Julian Schwartz worried he's going to jail? What the hell?

but what tiny percentage of current members falls into that category, at this point where there's almost no recruiting -- especially after the start of the pandemic, when the Chase Wave had crashed and then the orgs virtually shut down and have had trouble getting going again?

i'll be curious to see how many there are who are on the fence or UTR who may have had enough -- and are not still so tightly connected, and afraid of disconnection, that they will come out about it or at least become more active lurkers on some of the boards.

and as i may have said here, i wonder what effect the current scandals will have particularly on born-ins, who seem less dedicated if not more or less disinterested, and are probably more aware of that is going on in the world. i don't get the impression that they are really active members, but a fair number at least have a go at joining staff, and they seem to be who the sea org relies on for recruits.
I would think that with the current news of Scientology's complicity in the Masterson matter, the climate as regards Scientology is more polarized than it has been in a very long time, outsiders looking on with disgust, insiders digging in and doubling down. That has to shake a few of the squirrels out of the tree.
 
..


I would think that with the current news of Scientology's complicity in the Masterson matter, the climate as regards Scientology is more polarized than it has been in a very long time, outsiders looking on with disgust, insiders digging in and doubling down. That has to shake a few of the squirrels out of the tree.

.
Sure, that'll work like a charm.

For a couple moments. . .

But then Scientologists will start talking to each other (or themselves) about it.

At that point, the cult will necessarily "put a head on a pike" and blame one of the senior ETHICS or JUSTICE terminals.

Reading the Declare or hearing the news, all Scientologists (i.e. Staff, SO, OSA , Public & Celebrities) will momentarily smirk and nod to themselves for 1-2 seconds before going back to work with the highly satisfying thought-win that:

"I always picked up that something was really out with that guy!"​

:hattip:

..
 
I would think that with the current news of Scientology's complicity in the Masterson matter, the climate as regards Scientology is more polarized than it has been in a very long time, outsiders looking on with disgust, insiders digging in and doubling down. That has to shake a few of the squirrels out of the tree.
You know, I think this is gonna be like the Watergate thing. The coverup is gonna be FAR worse for the CoS than Masterson's actions themselves.

I really doubt any scientologist will have a change of heart just by learning that Masterson was a serial sex abuser. But I think those people who will look into how the CoS handled it, how it got Kenny Moxon involved, how they forced the victims to sign legal stuff and NDAs... none of that is good. Also Masterson himself got away with a slap on the wrist from the CoS and even by Hubbard's policies he should have gotten in serious ethics trouble and be taken off the PR lines forever.

If something about the Masterson case will prove to be the straw that broke the camel's cult back for someone it won't be the rape. It will be the coverup and lazy, inept ethics processing.
 
Last edited:
You know, I think this is gonna be like the Watergate thing. The coverup is gonna be FAR worse for the CoS than Masterson's actions themselves.

I really doubt any scientologist will have a change of heart just by learning that Masterson was a serial sex abuser. But I think those people who will look into how the CoS handled it, how it got Kenny Moxon involved, how they forced the victims to sign legal stuff and NDAs... none of that is good. Also Masterson himself got away with a slap on the wrist from the CoS and even by Hubbard's policies he should have gotten in serious ethics trouble and be taken off the PR lines forever.

If something about the Masterson case will prove to be the straw that broke the camel's cult back for someone it won't be the rape. It will be the coverup and lazy, inept ethics processing.
It will be standard "the end justifies the means" Scientology ethics. "The greatest good" has always been code for what promotes and protects the cult.
 
You know, I think this is gonna be like the Watergate thing. The coverup is gonna be FAR worse for the CoS than Masterson's actions themselves.

I really doubt any scientologist will have a change of heart just by learning that Masterson was a serial sex abuser. But I think those people who will look into how the CoS handled it, how it got Kenny Moxon involved, how they forced the victims to sign legal stuff and NDAs... none of that is good. Also Masterson himself got away with a slap on the wrist from the CoS and even by Hubbard's policies he should have gotten in serious ethics trouble and be taken off the PR lines forever.

If something about the Masterson case will prove to be the straw that broke the camel's cult back for someone it won't be the rape. It will be the coverup and lazy, inept ethics processing.
This will only come to any sort of fruition if the grand jury finds obstruction by COS in the Masterson case, and it proceeds from there. It will have to have much, much more bad PR than Masterson's verdict or Kushner's go soft letter to Masterton's judge to get any sort of traction with bubble living scio's.

They self police. They avoid entheta whether true or not. They think enthata is psych suppression of scientology. Do you think headlines such as: "Scientology covered up Masterson's rapes from police" will impinge on the average clam?:cautious:

Look at what the church is doing currently - telling their public and staff Danny is innocent and asking them to push Holly's statement to their friends. Do you think they will ever admit wrong doing in an obstruction case? Fair gaming leah? The other cases?

It's going to take a massive judgements against Scientology on the two big fronts - Leah's suit and the obstruction case to make national news to wake them up.

Mimsey
 
Last edited:
Julian Swartz only has to worry about going to prison, if he violated California criminal statutes that carry prison time as a penalty and which were in effect at the time. That having been said, he and others in the official corporate C of $ could possibly be charged as accessories after the fact to Masterson's Rape felonies under California Penal Code Title 2 § 32 (became law in 1872!) for their failure to report Masterson's this lifetime crimes to law enforcement.

PC 32 said:
Every person who, after a felony has been committed, harbors, conceals or aids a principal in such felony, with the intent that said principal may avoid or escape from arrest, trial, conviction or punishment, having knowledge that said principal has committed such felony or has been charged with such felony or convicted thereof, is an accessory to such felony.
 
Julian Swartz only has to worry about going to prison, if he violated California criminal statutes that carry prison time as a penalty and which were in effect at the time. That having been said, he and others in the official corporate C of $ could possibly be charged as accessories after the fact to Masterson's Rape felonies under California Penal Code Title 2 § 32 (became law in 1872!) for their failure to report Masterson's this lifetime crimes to law enforcement.
Accessories after the fact? What about obstruction?

What is obstruction of justice? California penal code section 148 makes it a crime to delay, resist, or obstruct law enforcement or emergency medical personnel when performing their job duties and doing so willfully.

and:

There is no specific crime of obstruction of justice under California state law. However, a number of offenses, mostly involving interference with the police or the judicial process, that fall under the rubric of obstruction of justice crimes.
These include:
Maybe it will have to be a federal case?

Under federal law, any act that “corruptly or by threats or force, or by any threatening letter or communication, influences, obstructs, or impedes, or endeavors to influence, obstruct, or impede, the due administration of justice” can be considered obstruction of justice. Obstruction of justice often involves the interference of a law enforcement investigation in which suspects attempt to conceal or destroy evidence, or they refuse to cooperative with law enforcement officers.
Although California law doesn’t contain specific statute for “obstruction of justice,” there are several types of misdemeanor and felony offenses that fall into the category of obstructing justice. The state’s legal system is designed to provide law enforcement with the ability to perform official duties without interference. This means if police believe your actions interfere with how they are operating in an official capacity, then you can be arrested for obstructing justice.
 
Accessories after the fact? What about obstruction?

What is obstruction of justice? California penal code section 148 makes it a crime to delay, resist, or obstruct law enforcement or emergency medical personnel when performing their job duties and doing so willfully.

and:

There is no specific crime of obstruction of justice under California state law. However, a number of offenses, mostly involving interference with the police or the judicial process, that fall under the rubric of obstruction of justice crimes.
These include:
Maybe it will have to be a federal case?

Under federal law, any act that “corruptly or by threats or force, or by any threatening letter or communication, influences, obstructs, or impedes, or endeavors to influence, obstruct, or impede, the due administration of justice” can be considered obstruction of justice. Obstruction of justice often involves the interference of a law enforcement investigation in which suspects attempt to conceal or destroy evidence, or they refuse to cooperative with law enforcement officers.
Although California law doesn’t contain specific statute for “obstruction of justice,” there are several types of misdemeanor and felony offenses that fall into the category of obstructing justice. The state’s legal system is designed to provide law enforcement with the ability to perform official duties without interference. This means if police believe your actions interfere with how they are operating in an official capacity, then you can be arrested for obstructing justice.


Your post is kind of confusing. You say there is no "OBSTRUCTION" crime in CA? Where did you get that info? But then you quote law firm that says there IS a serious crime of OBSTRUCTION in CA?
Are you quoting different sources or saying your opinion or ???

I think you are trying to make a semantic point? In other words HOW the crime of "obstruction" is variously charged, in the english language in a CA court? If the action of obstructing is a crime, it seems hardly relevant how it's described.

Here's an excerpt from a CA law firm that promotes online:

Obstruction of justice is a serious crime in California, one that may leave you facing serious criminal penalties if convicted. At The Justice Firm, we provide exceptional legal guidance and support to those who have been accused of any criminal offense. We understand the fear, stress, and uncertainty individuals experience when potentially facing criminal charges. Our Los Angeles obstruction of justice defense attorneys work vigorously to protect your freedom and avoid a conviction. What is obstruction of justice? California penal code section 148 makes it a crime to delay, resist, or obstruct law enforcement or emergency medical personnel when performing their job duties and doing so willfully. Basically, if an individual performs any action or conducts him or herself in any way that prevents or hinders a police officer, emergency medical technician, or other authority from performing duties such as enforcing the law, administering court duties or which hinders the judicial process, you may be arrested for obstruction of justice. Examples of this criminal offense which may be charged as either a misdemeanor or felony include falsifying or concealing evidence, bribing or threatening a judge, lawyer, juror, or witness, lying while under oath as a witness, or resisting arrest.​
​
Here's another site:​
​
"Conviction of “obstruction of justice” is an aggravated felony if a sentence of a year or more is imposed."​
​
​
Here's another site: ​
​
What Is Considered Obstruction of Justice in California?
March 11, 2022
​
Under federal law, any act that “corruptly or by threats or force, or by any threatening letter or communication, influences, obstructs, or impedes, or endeavors to influence, obstruct, or impede, the due administration of justice” can be considered obstruction of justice. Obstruction of justice often involves the interference of a law enforcement investigation in which suspects attempt to conceal or destroy evidence, or they refuse to cooperative with law enforcement officers.​
Although California law doesn’t contain specific statute for “obstruction of justice,” there are several types of misdemeanor and felony offenses that fall into the category of obstructing justice. The state’s legal system is designed to provide law enforcement with the ability to perform official duties without interference. This means if police believe your actions interfere with how they are operating in an official capacity, then you can be arrested for obstructing justice.​
The following California Penal codes cover actions related to obstruction of justice:​
  • Penal Code 132 PC: It is illegal to offer false physical evidence you know is forged or fraudulent. Even if the evidence is partially true, if a single piece of it is known to be forged or fraudulent, it still violates this law and is considered obstruction of justice. This crime is a felony offense. If convicted, you can face a prison sentence between 16 months and three years and up to $10,000 in fines.
    • Penal Code 134 PC: It is illegal for an individual to prepare false evidence with intent to use it fraudulently in a legal proceeding or investigation. If you break this law, you can be charged with a felony and face a jail sentence between 16 months and three years, as well as $10,000 in fines.
      • Penal Code 135 PC: It is illegal to knowingly and willingly destroy, erase, or conceal any physical evidence that is in someone else's possession. Deleting incriminating files from your computer hard drive during a criminal investigation is an example of an act that violates this law. If you are charged with destroying evidence, it is a misdemeanor that carries a penalty of up to six months in jail and a fine of $1,000.
      • Penal Code 136.1 PC: It is illegal to tamper with, intimidate, prevent, or make an attempt to prevent a witness from giving their testimony at a legal proceeding. If the charge is treated as a misdemeanor, you can face up to one year in jail and $1,000 fine. If the charge is treated as a felony, you can face a two to four year jail sentence and up to $10,000 in fines.
      • Penal Code 148 PC: It is illegal to intentionally resist, delay, or obstruct a law enforcement officer or EMT performing their official duties. This also includes obstructing an officer from interviewing a witness to a crime and interfering with police officers who attempting to arrest another person. This crime is a misdemeanor that is subject to a year in jail and up to $1,000 in fines.
 
Accessories after the fact? What about obstruction?

Accessory after the fact says these persons are - in effect - participants in the crime(s) to which they are accessory. So far as I am aware, the statute penalties for being an accessory to a felony are far, far worse than mere obstruction.
 
Your post is kind of confusing. You say there is no "OBSTRUCTION" crime in CA? Where did you get that info? But then you quote law firm that says there IS a serious crime of OBSTRUCTION in CA?
Are you quoting different sources or saying your opinion or ???

I think you are trying to make a semantic point? In other words HOW the crime of "obstruction" is variously charged, in the english language in a CA court? If the action of obstructing is a crime, it seems hardly relevant how it's described.

Here's an excerpt from a CA law firm that promotes online:

Obstruction of justice is a serious crime in California, one that may leave you facing serious criminal penalties if convicted. At The Justice Firm, we provide exceptional legal guidance and support to those who have been accused of any criminal offense. We understand the fear, stress, and uncertainty individuals experience when potentially facing criminal charges. Our Los Angeles obstruction of justice defense attorneys work vigorously to protect your freedom and avoid a conviction. What is obstruction of justice? California penal code section 148 makes it a crime to delay, resist, or obstruct law enforcement or emergency medical personnel when performing their job duties and doing so willfully. Basically, if an individual performs any action or conducts him or herself in any way that prevents or hinders a police officer, emergency medical technician, or other authority from performing duties such as enforcing the law, administering court duties or which hinders the judicial process, you may be arrested for obstruction of justice. Examples of this criminal offense which may be charged as either a misdemeanor or felony include falsifying or concealing evidence, bribing or threatening a judge, lawyer, juror, or witness, lying while under oath as a witness, or resisting arrest.​
​
Here's another site:​
​
"Conviction of “obstruction of justice” is an aggravated felony if a sentence of a year or more is imposed."​
​
​
Here's another site: ​
​
What Is Considered Obstruction of Justice in California?​
March 11, 2022​
Under federal law, any act that “corruptly or by threats or force, or by any threatening letter or communication, influences, obstructs, or impedes, or endeavors to influence, obstruct, or impede, the due administration of justice” can be considered obstruction of justice. Obstruction of justice often involves the interference of a law enforcement investigation in which suspects attempt to conceal or destroy evidence, or they refuse to cooperative with law enforcement officers.​
Although California law doesn’t contain specific statute for “obstruction of justice,” there are several types of misdemeanor and felony offenses that fall into the category of obstructing justice. The state’s legal system is designed to provide law enforcement with the ability to perform official duties without interference. This means if police believe your actions interfere with how they are operating in an official capacity, then you can be arrested for obstructing justice.​
The following California Penal codes cover actions related to obstruction of justice:​

  • Penal Code 132 PC: It is illegal to offer false physical evidence you know is forged or fraudulent. Even if the evidence is partially true, if a single piece of it is known to be forged or fraudulent, it still violates this law and is considered obstruction of justice. This crime is a felony offense. If convicted, you can face a prison sentence between 16 months and three years and up to $10,000 in fines.
    • Penal Code 134 PC: It is illegal for an individual to prepare false evidence with intent to use it fraudulently in a legal proceeding or investigation. If you break this law, you can be charged with a felony and face a jail sentence between 16 months and three years, as well as $10,000 in fines.
      • Penal Code 135 PC: It is illegal to knowingly and willingly destroy, erase, or conceal any physical evidence that is in someone else's possession. Deleting incriminating files from your computer hard drive during a criminal investigation is an example of an act that violates this law. If you are charged with destroying evidence, it is a misdemeanor that carries a penalty of up to six months in jail and a fine of $1,000.
      • Penal Code 136.1 PC: It is illegal to tamper with, intimidate, prevent, or make an attempt to prevent a witness from giving their testimony at a legal proceeding. If the charge is treated as a misdemeanor, you can face up to one year in jail and $1,000 fine. If the charge is treated as a felony, you can face a two to four year jail sentence and up to $10,000 in fines.
      • Penal Code 148 PC: It is illegal to intentionally resist, delay, or obstruct a law enforcement officer or EMT performing their official duties. This also includes obstructing an officer from interviewing a witness to a crime and interfering with police officers who attempting to arrest another person. This crime is a misdemeanor that is subject to a year in jail and up to $1,000 in fines.
What those law firms said was there was no specific obstruction of justice statutes in California, but others could be used such as you mentioned. There are however, federal statutes that prohibit the practice.

Possibly an argument could be made for penal code 148 PC that Julian, OSA and Moxon intentionally delayed or obstructed a law officer, but I don't see how the other 2 qualify.

Then there's this:

The crimes covered by the mandatory reporting laws include sexual abuse, physical abuse, verbal abuse, child endangerment, and neglect of a child. Failure to report under this statute is a misdemeanor that is punishable by up to six months in county jail and a fine of $1000.

Chump change to an organization like the COS though Julian might enjoy something other than rice and beans at the county's expense.

There has to be something that pushes the penalties into a higher status or it's a waste of the legal systems time. You have Moxon arranging a payoff between Danny and Jane Doe to keep it on th QT, Could all 3 be guilty of violating Penal code 148 pc?

Mimsey
 
Accessory after the fact says these persons are - in effect - participants in the crime(s) to which they are accessory. So far as I am aware, the statute penalties for being an accessory to a felony are far, far worse than mere obstruction.
Good point. If that's a bigger penalty, it might be worth pursuing. What I have no data on, is how does this relate to a corporation, how can it have any bite? Do they go after the individuals involved, or the COS itself?

Do they charge everybody in CCint, COS, OSA, RTC etc who were directly involved? That could be a lot of staff.

Mimsey
 
Last edited:
What I have no data on, is how does this relate to a corporation, how can it have any bite?

AFAIK, corporations can only be sued in civil courts for civil torts. Legally, this has nothing to do with the C of $ organization and everything to do with the specific individuals who knew of the felony and conspired or directly acted to hide it.

Obviously to us, Mr. David "Destructive Micromanagement" Miscavige ran this entire conspiracy to hide Masterson's crimes. But how is prosecutor ever going to get enough evidence to prove this was done on his orders ? I have no idea.

Edit: Please don't try to throw the R.I.C.O. Act into this mix, because to invoke it requires so many convictions from a list of federal felonies within the last 10 years (IIRC) and not even one of those has happened, as yet.
 
AFAIK, corporations can only be sued in civil courts for civil torts. Legally, this has nothing to do with the C of $ organization and everything to do with the specific individuals who knew of the felony and conspired or directly acted to hide it.

Obviously to us, Mr. David "Destructive Micromanagement" Miscavige ran this entire conspiracy to hide Masterson's crimes. But how is prosecutor ever going to get enough evidence to prove this was done on his orders ? I have no idea.

Edit: Please don't try to throw the R.I.C.O. Act into this mix, because to invoke it requires so many convictions from a list of federal felonies within the last 10 years (IIRC) and not even one of those has happened, as yet.
Perhaps the grand jury can subpoena records. Lord knows they have tons. The CofS will fight that to the last man. It would be interesting if the LAPD showed up with a search warrant at the HGB and CC how that would go down.
Mimsey
 
AFAIK, corporations can only be sued in civil courts for civil torts. Legally, this has nothing to do with the C of $ organization and everything to do with the specific individuals who knew of the felony and conspired or directly acted to hide it.

Obviously to us, Mr. David "Destructive Micromanagement" Miscavige ran this entire conspiracy to hide Masterson's crimes. But how is prosecutor ever going to get enough evidence to prove this was done on his orders ? I have no idea.

Edit: Please don't try to throw the R.I.C.O. Act into this mix, because to invoke it requires so many convictions from a list of federal felonies within the last 10 years (IIRC) and not even one of those has happened, as yet.


Perhaps my understanding of the Law....is pretty bad. But for sure and certainly Corporations can be Criminally Sued....pretty much for anything an individual can be sued for.....


I've always thought that the Law considering Corporations "legal persons" was pretty weird....but that is another discussion. They are capable of being sued and suing others.....and being Criminally sued.....just like an individual is.

On another note.....only "we the people" can criminally sue another. So....only Govt entities....can criminally sue.

This is interesting:

The Prosecution must decide whether to sue the "Corporation" or the "Agent/Agents of the Corporation." They cannot do both.

 
Last edited:
Perhaps my understanding of the Law....is pretty bad.

Well, this is why I have a that "I am not a lawyer" disclaimer in my signature box on every post. |

One point of lawyer language, though. I'm pretty sure "sued" is generally understood to be a civil matter with "charged", "indicted", and "prosecuted" used for criminal matters.

Thanks for the references!
 
You know, I think this is gonna be like the Watergate thing. The coverup is gonna be FAR worse for the CoS than Masterson's actions themselves.

I really doubt any scientologist will have a change of heart just by learning that Masterson was a serial sex abuser. But I think those people who will look into how the CoS handled it, how it got Kenny Moxon involved, how they forced the victims to sign legal stuff and NDAs... none of that is good. Also Masterson himself got away with a slap on the wrist from the CoS and even by Hubbard's policies he should have gotten in serious ethics trouble and be taken off the PR lines forever.

If something about the Masterson case will prove to be the straw that broke the camel's cult back for someone it won't be the rape. It will be the coverup and lazy, inept ethics processing.
I came across this story of another rapist, and was thinking that Masterson was lucky that non of the girls had a daddy like this.


@Karakorum what do you think Scientology's reaction would be if a girl's father reacted by beating Masterson enough to put him in the hospital (but not actually killing him)? Would the rule about "not involving civil authorities" apply then?

Or would they declare the dad for damaging a celeb, and THEN have it be OK to call the cops?
 
@Karakorum what do you think Scientology's reaction would be if a girl's father reacted by beating Masterson enough to put him in the hospital (but not actually killing him)? Would the rule about "not involving civil authorities" apply then?

Great question. I never had to deal with anything even remotely like that, so time for a DISCLAIMER: I will need to answer and speculate based on my general scn knowledge, as opposed to my own experience.


First of all, a murder is extremely hard to cover up. Especially one where the person was beaten to death (as opposed to say falling out of a window or drowning in the sea etc). So I guess even if the intent and desire would be not to involve the police, there would be an instant: "Oh yeah wise guy, how do you exactly plan to hide the body?!" pushback. I really doubt anyone in scn would help the murderer to bury the body or dispose of it in a fire etc.

So I think they would report it to the police, then tell the murderer:
"Fine, you got yourself into this bloody mess yourself. You should have fucking reported him to ethics LIKE THE FRUCKING POLICY TELLS YOU TO! But because you an idiot, you took stuff into your own hands. You left us with no easy way out whatsoever because of your own inherent misemotional stupidity. Now take responsibility, keep the church out of it."


Now, if this was something less dramatic and less 'terminal' than murder (like just a beating that leaves just bruises etc), then I'm quite sure they would not involve the police. They would just do regular ethics actions.
 
First of all, a murder is extremely hard to cover up
That's why I very specifically said "beating" rather than "kill". Specifically a beating requiring medical treatment or hospitalization.

I would have thought you saw cases where Scientologists engaged in inter personal violence in instances where Ethics didn't handle the issue to the satisfaction of one of the parties.

Or did OSA get all those?
 
That's why I very specifically said "beating" rather than "kill". Specifically a beating requiring medical treatment or hospitalization.

I would have thought you saw cases where Scientologists engaged in inter personal violence in instances where Ethics didn't handle the issue to the satisfaction of one of the parties.

Or did OSA get all those?
There was a murder a while back - one scio business partner was giving $ to the IAS, and was shot by his non- scio partner. I don't recall how ethics handled this, He ended up in jail. Other than retrieving his OT materials, what did the church do?

Mimsey

"Fowler Software Design ran smoothly and profitably for years, even as the staff was divided between Scientologists and nonmembers of the controversial group.
But a full-blown schism developed after employees learned that the company’s founder — 59-year-old William Rex Fowler — gave as much as $250,000 of the firm’s money to the Church of Scientology, according to witness statements given to investigators.
Those conflicts were readily apparent after 42-year-old Thomas Ciancio, a non-Scientologist, was shot and killed by Fowler on Dec. 30, 2009.
Fowler was convicted in Adams County district court Feb. 25 and sentenced to life in prison. The witness statements were released Friday after an open-records request.
Fowler’s family has declined comment, and the Church of Scientology couldn’t be reached for comment."

and:

"Fowler’s wife, Jan Fowler, told police Ciancio was to blame for the company’s failings. She also brushed aside the gift to Scientology as “stretching the rules of the company” and said Fowler was paying it back.
She talked about the contents of a briefcase belonging to Fowler that included insights into the highest levels of Scientology. A beginning Scientologist like herself could never comprehend the writings. “Cause it’s hard on them,” Jan Fowler said. “. . . that’s why it’s confidential. Not from commercial reasons. Not because it is hurtful. . . . it’s big dose for somebody who’s not ready for it.”


More at link:


Mimsey
 
Last edited:
That's why I very specifically said "beating" rather than "kill". Specifically a beating requiring medical treatment or hospitalization.

I would have thought you saw cases where Scientologists engaged in inter personal violence in instances where Ethics didn't handle the issue to the satisfaction of one of the parties.

Or did OSA get all those?
Oh sorry, my mistake you are right. I somehow missed that part of your post. I guess I'm trying to do too many things at once. My bad! :duh:

I would have thought you saw cases where Scientologists engaged in inter personal violence in instances where Ethics didn't handle the issue to the satisfaction of one of the parties.

Ok, let me go back and try to answer this thing properly:

1. We never got any case that had to do with celebrities. I imagine small-time stuff got handled inside CC, big stuff went directly to OSA. So if the beating would involve Masterson, most likely we wouldn't ever get it to begin with.
2. We absolutely did get cases involving violence or physical alternations for non-celebrities. Quite a few were spouse-on-spouse cases for example. We'd proceed with a normal investigation, sec-check people, sometimes sec-check their friends and co-workers, follow policy whenever it did not get in the way etc.
There could be a lot of different outcomes depending on what happened, who started it, what were the circumstances, if it generated additional problems or bad PR for others etc. But I can't imagine such a thing being reported to the police unless it was absolutely unavoidable.
3. Yeah of course sometimes the final decision was not to the liking of one or both parties involved. Everything from "you are being too harsh" through: "you are being too soft" and "Well you sure took your goddamn time getting this closed!"
 
Back
Top