Ruth Minshull

Anyone know if Ruth Minshull is still in the land of the living? She has not posted to her blog since 2016 but I find no reference to her passing. In her blog she left her current thoughts on LRH to herself.


Have you checked with "find a grave"? to see if she's still in the land of the living?

Could you pinpoint, or quote, her thoughts on Hubbard? I can't find them with a quick scan.

Hubbard purged Minshull's books from Scientology during the early 1980s.

People abused by Scientology sometimes blames themselves, and disappear, or create a "good roads and fair weather" cover story.
 
I wonder if El Er Aitch was ever jealous and resentful of Ruth Minshull. She managed to communicate and explain Scientology concepts to new people in a no nonsense straight forward way that Hubbard never would or maybe never could.

I would put her in a group of people such as Peter Gilham, John McMaster, and Bill Franks; all very likable people with some shred of decency. Was Hubbard resentful of such people? Was he jealous? Hubbard was once described as always wanting to be thought of as a "wonderful guy", in other words a perfect super wonderful hero who was kind, likeable, but always courageous and ready to get righteously angry and tough when need be. To his followers he was and he must have loved it.

I wouldn't be surprised at all that he was jealous.
 
Have you checked with "find a grave"? to see if she's still in the land of the living?

Could you pinpoint, or quote, her thoughts on Hubbard? I can't find them with a quick scan.

Hubbard purged Minshull's books from Scientology during the early 1980s.

People abused by Scientology sometimes blames themselves, and disappear, or create a "good roads and fair weather" cover story.

I was not clear. I meant to say she did not make her current thoughts on Hubbard plain. As late as 1983 she was still exchanging letters with Hubbard (or his service pretending to be him). Here is an example: L. RON HUBBARD SIGNED LETTER TO AUTHOR MINSHULL - Apr 05, 2008 | Signature House in CA

Here is another from 1980 where Hubbard(?) responds to what apparently was a complaint on her part that she is having trouble with the organization regarding her books: L. Ron Hubbard Typed Letter Signed, "Ron", one page on personal | Lot #30321 | Heritage Auctions

The only mention of Hubbard on her blog is a single quote on 'happiness': Happiness
 
Her book "How To Choose Your People" was very popular when I was "in" and it seemed that everyone I knew in the FZ had a copy. She wrote a follow-up called "Miracles For Breakfast" about raising children.

This update suggests that she's still alive and well;


When I was on staff at Boston Org in the early 80's I recall both her books being sold through our bookstore. Then one day they were all removed for reasons that weren't made clear.
 
.

When I was on staff at Boston Org in the early 80's I recall both her books being sold through our bookstore. Then one day they were all removed for reasons that weren't made clear.

.
REASON: Because the books were "off Source".

Anything not discovered by L. Ron Hubbard is worthless and most often evil-purposed destruction intended to sabotage Ron's bridge to total freedom for all beings in the universe.

It's an unforgivable crime to not recognize Dr. Hubbard as the sole source. See "Keeping Scientology Working".

It's also a high crime to pretend to do "wholetrack research" and discover a breakthrough. Only Ron can do that. If YOU discover tech, you are a sinful lying squirrel SP--who needs to be declared, disconnected, fair gamed and utterly destroyed.

SUMMARY: Only L. Ron Hubbard can discover anything. The only exception is Scientology PCs, who are allowed to discover how miraculous Ron's tech is while they are cogniting in a session that they paid Ron lots of money for.

.
 
Last edited:
I was not clear. I meant to say she did not make her current thoughts on Hubbard plain. As late as 1983 she was still exchanging letters with Hubbard (or his service pretending to be him). Here is an example: L. RON HUBBARD SIGNED LETTER TO AUTHOR MINSHULL - Apr 05, 2008 | Signature House in CA

Here is another from 1980 where Hubbard(?) responds to what apparently was a complaint on her part that she is having trouble with the organization regarding her books: L. Ron Hubbard Typed Letter Signed, "Ron", one page on personal | Lot #30321 | Heritage Auctions

The only mention of Hubbard on her blog is a single quote on 'happiness': Happiness
I think that Hubbard did occasionally really see some letters from celebrities and other people important to his income. For response, though, he might have given brief instructions to a Messenger.
 
.



.
REASON: Because the books were "off Source".

Anything not discovered by L. Ron Hubbard is worthless and most often evil-purposed destruction intended to sabotage Ron's bridge to total freedom for all beings in the universe.

It's a crime to not recognize Dr. Hubbard as the sole source. Just read "Keeping Scientology Working".

It's also a high crime to pretend to do "wholetrack research" and discover a breakthrough. Only Ron can do that. If YOU discover tech, you are lying squirrel SP who needs to be declared, disconnected, fair gamed and utterly destroyed.

SUMMARY: Only L. Ron Hubbard can discover anything. There only exception is that Scientology PCs are allowed to discover how miraculous Ron's tech is while they are cogniting in a session that they paid Ron lots of money for.

.


So, the reason had nothing to do with the fact that Ron wasn't earning any income from the Ruth Minshull books? :unsure:



doubt.jpg
 
So, the reason had nothing to do with the fact that Ron wasn't earning any income from the Ruth Minshull books? :unsure:



View attachment 12339

I do not know for sure but considering that this is Ron Hubbard, I am sure it had something to do with it among other reasons. This is the guy who did not want anyone joking about him after all. Ruth probably made peanuts off the sale of her books but greedy Ron couldn't even handle that. He no doubt reasoned that it was his marvelous "tech" that made all of this possible so the asshole I bet resented people getting any money at all from his "work". Peter Gilham's books also disappeared from org bookstores as well back then. I have met assholes just like vain conceited Ron Hubbard over and over again in my life. None of this is new.

Remember, this is the guy who had everything named after himself in Scientology. That should clue anyone in.
 
So, the reason had nothing to do with the fact that Ron wasn't earning any income from the Ruth Minshull books? :unsure:



View attachment 12339

.
Oh, but he was earning money on the sale of Minshull's books, just not enough. LOL. Whatever royalty Hubbard earned from her books (e.g. 10%) would have been deemed an "out exchange" by the narcissistic guru. After all, he saved all beings in he universe and Minshull was merely an implanted human living on a slave planet.

Hubbard despised seeing anyone else making money, other than the 10% sales commissions he paid to the "useful idiots" he recruited to sell his hoax.

Even if Minshull had licensed all rights to her books in perpetuity to Hubbard for one penny (void of any royalty obligation) he still would have disconnected her from his bookstores. Because of Scientology's Bible, which replicated Christianity in more ways than just clerical collars and jumbo crosses...

[Book of John 14:6]: Jesus said, “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.”​
​
[Book of Rohn 14:6]: Rohn said, "I am the way and the source and the bridge. No one comes to Eternity except through me, and only if they have paid invoices totaling $600K." ​


.
 
Last edited:
I was not clear. I meant to say she did not make her current thoughts on Hubbard plain. As late as 1983 she was still exchanging letters with Hubbard (or his service pretending to be him). Here is an example: L. RON HUBBARD SIGNED LETTER TO AUTHOR MINSHULL - Apr 05, 2008 | Signature House in CA

The give away was "Mary Sue and I were very pleased." By that time, Mary Sue had been indicted, convicted, and was serving time in prison.

Is it possible that Ruth Minshull believed that these were actually letters from Hubbard? And signed by Hubbard? And then was selling them as Hubbard's letters? Or is it more likely that someone else, an heir?, was selling them?

Here is another from 1980 where Hubbard(?) responds to what apparently was a complaint on her part that she is having trouble with the organization regarding her books: L. Ron Hubbard Typed Letter Signed, "Ron", one page on personal | Lot #30321 | Heritage Auctions

The 1980 letter is also not from Hubbard but, at least, appears to be an attempt to be of assistance to Minshull.

How much are these letters, with Hubbard's forged signatures, going for?

The only mention of Hubbard on her blog is a single quote on 'happiness': Happiness

"Wanting to be happy is the biggest swindle in the universe. One would be miserable if he were happy. What one is seeking is drama, strain." L. Ron Hubbard

And above it is a quote from long time Scientology Inc. apologist, and patsy, Thomas Szasz:

"Happiness is an imaginary condition, formerly often attributed by the living to the dead, now usually attributed by adults to children, and by children to adults."

Odd quotes.

Too bad, Ruth Minshull, as with so many others, was mute on her experiences with Hubbard and Scientology.

Some years ago, a fellow came up with the term "SILENTOLOGY," to describe this state. It can manifest by silence and disappearance, such as with Mary Sue Hubbard.

Mary Sue in 1952
msh_what-to-audit.jpg

"This is a cold blooded and factual account of your last sixty trillion years."
Mmmm... I think I'll marry this man.
​
Or it can simply manifest by selective silence of the topic of Hubbard and Scientology.

The list of favorable books and booklets on Scientology by people who were subsequently (officially) erased and silenced, declared enemies of Mankind, life, and the universe, or simply silenced, is quite long.

Most of the names are forgotten. They are numerous. A few that come to mind are J. Horner, 1954, Any Two People Can Do It (the first Doctor of Scientology), Declared "SP" in 1965; Reg Sharpe, 1961, This is Life, Declared "SP" in 1967; Omar Garrison, 1970s, a non Scientologist professional author who was hired to write several books favorable to Scientology and, then, was hired to write the official biography of Hubbard, only to be silenced, and replaced by Dan Sherman - who is David Miscavige's speech writer, and the official LRH bibliographer - who solved the problem of the how to write the official biography of L. Ron Hubbard by creating a collection of coffee table picture books called The Ron Series, a sixteen volume "biographical encyclopedia."

Dan_Sherman-e1364012249434.jpg


​
 
The give away was "Mary Sue and I were very pleased." By that time, Mary Sue had been indicted, convicted, and was serving time in prison.

Is it possible that Ruth Minshull believed that these were actually letters from Hubbard? And signed by Hubbard? And then was selling them as Hubbard's letters? Or is it more likely that someone else, an heir?, was selling them?



The 1980 letter is also not from Hubbard but, at least, appears to be an attempt to be of assistance to Minshull.

How much are these letters, with Hubbard's forged signatures, going for?



"Wanting to be happy is the biggest swindle in the universe. One would be miserable if he were happy. What one is seeking is drama, strain." L. Ron Hubbard

And above it is a quote from long time Scientology Inc. apologist, and patsy, Thomas Szasz:

"Happiness is an imaginary condition, formerly often attributed by the living to the dead, now usually attributed by adults to children, and by children to adults."

Odd quotes.

Too bad, Ruth Minshull, as with so many others, was mute on her experiences with Hubbard and Scientology.

Some years ago, a fellow came up with the term "SILENTOLOGY," to describe this state. It can manifest by silence and disappearance, such as with Mary Sue Hubbard.

Mary Sue in 1952
msh_what-to-audit.jpg

"This is a cold blooded and factual account of your last sixty trillion years."
Mmmm... I think I'll marry this man.
​
Or it can simply manifest by selective silence of the topic of Hubbard and Scientology.

The list of favorable books and booklets on Scientology by people who were subsequently (officially) erased and silenced, declared enemies of Mankind, life, and the universe, or simply silenced, is quite long.

Most of the names are forgotten. They are numerous. A few that come to mind are J. Horner, 1954, Any Two People Can Do It (the first Doctor of Scientology), Declared "SP" in 1965; Reg Sharpe, 1961, This is Life, Declared "SP" in 1967; Omar Garrison, 1970s, a non Scientologist professional author who was hired to write several books favorable to Scientology and, then, was hired to write the official biography of Hubbard, only to be silenced, and replaced by Dan Sherman - who is David Miscavige's speech writer, and the official LRH bibliographer - who solved the problem of the how to write the official biography of L. Ron Hubbard by creating a collection of coffee table picture books called The Ron Series, a sixteen volume "biographical encyclopedia."

Dan_Sherman-e1364012249434.jpg


​
You have to have an account on the site to see the sale prices - I do not. But I think this was Minshull herself selling the letters. One was sold in 2007 and the other in 2008. Minshull was active on her blog until 2016. But this page L. Ron Hubbard Autographs, Memorabilia & Collectibles Page 1 | HistoryForSale shows that some of these standard stamped 'Ron' letters from the 1970s go for over $500.
 
I was not clear. I meant to say she did not make her current thoughts on Hubbard plain. As late as 1983 she was still exchanging letters with Hubbard (or his service pretending to be him). Here is an example: L. RON HUBBARD SIGNED LETTER TO AUTHOR MINSHULL - Apr 05, 2008 | Signature House in CA

Here is another from 1980 where Hubbard(?) responds to what apparently was a complaint on her part that she is having trouble with the organization regarding her books: L. Ron Hubbard Typed Letter Signed, "Ron", one page on personal | Lot #30321 | Heritage Auctions

The only mention of Hubbard on her blog is a single quote on 'happiness': Happiness

Those appear to be pretty standard letters from the SO#1 line (Ron’s “personal impersonal letter writing team”).

One of the Anons did some deep research on some of Ron’s friends whose books were promoted in the Scn bookstore. Adele Davis had history with L Ron, as I recall, knowing him in his pre-Dn days. She was a popular natural-style nutritionist but died of cancer fairly young.

I don’t remember anything written about Ruth Minshull, but someone at WWP might know.
 
I do not know for sure but considering that this is Ron Hubbard, I am sure it had something to do with it among other reasons. This is the guy who did not want anyone joking about him after all. Ruth probably made peanuts off the sale of her books but greedy Ron couldn't even handle that. He no doubt reasoned that it was his marvelous "tech" that made all of this possible so the asshole I bet resented people getting any money at all from his "work". Peter Gilham's books also disappeared from org bookstores as well back then. I have met assholes just like vain conceited Ron Hubbard over and over again in my life. None of this is new.

Remember, this is the guy who had everything named after himself in Scientology. That should clue anyone in.

I’m not so sure it was Hubbard who pulled the other authors’ books from Scn shelves. They were still there in the late 70s and early 80’s. To the best of my memory, they were pulled around 1980 or 1981 - after those that broke into the FBI had been sentenced and the church structure and other things were changed to be more religious and statements were made that L Ron was not involved with the management of Scn. He was traveling around in his Bluebird by then and only minimally involved with the cult.
 
Back
Top