i've been very frustrated about the lack of any sort of recent information, like actual membership numbers, or accounts of the effects of the pandemic on activities. i suspect a number of factors are at work:
* defectors with high level insider knowledge are being bought off with NDAs based on ongoing payments to ensure compliance, after the Debbie Cook debacle -- and perhaps also looking to what it took to shut down Marty Rathbun
* many of those remaining in international management are diehards who will only leave feet first -- and who are being taken care of internally in their old age, to ensure they aren't wandering around telling tales
* there aren't proportionally as many people left to leave, as the CoS has shrunk, so the pool of potential sources and whistleblowers is just that much smaller
* those who do leave, particularly at the lower levels and public members, may be totally burned out after hanging on far too long over fear of ethics and disconnection, and just want to put it all behind them and not even talk about it -- i think that's part of what we're seeing in the indie field, where they don't seem to be getting a flow of people like they used to coming out of the CoS and looking to try to practice the 'good' in the tech, when members finally leave now it seems they're done with the 'subject'
also, i think those left including 'public' members have mostly been winnowed down to a hard core that is particularly gullible and overcommitted, and is blind to the decline and readily falls for the claims of 'expansion'.
I wish we had some more recent high level leaks, but I doubt we'll be seeing many more of those. There have been a few lower level leaks recently, the NY org stuff, there was some stuff about Tampa, I think there was also a post from a supposed group in the Portland area that was going to leak stuff? but I don't think anything came from them. Also, we've had the leaks posted on Ortega's site. I'm sure there's more I'm forgetting. I think we will start to see more of these type of lower level leaks as more and more people become disillusioned and leave.
I think that Scientology, and especially Class V/SO orgs, are at a critical point. For the most part they have an aging staff and they are not getting new people to join staff/SO at anywhere near what they need to. And of the younger generation, they are far less likely to stay and devote their whole life. They might do a contract or stay in the SO for a few years, but they aren't at the point where they are willing to devote everything to it. In my opinion Scientology has actually made it worse for themselves with their continual fundraising and turning the big donors into the true VIPs. No one wants to be a staff/SO auditor, they want to be the next mega donor. They got rid of Auditor's day as an int event, but the IAS event is still there. I think you're right that those who are left have been for the most part winnowed of any who would leave. The ones left are the hardcore, blind and overcommitted who will never leave. But they are getting older and they don't have replacements for all of them.
The last two ideal orgs, KC and Columbus are a sign of things to come. Right now, it is not common for Class V orgs to be manned by SO members, but that's the only thing that I see working as far as keeping orgs open. So right now it isn't the norm, but I think we will start seeing more of it. That's one of the reasons I'm so interested in Austin and Chicago, will they be manned by SO members? Or will they have enough staff to put together a token crew for the opening at least? They've had a lot of extra time to recruit, so I wouldn't be surprised if they do actually open manned by Class V staff, they've had SO missions recruiting full time for years at this point. But if they have to be manned by SO I think it will be a sign that things are even worse than I'm currently estimating.
The next 10-20 years will be interesting for Scientology. I think 20 years from now Scientology will be much different. It already pretty much only exists in CW and LA, I think this is only going to become more and more true.
that sounds like a very odd cult indeed. i know of a curiously similar one where they do much the same, only dressed as upmarket hotel staff:
i do want to state categorically that i agree with, and think it's best to work off the assumption of, the conventional wisdom that people join high control groups or cults when they are at points of vulnerability, not because they're gullible or stupid; they may even have been people who were somewhat above average in intellectual curiosity, or in desire to better themselves and care for the world around them. however, when it comes to those who stay long term in an uber cult like the CoS, i think all bets are off.
and, well, i guess there's maybe also a point when it comes to a group that has accumulated such widespread notoriety that they have become the subject of continual criticism and even ridicule in the media, and are constant fodder for checkout stand tabloids, maybe at that point it does take a special sort of person to still fall for it in spite of all the warning signs....
The study of cults and what makes people join/stay is very interesting. I think the post on Ortega's site today does a good job of giving an example of how it happens. I think humans are extremely adaptable, all of a sudden all the crazy stuff in Scientology becomes the norm and you just go with the flow. Snapping out of it at that point can be hard. Once you're conditioned to something it doesn't seem crazy, it's the usual. Scientology does a good job of exerting control over its members (especially people on staff and in the SO) and doesn't give people an opportunity to step back and look at things. Verbal tech, don't discuss your case, only look to LRH for the solution, etc. are all policies that make it hard for you to break free of the hold Scientology puts on you. The prison of belief is a real thing.
Side note, all of that stuff about Class V orgs not being manned by SO, that picture is Orlando. I'm 95% sure those are SO members in the photo. Flag has run Tampa for a while. I wonder if they were ordered to take Orlando under their wing and boom it. Of course they can't. It isn't good management or Tampa being on policy that's made Tampa big. Tampa is the only Scientology org that actually gets a steady flow of new Scientologists, not brand new Scientologists, but people moving to the area. Orlando doesn't have that, so it's going to stay small.
I think the intent was for CC orgs to be established where there were lots of people in the entertainment industry residing (mainly NY and LA) and try to help the careers of Scn celebrities, who would then promote Scientology.
Regular orgs would not have any focus on helping the careers of their regular public.
I think that was kind of the idea, but like many things with Scientology they didn't really have a good idea of what they were doing.
The difference between a CC and a Class V org was the CC had the presidents office in Div 7 who is supposed to handle celebs. They are also supposed to have different delivery areas for celebs. I don't know of any that actually had that though, they were just Class V orgs competing with the other Class V org in the same city for the most part.
LRH also made it confusing because he gave some broad definitions of who a celebrity was. This then justified the creation of CCs where there weren't any real celebs. They'd use the LRH definition to justify the creation/existence of a CC, but in reality they wanted the CC network to attract actual celebrities.
Maybe a CC in LA/NY makes sense. Dallas? Portland? Nashville? I don't see it. While they may have said a CC was for anyone who was an artist, they actually wanted a celeb with name recognition. Typical Scientology, confusing itself and overly complicating things.