaining. Nor would I ever suggest that political posts be banned. People are entitled to post about what actually interests them. It is what it is.

I would never suggest censorship, though I have sometimes wished -- both on this board and on Ortega's comment section (when I posted there) -- that people would consider exercising some self-restraint and have some concern about driving people away. Alas, those are not the times that we are living in. Being snarky, being hurtful, mocking people -- driving them away -- is often the point.

Originally, probably both sites were closer in purpose. But most news these days comes from not just the Bunker but many sites and video blogs that didn't exist years ago.

I've noticed that when there IS news such as a new book coming out or another whistleblower coming forward it doesn't seem to have as big of response here on the forum as it would have when I first joined originally. Those types of things were relatively infrequent back then but these days it seems that there's a new book coming out at least once a month critical of Scientology as well as new whistleblowers, etc. And so much of the history of Scientology has already been published. The organization and Hubbard have been completely exposed for what and who they are.

As far as educating people who are still in and warning the public, there is a wealth of resources for them these days with all the books, documentaries, blogs, video blogs, thousands of EX'es on Facebook and other social media, etc. And for those in need of assistance leaving Scientology there is the Aftermath Foundation.

I'm not suggesting that we shouldn't or can't be of help to the people leaving Scientology or to the general public. I think we can and we should whenever we're able to.
 
Last edited:
.
--snipped--
I would never suggest censorship, though I have sometimes wished -- both on this board and on Ortega's comment section (when I posted there) -- that people would consider exercising some self-restraint and have some concern about driving people away. Alas, those are not the times that we are living in. Being snarky, being hurtful, mocking people -- driving them away -- is often the point.
/
.
It's an interesting subject, this concept of "driving people away". I have some familiarity with that notion, having been accused of that on more than one occasion (LOL).

I guess all of life to a greater or lesser extent has that liability. For example--

- - Does CNN "drive away" from their viewership those who do not agree that Trump is literally worse than Hitler?​
​
- - Does Fox News "drive away" from their viewership all the devotees of Michael Avenatti who (at one time before he was sent to prison) avidly supported his campaign to run for President in the 2020 election?​
​
- - In the 2016 presidential election did Trump's rhetorical shenanigans and unfiltered opinions "drive away" all of Hillary's voters. Was that a bad thing?​
​
- - In the SuperBowl, doesn't the (highly supportive) local tv sports show of one city "drive away" all the viewership and high ratings they could have gained by tv viewers from the other team's city?​
​
- - What about individuals who come to a discussion forum to promote L. Ron Hubbard's ridiculous "magical miraculous powers" hoax?​
​
Wouldn't the seemingly appropriate ​
response to the ridiculous be--​
(by definition)​
ridicule?​
LOL​


I guess it all comes down to individual's personal OPINIONS of how much disagreement or how much satire or how much parody is too much.

And, more importantly, it comes down to individual's personal OPINIONS of whether others should or should not say/post what they are actually thinking and want to say. I personally don't see any harm in speaking candidly when all the participants in the conversation are adults.


.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top