Ann Bailey

Again, Janis Gillham Grady was with Hubbard in Florida during the period in question. Other persons who were responsible for his personal safety 24/7 were there also (Steve "Sarge" Pfauth in particular). He couldn't go anywhere without a medical personal assistant (Jim Dincalci or Kima Douglas) because of his medical issues per their own public statements.

You've had since the Clearwater Hearings in 1982 to produce even one corroborating witness from the Guardian Office, the Celebrity Center, or any other person who would have to have been involved in this conspiracy to get Hubbard in that room with that woman.

You are actually attacking Janis Grady's credibility as a witness directly and personally involved in Hubbard's affairs at the time. In fact, you seem to be insinuating that she and other close personal staff were involved in it and are covering it up.

I guess that makes you a conspiracy theory nutjob. I don't know why I failed to see it long ago.

.
Relax dude, you don't need to spew insults and accusations about "conspiracy theory nutjobs" against others just because they think it's "possible" that Hubbard engaged in sleazy activities other than the sleazy, criminal activities that we already have hard proof of.

You don't need to defend Hubbard. He's arguably one of the biggest criminal frauds that lived in the 20th century. And if you are going to try to defend Hubbard, try gathering up some exculpatory evidence first. When you try to position Janis Grady as an "alibi witness" it's really lame because Janis Grady did not live with L. Ron Hubbard 24 hours a day 7 days a week to know what he was or was not doing every single minute.

Your credibility is badly damaged when you leap to Hubbard's aid so often with the "snarling defense"--the way Hubbard ordered Scientologists like you to do on his behalf (when he is criticized) in the HCO BULLETIN "The Responsibility of Leaders". That's a bad Scientological "tell" and "hangover" that you'd fare a lot better without.


.
 
Last edited:
On another note....didn't one of Hubbard's daughters have an Apartment at the Manor on an upper floor...?

After the building was acquired in 1973 (CC had been renting it before that), the uppermost floors were all renovated into organizational office spaces. Henning Heldt of the Guardian Office had the 6th Floor as his office during the FBI Raid, for example. There was no 7th Floor luxury suite as described in Bailey Affidavit at that time.
 
Let's get in the mood with a little music...


"You are a master. You are as sexy and sensitive as Pan. Lord help women when you begin to fondle them.
You are master of their bodies, master of their souls as you may consciously wish.
You have no karma to pay for these acts.
You cannot now accumulate karma because you are a master adept.
Your voice is low and compelling to them. Singing to them, for you sing like a master, destroys their will to resist..."


From L. Ron Hubbard's Affirmations​



....

You are actually attacking Janis Grady's credibility as a witness directly and personally involved in Hubbard's affairs at the time. In fact, you seem to be insinuating that she and other close personal staff were involved in it and are covering it up.

I'm doing no such thing. Although, inadvertently, I have allowed you to trick me into making this about Janis when it's not. But now that she's part of the discussion, so be it.

I guess that makes you a conspiracy theory nutjob. I don't know why I failed to see it long ago.

Uh huh.

Janis Gillam Grady was a legal adult at the time in question.

Also, you clearly couldn't be bothered to read her books because, I guess, you already falsely imagine you know everything about Ron Hubbard, so why should you bother with the account of any close personal associate, right ? There is a healthy dose of greatly derogatory material about Ron Hubbard in her books (his womanizing and unfaithfulness to his wife, Mary Sue Hubbard for instance), so you are just wrong about Janis being "protective".

I haven't read her books, but it's good that she's written about her time in the cult. Everyone has a different perspective.

As an aside, a while back someone posted videos of a slide presentation that Janis made to Ron's Org - Ron's Org regards Hubbard as the galactic hero, and commander of sector nine of the galaxy. They revere Hubbard. I doubt if Ron's Orgs would have invited Jon Atack, or Mike Rinder, or Hana Eltringham to make a slide presentation.

She has been torpedoing false reports about Hubbard for many years

....

I'm sure you have found that irritating and inconvenient.

Not at all. I believe in free speech. I'm not a Scientologist.

So you are calling her a liar now, but you lack the manhood to do so directly.

I didn't even mention Janis, till you started doing you instigator/"third party" routine.

Edit addition: since you have seen fit to propagandize against Janis, I've notified her and asked her to drop by to comment.

You need to take a cold shower.

After the building was acquired in 1973 (CC had been renting it before that), the uppermost floors were all renovated into organizational office spaces. Henning Heldt of the Guardian Office had the 6th Floor as his office during the FBI Raid, for example. There was no 7th Floor luxury suite as described in Bailey Affidavit at that time.

What is your point? That Ann Bailey miscounted the number of floors, or typed the 7 instead of 6 in her affidavit?

And I'd have to review the affidavit, which I'm not going to do at this time. I've not asserted that it's true, only that it exists, and should not be completely discounted.

As a general rule, I don't think people who come forward as rape victims should be ignored.

I haven't called anyone a liar.

I am calling L. Ron Hubbard a child abuser, who used children as his servants, in a destructive cult, of which he was the unquestioned, unchallenged, cult leader, Source, and Commodore.

Does that make you angry too?
 
Last edited:
The only other reference I can find to Ann Bailey is her story of her time in the tunnels under the Cedars. Parts of the story read like something out of 'Night of the Living Dead'. To me it sounds somewhat theatrical, but who can say? I wonder what became of her.


A former Sea Org member described Ann Bailey as tall and aristocratic-looking with red hair.

That's the only additional informational I have on the topic.
 
There was no 7th Floor luxury suite as described in Bailey Affidavit at that time.

to the best of your awareness and recollection.

you could well be right.

on the other hand, i have also seen people as certain as you seem to be, proven wrong by the emergence of incontrovertible evidence demonstrating that either their memories of facts and/or dates were inaccurate, or that they were unaware of some part of what was actually going on.
 
Last edited:
The only other reference I can find to Ann Bailey is her story of her time in the tunnels under the Cedars. Parts of the story read like something out of 'Night of the Living Dead'. To me it sounds somewhat theatrical, but who can say? I wonder what became of her.


Being a contemporary of Ann at the time of this Incident (I don't really recall her), I can attest that this story has gross factual errors and should be discounted.

The dream-like content should make anyone suspicious of its veracity.

Being sleep-deprived can make one recall the content of dreams as actuality; this is a possible explanation.
 
.


"There was no 7th Floor luxury suite as described
in Bailey Affidavit at that time."

-expert witness certified in floor counting
​

to the best of your awareness and recollection. you could well be right. on the other hand, i have also seen people as certain as you seem to be, proven wrong by the emergence of incontrovertible evidence demonstrating that either their memories of facts and/or dates were inaccurate, or that they were unaware of some part of what was actually going on.


Yes, eyewitnesses so often diametrically disagree!

Contrary to the "no 7th floor" theory, I read yet another declaration where the affiant (Nigel Tufnel)
swore under penalty of perjury that the elevator in that building went up to 11.



.
 
Last edited:
Being a contemporary of Ann at the time of this Incident (I don't really recall her), I can attest that this story has gross factual errors and should be discounted.

The dream-like content should make anyone suspicious of its veracity.

Being sleep-deprived can make one recall the content of dreams as actuality; this is a possible explanation.

thanks for that bit of experienced insight. the conditions sea org members live and work under are well worth taking into consideration; and i think it's no accident that they, as is actually typical of those in high control groups, are kept in a state of sleep deprivation (and limited diet), which among other things starts to blur their connection to reality.

on the other hand, keep in mind that it's been shown that the victims of trauma like rape, often have reactions and memories that don't conform to what people who haven't had such extreme experiences, think they should be or which even seem counter-intuitive to laypersons.

dissociation is actually a common response to being raped. as is having trouble remembering details correctly.
 
The OP only linked to an excerpt of Ann's affidavit, which had been published
in a book. Here's the whole affidavit, start to finish. Let's see if anyone has got
the time and interest to read the whole thing and give us a report on her potential
reliability as a witness and accurate chronicler of her era. I remember this exact
topic being argued on the previous ESMB a few times. I thought it had been put
to bed, so to speak, but I was very wrong by the looks of it. :coolwink:

EXHIBIT 67: AFFIDAVIT OF ANN BAILEY
Anyone? :LOL:

Maybe Tony O can hunt her up and interview her for us "in a new unit of time,"
so we can rest easy. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
thanks for that bit of experienced insight. the conditions sea org members live and work under are well worth taking into consideration; and i think it's no accident that they, as is actually typical of those in high control groups, are kept in a state of sleep deprivation (and limited diet), which among other things starts to blur their connection to reality.

on the other hand, keep in mind that it's been shown that the victims of trauma like rape, often have reactions and memories that don't conform to what people who haven't had such extreme experiences, think they should be or which even seem counter-intuitive to laypersons.

dissociation is actually a common response to being raped. as is having trouble remembering details correctly.


Having experienced the inside of the cult of Scientology, I can confidently state that I lack confidence in the truth of "bizarre narratives" told by Scientologists unless there is some kind of corroborative support.

Simultaneously, I lack confidence in assuming that just because someone's narrative is entirely bizarre beyond belief—that it's not true.

This is the nature of cults.

Imagine a simple German village in 1944 where a crazy-eyed person wanders into the town and claims that they escaped an evil prison where millions of innocent people were being murdered. The simple folks in that town would normally react with horrified disbelief in this "crazy" individual's story.

There is very little I would not be willing to believe could have happened when it pertains to Hubbard, Miscavige and their henchmen—if a modicum of proof was presented. Once you've realized that murder is something Scientology gurus would have no problem with (if they thought they could get away with it) pretty much any other extremes of evil and insanity would only elicit a blithe "sure-why-not?" shrug.

.
 
Last edited:
dissociation is actually a common response to being raped. as is having trouble remembering details correctly.


.

In the theme park known as ScientologyLand, dissociation (and depersonalization) are not indicia of severe trauma and mental illness.

As you likely already know, such phenomena are, instead, often celebrated by the individual attesting to an advanced level or receiving a fancy completion certificate for having successfully attained the OT ability called "EXTERIORIZATION".



[from MAYO CLINIC website]:​

Overview​
Depersonalization-derealization disorder occurs when you persistently or repeatedly have the feeling that you're observing yourself from outside your body or you have a sense that things around you aren't real, or both. Feelings of depersonalization and derealization can be very disturbing and may feel like you're living in a dream. . .​
​
​
.​
 
Depersonalization-derealization disorder occurs when you persistently or repeatedly have the feeling that you're observing yourself from outside your body or you have a sense that things around you aren't real, or both. Feelings of depersonalization and derealization can be very disturbing and may feel like you're living in a dream. . .​
.​


I think an editorial note on "exteriorization" could be added to that.

Just because Scientology drives people into nutty states where their mental illness and delusions are regarded as "OT POWERS", there is nothing that dissuades me from simultaneously thinking that there actually COULD be an "out of body" state at the other end of the life spectrum that is as magnificent as it is miraculous.

The universe (from my infinitely limited perspective) does seem to always provide "counter-balances" for all extremes and things that exist, both good and bad. In other words, just because no Scientologist in history can demonstrate the state of exterior, that is no reason at all to assume the state doesn't exist in some form, even if unrecognizable from Scientology's descriptions and beliefs.

CONCLUSION: I'll have much more to say about the mysteries of the universe when I come back to Earth 835 million years from now and I've had a little time to catch up on reading what man discovered after February 8th 2022.


.
 
.


"There was no 7th Floor luxury suite as described
in Bailey Affidavit at that time."

-expert witness certified in floor counting
​




Yes, eyewitnesses so often diametrically disagree!

Contrary to the "no 7th floor" theory, I read yet another declaration where the affiant (Nigel Tufnel)
swore under penalty of perjury that the elevator in that building went up to 11.



.


........"there was no second wife"............
 
The OP only linked to an excerpt of Ann's affidavit, which had been published
in a book. Here's the whole affidavit, start to finish. Let's see if anyone has got
the time and interest to read the whole thing and give us a report on her potential
reliability as a witness and accurate chronicler of her era. I remember this exact
topic being argued on the previous ESMB a few times. I thought it had been put
to bed, so to speak, but I was very wrong by the looks of it. :coolwink:

EXHIBIT 67: AFFIDAVIT OF ANN BAILEY
Anyone? :LOL:

Maybe Tony O can hunt her up and interview her for us "in a new unit of time,"
so we can rest easy. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I read the whole affidavit some time ago and, for the most part, found it to be drearily realistic. As for the parts that made it into print, not so much.
 
Is there a 7th floor? Hmmmm . . . .

90

Chateau Elysee, 1929 | Ralph Morris Collection
Courtesy of the Los Angeles Public Library
​
 
Is there a 7th floor? Hmmmm . . .

Of course there is a 7th Floor. There probably was a luxury penthouse suite at some point, too.

That is, before C of S bought the building outright in 1973 and then renovated it and made the upper floors into office spaces.
 
Being a contemporary of Ann at the time of this Incident (I don't really recall her), I can attest that this story has gross factual errors and should be discounted.

The dream-like content should make anyone suspicious of its veracity.

Being sleep-deprived can make one recall the content of dreams as actuality; this is a possible explanation.

Sleep deprivation would be a factor to consider. And there are other factors.

Susan Meister comes to mind.

susan.gif

​
Of course, in that case, there was a dead body left behind. Much more difficult to make disappear. Has there been conclusive agreement on that?

All sorts of inconsistency can be found in accounts, testimony, affidavits. Five people witness an incident and have five different descriptions - descriptions that vary as to some detail or another.

Is it a pure fabrication? A hoax? Perhaps a malicious hoax written by a suppressive person? Or just a bored merry prankster?

Or is it a recollection of a person in a state of shock or PTSD?

What was the person's mental state at the time of its writing?

I have never experienced being asked to write down a traumatic experience on paper. Have you?

These are all valid questions.

My attitude is what it's always been. I'm agnostic. What holds my attention slightly is a reluctance to dismiss completely the testimony of a possible traumatized rape victim.

More interesting than the affidavit itself is the reaction to it.
 
More interesting than the affidavit is that only the racy parts were picked to be published and nothing else. Got to sell a book, I guess.
 
More interesting than the affidavit is that only the racy parts were picked to be published and nothing else. Got to sell a book, I guess.


The title of the chapter was provocative, but the content is disturbing not "racy."

Rape is not "racy."
 
Back
Top