The Insider speaks: Scientology’s recent crises, now in a podcast with Chris Shelton

So right there you have 23 people.

With fewer staff likely the Tech div dept heads would be missing with the Tech Sec holding all from above
The HES might hold HAS from above although there is usually a lot of pressure to have a HAS posted. That person might hold E/O from above.
The Public Div secs may be held from above by the PES

from what i've seen, a lot of the medium to smaller orgs have about a dozen staff at best. which is still a pretty high ratio, when they're serving 3 or 4 dozen active public. Catherine Olsen said Columbus had only 9 or 10 to start; and Plymouth has been reported as having only 5 or 6 full time, which i suspect is typical of some of the smallest orgs in the US as well.

i wish we could get photos of a couple of org boards to see just what the staffing levels are, and how they're handling lack of enough people to fill all the positions.
 
Here's a very basic set of staff posts that usually are filled:

ED
D/ED
FBO
LRH Comm
HES
OES
PES
HCO Area Sec (HAS)
Ethics Officer
Reg
Bookstore Officer (maybe)
Treasury Sec
Tech Sec
Dir of Tech Services
Dir of Processing
Dir of Training
Course Supe
Auditor(s)
C/S
Qual Sec
Public Contact Sec
Public Services Sec
Basic Course Supe

So right there you have 23 people.

With fewer staff likely the Tech div dept heads would be missing with the Tech Sec holding all from above
The HES might hold HAS from above although there is usually a lot of pressure to have a HAS posted. That person might hold E/O from above.
The Public Div secs may be held from above by the PES

There are a lot of other posts available if there are more staff available. An org will usually have a DSA (OSA type) as well.

Good list, I'll add a few more common posts.

Cope Off
Dir I&R (ethics officer is probably posted as this, if it isn't all being handled by the cope off)
PPO
Dissem Sec (reg is probably posted as this)
CF Officer (not sure that's the title, someone in CF handling things)
Purif I/C (if the tech sec/OES isn't a supe, one of them is probably doing this)
SSO
MLO (probably being held by the SSO)
Snr C/S (in most orgs I would expect them to have one C/S, and they would likely be posted as the Snr C/S)
Dir Corr
Cramm Off
Body router (whatever that department head is called, really they are just a body router)
FCS

In my opinion an example of what a 30 person org board would look like, would be something like this

ED
D/ED
HES
OES
PES
DSA
LC
HAS
Cope Off (handles E/O functions)
PPO
Dissem Sec
Reg
BSO
Treas Sec
Tech Sec
DofP (Purif I/C)
Auditor (2x)
DofT (really a supe)
Supe
Course Admin
Qual Sec
Snr C/S
SSO
PCS
PSS (div 6 supe)

And then they have three SO members, FBO, D/FBO & FR. That gets us to 30ish. I think this would be a typical example of a 30 person org.

Now what gets really crazy is out of those 30 how many actually service public? The only ones that directly service public are the DofP (Purif I/C), DofT (supe), Supe, two auditors, and PCS, so 6 out of 30. Then you have three that do various sales (Dissem Sec, Reg, BSO), arguably you could say the PCS also does this and some other execs may also be active in the area. At best you have 10ish people actually selling and delivering to public. If you take a slightly wider view you can say the Cope Off (as E/O), Course Admin and Snr C/S are also related to delivery, even if they don't always directly do it. Qual Sec can also be included (exams, cramming, etc.) Out of 30 staff we're left with about 15 who work with public and sell/deliver to them. What do the other 15 staff do? Well, that's the magic of hubbard management tech. I could tell you but I don't understand it myself, I haven't done these new OEC vols.

from what i've seen, a lot of the medium to smaller orgs have about a dozen staff at best. which is still a pretty high ratio, when they're serving 3 or 4 dozen active public. Catherine Olsen said Columbus had only 9 or 10 to start; and Plymouth has been reported as having only 5 or 6 full time, which i suspect is typical of some of the smallest orgs in the US as well.

i wish we could get photos of a couple of org boards to see just what the staffing levels are, and how they're handling lack of enough people to fill all the positions.

It's pretty simple, when positions aren't filled it rolls up to the next highest person on the org board. An org with 6 staff might look something like this.

ED
HES (handles regging/sales)
OES (C/S and also Supe trained)
PES (mainly works on PCS stuff)
HAS (recruitment/ethics)
Tech Sec (audits)

This way they still do most of the main org functions and can pretend like they produce something. This would also be a pretty sane way to have the org board posted. In reality they'll have had some project come down from Int to get an Ext Crs I/C on post or something, they'll have two people randomly posted like this.

I'm sure we'll eventually get data about staffing levels. From what I'm seeing though they are resorting to SO more and more. This makes sense based on the numbers that I do know about staffing levels. Staff numbers are getting low, but maybe not as low as you might think. Columbus and Plymouth have always been tiny tiny orgs. The bigger orgs are the ones that went Ideal a long long time ago. I'd love to know what OCs staff is like, or some place like NY/Cincinnati.
 
Dir I&R (ethics officer is probably posted as this, if it isn't all being handled by the cope off)
Exactly. That was also my post when I was the EO.


It's pretty simple, when positions aren't filled it rolls up to the next highest person on the org board. An org with 6 staff might look something like this.

ED
HES (handles regging/sales)
OES (C/S and also Supe trained)
PES (mainly works on PCS stuff)
HAS (recruitment/ethics)
Tech Sec (audits)
With just 6 people, the ED would almost certainly also act as a reg and dissem.

From what I'm seeing though they are resorting to SO more and more.
The SO appears to be aging as a group and they've already been overworked back in my day. So plugging the gap with old-timer SO members does not appear to be a viable long term strategy. If you plan to put octogenarians onto 4-sleep-hours-per-day schedules, things won't get done.

I also imagine you won't get many Russian or Ukrainian SO members due to the current situation. The same might be with Venezuelans and Colombians. These countries provided much needed recruits in their 20s.


If scientology was a normal business, the obvious solution to the workload issue would be to outsource most of the more simple jobs that do not require scientology training. IE: Hire an external company to do all maintenance, provide cleaning ladies etc. But I don't think scn will do that, not under Davey.
 
Last edited:
I'm not done listening to it yet, I agree with everything he's saying but I want to make a few notes.

In my observation he's correct that there are essentially three areas where Scientologists have been donating money. IAS, buildings, and services. Increasingly services has been a smaller and smaller amount, with more going to the IAS and buildings. But from what I recall the chase wave stuff was mainly for service donations.

He mentions the chase wave starting around 2013-2014 when LA switched to SO. I do think this is when it began being exported all over the world and spread to every org. But in my opinion a lot of the techniques came from Ideal Org regging. It may have been refined and performed with more finesse once LA org started doing it on a widespread basis, but Ideal org regging was using all the shady techniques way before LA opened. So I don't think it spread from LA org to Ideal org regging, it was the other way around if anything. But maybe once LA org had perfected the technique it then bounced back to the Ideal org regges.

The logic behind LA being turned into an SO org, what I remember hearing was that it was supposed to be the model Ideal Org internationally. Each cont. was kind of supposed to have a "continental" ideal org that served as a model for the continent. NY for EUS, LA for WUS, Denmark for EU, etc. This wasn't really super successful, so they turned LA into the model Ideal org, on this planet. Like he said, it was absolutely used to justify everything. Look how well LA is doing, obviously the Ideal org program works and so does everything else. They do so well because they properly use CF, all you need to do is write enough letters to CF and you too can make 500K a week. This is an acceptable truth, especially because it mirrors what LRH says.

As far as Scientology going off a cliff, the more I think about it I think Scientology went off the cliff some time ago. Maybe as far back as the mission massacre. As soon as Scientology stopped getting in new members it started dying. I do think its death has sped up in recent years, and as the hardcore members get older and contribute less, it will only die faster. I am not that optimistic about being able to speed up its death or cause a bunch of people to walk out. I think the people who are left are the hardcore ones and they won't be affected by even a small group renouncing Scientology. But as Scientology relies more and more on the 2nd gen people they will have a rough time, the 2nd gen people just aren't as dedicated and willing to throw their life away.

There was podcast posted on reddit, I'll try to link it sometime. Nothing revelatory in it, but I think it was a good example of what I'm talking about when I say the 2nd gen people are just not as into it. He had grown up in Scientology, did childrens courses, had done some auditing, etc. Then he gets on LA orgs radar and they get him there and crush sell him to take out a 10K loan for services. This basically freaks him out and then he's gone, if I'm remembering things correctly. I think this is a good case study for many 2nd gens, they have done some Scientology and consider themselves Scientologists, then they do a stint in the SO or on staff, or get regged and see what Scientology is really about. After that they decide they don't want to have anything more to do with it and they're out, maybe not publicly but you won't see them on services or even at events.

I also think its interesting how many people we have coming out recently. Katherine Olson, this insider, whoever leaked the audio from the event, the NY leak, etc. Maybe some of this is the same person, but it seems like we at least have a few recently leaking info.
I think the problem is a bit different. Hubbard relied on gullible people to be public and staff. In his books there are things like him breaking a bronco as a child, which anybody with a brain would recognize as BS and stay away.

Deliberate filters to keep the questioners away.

However the idealistic personality he was after would buy into all that he was saying - pretty much without examining it. They would carry the org and thus scientology forward as they reached for achieving the espoused goals of OT etc.

However, that doesn't mean their children were also gullible.

Though raised on a diet of the scientology principles espoused by their parents, they would veer away naturally as teens, as that's programmed into them by nature. It's nature taking them out of the nest and into the diversity of life. There's an article in National Geographic that goes into that aspect of them.

Beautiful Brains
Moody. Impulsive. Maddening. Why do teenagers act the way they do? Viewed through the eyes of evolution, their most
exasperating traits may be the key to success as adults.
By David Dobbs
Although you know your teenager takes some chances, it can be a shock to hear about them.
One fine May morning not long ago my oldest son, 17 at the time, phoned to tell me that he had just spent a couple hours at the state police barracks. Apparently he had been driving "a little fast." What, I asked, was "a little fast"? Turns out this product of my genes and loving care, the boy-man I had swaddled, coddled, cooed at, and then pushed and pulled to the brink of manhood, had been flying down the highway at 113 miles an hour.
"That's more than a little fast," I said.
He agreed. In fact, he sounded somber and contrite. He did not object when I told him he'd have to pay the fines and probably for a lawyer. He did not argue when I pointed out that if anything happens at that speed—a dog in the road, a blown tire, a sneeze—he dies. He was in fact almost irritatingly reasonable. He even proffered that the cop did the right thing in stopping him, for, as he put it, "We can't all go around doing 113."
He did, however, object to one thing. He didn't like it that one of the several citations he received was for reckless driving.
"Well," I huffed, sensing an opportunity to finally yell at him, "what would you call it?"
"It's just not accurate," he said calmly. " 'Reckless' sounds like you're not paying attention. But I was. I made a deliberate point of doing this on an empty stretch of dry interstate, in broad daylight, with good sight lines and no traffic. I mean, I wasn't just gunning the thing. I was driving.
"I guess that's what I want you to know. If it makes you feel any better, I was really focused."
Actually, it did make me feel better.
That bothered me, for I didn't understand why. Now I do

More at link:
 
If scientology was a normal business, the obvious solution to the workload issue would be to outsource most of the more simple jobs that do not require scientology training. IE: Hire an external company to do all maintenance, provide cleaning ladies etc. But I don't think scn will do that, not under Davey.
They won't do that, because a non-Scn company would expect to get paid, and wouldn't show up if the org was behind on payments.

Scn only seems to work when it has plenty of people willing to work for free.

You also have a mix of modernity and 1950's technology.

CF? Actual paper to be filed in folders and filing cabinets? Really? In 2022?

In a computerized approach, actual letters in from the public could be scanned and tagged to the public's name, then (maybe) put into a box and the box# recorded if they ever needed the physical paper. The functions that needed a full time CF and addresso could be done in minutes per day (less given the negligible amount of letters in and new-names).

And if auditing actually WORKED, in the sense of actually (measurably and significantly) increasing ability (and thus making the person able to earn more money), the orgs would be flooded with people.

My criterion for "worked"? the person's abilities become so much higher, that the cost of the auditing is paid with the raise he gets at end of year.
 
I forget the name of the post, but you all are missing it. It's the finance person who reports to folo and has the orgs money by the balls and extracts the so's money from the org, and leaves a pittance for the org to run on.

Mimsey
Flag Banking Officer. The person in charge of sending all money uplines, less the minimal amount needed to keep the doors open.
 
No LRH Comm these days?

LC was on my list. But I wouldn't be surprised to hear that many orgs lack one.

Exactly. That was also my post when I was the EO.



With just 6 people, the ED would almost certainly also act as a reg and dissem.


The SO appears to be aging as a group and they've already been overworked back in my day. So plugging the gap with old-timer SO members does not appear to be a viable long term strategy. If you plan to put octogenarians onto 4-sleep-hours-per-day schedules, things won't get done.

I also imagine you won't get many Russian or Ukrainian SO members due to the current situation. The same might be with Venezuelans and Colombians. These countries provided much needed recruits in their 20s.


If scientology was a normal business, the obvious solution to the workload issue would be to outsource most of the more simple jobs that do not require scientology training. IE: Hire an external company to do all maintenance, provide cleaning ladies etc. But I don't think scn will do that, not under Davey.

Yeah, ED will also do recruitment and anything else needed. With 6 people you'll have a lot of crossover and people holding random functions.

I agree, long-term SO is not a solution. But for the short-term it might keep up appearances a little longer. I'd imagine being posted to a Class V org is in many ways an easier posting. Less insane orders/projects and insane seniors. The distance provides protection and you can just focus on your Class V post, and hopefully stick to the Class V schedule. Whether they post SO to Class V orgs or not, they have a big problem coming up as their core population ages, this includes many SO members. When these guys start to go, or can't hold a post, what are they going to do? They have no way to replace them.

Outsourcing would make a lot of sense. Maintenance/cleaning and treasury are the obvious ones to out-source. Most orgs have someone posted in treasury who has no clue what they're doing. It's not like they have a CPA posted as the treas sec, at least I've never heard of one. Maybe at Flag or something.

I forget the name of the post, but you all are missing it. It's the finance person who reports to folo and has the orgs money by the balls and extracts the so's money from the org, and leaves a pittance for the org to run on.

Mimsey

FBO, it's an SO post and most orgs have one. It was on the list.
 
LC was on my list. But I wouldn't be surprised to hear that many orgs lack one.
It might be superceded by "RTC Rep".

Back in the 80's, orgs had

LRH comm, Flag Banking Officer, Flag Rep (responsible for getting Flag programs done) and an ED, all sticking their fingers into the running of the org.

And now you know why there were so many administrative people running around madly and getting little sleep, while not really accomplishing much.
 
Flag Banking Officer. The person in charge of sending all money uplines, less the minimal amount needed to keep the doors open.
Yeah the good ol' FBOs.


Scientology alphabet soup. Gotta love it.
 
It might be superceded by "RTC Rep".

Back in the 80's, orgs had

LRH comm, Flag Banking Officer, Flag Rep (responsible for getting Flag programs done) and an ED, all sticking their fingers into the running of the org.

And now you know why there were so many administrative people running around madly and getting little sleep, while not really accomplishing much.

Flag reps are back. Most ideal orgs have at least three SO members posted there. FBO, D/FBO and FR. I'm kind of surprised they haven't made the LC an SO post. But from what I recall the FR ends up doing a lot of LC functions, so maybe they feel they don't need a sea org LC as long as they have the SO FR posted.

I'd be shocked if they started posting RTC members to individual orgs. But hey, they've done lots of crazy things.
 
Though raised on a diet of the scientology principles espoused by their parents, they would veer away naturally as teens, as that's programmed into them by nature. It's nature taking them out of the nest and into the diversity of life.

thanks, that's a really good point.

you may have noticed that i often point out how cognitive biases or innate behaviors/responses come in to play with people's involvement in groups like cults. it's clear that scientology has trouble keeping subsequent generations involved, i think most obviously because it is dated and no longer really appeals (the reason they can longer recruit new members), but i hadn't thought of how mechanisms like that would tend to drive young people to reject their parents' belief and affiliation.

on a related note, being a lifelong learner of multiple languages, one of the things i've noticed with interest is that parents who try to bring up children speaking a foreign language at home, have an almost impossible time getting them to keep up with it once they get old enough to go off to day care or school; they'll start responding to their parents in the common language (English, in our case) and will begin to lose their ability to speak the foreign language, even though they continue to be able to understand it. kids are powerfully driven to bond and identify with their peer group, even to the exclusion of family.
 
I'd be shocked if they started posting RTC members to individual orgs. But hey, they've done lots of crazy things.
Do they even have enough RTC reps to have one at each org? I doubt it, unless they suddenly promoted a ton of people to rtc.

on a related note, being a lifelong learner of multiple languages, one of the things i've noticed with interest is that parents who try to bring up children speaking a foreign language at home, have an almost impossible time getting them to keep up with it once they get old enough to go off to day care or school; they'll start responding to their parents in the common language (English, in our case) and will begin to lose their ability to speak the foreign language, even though they continue to be able to understand it. kids are powerfully driven to bond and identify with their peer group, even to the exclusion of family.
If you ever heard one of the interviews with me, you'd know I still speak English with a visible accent. And that's despite the fact taht between the ages of 8 and my mid 20s I spoke pretty much only English.

Well, other than interrogating Russian SO members. :P
 
I think the problem is a bit different. Hubbard relied on gullible people to be public and staff. In his books there are things like him breaking a bronco as a child, which anybody with a brain would recognize as BS and stay away.

Deliberate filters to keep the questioners away.

However the idealistic personality he was after would buy into all that he was saying - pretty much without examining it. They would carry the org and thus scientology forward as they reached for achieving the espoused goals of OT etc.
I didn't believe all the BS, like the bronco-busting at age four or whatever. I knew Hubbard wasn't really a nuclear physicist. I thought All About Radiation was nonsense. (The Purif was still a few years down the road.) There were lots of things I didn't buy into.

But they told us we didn't have to believe anything: "Nothing in scn is true for you except what you yourself have experienced." That's what I applied when I was confronted with things that I considered impossible. I believed that I could take only the parts of scn that I found workable and use those.

Even when I read Keeping Scn Working for the first time, where Hubbard says, "I figured it all out, so it's my way or the highway," I though, "Well, I don't have to believe that."

The stuff I thought was BS I sort of mentally "put on hold." I excused it as PR, "permissible deception." Or I thought maybe I'd see it differently when I got farther up the Bridge. After all, Hubbard said, "Reality is proportional to charge off the case."
 
The stuff I thought was BS I sort of mentally "put on hold."

Yeah, I know exactly what you mean. The ex-mormons call that process "putting stuff on the shelf... until the shelf brakes".

I never believed in postulates. And nobody at inv believed in touch assists. Also, after a few month at the CLO, I became a full-blown atheist when it came to the admin tech,
 
Do they even have enough RTC reps to have one at each org? I doubt it, unless they suddenly promoted a ton of people to rtc.
He wouldn't necessarily need to be RTC qualled to be an RTC rep. Just some warm body which is dedicated to reporting back on what RTC is curious about, and relaying what RTC wants done. He would not be given RTC ethics authority.
 
Do they even have enough RTC reps to have one at each org? I doubt it, unless they suddenly promoted a ton of people to rtc.

They'd have to promote a ton, they don't have close to enough.

I didn't believe all the BS, like the bronco-busting at age four or whatever. I knew Hubbard wasn't really a nuclear physicist. I thought All About Radiation was nonsense. (The Purif was still a few years down the road.) There were lots of things I didn't buy into.

But they told us we didn't have to believe anything: "Nothing in scn is true for you except what you yourself have experienced." That's what I applied when I was confronted with things that I considered impossible. I believed that I could take only the parts of scn that I found workable and use those.

Even when I read Keeping Scn Working for the first time, where Hubbard says, "I figured it all out, so it's my way or the highway," I though, "Well, I don't have to believe that."

The stuff I thought was BS I sort of mentally "put on hold." I excused it as PR, "permissible deception." Or I thought maybe I'd see it differently when I got farther up the Bridge. After all, Hubbard said, "Reality is proportional to charge off the case."

Yes, that's a very good point. I'm sure there are many who believe some/part of it, but not all of it. Or they want to believe it, they want to believe the OT levels will turn them into superman, so they ignore the parts that don't make sense to them.
 
Back
Top