Chuck Beatty x 75-02
2024
Sylvia is a fan of Hubbard but she is not a Rondroid.
This video contains some wisdom, a little foolishness, and much reminiscing.
Excellent history.
Is that Phoebe Maurer with MSH at 14:35?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Sylvia is a fan of Hubbard but she is not a Rondroid.
This video contains some wisdom, a little foolishness, and much reminiscing.
.. Ron spent the rest of his life manically promoting the OT levels—all of which were science fiction, incessantly boasting himself as the writer.
..
Chuck - You continue to make me smile and laugh with your witticisms about various aspects scn, the latest being DMSMH dianetic auditing as fetal trauma talk therapy. laughterExcellent huge chunk of Sea Org history, thanks for doing this.
14:35. Is that Phoebe Maurer and MSH?
So many excellent photos, some of the best I've seen of Otto Roos.
It answers the question who took all these excellent photos, thanks for filling in history.
24:15 Craig Lipshitz, LRH, MSH, Leon Steinberg, Irene Dunlevy.
Amazing to have the woman who took all the historic photos explain this.
26:57 Sylvia took the famous LRH photo. 1:09:40 Tragic that she is a deep state believer, ,,,,(to the contrary, the anti Hubbard critics got it pretty much correct, Dianetics was fetus trauma talk therapy, which didn't go anywhere, only the "locks" and "secondaries" two way comming techniques survived, and then some principles like "basic basic" and earlier similar, for the later Hubbard pseudo-therapy---but the critics nailed Hubbard's Dianetics as pseudo-therapy quackery, and fetal trauma memories being "basic basic" was and always will be quackery, people who praise Dianetics conveniently forget the fetal trauma talk therapy of Dianetics which Hubbard stressed as being the top focus, but it's quackery and fetal trauma is not today focused on at all by Scientology re-use of the Dianetics book when today seminars do Dianetic techniques, they omit focus on digging into fetal trauma as they once did in summer of 1950.)
1:13:22. She explains essentially he lost any outside old friends into his final years. (I wish the interviewer had mentioned Sarge and LRH's admission to Sarge, as Sarge seemed to be as close to a final friend that LRH had, but still Sarge was following LRH's orders and not a contemporary like LRH's earlier contacts.).
1:26:10. ANSWER: Dianetics is essentially fetal trauma talk therapy that didn't go anywhere, it was quackery, and fetal trauma "basic basic" talk therapy isn't done by Scientology today. Scientology past lives therapy, is not universally even accepted as also nothing by quack past lives pseudo-therapy. Next, is the exorcism of OT 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 today considered legit, no, since exorcism isn't taken seriously. So the Dianetics Scientology core practices, fetal trauma therapy, past lives therapy and exorcism of surplus souls that supposedly infest our human bodies, are considered pretty quack. That takes zero "Deep State" conspiracy theorizing to explain to the non deep state humans who do think Dianetics and Scientology were and are quackery. And a con therefore, like snipe hunting, like selling false promising quackery. Placebo theory is something explains why some people will get positive results from even quackery. Hubbard's Keeping Scientology Working core theory blames the followers, blames the staffs, for the quackery failing, and the quackery failing is on Hubbard. No deep state needed to explain that.
2:06:04 Looks like the basketball team, left to right, Andre Tabayoyon(?),knelling guy (?), standing above him Chuck Murray, David Ziff, (?), (?), Wendell Reynolds, (?).
2:06:08 Sylvia, Art Webb
2:06:12 Art Webb above, (?) Nieman (?)....
2:06:16 Quentin 2:06:19 (?), (?)
2:06:54 (?), Baron Berez (?) right
2:07:01 left to right (?), (?), Art Webb, (?). (?), (?)
2:07:06 (?), (?)
2:07:09 (?), Sylvia's sister (?)
2:07:26 Bill Robertson
2:07:27 ", Quentin
2:07:33 2:07:36 Otto Roos (?)
2:07:40 third from left Mary Sue (?)
2:08:08 big afro Rick Sheehy, LRH
The poem at the end has a trace of "we come back" in it, re hearing a future bugle and all.
Very touching video.
^^^^^^
This is why I never discuss the "tech"
There is no tech, there is no spiritual level , there is no knowledge,
Thete is only a whole bunch of fabulated material put together to recycle sci-fi stuff as
a fraudulent mystical content allowing one to acces higher spiritual realms... Using a lie detector and exorcism…..
Spiritual my arse
It's a bad farce that cost the sanity, life, family, and belongings of hundred of thousands of people..
There is no clear
There is no OT
There is no tech..
![]()
lotus said - This is why I never discuss the "tech"^^^^^^
This is why I never discuss the "tech"
There is no tech, there is no spiritual level , there is no knowledge,
Thete is only a whole bunch of fabulated material put together to recycle sci-fi stuff as
a fraudulent mystical content allowing one to acces higher spiritual realms... Using a lie detector and exorcism…..
Spiritual my arse
It's a bad farce that cost the sanity, life, family, and belongings of hundred of thousands of people..
There is no clear
There is no OT
There is no tech..
![]()
As a previous scn auditor fully trained in obnosis (observing the obvious) I am able to obnose my friend's unspoken reaction when I say the word Scientology. He's thinking, "What the hell is he doing still thinking about that stupid nonsense?"lotus said - This is why I never discuss the "tech"
The friend I mentioned above is an atheist scientific realist and has no interest in the paranormal or supernatural. These days I never mention anything from scn because that gives him concern that I'm still "stuck in Scientology."
Did Hubbard ever write up a mysticism to scientific realism scale? Probably not. You wouldn't get very far in scn without at least being agnostic about a few mystical ideas or beliefs at the beginning. There would probably be some "gradations" on that type of scale.
It's only recently I've thought about how boring it must've been to run those prenatals. A fetus has no visio, and if you did have it that meant an exteriorized viewpoint, indicating the incident was dub-in or you were out of valence. (Exteriorization was then considered a bug, not a feature.) Easy to see why people might lose interest after a few dozen hours.Dianetics was fetus trauma talk therapy, which didn't go anywhere, only the "locks" and "secondaries" two way comming techniques survived, and then some principles like "basic basic" and earlier similar, for the later Hubbard pseudo-therapy---but the critics nailed Hubbard's Dianetics as pseudo-therapy quackery, and fetal trauma memories being "basic basic" was and always will be quackery, people who praise Dianetics conveniently forget the fetal trauma talk therapy of Dianetics which Hubbard stressed as being the top focus, but it's quackery and fetal trauma is not today focused on at all by Scientology re-use of the Dianetics book when today seminars do Dianetic techniques, they omit focus on digging into fetal trauma as they once did in summer of 1950.)
Cartoon from 1952.The "clear and above seating" would be vacant because there are none.
![]()

"It's a bad farce that cost the sanity, life, family, and belongings of hundred of thousands of people."
Nah - That's too much of a "broad-brush".
Yes it is. And what's the point of it? To "sing to the choir"? It's possible that someone who saw the video interview of Sylvia will also see this thread? Would this vvvvvvvvvvvv be helpful to them?
Probably not.
probably one should ask how did the boring running of prenatals switch to running whole track of past lives? And how did Hubbard get one to believe in whole track past lives?It's only recently I've thought about how boring it must've been to run those prenatals. A fetus has no visio, and if you did have it that meant an exteriorized viewpoint, indicating the incident was dub-in or you were out of valence. (Exteriorization was then considered a bug, not a feature.) Easy to see why people might lose interest after a few dozen hours.
So in 1952 we switch to HOM sci-fi horror whole track implants. Much more exciting, though probably even less therapeutic.
Note how this switch from running no-visio prenatals to MIP-based implants parallels the shift from radio to TV which was happening around that time.
Didn't listen to the whole thing, just parts, curious to know if she still believes in Clear and/or OT?
Sylvia is a fan of Hubbard but she is not a Rondroid.
This video contains some wisdom, a little foolishness, and much reminiscing.
that's very true, just obnosis, or observing, who is a clear or a ot, one will discover that they are just ordinary people who somehow came to believe that they are clear or ot. But it is not true. Hubbard played many mind tricks thru the spoken word, afterall he was just a writer.As a previous scn auditor fully trained in obnosis (observing the obvious) I am able to obnose my friend's unspoken reaction when I say the word Scientology. He's thinking, "What the hell is he doing still thinking about that stupid nonsense?"
(joke)
I'd say that after two years when dianetics was rejected as science and flopped Hubbard decided to expound on his previously held occult beliefs and go for the religion angle. He made a boatload of money but in fairness he worked his ass off for the rest of his life to get it. He wasn't a lazy con man and as a critic once noted, "At one point Hubbard even had his own goddamn navy!"It's only recently I've thought about how boring it must've been to run those prenatals. A fetus has no visio, and if you did have it that meant an exteriorized viewpoint, indicating the incident was dub-in or you were out of valence. (Exteriorization was then considered a bug, not a feature.) Easy to see why people might lose interest after a few dozen hours.
So in 1952 we switch to HOM sci-fi horror whole track implants. Much more exciting, though probably even less therapeutic.
Note how this switch from running no-visio prenatals to MIP-based implants parallels the shift from radio to TV which was happening around that time.
Donovan had a song called Mellow Yellow which included the words "electrical banana" which started some "serious inquiry" by hippies about whether you could get stoned by smoking banana peels....
Good summary. Here is the micro-melodic version of it.
SING ALONG!
First there is a sci-fi
Then there is no sci-fi
Then there is.
The onion sheds its skin to find a hoax within
Onion sheds its skin to find a hoax within.
..
Donovan had a song called Mellow Yellow which included the words "electrical banana" which started some "serious inquiry" by hippies about whether you could get stoned by smoking banana peels. excerpt from an article:
When the song was released in 1966, everyone was convinced that it referred to a rumor that smoking banana peels would get a person high. (It doesn't work.) Donovan said that was never the case. "I was reading a newspaper and on the back there was an ad for a yellow dildo called the mellow yellow," he said. "Really, you know the 'electric banana' was right in there and gave it away. And that's what the song's about."