onceuponatime
Well-known member
not sure what you mean by operating costs, so here is a list i picked up off a Quicken blog as what should be a common way to look at it:
it still looks to me like there are probably $100k+ base operating costs for any org -- the utilities costs of a huge 'ideal' building will more or less wipe out the savings of not paying commercial lease rates for the previous modest types of space just about 30% the size.
- rent -- n/a for 'ideal' orgs, but the standard utilities for a 50k sq ft are about $100k per year, and even if they skimp it could well be 1.5 to 2 times that regardless in extreme climates. for regular orgs it's still probably $100k - $250k for rent and utilities.
- inventory costs -- minimal except when new editions mean throwing out unsold stock
- equipment -- computers, copiers etc.
- insurance -- presumably n/a
- payroll -- negligible
- marketing -- sending out flyers must cost each org a lot
- other overhead costs -- property maintenance is my guess for the largest. but there must be unique payments to CoS entities.
the orgs that can no longer keep regular hours have got to be the canary in the coal mine, but i wonder how many others still can't make expenses all the time.
if figure that DM will keep them all open regardless of the cost, lest his myth of 'expansion' be proven incontrovertibly to be a lie. if they reduced operations to skeleton staffs just using a small part of the 'ideal' buildings and turned utilities down to uninhabitable levels in the rest, they could probably significantly pare costs.
we'd of course know a lot more if we got a recent defector from management at a high enough level and with a good enough head for figures, to provide some really solid info about what's going on. though even one or two people with good numbers for presumably average orgs would still give us some insight.
Operating costs of 100k per year, or even 200k, still only comes out to 4k/week. That should be a pathetic number for even struggling ideal orgs.
Non ideal orgs won't necessarily have cheaper utilities, and they have rent which can be quite a lot. With rent they might need to average 10k+ per week to "break even" and I think that would be more of a struggle. Especially for the orgs that haven't gone ideal already, they aren't exactly the big booming ones.
Roughest of estimates here, (I'm an accountant with some accessories) might be around 50k/year for a "bought the building" ideal org scenario. But 50k - 100k, pretty close. This money can be raised from several donors over a year of regging incidents, as needed. I've seen this exact sort of regging happen over the years. Local "financial flaps" are kept off lines as much as possible.
Thanks for the numbers, and yes that's my experience as well. Orgs will do everything possible to keep it off management lines. That might even be what happened with joburg, the org just didn't tell management. I don't believe management would know electric was being shut off and just go oh well. I think it's more likely the local execs didn't want to tell management and tried to handle things themselves, which obviously didn't work.
Orgs always operated short of money, even when income was decent. Most of the money then went "uplines" to pay for lawyers, PIs etc.
That "uplines" cash flow no longer exists.
DM no longer can afford the kind of OSA infrastructure needed to intimidate critics and "fair game" apostates and squirrels.
I don't think orgs ever sent a significant amount up lines, that's only flag. The stat to really watch is flags GI. Good luck getting PT info on that though.
except that direct regging of whales by int management for IAS statuses became a substitute source for that cash flow, didn't it?
still, i have my suspicions that is also starting to dry up -- though just one mega whale like Trish Duggan could probably make up for it if squeezed extra hard. (and i've wondered what would happen if TC retires from making moves and turns scn into his hobby, reaching into his very deep pockets)
i'd say signs are OSA is still doing plenty, now more focused on those bringing suits against the CoS, and at the Aftermath Foundation. do you think that's not really comparable?
still, like with keeping open orgs that are showing increasing signs of insolvency, i suspect that either they're at least no longer able to continue to build up reserves like they have for decades (internal accounting can make DM's 'stat' appear to continue to rise by increasing the book value of properties), or even have had to start spending them down under 'emergency' justifications (the pandemic could well have triggered and justified that, at a point of decline where it was going to be inevitable before long anyway).
i'm genuinely interested in what's going on, and asking questions regarding things i'd be happy to be better informed about by those with relevant experience or better information.
I think finances will continue to be an issue and will only become more and more of a problem. But their pressing concern is staff. They are starting to resort to some pretty extreme measures to get people back on staff, really pulling out all the stops and trying to steam roll any obstacles. They want to get back to the highs of 2017ish, without all the financial stuff of course.
Last edited:


