How Ideal Orgs Are Causing Current Scientologists To Leave Scientology

Dotey OT

Re-Membered
20191109-central-ohio-grand-opening-08c5764_en.jpg

Anyone involved in the COS prior to 2003 can attest to the fact that the state of the buildings housing the orgs was pretty horrible. I had been to a few orgs by that time, none were impressive and most actually looked downstat and were in disrepair. LA Day & FDN, Tampa, CC Nash, Atlanta, Cincinnati, Columbus and Las Vegas were an embarrassment to any hardcore Scientologist. That’s why when the ideal org projected started, a certain excitement and hope started to enter in. Will we actually be able to throw away the folding chairs???

A concern sprung up, which was only whispered amongst friends that were old war horses, which was "this is a violation of having to have before you can do, isn't it?" One could only whisper this. Better not whisper it to the wrong person.


Long wait.jpg

The excitement was pretty much drained out by the ten years plus that it took to raise the money for our org. I don't think we were the only org that took that long, and I believe there were a few others which took much longer. A testament to that fact is that it's now 2020, and there are still orgs fundraising at "full blast."

Also, during the period of time from the commencement of fund raising to the grand opening, there was an attitude of "we aren't really worrying about clearing the planet right now because we are fundraising for the new building." It most definitely wasn't business as usual. Again, the old war horses and anyone that had a concern for the production occurring in the org could see the effect that the complete attention org management had on fundraising. Us old war horses had to stifle our concern for fear of not being "with it." What happened to the "The Business of Orgs"???

Then there is the subject of construction or remodeling of buildings. Construction can be a crap shoot. Even the experienced builders/remodelers run into an expensive surprise occasionally, and the surprises that were too great caused the company to go under. The amateurs involved in ideal org projects take the cake!! Earthquake zones, incorrect drainage per NPDES protocols and mold remediation were a few of the very expensive surprises that many a dedicated public had to swallow and donate to overcome. I can't recall all the stories, but I suspect there has been a building or two which was purchased and had to be abandoned as a result of such oversights. (If you have knowledge of these sorts of things with your

orgs, chime in!!)

Value Engineering

Definition : Value engineering is an exercise that involves most of the project team as the project develops. It is about taking a wider view and looking at the selection of materials, plant, equipment and processes to see if a more cost-effective solution exists that will achieve the same project objectives.

Value engineering was non-existent in the process of ideal orgs, at least the ideal org that I was aware of. Maybe actually the opposite was the operating basis. During the fundraising, org public were made aware of the entire process by the landlord office, fundraisers, etc., more or less to make everyone a stakeholder in the process. We were told many of the more finer details of the building plans. I happened to be in the construction industry at the time, and had SCN friends in construction. The lack of attention to value engineering was staggering!! We all had many conversations about how we could speed up the process because we could build the building for way less. Another point in this fiasco, maybe the most important point, was the breaking of a sacred rule. The rule goes like this : Never fall in love with the property. One should always have a dispassionate viewpoint over property, because if you don't, it will cost you. Apparently, cost is no object.

For myself, the ideal org project for our area acted as a never ending supply of conflicting datums. Fundraising, withered orgs, people leaving (Suddenly people were missing or hard to get hold of) events, events, events took it's toll. It didn't cause me to leave at that time, but I became very wary of what was going on. I had to take the attitude of "We will See". I guess that leads to the next point.

Ideal org buildings are very, very empty. I drive past the org in my city on occasion, and there are never more that eight cars in the parking lot. If you frequent Tony Ortega or Mike Rinder, you get a feel for this. There are frequently reports of recently opened ideal orgs with no cars in the parking lots. This is a standard.

I haven't even covered the financial irregularities that I knew of during the fundraising portion. That will have to come at a later time.
 
Last edited:
Another point to make on this was the money and lack of the desire to save money. In numerous conversations with active Scientologists, the comparison in regards to buildings, Scientology = Government. The similarity to the entity that was trying to build Scientology orgs and a government trying to build something was obvious. Why scrimp when you don't need to? There is an endless supply of money, let's spend it!!!
 
Wonderfully informative read. Keep on! :thumbsup:

I remember making a $30 donation one time at Flag. That's my only "dono" ever.
Then GAT I came out. From home, I mailed in my Solo Nots materials with a letter
and left for good. I could see the future. That was my EP from Solo Nots, LOL.

I guess I missed out on a lot of fun from what I'm reading. I would have never made
it through this era if a "$30 donation" is my snapping point. :coolwink:

I knew policies cold and I knew the whole COS was going down a losing and criminal
path. A slippery slope. It was obvious to me.

About a year after I left and turned in my OT7 materials, two Class 9s from Flag
showed up to try to salvage me. (Long story.) They revealed I was the 400th
OT7 person
they had visited at home. At the time I had no idea how many other
Solos Nots people had left, since I lived in a remote region.

But I interrupted your story. Please continue your great writing and story telling. :love8:
 
Last edited:
Great thread!

I think I need to structure my reply in 3 parts, because there's so much in the initial post I want to address:

1. Early 2000s and my initial feelings as a cultie.

I know what you mean about the state of the orgs in the early 2000s. Las Vegas was a joke, Pasadena was a dump once you made one one step outside the public-facing areas. I'm not even gonna describe some of the small missions.

So some repair and renovation was in order, but IMHO could be done on a cyclical no-nonsense scale using mostly bussed-in SO labor with a sprinkling of hired external professionals. But of course in Scientology no sensible act can occur and Dave had to crank it up to 11 , I guess because he likes being 'significant'.

Even when I was inside, I always felt they started from the wrong end. They should start by fixing horrible berthing like the AB before they got to fixing orgs. I'm not sure if the Anthony building has changed any, but when I last saw it in the late 2000s it was still LA's tallest dumpster.

What I did not realize at the time is that the Ideal Orgs were a way to turn liquid assets into real estate without endangering the tax-exempt status (Churches are not supposed to be banks or hoard large amounts of unused money).

2. Costs, engineering, accidents.

Well, I was not an engineer and as Ideal Orgs were the "COBs pet project", we at Inv did not (surprise surprise!) get orders to investigate if the people who planned it are SPs who want to waste money. So I cannot comment on value engineering, that was not a focus for us. We did get into some individual financial stuff (ie: "Did guy X get a bribe to order material Y specifically from company Z" or "Did all the funds raised in org X were in fact sent out, or are they keeping some for themselves?"), but it was really a sideshow with a limited number of cases like that.

Workplace accidents? Different story. We had many cases dealing with that (apparently the management thought us Ethics Gators were the best qualified for the job, rather than safety inspectors or engineers). People falling from heights, cutting themselves with carpeting knives, injuring themselves with a nailer... You name it, we had cases for it. To be honest, most of these cases I delegated to other members of my team due to internal reporting reasons (2D and financial cases got more heat from up high, so I often took these upon myself, accidents were mostly assigned to others). But I was aware of the volume and it was not a marginal thing.

Oh I'd love to hear about the financial irregularities of the fundraising, because we really did not get that many cases for it. I did not get at the time an impression that we are being politely told to look the other way, but maybe that's because I was not aware of the real scale of the problems. I'd love to hear more.

3. People leaving

The way I remember it, population appears to have been stable right up to roughly the Iraq war. Some left, some joined. The trend seems to have shifted roughly in late 2003. We saw more people leaving then before, but it was not overwhelming at first. From 2005 it was clearly the biggest "exodus" anyone seen and by 2006 it was obvious that the levee had broken and that there was a mass of people leaving the church. This would be the flood that would also take myself out, so I have no idea when it ended or reached its zenith.

But it is curious to see a correlation between the trend shift and the "Ideal Org" program.
 
Last edited:
3. People leaving

The way I remember it, population appears to have been stable right up to roughly the Iraq war. Some left, some joined. The trend seems to have roughly in late 2003. We saw more people leaving then before, but it was not overwhelming at first. From 2005 it was clearly the biggest "exodus" anyone seen and by 2006 it was obvious that the levee had broken and that there was a mass of people leaving the church. This would be the flood that would also take myself out, so I have no idea when it ended or reached its zenith.

But it is curious to see a correlation between the trend shift and the "Ideal Org" program.

I think a lot of that might well have been more because of the (justifiably) negative media attention that the 'church' was increasingly receiving - think Tom Cruise jumping on Oprah's couch, Tom Cruise lecturing Matt Lauer on psychiatry, that South Park episode, to name but a few.
 
I think a lot of that might well have been more because of the (justifiably) negative media attention that the 'church' was increasingly receiving - think Tom Cruise jumping on Oprah's couch, Tom Cruise lecturing Matt Lauer on psychiatry, that South Park episode, to name but a few.
I checked the dates and both things happened in 2005.
I wonder - were public scientologists and staff aware of the South Park episode and Cruise couch hopping? Did it have a big impact on them? We in the SO certainly were not aware (Though I privately considered Cruise to be a bag of hot air long before that).
 
I think a lot of that might well have been more because of the (justifiably) negative media attention that the 'church' was increasingly receiving - think Tom Cruise jumping on Oprah's couch, Tom Cruise lecturing Matt Lauer on psychiatry, that South Park episode, to name but a few.
The ideal org evolution didn't cause me to leave, but it started to wake me up. There were things that I knew in regards to financing and undertaking such endeavours that bothered me, but the overt lack of concern for cutting costs to make it happen quickly. There was a thought at first many of us had that we would be helped by management. That went away VERY quickly. People realized that WE were going to have to finance this ourselves. There will be no bail out.

I thought Tom Cruise was overrated as a spokesperson for the church, and that he had certain liabilities. I knew that he thought he had the bully pulpit as a Hollywood star, but was actually not very good at it. I thought the circus of his relationships with Nicole Kidman and Katie Holmes wasn't a great thing, not a plus. The Matt Lauer thing may have kind of been true, but didn't really work, did it? It wasn't great press unless you REALLY drank the kool-aid, and could find good things about disaster. It didn't make me leave. It was embarrassing.
 
Wonderfully informative read. Keep on! :thumbsup:

I remember making a $30 donation one time at Flag. That's my only "dono" ever.
Then GAT I came out. From home, I mailed in my Solo Nots materials with a letter
and left for good. I could see the future. That was my EP from Solo Nots, LOL.

I guess I missed out on a lot of fun from what I'm reading. I would have never made
it through this era if a "$30 donation" is my snapping point. :coolwink:

I knew policies cold and I knew the whole COS was going down a losing and criminal
path. A slippery slope. It was obvious to me.

About a year after I left and turned in my OT7 materials, two Class 9s from Flag
showed up to try to salvage me. (Long story.) They revealed I was the 400th
OT7 person
they had visited at home. At the time I had no idea how many other
Solos Nots people had left, since I lived in a remote region.

But I interrupted your story. Please continue your great writing and story telling. :love8:
This is indeed a compliment, and I thank you!! And btw your story is phenomenal!!

You did miss a lot. It is when it stopped having in mind the servicing of those that wanted it, to buying buildings. If you were there and didn't notice that in some small bit, you were really lost. I wasn't a mega donator for that particular cause. I've given some embarrassing sums to the IAS, but not to the ideal org campaign. But I guess that is all relative?

There were WEEKLY events. WEEKLY. I bet in some given year there may have been fifty events.

There was a low growl from the S.O. reges towards people that didn't donate "enough" to everyone's liking. That growl was passed along as much as possible. I actually heard it today, my other half was still growling at some guys (still in) that didn't attend events hardly, and didn't donate. Your status was know by many. The constant barrage of comm was tremendous.
 
Last edited:
In the book "Escaping Scientology" by Karen Schless Pressley she describes being in David Miscavige's office in 1997 when he said to her: "We can't get people to pay for Scientology services. But we can get them to give plenty of money to the International Association of Scientologists for nothing"

It was the "for nothing" that hit her hard and eventually led her to escaping.
 
Added to the insane regging for Ideal Floors you had the Basics release in '07. That release really pissed off a lot of people.

Started with GAT I '95-96 - squirreling F/N and all. Certs cancelled.
then the Ideal Morg rape (started in '01 in my parts) on-going
then the Bascis '07 - semi-colons fixed - re-buy all your books (again) plus a whole lot more stuff
then Anonymous '08 -- mass protest at all orgs world-wide -- this woke a few peeps up
then Marty & Friends '09 -- St Pete Times devastating series of articles (DM beatings, etc.)

It's all been down-hill since then.
 
The ideal org mess has a weird vibe to it. It's like this:

You live in a house that's just enough, nothing stellar, in fact it could use some work.

Someone comes along and tells you they think you need a new house, and then shows you pictures of new homes they've helped people obtain. The price seems really, really high, but what the hell!

Then twenty people move into your current house to "help" you get the new one. Suddenly the new guys start to have parties every day, and they ask you to pay for these parties. What you have to pay for a party is more than you make in two months, but they have them once each week.

Then someone comes to you and they say "Great news!!! We've figured out how you can pay for a year of parties!! Sign here." You sign here. The next week you are now paying someone's mortgage. But now we are up to having raised 5% of the money needed for your new house.

Big event. Someone from management unveils the news that the price of your new house has doubled. But reassurances from all those people about how much people have liked new houses in other cities keep you going.

Everyone around you is in debt up to their eyebrows, but so proud.

Over time, you have raised over 25 million for your new house. You still don't have it.

Oven ten years have gone by. You sleep in a closet in your old house because the other rooms have all been converted to war rooms. Well, that's what they called the main room for the int reges. Every other room has something going on in it.

Finally, you're getting close to being done. Oops. Someone forgot to add to the price for a (fill in the blank here. Every ideal org had a huge surprise) roof. The roof costs between 500k and 2 million. Now you are paying two mortgages.

The big event is coming!! Whoopie!! Big party!! COB sends you chocolates and chocolate fountains to congratulate you. Now you can start construction.

In this period of time, kids were born and are now in high school, entire regimes have come and gone, some elderly have passed away, several bankruptcies have occurred, marriages made and ended, and made and ended again. You still live in your old house.
 
I've long been saying that I suspect the "ideal orgs" project to be cover for skimming money into certain private pockets.
I have always had that same thought. They have selected several suppliers for certain items, such as the large amount of steel office desks, file cabinets and chairs. Each ideal org has large amounts of donations dedicated to FFE (Furniture, fixtures & equipment).

It might look like this:

$ 10,000,000.00 Building
$ 6,000,000.00 Renovations including site work, remediation, electrical & plumbing, drainage, etc.
$ 4,000,000.00 Meters, books, etc. purchases from Bridge, Gold etc.
$ 8,000,000.00 FFE (Office furniture, other furniture, file cabinets (including CF)

They were very careful to point out that major purchases were arranged with single suppliers. If I could remember some of the names from that video we watched many times!!
 
Last edited:
I have always had that same thought. They have selected several suppliers for certain items, such as the large amount of steel office desks, file cabinets and chairs. Each ideal org has large amounts of donations dedicated to FFE (Furniture, fixtures & equipment).

It might look like this:

$ 10,000,000.00 Building
$ 6,000,000.00 Renovations including site work, remediation, electrical & plumbing, drainage, etc.
$ 4,000,000.00 Meters, books, etc. purchases from Bridge, Gold etc.
$ 8,000,000.00 FFE (Office furniture, other furniture, file cabinets (including CF)

They were very careful to point out that major purchases were arranged with single suppliers. If I could remember some of the names from that video we watched many times!!
I remember at least one or two instances where the "was the best supplier chosen, or was it a bribe/scam/fix thing?" investigation had occurred. So either not all of the supply orders came directly from the top (and thus there was reason room for fraud), or it was all one big song and dance they did for us. I do not think it was the latter, because they were not that smart and we were not that important.
 
.

The IDEAL ORG program is entirely ludicrous on its face.

It's an extension of the Grade Chart, really, if you think about it. Clear and OT are the "IDEAL BEING" that is dreamed up by a con man that promises "everything will be perfect when you get there!"

Naive and credulous culties believed that if you could only have an IDEAL-looking building, everything in Scientology will be perfect when the public gets there.

"Hey nobody is coming into our old org, but wait until we raise 15M dollars in ten years and remodel---and the public gets a load of our new marble floors, it's going to blow them away and they will flood in!"

Who thinks like that? LOL

Let's see how it looks if it's not Scientology that is saving the world with miraculous auditing. Let's play out the same crazed thinking in another venue, just to get a better sense of how incredibly stupid the entire theory is. We now switch to a small town somewhere in the Midwest that consists of 1,400 people and endless corn fields.

The town has one taxi cab driver who rents his cab from a big cab company located in another part of the state. He barely makes a living on fares to take locals to the airport or shopping mall that are both few hours away. But one day a salesman comes to visit with a slick glossy brochure and a pitch about buying a STRETCH LINCOLN LIMOUSINE which will 10X his fares.

1586441962059.jpeg

The simpleton is electrified! Now all he can do is obsessively dream of the glorious day in the future when he owns his own stretch limo and VIPs and CELEBRITIES and POLITICIANS and CORPORATE GIANTS will become his clients. Then he can move out of his tiny studio apartment above Roy's Farm Feed store and then he get himself a nice little house and finally attract a pretty gal! It'll all be so perfect!

Years later he has saved and borrowed enough to put his downpayment on the limo and he gets it!! Eurhoria!

The payments are a lot higher than he wanted and he doesn't exactly own it, but he sure as heck leases it and can drive it any time he wants. So he borrows some more to get an awesome black livery uniform, just like the ones in that brochure!

Now with uniform crisply pressed, he takes his limo through the car wash on day number one of his new ideal limo and his new ideal life.

Gleaming car, sunny day.

Still no customers.

Months go by and his fares are less than they were when he had the old taxi cab. So he calls the salesman who pitched him the IDEAL CAB deal and complains that he's going broke with the new limo payments and there is less business than ever.

The salesman patiently explains that it's because the failing limo driver needs to handle black pr that people have against limousines. And he schedules an appointment to show the driver a new brochure that offers a series of books and training courses of how to market limousine services and handle resistive customers. And best of all when he completes the training courses his limo business will boom!

The limo driver hears the price of the training and says he can't afford it, he's broke. But the salesman says, it's no problem he doesn't have to pay for it all in cash..they can refinance his lease and just add the new purchases to his monthly lease payments.

He hesitates, worried to death that he's already behind in his current lease. The salesman looks at him with great blinkless sincerity and asks: "You do want your limo business to flourish and prosper, right? You do realize that after your training, your limo sales will 5X, right? You do want to have an ideal business and an ideal life, don't you?"

The limo driver sighs and takes the pen to sign it with "I sure hope this works, okay". He signs it and feels for that moment quite ideal again.

.
 
.

The IDEAL ORG program is entirely ludicrous on its face.

It's an extension of the Grade Chart, really, if you think about it. Clear and OT are the "IDEAL BEING" that is dreamed up by a con man that promises "everything will be perfect when you get there!"

Naive and credulous culties believed that if you could only have an IDEAL-looking building, everything in Scientology will be perfect when the public gets there.

"Hey nobody is coming into our old org, but wait until we raise 15M dollars in ten years and remodel---and the public gets a load of our new marble floors, it's going to blow them away and they will flood in!"

Who thinks like that? LOL

Let's see how it looks if it's not Scientology that is saving the world with miraculous auditing. Let's play out the same crazed thinking in another venue, just to get a better sense of how incredibly stupid the entire theory is. We now switch to a small town somewhere in the Midwest that consists of 1,400 people and endless corn fields.

The town has one taxi cab driver who rents his cab from a big cab company located in another part of the state. He barely makes a living on fares to take locals to the airport or shopping mall that are both few hours away. But one day a salesman comes to visit with a slick glossy brochure and a pitch about buying a STRETCH LINCOLN LIMOUSINE which will 10X his fares.

View attachment 2683

The simpleton is electrified! Now all he can do is obsessively dream of the glorious day in the future when he owns his own stretch limo and VIPs and CELEBRITIES and POLITICIANS and CORPORATE GIANTS will become his clients. Then he can move out of his tiny studio apartment above Roy's Farm Feed store and then he get himself a nice little house and finally attract a pretty gal! It'll all be so perfect!

Years later he has saved and borrowed enough to put his downpayment on the limo and he gets it!! Eurhoria!

The payments are a lot higher than he wanted and he doesn't exactly own it, but he sure as heck leases it and can drive it any time he wants. So he borrows some more to get an awesome black livery uniform, just like the ones in that brochure!

Now with uniform crisply pressed, he takes his limo through the car wash on day number one of his new ideal limo and his new ideal life.

Gleaming car, sunny day.

Still no customers.

Months go by and his fares are less than they were when he had the old taxi cab. So he calls the salesman who pitched him the IDEAL CAB deal and complains that he's going broke with the new limo payments and there is less business than ever.

The salesman patiently explains that it's because the failing limo driver needs to handle black pr that people have against limousines. And he schedules an appointment to show the driver a new brochure that offers a series of books and training courses of how to market limousine services and handle resistive customers. And best of all when he completes the training courses his limo business will boom!

The limo driver hears the price of the training and says he can't afford it, he's broke. But the salesman says, it's no problem he doesn't have to pay for it all in cash..they can refinance his lease and just add the new purchases to his monthly lease payments.

He hesitates, worried to death that he's already behind in his current lease. The salesman looks at him with great blinkless sincerity and asks: "You do want your limo business to flourish and prosper, right? You do realize that after your training, your limo sales will 5X, right? You do want to have an ideal business and an ideal life, don't you?"

The limo driver sighs and takes the pen to sign it with "I sure hope this works, okay". He signs it and feels for that moment quite ideal again.

.
When you put it like that, it's make one wonder "WHAT IN THE HELLS WAS I THINKING!!!"

But that is exactly so. So the WHY is (since we are so smart and blessed with the Data Series) "The public is not coming into our orgs in droves because our buildings look like third world markets. Therefore when our buildings look like the lobby of The Commerce Bank of Beverly Hills, we will get enough public to clear the planet."

Ask a general person on the street "Would you consider going into a Church of Scientology?" The answer is:

1. Church of what??
2. Not those crooks!!
3. I would if their buildings looked like The Commerce Bank of Beverly Hills. But until then I will be a wog thank you!
 
Ask a general person on the street "Would you consider going into a Church of Scientology?" The answer is:

1. Church of what??
2. Not those crooks!!
3. I would if their buildings looked like The Commerce Bank of Beverly Hills. But until then I will be a wog thank you!
I think the real (and sad) answer would be:

4. I would, if the body router had a body like the 4th wife of the CEO of The Commerce Bank of Beverly Hills.
 
Back
Top