Karakorum
千差万別
I think there is another point, and that is this:
6. The scientology business model doesn't work.
The cost of going clear, let alone OT, is out of the reach of most people. I watched a video that I now wish that I had recorded. It was COB briefing org ED's, maybe dated 2013 - 2014. I think it occurred somewhere in EU, maybe at AOSH EU. In this briefing, he talked about pricing the new courses like SRD and student hat at $ 2500 USD. He said (paraphrased) "you guys told me the price that you wanted, that is where that price came from. It could be lower but YOU said that was the price that you were comfortable with." I didn't see how this could be possible, that someone didn't really noodle the pricing out to give economy of scale, or make it more attainable. I don't see how a young college graduate earning 30 - 40k in a starting position could afford to go clear in a year or two if they decided that was what they wanted to do. All other arguments aside, of course the DIV 6 line is not bringing people in in droves, the floors are not collapsing, of course again for various other reasons. But consider this my current scientologist friend, could you have afforded this when you were 20? 30? The pricing scheme is still awkward, with the sliding scale, and it is still out of reach of many.
I think we have the difference between Hubbard and DM here. Hubbard was in many ways the classic cult guru and, while he was out to get cash, he was out to spread his ideas and he was interested in expanding the reach of the CoS.
Dave I believe sees himself as a "caretaker" of scientology and long ago made the decision not to try to expand with what is an unpopular product. Rather, he is all about "managed decline" and milking the existing "customers" rather than getting new ones. And the focus is squarely on whales, not on joe shmoe. That's why existing services are expensive, donations are more important that services and things get re-written every few years. Its milking the existing customers again and again.
