Or hitting someone to hard...so to speak....?
Hitting someone too hard was a problem, but probably not in the way you think.
See, within an investigation everything is a tool geared towards controlling the environment to go towards a solution (
"There must be a victory!"). One of the most important factors to control is the anxiety of the accountable unit. If there's too little anxiety, then the person will feel "high and mighty" and probably not cooperate as much as you want. That's obvious.
What is not obvious is that too much anxiety (what you called "hitting someone too hard" ) is equally bad, if not more so. An inexperienced MAA often thinks "the more anxiety and fear the better" and goes way, way too far. Too much anxiety results in one of two possible states:
- "Cornered rat mode". The accountable unit will decide they have nothing to lose and lash out, decline to cooperate, decline to say anything (or just say: "Fuck this, fuck you, fuck your investigation!" etc). Sure, that person is then in deep trouble, but the investigation is stopped. Good luck getting any good info from that person.
- "Panic mode" (Spanish inquisition galore). The person will be so scared that they will try very hard to tell you whatever they think you want to hear. They will admit to crimes they have not committed. They will make up imaginary crimes, implicate innocent people... say every dumb and crazy thing to get out. And that's a problem, because then you end up with a mix of lies and truths you have to sort out. Good luck going on all the wild goose chases the panicked person sent you on. Oh and if you are found wasting time looking into false stuff, YOU get blamed because "obviously the meter is infallible, so you fucked up when you ran them through the fucking list"
Thus the accountable unit needs to be kept in the "goldielocks zone" - not too hot, not too cold. The fear level has to be "just right". And for each individual that zone is somewhere else. You need to learn when to be nice and lower anxiety and when to play hardball. None of this is part of the tech, all of it is part of experience.

And they don't teach that at the local orgs.
Just curious @Karakorum , did you yourself ever experience "retribution" due to stepping on the wrong toes....?
There were some people that were... problematic. Kevenaar, the Pouws, pretty much anyone from OSA int or RTC etc. And of course CMO were more than problematic.
But that's the thing: At inv I did not get in trouble for going after people. Actually pretty much every single time I got myself in trouble it was because:
- I told people that what they are demanding is impossible, that the deadlines can't be met, that it can't be done with so few men in such a short time etc.
- I was telling people that X is an absolutely stupid idea and I will under no circumstances waste my team's time and manpower on it.
- I was proven right when I said that some project will certainly fail
- I was working too slowly and missed some deadline
- My stats dropped
- I had too many aged cases
- I made some documentation error (often because I was sleep-deprived, tred and doing 7 things at once while being interrupted all the damn time)
- I got into some shouting match with the CMO that escalated enough that someone decided I need to be taught a lesson.
The funny thing is: They could never come up with a long-term punishment or amends project that I could actually complete. Amost every time I got quickly recalled back from it to my regular duties because
"OMFG the sky is gonna fall on our heads, the aged cases are piling up and nobody really understands what was going on in your case #123456 so you have to go back and close it NOOOOOWWWWW!".