CoS vs indipendent

Noteta

Member
What is the difference between Scientology organizations and independent Scientology?
 
Last edited:
What is the difference between Scientology organizations and independent Scientology?

Independents have no affiliation with the official corporate Church of Scientology and do not consult with or take orders from its dick-tater, David Miscavige.

Indies pretty uniformly repudiate all of the vile spiritual, mental, and physically abusive mistreatment of staff and public members that has become endemic in that toxic group. We don't destroy families and friendships or ruin people's businesses by forced shunning (disconnection). Neither do we bankrupt people with continual donation drives for things that have nothing at all to do with auditing people or training auditors as does Cof$.

Indies have no central authority and there are multiple disparate factions which vary widely between close adherence to Ron Hubbard's theories and authorized techniques of auditing and loose adherence with their own variations on the subject.
 
Last edited:
Independent are slightly less expensive, but they sell the same crap.
 
Yes to what Sneakster said, but will add the following.

Indies, like all groups, often carry their own versions of politics and their share of "colourful" toxic personalities as well. Some groups obviously better than others. One such "colourful" character I seem to remember reading about was Pierre Ethier, one who allegedly turned out to be a not very nice person. YMMV.

However with that, it is still a free group and you can come and go as you please (even between different groups) without the penalties that the CoS subjects you to.

I believe it is still all about trying to pick up a turd by the clean end. Or putting lipstick on a pig, if you like.

Scientology does contain the odd truths here and there, but overall, it is all a load of garbage. It was originally based an old versions of psychotherapy that is pretty much outdated and discredited . In a funny way, it is kind of based on psychiatry and psychology of the past with Hubbard making lots of stuff up and mixing it all in. Little has changed with it since it started, since no one is allowed to research it or test its validity without being kicked out and branded as some sort of enemy of the church.

To me, the independents are still caught up in cult think in a way by not taking enough of a step back and seeing things for what they really are.

It is jumping from one belief system to another which many people who leave cults tend to do. Some will do it all their lives, some never again and all the different levels in between. It is hard to let go of what you had invested so much of yourself in and thinking yourself a fool for ever doing it. Much easier to keep following the thought train that got yourself into it in the first place.

This is one of the first things that ex-cult followers have to face (apart from other everyday issues). What got you into it in the first place? What issues made you seek or allow yourself to get into such a thing? How did you let your ability to think critically fail you?

Doing some self reflection is probably a better thing to be doing than looking for another rabbit hole to dive into. It tends to deepen the problems you face rather than enlighten you.

My own experiences after I left the cult was to get caught up in others, those of faith, business, money and whatever else until I had to stop and ask myself what the hell I was doing. The average cult follower is much more prone to getting caught up in other subsequent cults afterwards and it is important to ask what needs to be asked of yourself to be able to restore or find some balance in your life.

Having said all that, it also is difficult to not turn yourself into an overly cynical person as a result as well. That's another trap.
 
What is the difference between Scientology organizations and independent Scientology?

the former is the group called “The Church of Scientology”- the one with all the scandals, mistreatment of staff, etc.

The latter is basically a heretical scenario that is not centralized and has a whole lot of cherry-picking.
 
The independents use the designated hitter rule and the pitch clock.
 
The independents use the designated hitter rule and the pitch clock.

Sorry, I don't really understand that answer.

@I M Dex is using a professional baseball metaphor suggesting the independents are the Major League which would imply the official corporate Co$ are the Minor League, I think.
 
The Independents have more freedom to innovate (and cherrypick, as Inanna said). I don't know where you would find an independent auditor now (outside of Ron's Orgs, who more or less do their own thing). The one I went to is now long gone.
 
Independent are slightly less expensive, but they sell the same crap.

The Church of Incessant Abusive Solication (IAS), piles on required large donations to the IAS and Ideal Orgs scams, lengthy expensive interrogations and "ethics programs" (all of which multiply the already the massive base cost they charge for the Bridge from Comm Course to OT VIII by around ten or twenty times).

Generally speaking, independents have drastically lower base rates for the same or similar services compared to the Co$ and none of the added expense of those donation scams.

Of course, if one thinks Scientology training and processing service are all crap, well I'm sure they won't be paying for them at all.
 
The Independents have more freedom to innovate (and cherrypick, as Inanna said). I don't know where you would find an independent auditor now (outside of Ron's Orgs, who more or less do their own thing). The one I went to is now long gone.
I’ve been saying for a while, that if Scientology actually worked, in the sense of measurably increasing abilities, that they would have people with suitcases full of cash lined up around the block. That they don’t, tells you all you need to know.

If a stock broker could be just 10% better at figuring out how the market was going to move, or a lawyer got 10% better at winning million dollar cases, or a businessman get better at growing his company—- that slight increase in ability would be worth large chunks of money, and everyone around them would be fascinated at how they became more successful.

It’s now been 75 years that they’ve had a chance to demonstrate results.
 
Da un po' di tempo sostengo che se Scientology funzionasse davvero, nel senso di aumentare in modo misurabile le capacità, ci sarebbero persone con valigie piene di soldi in fila intorno all'isolato. Il fatto che non lo faccia, vi dice tutto quello che dovete sapere.

Se un agente di cambio riuscisse a capire meglio anche solo il 10% di come si sarebbe mosso il mercato, o un avvocato riuscisse a vincere casi da milioni di dollari meglio del 10%, o un uomo d'affari riuscisse a far crescere la sua azienda, quel piccolo aumento di capacità varrebbe un sacco di soldi e tutti intorno a loro rimarrebbero affascinati dal modo in cui hanno ottenuto più successo.

Sono ormai 75 anni che hanno avuto la possibilità di dimostrare i risultati.
[/CITAZIONE]


Nel mio caso, non credo assolutamente a Xenu e alla space opera.
Mi chiedo solo se l'auditing abbia qualche valore ed effetto terapeutico.
 
.

Independent are slightly less expensive, but they sell the same crap.


Nicely captured in under a dozen words!

I think the INDEPENDENT CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY has very distinct marketing advantages that they are not taking advantage of. They could use a new marketing campaign to effectively take away some of the COS' customers & market share.

Here's a possible angle for a bulk mailer to all COS Scientologists---

ARE YOU ARC BROKEN WITH THE COS AND THEIR LAVISHLY
EXORBITANT PRICE OF RECEIVING 100% STANDARD TECH
IN ORDER TO ATTAIN 100% TOTAL FREEDOM?

HELLO! WE ARE THE INDEPENDENT CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY!
WE OFFER 125% STANDARD TECH, 70% TOTAL FREEDOM AND
ALL OF THAT AT A LOW LOW 50% DISCOUNT!

AND NOT ONLY THAT. IF YOU DECIDE TO LEAVE
THE INDIE CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY WE
WON'T EVEN KILL YOUR PETS!



...​
 
Last edited:
Yes to what Sneakster said, but will add the following.

Scientology does contain the odd truths here and there, but overall, it is all a load of garbage. It was originally based an old versions of psychotherapy that is pretty much outdated and discredited . In a funny way, it is kind of based on psychiatry and psychology of the past with Hubbard making lots of stuff up and mixing it all in. Little has changed with it since it started, since no one is allowed to research it or test its validity without being kicked out and branded as some sort of enemy of the church.

Fixer - I respectfully disagree with your statement.

Just to introduce myself, here is my history with Scientology. I learned how to audit during my yearlong stint on the Excalibur's RPF (1974-1975) where I delivered many hours of R3R which included running Evil Purps. After graduating I went back to the San Diego Org where I both C/Sed and audited hundreds of hours of R3R. I finished my 5 year contract with the Org and moved to Oklahoma where I have run a retail tire business for the past 40 years.

A couple of years ago I researched Abreaction and published its comparison to Dianetics here - https://scientolipedia.org/info/Dianetics,_Abreaction_Therapy_for_the_common_man

I had one of my customers review the article, who still works for the Oklahoma National Guard as a therapist. She commented - "Abreaction has been proven most effective when used integrationally in treating PTSD".

I have another customer who is studying to be a psychiatrist and one of her books to read is the 1895 book "Studies on Hysteria" by Doctor Josef Breuer and Doctor Sigmund Freud. Abreaction was very effective when used on WWII soldiers as noted in the 1943 book "War Neuroses" by psychiatrists Lt Col Roy Grinker Sr. and Major John Spiegel.

Dianetics is Abreaction therapy for the common man. LRH did a wonderful job making the therapy usable for everyday people. My PC's felt much better after my sessions with them, and I am glad that I was able to help them.

Howard Dickman
 
Independent are slightly less expensive, but they sell the same crap.
They sell the same crap

AND

they lack the ability to fair game you and try to ruin your life if you decide it’s not working for you and say as much to your friends.

This may be the real reason LRH was so down on independent groups: his operation was dependent on his ability to suppress unfavorable opinions.
 
The Church of Incessant Abusive Solication (IAS), piles on required large donations to the IAS and Ideal Orgs scams, lengthy expensive interrogations and "ethics programs" (all of which multiply the already the massive base cost they charge for the Bridge from Comm Course to OT VIII by around ten or twenty times).

Generally speaking, independents have drastically lower base rates for the same or similar services compared to the Co$ and none of the added expense of those donation scams.

Of course, if one thinks Scientology training and processing service are all crap, well I'm sure they won't be paying for them at all.

That's an interesting and apt point you raised there. A major difference I forgot about just then.

Apart from the auditing, I'm assuming it is probably the major methods employed by the cult that makes them money now. I would assume the income from auditing simply wouldn't be enough.

Given the nature of Stats, when you reach saturation point, i.e., every hour they are open is fully booked for auditing, your income then becomes static. The graph no longer points upwards, but is a flat line and you would have to be opening a fully functioning org every week in order to achieve that line on the graph to point upwards. Introducing those nefarious methods you mentioned would also result in a flat line eventually unless you find ways to squeeze them further.

All those money chasing programs the Church itself employs is something the Independents don't use as a rule. They'd soon find themselves out of business if they did.
 
They sell the same crap

AND

they lack the ability to fair game you and try to ruin your life if you decide it’s not working for you and say as much to your friends.

This may be the real reason LRH was so down on independent groups: his operation was dependent on his ability to suppress unfavorable opinions.

Thank you for help me! 🙏🙏🙏😢
 
Given the nature of Stats, when you reach saturation point, i.e., every hour they are open is fully booked for auditing, your income then becomes static.
If they were selling something that really worked, then they would be able to pay auditors a middle-class professional wage.

So there would be actual interest in becoming an HGC auditor, and young people’s parents would buy auditor training packages instead of sending them to college, resulting in a steady increase in new tech people to handle the demand.

If orgs had to pay professional salaries, no org could stay open for a week.
 
If they were selling something that really worked, then they would be able to pay auditors a middle-class professional wage.

So there would be actual interest in becoming an HGC auditor, and young people’s parents would buy auditor training packages instead of sending them to college, resulting in a steady increase in new tech people to handle the demand.

If orgs had to pay professional salaries, no org could stay open for a week.

Forget professional salaries...how about toilet paper?
 
Back
Top