While there certainly is truth in your belief that "they were both monsters in their own right", I hold Hubbard 110% responsible for the damage caused by Miscavige for these reasons:
1) Hubbard
created the Scientology cult, knew David Miscavige, and allowed him to get into the most senior levels of international management. Given that he was in charge of the Watchdog Committee, Author Services, CMO, and the All Clear Unit. The first three were the highest and most critical international management units in Scientology back at that time. So it is irrelevant whether Hubbard created the monster or not that DM became. He allowed him to get to the most senior management positions. Whether it was his idea or not he approved it at some point.
2) The power structure of a destructive cult like Scientology along with the insane beliefs Scientologists were indoctrinated in (such as KSW, Fair Game, and others) can cause good people to act in evil ways, and enable evil people to be infinitely more destructive when within the cult. DM would never have been able to get away with his torture and imprisonment of so many at the Int Base had Hubbard not created a religious cult with First Amendment protections. The research by Zimbardo
details how situational forces and group dynamics can work in concert to make monsters out of decent men and women. It explains to a large degree why even some good people that became Scientologists acted in an evil way, and why sociopaths like Miscavige become even eviler
.
APA PsycNet
How Good People Turn Evil: The Stanford Prison Experiment
Psychologist Philip Zimbardo once carried out a controversial experiment about how good people turn evil: the Stanford prison experiment.
exploringyourmind.com
I'll mention something else about Author Services, the organization that DM had been in charge of. Wikipedia describes its purpose as:
"an entity to manage Hubbard's literary and financial affairs" It also served other purposes which involved the management of Scientology itself. I know this first hand. Back in 1988, I worked for SOCO INT ( Social Coordination International, which managed the Narconon network, The Way to Happiness Foundation International, Applied Scholastics, etc back at that time. Now it's ABLE that has that function). I assisted the woman in charge of a mission whose purpose was to expand Dianetics and Scientology into China. We sent about a dozen celebrities there that did a series of concerts around the country. And there was a promotion of Dianetics and Applied Scholastics in the country as well. Martha Levitsky, the Mission I/C, who normally was the Treasury Chief at SOCO was being overseen by Author Services while she was running this mission. So Wikipedia's description of Author Services is a bit misleading.
Praise Xenu that our dissemination efforts over there have ultimately failed. Scientology and mainland China are not on good terms! CoS is one of the organizations listed here:
Global Call to Join a Diplomatic Boycott of the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics
www.civicus.org
This is one of the main points about abusive cults and the abusers who create them.
Take, for instance, Rinder. I'm certain that he's a good guy who did a tremendous amount of bad things. He implemented all of those bad things in an effort to do good.
That's what cults do.
They're so subversive that they make good people do terrible things.
Scientology, Islam, the progressive Queer Woke Cult do this to people. The more that a person immerses themselves into these cult cultures the worse it gets for them and the loss of themselves. It appears that this immersion is an effort to purify themselves or something.
I know someone who lost their adult child to college indoctrination. They weren't liberated they were toxically transformed into a Scientology dedicated glare mindset of activist hatred and tilting at windmills of all the conspiracy theories that they were indoctrinated with - "the patriarchy", "intersectionality", "heteronormativity", "rape culture", "gender spectrum/binary" and all the sundry "oppressions" of Capitalism, etc. I actually know several families that experienced this.
This is what happens with cults.
Fortunately, I was never in a position where I could do harm to others in Scientology. I was always on the fence and I hope that I would've passed the test and not performed harm but I have no idea if that's the case.
Rinder failed...others have too. I'm sure he was trying to be a "good" Scientologist. That's the nature of ideological possession and it's cure - whether "fast" or "slow" - we all go through the very same. For me it was a combination of both.
This is why cults have apostates. These apostates are viciously attacked by the cults. The existence of apostates AND victims is a sure sign of a cult.
Scientology has apostates - Rinder is one of them...many of us are, too.
Islam has apostates. These people often wind up dead.
The Queer Woke Cult has apostates. #WalkAway, Rubin, Owens, et al.
All three of these have many, many victims...some are dead.
With apologies to Dr. Peterson, and an open invitation to him to amend and augment the following (he is the clinician, after all), here, for diagnostic purposes, is a list of symptoms of ideological possession—that most fatal of epistemic diseases.
fee.org
List of Symptoms for Diagnostic Purposes
Major Symptoms
- The possessed insists that anyone who disfavors a specific view or policy must also reject the basic moral value that, to the possessed individual, justifies that view or policy. This is the fallacy of the assumed paradigm. (L: “If you won’t let mothers protect their children with guns, you’re a misogynist.” C: “People who favor gun control don’t value freedom.” P: “People against regulating firearms don’t care about violence against children.”)
- The possessed uses one-dimensional labels for people they’ve never met and who clearly aren’t one-dimensional as a means of dismissing the value of all their beliefs or actions. (L: “Churchill was a mass-murderer.” C: “Gandhi was a pedophile.” P: “Thatcher was a witch.”)
- Related to the above, the possessed will regard a few quotes or actions by an individual as proof that the individual is evil without regard to context, appreciation that everyone is a product of his time, recognition that people change over time, or consideration of other quotes and actions that provide evidence against the claimed ill intent of the individual in question.
- The possessed advocates worse treatment of people within a specified group than others. (P: “Straight white men have privilege and so should have their opinions discounted or suppressed.” L: “People who work for the state initiate violence, and it is ok to use violence against those who initiate violence.” C: “People who burn the flag are traitors and should be punished as such.”)
- The possessed believes that a single principle provides answers to most important moral and political questions, disregarding reasonable moral intuitions to the contrary (precisely because they are to the contrary) and any uncertainty regarding the precise meaning or application of the principle. (P: “Equality.” L: “Non-aggression.” C: “Biblical authority.”)
- When the results of an ideologically justified action are the opposite of those intended or used to justify that action in the first place, the possessed is convinced that not only is the action not the cause of any resulting problem but that more of the same action will eventually solve that problem. (P: “Venezuela needs more socialism.” C: “We need more unprovoked military involvement in conflicts that don’t involve us.” L: “Europe should open its borders immediately to everyone.”)
Minor Symptoms
- The possessed enjoys opportunities to defend what he believes more than opportunities to make his beliefs more accurate.
- The possessed collects data that support her beliefs instead of seeking data that would help her correct false beliefs.
- The possessed offers unsolicited opinions without any empathic engagement with the recipient or any interest in whether she is in any state to be positively influenced by them.
- The possessed would rather reform society’s institutions to better serve his ideology than reform his ideology to better serve people.
Immunity, Pathology, and Cure
Fortunately, the epistemic immune system of most mentally healthy people protects them from ideological possession. The core of the immune response—and indeed an effective cure—is Love of Truth, specifically the holding of Truth as the highest moral value.
Love of Truth, in fact, provides a near-perfect protection against ideological possession.
Pathologically, ideological possession may even be understood as the substitution of that highest value by another.
Love of Truth, in fact, provides a near-perfect protection against ideological possession because the disease, while deadly, has no defense against the honest admission by the afflicted of his or her symptoms.
Nevertheless, the most pernicious and subtle feature of the disease prevents the possessed from seeking treatment or treating himself: ideological possession can disguise itself in the mind of the afflicted as that very same Love of Truth that, in its authentic form, would cure it.
What conditions, then, enable those in the grip of ideological possession—whose love of Truth may have already been replaced by a counterfeit—to cure themselves?
To answer that, it is important to understand the symbiotic relationship of the disease with its host.
Although epidemics of ideological possession can be fatal to entire societies, the disease provides immediate benefits to the individual who is afflicted, such as intellectual certainty and stability, feelings of moral superiority, an apparent simplification of life’s difficult decisions and questions, avoidance of true moral responsibility, and a sense of belonging among others similarly afflicted. All of these tend to prevent self-treatment.
The painful shock activates the Love of Truth long enough to locate the cause of the pain.
Accordingly, the cures for ideological possession tend to be external and unsought. They nevertheless exist and fall into two broad categories—fast cures and slow cures.
Fast cures tend to be triggered by a catastrophic failure of one or more of the above benefits to the afflicted individual. This may occur when, despite the highly motivated perception and reasoning of the possessed individual, she experiences an unexpected, painful, and shocking outcome of an ideologically motivated action. The painful shock activates the Love of Truth long enough to locate the cause of the pain, forcing the afflicted to admit the symptoms, and therefore identify the disease for what it is, effecting the rapid cure.
Slow cures tend to involve a rising awareness by one afflicted individual of the same disease in friends or others with whom she identifies. This can be induced when the individual sees inconsistencies in those others’ words and actions that cause direct harm to others and to the stated goals of the possessing ideology. (In theory, this slow cure could be induced by observations of one’s own actions under ideological possession, but this is prevented by the self-righteousness that is felt when one acts in the grip of the disease.)