Don't want to give you a hard time on this, but...
One can have a negative experience, and certainly can observe others having negative experiences, without being traumatized and driven to a state of permanent irrationality (on the topic), such as would characterize PTSD.
This is too close to Hubbard's instructions in his Manual on Dissemination of Material that people be told that dissenters and critics have something wrong with them.
"Another frame of mind we would like to see the public have and register is that people attacking Scientology have something wrong with them."
And any "slight" is regarded as an "attack."
And, to continue this line of thought...
If those who are disapproving of Scientology are "keyed in," "ARC broken," have "missed withholds." etc., then how would an enthusiastic proponent of Scientology/Hubbard be characterized?
Take this recent example from the Director of the Dror Center, an Independent Scientology center in Israel.
Out of Scientology Inc. for eight years, and having audited on solo NOTs for fourteen years, this is where he is.
Referring to the Organization and why Hubbard has a bad reputation:
"They managed to give Ron Hubbard a bad name, so Ron Hubbard who you and I admire, and hold him as the greatest genius who ever lived, a great man, the greatest man who ever lived, and created, and gave so much to us and all Mankind; his name has become a bad name. He's been vilified by the Church of Scientology, because of the terrible things that they do and they attribute to Ron Hubbard, like Declaring people Suppressive, Disconnection policy, and more..."
This is an example of a typical view held by many Independent Scientologists.
How would this person be diagnosed?
Is he lying? Perhaps he doesn't actually believe what he's saying, and thinks that not praising Hubbard would be bad for business?
Or does he actually believe this?
If he actually believes this, is there something wrong with him?
Terms such as (personality) cultism, brainwashing, psychological conditioning, etc. come to mind.
Is that unfair?
Don't want to give you a hard time on this, but...
One can have a negative experience, and certainly can observe others having negative experiences, without being traumatized and driven to a state of permanent irrationality (on the topic), such as would characterize PTSD.
This is too close to Hubbard's instructions in his Manual on Dissemination of Material that people be told that dissenters and critics have something wrong with them.
"Another frame of mind we would like to see the public have and register is that people attacking Scientology have something wrong with them."
And any "slight" is regarded as an "attack."
And, to continue this line of thought...
If those who are disapproving of Scientology are "keyed in," "ARC broken," have "missed withholds." etc., then how would an enthusiastic proponent of Scientology/Hubbard be characterized?
Take this recent example from the Director of the Dror Center, an Independent Scientology center in Israel.
Out of Scientology Inc. for eight years, and having audited on solo NOTs for fourteen years, this is where he is.
Referring to the Organization and why Hubbard has a bad reputation:
"They managed to give Ron Hubbard a bad name, so Ron Hubbard who you and I admire, and hold him as the greatest genius who ever lived, a great man, the greatest man who ever lived, and created, and gave so much to us and all Mankind; his name has become a bad name. He's been vilified by the Church of Scientology, because of the terrible things that they do and they attribute to Ron Hubbard, like Declaring people Suppressive, Disconnection policy, and more..."
This is an example of a typical view held by many Independent Scientologists.
How would this person be diagnosed?
Is he lying? Perhaps he doesn't actually believe what he's saying, and thinks that not praising Hubbard would be bad for business?
Or does he actually believe this?
If he actually believes this, is there something wrong with him?
Terms such as (personality) cultism, brainwashing, psychological conditioning, etc. come to mind.
Is that unfair?
I've attempted to reply twice. Still don't fully understand how to use this forum. My apologies. I hate having to say that.
Did you receive my previous responses. I'm still don't understand how to use this forum.
To answer your question, Ron said (I'm paraphrasing), if we pull this off, it will be because nobody believes it. There are many other things that he said; for instance, Scientology is not for everyone. Another author, I believe his name was Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, said;, (paraphrasing again)
;the best place to hide something is in plain sight. Hubbard also said; what is real for you, is what you experience to be true.
Over the years I've gotten messed with a lot by THE CHURCH, and I've seen a lot of screwy stuff and changes. I reiterate, by THE CHURCH. Are you familiar with the saying; "one bad apple can spoil the bunch"? I've also donated millions of $'s, and many of my best years to the C of S, so I guess I was a fool to keep going back for more. I cannot hold anyone responsible other than myself. So, Que Sera Sera! I'm just tired of hearing people complaining about their conditions, i.e. crying over spilt milk.
I've been independent and in business for myself most of my life, and it's like that song by Queen "and mistakes, I've made a few". To the best of my knowledge I've tried not to have any shame blame or regrets. It's always easy to blame someone else for our misfortunes. I read somewhere once upon a time that one should take responsibility for their own condition, can't remember quite where I heard that, Ha-ha.
So I will leave you with this thought; anyone that never got any gains or enhancement from the tech obviously didn't understand something along the way. I once saw an interview with Ron, and he was asked what he thought he would be remembered for, and his reply was, the Way to Happiness, not anything else.
I hope any of you out there that read this, will get something out of it.
So for the record I do not care for the direction that the church has gone in. I started seeing changes in the mid 70's. I think DM is a megalomaniac who only cares about money.
I hope I've made my position clear!!
I also don't appreciate disgruntled comments directed at me.
And again, feel free to ask me questions, and I will answer them as honestly as I can, if I don't, kow the answer, I will tell you. I believe it's called TR-3, for any of you who have done the comm Course.