This story raises an issue that I don't believe has been raised elsewhere. The issue is whether all Scientologists believe that all of Scientology, including the space opera, is literally true. Not whether they are arguably required to do so per KSW, but whether they, as a matter of empirical fact, actually do believe that it all is literally true.
The overwhelming majority of Scientologists that I knew did not and believe that Mars was inhabited. The overwhelming majority did not believe that there were trains running on Venus. Many, perhaps a majority, did not believe in any of Hubbard's space opera.
There was no cognitive dissonance associated with these beliefs. They viewed such stories the same way that many modern Christians consider the stories of Adam and Eve, Noah's Ark, the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, and sometimes even Jesus's resurrection from the dead -- not literally, but as metaphors or parables that teach a lesson. As valid under what philosopher William James referred to as the pragmatic criterion of truth.
Tony notes that the NASA scientist, Robert Hoag, was working towards doing OT 4, which means that he completed OT 3 and knows the Xenu story. I would be shocked if he ever literally believed the Xenu story, or saw it as anything other than a metaphor or allegory, given his obvious education and background.
I knew a number of OT 3s. None of them believed it literally. (And yes, we talked about it eventually.) To the extent that they took it seriously, they searched for some metaphorical or parable meaning, some underlying lesson. Thus, they weren't the least bit disturbed by academic papers showing that Hawaii didn't have volcanoes at the time of OT 3.
There are many never-ins who will insist, and quite frankly are quite invested in believing, that every Scientologist believed and believes in each and every thing that Hubbard taught. Perhaps, per KSW, it was and is supposed to work that way; it doesn't and never has. (The greatest believers in KSW are hard core Scientologists and hard core critics.) Just as there are Cafeteria Catholics, there are Cafeteria Scientologists --- even there aren't supposed to be.
Some never-ins will insist that I *must* be wrong, a priori, despite the fact that I was there, and am UTR and still in communication with Scientologists. They see no need to actually listen to current and ex-Scientologists because they know what KSW states, and believe that everyone always follows KSW.
There are many ex-Scientologists, generally those who got into and often left Scientology before I started, who may insist that I am wrong because their personal experience was different. What they fail to recognize is that the population of Scientology has changed over time.
In the 1950s, many of the early Dianeticists and Scientologists were obviously science fiction fans who were susceptible to space opera.
The 1960s and 1970s added seekers who were also susceptible to space opera.
Beginning in the 1980s, Scientology drew more people seeking practical therapy, self- improvement and personal power. The WISE types sought wealth and success. All of these people who were less susceptible to space opera.
Indeed, I never personally knew a WISE type who was really into space opera. Many, perhaps a majority, of Scientologists seeking practical therapy, self- improvement and personal power were not into, and quite frankly didn't really believe, the space opera..
The WISE types were and are largely into the Admin Tech, and often the Ls. The Scientologists seeking practical therapy, self- improvement and personal power were into the things that were believed to produce such results -- e.g., the ARC Triangle, KRC Triangle, Tone Scale, TRs, Auditing as therapy and self-improvement.
Yes, anyone who continues with Auditing eventually goes "past life." It is expected and in the end required. (There is a prescribed remedy if you don't.) I certainly knew people who really believed in their past lives. Indeed, I knew people who became obsessed with them. Conversely, I knew people who viewed their "past lives" as not being literally true, but the auditing of same as being beneficial on or through some sort of metaphorical or allegorical level. (Maybe very roughly akin to dream analysis.) While I don't have the reference handy, I recall Hubbard saying that it didn't matter if past life stories were "true," it only mattered if processing them "worked." In any event, these PCs and Pre-OTs never thought about their "past lives" outside of session (Maybe it was just my peer group.)
Nobody ever publicly expressed disbelief in Hubbard space opera, or anything else that Hubbard wrote. They knew better. But they were fine as long as they kept their opinions to themselves.
Differences of opinion on this issue may arise from the sample of Scientologists that one surveys. If you survey ex-Sea Org who lived Scientology 24/7, or ex long-term, high level OTs and Auditors *who had nothing else going on on their lives*, you are more likely to find people who took the space opera literally. If you survey the people who I believe make up the majority of Scientologists, the people who Hubbard called dilettantes, the people who did it intermittently or part time, the people who had other things going on in their lives and other priorities, the people who were not invested in "Clearing the Planet," but were instead interested in self-improvement, you are much less likely to find people who took the space opera literally. Understandably but perhaps unfortunately, it is the former group that is generally the subject of news stories and interviews.
IMHO, laughing at a NASA scientist who is a Scientologist because Hubbard said Mars is inhabited is at least somewhat akin to laughing at a Ph.D. in geology who is a Christian on the ground that *all* Christians *must* believe that the earth is 6,000 years old, believe in the flood of Noah's Ark, and that early man coexisted with the dinosaurs. Obviously, neither the Scientologist who is a NASA scientist nor the Christian who has a Ph D. in geology literally believe in the metaphors and allegories of their respective religions. Viewing the metaphors and allegories as such, they have no difficulty reconciling them with modern science.
In other words, the NASA scientist who is a Scientologist and who does not believe that Mars is inhabited has no problem believing that the ARC Triangle, KRC Triangle, Tone Scale, TRs and Auditing are beneficial. The Ph D. in geology who doesn't believe that the earth is 6,000 years old has no problem finding his belief in Christ, and perhaps more importantly his belief in what Christ preached, to be beneficial.
/
What you're describing is a manifestation of the layered and compartmentalized Scientological Onion.
The people you're describing are secretly "squirrels" and "out ethics." At best they would be regarded as "dilettantes." They could be classed with the people who secretly smoke pot between being "on lines."
I knew people like this and was one myself. Being "off lines" - between stints inside Scientology - was the only way to tolerate being involved with Scientology at all.
However, I never met anyone who doubted that past lives existed, which is different than thinking that anything the appears in a session is an actual past life, or one's own facsimiles.
I've seen people, after leaving Scientology, insist that they didn't believe the OT 3 incident (Inc. 2 or Inc 1) when doing it, but I've seen too many people who took it
very seriously, some even dripping with sweat before going into session, to run materials that they would, later, claim they "didn't believe" and "laughed about."
Plus it's a "PR handling" to tell people that "We don't believe, we just look." "What true for you is what's true for you," etc.
"Metaphors" don't "as is," Per Scientology, only "time, place, form, and event" can "as-is."
As early as 1971, this is what David Gaiman, then Public Relations Director for Scientology in England, wrote to Paulette Cooper. From question/answer #19, in the Appendix of Cooper's book:
#19. (From Cooper) "DO SEA ORG PEOPLE SIGN A BILLION YEAR CONTRACT?"
(From Gaiman) "Never make an allegoric joke near literal minded humorless reporters."
Scientology's paid apologists often liken OT 3 (which has been a PR embarrassment) to an allegory or a metaphor. Even some independent Scientologists, when talking to "wogs," have used this PR angle.
On the other hand, the (default) fall back position - that I have occasionally witnessed inside Scientology, from an exasperated tech person - is that "It doesn't matter if it actually happened or is 'real' to you. It just has to read on the meter, get Tone Arm motion, and bring you up tone," etc.
Inevitably though, if incident 2 or incident 1 are not "real" to a person, it will be regarded as a "bad indicator," which, of course, is why a person, inside Scientology, would usually keep such thoughts to himself, if they occurred.
Finances also are a factor, and if a person is about to spend a large sum of money for the levels
after OT 3, there will, likely, be a reluctance to delay the person's passage onto the next level or levels, especially since he can be ordered into review or retred at any time.
Even on OT 2, I've heard of solo auditors being told, "It doesn't matter if you don't understand it. Just get Tone Arm motion!
*
The idea that the average Scientologist is less suggestible now seems very unlikely.
When I was "on lines" from 1969, on and off, through to 1976, only the very dumbest people actually thought Scientology was an actual, sincere, religious institution. They knew that the religion thing was a ruse used for protective purposes.
Now, Miscavige has Scientologists parroting the words "my religion," "the Scientology religion," etc. as part of the Scientology indoctrination. What percentage really believe it, I can only guess. (In effect, it's become part of the "brainwashing." It wasn't part of the "brainwashing" before.)
But I agree with your primary point, there are degrees of involvement, and not everyone, even though involved in Scientology Inc. today, accepts "the total package," however, since there are some things in Scientology they want, and find beneficial, they remain members.
Always blanketly denouncing every inch of Scientology, and characterizing every (seeming) Scientologist as an idiot, although it may feel good, excludes people who might otherwise be reached and helped.
(

I know, I know. Some don't care about that. However, having a wider range of views on the message board would increase participation and make it more interesting.)
"Always" is the qualifying adverb since, obviously, in brief, or satirical, presentations, it's impractical to go into detail or subtleties.
Plus sometimes members of Scientology can have mixed feelings. Fox example William Burroughs, while IN Scientology Inc., regarded himself as an outsider but, when, outside Scientology Inc., although still a member, and surrounded by people "hostile" to Scientology, would defend Scientology Inc.
For example, this image of Dr. Hubbard with his hypnotic stethoscope, might have made him laugh if alone, but, if he was surrounded by unfriendly press showing him the image he would probably launch into a explanation that Scientology is the opposite of hypnosis, etc.
So there are differing situations, variations and nuances.
In any event, thanks for the insightful observations.