How Ideal Orgs Are Causing Current Scientologists To Leave Scientology

Having been out for decades, (Hubbard was still alive and crazy when I left), all I can say is that I am glad. I love the fact that Scientology itself is increasingly causing its members to leave. It always had that effect but I am smiling because the church is getting even better at pissing off its own people. I mean, Scientology is worse than a load of shit. Shit at least can be used as a fertilizer and even dung beetles have no use for Scientology.
 
Jokes aside, I think I would recommend this video:

I mean the title may be somewhat grandiose and sensationalized, but the content is actually very down-to-earth and very serious.

Chris, John and Dr.Jeff Wasel are talking about the policy changes introduced by the current administration including Ideal Orgs and GAT and how these pieces fit into the larger puzzle of the way CoS is being ran now.

Vid is long, but if you have some spare time during the corona bug doldrum, I really suggest you listen to it.
 
Scientology burns people off in batches. The mission holders conference in (whenever it was) basically killed off the missions and mission holders. The GAT in 1996 killed off the old timers who had spent all their lives training and getting audited prior to the GAT. Then the Ideal Org project killed off the public who had hung around through all that other rubbish. Thanks DM.
 
Scientology burns people off in batches. The mission holders conference in (whenever it was) basically killed off the missions and mission holders. The GAT in 1996 killed off the old timers who had spent all their lives training and getting audited prior to the GAT. Then the Ideal Org project killed off the public who had hung around through all that other rubbish. Thanks DM.
The Co$ has money to live off for the next 70 years or so. If nothing big will happen, then it will just continue to slowly bleed membership while disconnecting people, putting people through mental and physical abuse and getting 2nd gen kids thrown to the SO.

What the church needs is a big push that would either cause it to reform, or cause a systemic failure that makes people leave in droves as part of organized groups.
Because the "one person at a time" bleedout will be neither pretty, nor safe, nor quick nor good for those who are still inside.
 
I truly don't see anything other than the slow bleed you described. There have been books and movies and TV shows and editorials and documentaries and still Scientology is exactly where it was. Until a criminal case can be made against them for something big (like murder) I really don't see anything changing.

All you can do is be here for the refugees.
 
I truly don't see anything other than the slow bleed you described. There have been books and movies and TV shows and editorials and documentaries and still Scientology is exactly where it was. Until a criminal case can be made against them for something big (like murder) I really don't see anything changing.

All you can do is be here for the refugees.

True. I can only use the orgs that I know of, and it's contracting, probably simply factors of people not letting it get into their system before they leave.

There has been a great amount of work done, books & movies to name a few. The presence of things like OCMB, ESMB, etc.

Has anyone tried to communicate directly to people currently in in large quantity that you know of?
 
I truly don't see anything other than the slow bleed you described. There have been books and movies and TV shows and editorials and documentaries and still Scientology is exactly where it was. Until a criminal case can be made against them for something big (like murder) I really don't see anything changing.
The books podcasts, anonymous and Remini's show speak mostly to outsiders and act as a warning to potential new recruits. Don't get me wrong: I feel like they did a great job in that field.

But the issue with all of them is that they don't speak to the people inside scientology using terms and language that will appeal to those inside the cult. To be very blunt: for most active members this is at best "wog stuff said in wog language for wogs". At worst its just entheta and agitprop of the psychs.

Even a declared SP like me: when I started watching Leah's show my reaction was: "Its great that it will inform the general American society. But after all is said and done it is pretty much just 3 seasons of waving the bloody shirt".

The last major criticism that came from inside scientology, was directed at scientologists and used the language and terms of scientology was Debbie Cook's letter. And it made a lot of people to leave. I do not think its a coincidence that there was no further great exodus.

All you can do is be here for the refugees.
I'm all for it! But I'm not satisfied with doing only that.
We should attempt to have people who ares still inside the church to act in their own best interest. Even those that are fervent believers in the tech.
 
Last edited:
I don't know about you guys, but there was nothing an outsider, friend or family member could have said to me that would have made a difference. It took for me to watch my husband be brutally treated when he wanted to leave staff after his contract ended for me to really start to question. Then I was brutally treated for questioning the treatment he received, and all of a sudden it was personal. Once the crack appeared it widened fairly quickly, BUT then you have to overcome to awful realisation that if you leave you will lose one or more of the following - family, spouse, children, religion, belief system, friends, career, social circle, job etc. It was all of those for me in the end and probably the same for many others.

I think it comes down to where the greatest pain lies - leaving or staying. I bet there are thousands of people "in" that are only there for appearances because they just don't want to deal with all the shit. In fact I know there are many like that even in my city.
 
I don't know about you guys, but there was nothing an outsider, friend or family member could have said to me that would have made a difference. It took for me to watch my husband be brutally treated when he wanted to leave staff after his contract ended for me to really start to question. Then I was brutally treated for questioning the treatment he received, and all of a sudden it was personal. Once the crack appeared it widened fairly quickly, BUT then you have to overcome to awful realisation that if you leave you will lose one or more of the following - family, spouse, children, religion, belief system, friends, career, social circle, job etc. It was all of those for me in the end and probably the same for many others.

I think it comes down to where the greatest pain lies - leaving or staying. I bet there are thousands of people "in" that are only there for appearances because they just don't want to deal with all the shit. In fact I know there are many like that even in my city.
I think the main reason why people are still inside is because they are not like us in some respect. So if they had the same feelings and behavioral patters as we do, then they would be here now with us and not still inside. That's the limitation of trying to apply our own personal experiences and projecting them on the population that is still in.

I for one came from a family background of LRH "bitterenders" and I had no big reverence for the new DM management to begin with. I also never had any great wins using the tech. I was never exterior, never found anything interesting with past lives etc. I wasn't there because I was in love with the tech.

Yet I get the feeling most people still inside are hard-core believers in the tech. The same arguments that would work wonders on me will not move them even one inch.

To use a political analogy: This is like being a bleeding-heart left wing liberal and then learning you need to run a campaign from some rural Nebraska district. You will never get elected if you just go on with your current line. You need to adapt your message, your language and your whole approach to politics if you want to be aligned with your new voters.

So if we want to reach the people who are inside, we cannot go on using "SP talk" and try to push "SP beliefs" on people who are all about being KSW. We shouldn't even try to make them abandon KSW, we should encourage them to act in their own best interest and reforming things while being more KSW than the current management.

I think that is why Debbie Cook's message worked in the first place. And why anonymous shouting "down with Xenu" didn't move anyone.
 
Last edited:
Scientology burns people off in batches. The mission holders conference in (whenever it was) basically killed off the missions and mission holders. The GAT in 1996 killed off the old timers who had spent all their lives training and getting audited prior to the GAT. Then the Ideal Org project killed off the public who had hung around through all that other rubbish. Thanks DM.

Sorry to ask but was the GAT?
 
Sorry to ask but was the GAT?
The "Golden Age of Tech", which was a change in the way that people were training to be auditors, and the requirements in order to audit people. There were new courses and drills that auditors had to do. The church claimed that this whole program should have been the way that auditors were trained, and as a result, required current auditors had to do that program in order to continue auditing. Some public auditors gave up. Die hard public signed up for the new courses and did them. As always, you had to pay for them, and it resulted in huge amounts of income for the church. There was even a new emeter released, which of course, cost money. You were either able to update your old meter, or there was a chance with some older emeters that you just had to but a new one.

This happened again, actually about a little less then ten years later. A little bit different, but essentially people had to buy new courses and do them, and of course, new meters. They called this the Golden Age of Tech Phase II. Or sometimes you will here it referred to as GAT2, (saying the letters G A T two) or gat2, as in gat, like cat, gat two.

This is about as simple as I can tell you this, because there is more to it, but that's it in a nutshell.
 
Last edited:
I think the Debbie Cook letter was so effective for three reasons. Firstly she was known to many scientologists. Secondly she made her concerns personal by contacting scientologists by email. Thirdly she framed it in terms of KSW.

In the current CoS I think the only scientologist of any authority that is known to the masses is DM. Therefore it would be difficut for anyone else to do what Debbie Cook did. When people like Mike Rinder and Marty Rathbun left there may have been some scientologists who wondered what happened to them but they wouldn't be looking on the internet to find out.
 
I think the Debbie Cook letter was so effective for three reasons. Firstly she was known to many scientologists. Secondly she made her concerns personal by contacting scientologists by email. Thirdly she framed it in terms of KSW.

In the current CoS I think the only scientologist of any authority that is known to the masses is DM. Therefore it would be difficut for anyone else to do what Debbie Cook did. When people like Mike Rinder and Marty Rathbun left there may have been some scientologists who wondered what happened to them but they wouldn't be looking on the internet to find out.
That's a great point, people took notice of Debbie precisely because it was Debbie. Yet I also strongly agree that "framing it in terms of KSW" was equally important. I think this second factor somehow got lost with the actions of subsequent critics.
 
I will say then there are five points (there may be more) that are probably parked in some current scientologist's minds:

1. Where is everybody??

This one was on my mind, certainly from a time just after I started, and became progressively more puzzling as I went. I knew that we didn't have the numbers that were being claimed fifteen years into my tenure as a scientologist. I was curious to resolve it, not necessarily to find out that I was being lied to, but to find something that made sense were there wasn't sense being made. That was the first subject that I searched for the day I went looking for data on the interwebs. I remember it clearly!! I think the main reason was I didn't see the numbers in my org. I went to Flag and didn't see it bursting at the seams. I will say that I noticed quite a lot of older periphery public in both CW and LA. But I also spent longs hours in CF in my org and LA org. In spite of lots of CF files, it took a bit to get to one that had recent activity, other than looking at the letters out in attempts to raise the dead.

2. Is the ideal org strategy really working?

One can see the cycle of an ideal org:
- Org barely alive, ten to fifteen staff with three full timers
- Ideal org program start
- Fifteen years between start and grand opening
- Lots of staff falsely labelled as staff, start with 200, shrink to 50 in just over one year
- Empty building
- Continued fundraising for other less fortunate orgs at your org (this was happening while the fundraising for our org was still going on, and was such an odd thing)

3. What happened to scientology TV?? Is it doing what it could do? (I am not sure about this one, but suspect that it exists)

SMP and scientology TV was going to solve all the problems of the world.

4. Continued delivery issues.

To an old timer, you had hoped that there would be no delivery issues after all this, but those problems still exist. Lack of auditors, odd schedules, etc. This goes on after the org gets past the hemorrhage of staff.

5. With everything that we know, and we know it all, why is this so tough?

This could be attached squarely upon the shoulders or current management. As scientology struggles, new businesses and industries start, make billions and fail, all the while scientology shrinks
 
I think the Debbie Cook letter was so effective for three reasons. Firstly she was known to many scientologists. Secondly she made her concerns personal by contacting scientologists by email. Thirdly she framed it in terms of KSW.

In the current CoS I think the only scientologist of any authority that is known to the masses is DM. Therefore it would be difficut for anyone else to do what Debbie Cook did. When people like Mike Rinder and Marty Rathbun left there may have been some scientologists who wondered what happened to them but they wouldn't be looking on the internet to find out.
Davey has spent DECADES making sure that nobody could ever supplant him.

This also means that when he goes, Scientology has a good chance of collapsing.
 
I think there is another point, and that is this:

6. The scientology business model doesn't work.

The cost of going clear, let alone OT, is out of the reach of most people. I watched a video that I now wish that I had recorded. It was COB briefing org ED's, maybe dated 2013 - 2014. I think it occurred somewhere in EU, maybe at AOSH EU. In this briefing, he talked about pricing the new courses like SRD and student hat at $ 2500 USD. He said (paraphrased) "you guys told me the price that you wanted, that is where that price came from. It could be lower but YOU said that was the price that you were comfortable with." I didn't see how this could be possible, that someone didn't really noodle the pricing out to give economy of scale, or make it more attainable. I don't see how a young college graduate earning 30 - 40k in a starting position could afford to go clear in a year or two if they decided that was what they wanted to do. All other arguments aside, of course the DIV 6 line is not bringing people in in droves, the floors are not collapsing, of course again for various other reasons. But consider this my current scientologist friend, could you have afforded this when you were 20? 30? The pricing scheme is still awkward, with the sliding scale, and it is still out of reach of many.
 
Back
Top