Some more on this; I'm thinking at the moment that a decent starting point for discussions like this one is to be open to the possibility that sometimes, in Scn and elsewhere too, good things may happen that don't have a ready explanation.
I've talked here before and on the old board about my Catholic housemate at university who went to confession one day and had a big win on it. What I didn't say was that he became an ex-Catholic - the big win he had on going to confession still wasn't enough to keep him in the Church. The same happened with me and Scn.; I also had a big win on something I did at my local org, but I still left (although I did return to the subject, in the FZ.).
If this was an ex-Catholics board, people would be saying how ridiculous it was that people believed in things such as *the Virgin Birth and the doctrine of transsubstantiation, and at the same time they'd be inveighing against the sexual abuses of children by priests, the deaths in the homes for unmarried mothers in Ireland, how the Church had got rich whilst many of its parishioners had stayed poor, etc. etc. And yet, there would most likely be people who could point to good things that happened when they went to Mass or confession, just as my housemate did.
I don't want to take the comparison between Catholicism and Scientology too far; Pope Francis is transparently a good man in a way David Miscavige clearly isn't. I'm simply pointing to what seems to me to be the fact that, in Scn as well as Catholic confession, sometimes very good things happen.
You can either reject them because of all the bad stuff that goes on, the silly stories about Xenu etc. the abuses of staff in the Sea Org, the continual ripoffs etc., or you can say, as Veda seems to be doing here, that sometimes good things happen that can be directly attributed to something the person did in Scn., irrespective of whether or not the reason they happened was the reason Scn would say that they happened. Similar things could be said about Catholics and Catholicism, but either way, we acknowledge that that is the case.
From that point, you can either say; good things like that happen in life as well, it isn't worth thinking about or discussing, let's just move on (Catholic apostasy on one hand, Scn exes who reject the whole concept of spiritual technology on the other); or, good things happen, let's find out why they happened so we can learn from them and possibly reproduce them but at any rate let's not throw the metaphorical baby out with the bathwater (the Anglicans, Methodists and other Christian denominations on one hand, the freezone in Scientology on the other). However, I think that's a better place to have the discussion from than from where we seem to be now, even though I accept that there's no solid proof for the proposition about direct attribution (in either case).
*Apologies to anyone who still does believe in Catholic doctrine; I was brought up and still consider myself a Protestant. I accept that there's the Frank Skinner view (when asked why he as a Catholic believes in the Virgin Birth etc.) that "he's God, he can do anything".
I just don't see a good enough reason to believe in the Virgin Birth, transsubstantiation etc., and I also dislike the enormous pressure of social conformity the Catholic Church puts behind it; not believing in it isn't an option for the Catholic priesthood, although I think the Catholic laity have more latitude in what they believe than Scn parishioners do about believing what Ron Hubbard said.