David Miscavige: Fanatic or Con Man?

I think the whole rollercoaster or bipolar swing of Scientology comes from the face that it is a restimulation of some failed purpose.

The emphasis on Religious Technology Center was scooted over to Church of Spiritual Technology and I think the game is a big GPM. I listened to a Jon Atack podcast with Andy Nolch and quoting Ron saying 'I like to catch the smart ones and reel them in.' This would have been around 1957. I was surprised . But I'd heard these same opinions in the lounge area of the AAC, way back in 83. It seemed the best people had all been handed unsolvable problems and finally fled for their own self preservation.

As Above So Below. Maybe the game is cyclic and there's a purpose to sack anyone with tools to get out. It seems to manifest a lot. So many fruitful teachings of the past needed to be kept secret if they pointed to a way out.

Alan Walter once wrote on the subject of Presence Liability. He said the more spiritually PRESENT a being becomes, the more tacit attempts will be made to sabotage you. These are relentless. It's the battle of the universes in play. The jointly created solid ones vs the spiritual being not fully tangled up.. One is the solvent and the other is a postulate to remain a solid. The solvent becomes the enemy of the group's creation and all its collective lies
 
I listened to a Jon Atack podcast with Andy Nolch and quoting Ron saying 'I like to catch the smart ones and reel them in.' This would have been around 1957. I was surprised.


But did you listen to Ron Hubbard saying that yourself in the original lecture (?) so as to know the full context, and - knowing Atack - you probably didn't get a proper citation of the original source of this alleged quote, either.

Atack is rather consistent with his out-of-context quote mining (so is David "Darth Midget" Miscavige).
 
Last edited:
But did you listen to Ron Hubbard saying yourself in the original lecture (?) so as to know the full context, and - knowing Atack - you probably didn't get a proper citation of the original source of this alleged quote, either.

Atack is rather consistent with his out-of-context quote mining (so is David "Darth Midget" Miscavige).
Yes, you are correct in that Atack is inconsistent in his criticisms of people. I was going down the VIDEOS thread here on the board this week. There were quite a few comments made about David Mayo and Johnny Mac and NIBS which ran at odds with some earlier ones. I chalk it up to time gone by in between critiques.

Is there a lecture or diary account proving what Jon Atack quoted Ron as saying? I don't think so, it's all hearsay. However, the sentiment that organized Scn acted as a theta trap to get in big beings, is common. I tend to feel recently that it is triggering a bigger GPM with some hidden evil being identities in play. Though cherch mgmt can seem to wear these roles, it projects it on others.

My mission one time, as a result of losing friends who never came back, was to find out why the occlusions were so deep. That was the upset that lead to surfing through so many spiritual technologies and tools for getting rehabbed and back out. I don't remember any bogeymen or counter intention hitting me as a result of ascensions or exteriorization by dynamics. Why the banana peel of Scientology. Why the destructive counter intention leveled at so many good beings. Why the re-enactment of implants to make you go back in or occlude all memory of your real self.

I've seen a few of the top auditors at Flag and AOLA who have managed to remain unscathed and I marvel that they were not attacked also. They're still working at the same Orgs and have not been declared. AMAZINGLY they've survived inside the organization. I wonder what their secret is.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe it is necessary to choose between fanatic or con man. :no:

I would say that Miscavige has a good measure of both in him.

I'd say con man more than fanatic, because he's doing absolutely naff all to actually get the tech out there and "clear the planet". Look at his record over, say, the last thirty years and you couldn't honestly say it's the record of someone who believes in, and / or cares about, the power of the tech to change people's lives for the better; he seems to use his position purely as a means to maintaining a sybaritic life style and hob nobbing with celebrities.

Someone like Tommy Davis strikes me as having more of the fanatic in him; for all his faults he generally does seem to believe in the CofS's "mission", but he's been weirdly silent recently.
 
Last edited:
But did you listen to Ron Hubbard saying that yourself in the original lecture (?) so as to know the full context, and - knowing Atack - you probably didn't get a proper citation of the original source of this alleged quote, either.

realistically, someone can't prepare for something like that and memorize the exact quote and proper citation for everything they might possibly want to use, can they?

it seems to me, the question is what is Atack's track record -- does he know LRH's work well enough that the generally gets it right when speaking off the curf, and that a quote more or less matching what he said can be found?
 
Yes, you are correct in that Atack is inconsistent in his criticisms of people. I was going down the VIDEOS thread here on the board this week. There were quite a few comments made about David Mayo and Johnny Mac and NIBS which ran at odds with some earlier ones. I chalk it up to time gone by in between critiques.

Is there a lecture or diary account proving what Jon Atack quoted Ron as saying? I don't think so, it's all hearsay. However, the sentiment that organized Scn acted as a theta trap to get in big beings, is common. I tend to feel recently that it is triggering a bigger GPM with some hidden evil being identities in play. Though cherch mgmt can seem to wear these roles, it projects it on others.

My mission one time, as a result of losing friends who never came back, was to find out why the occlusions were so deep. That was the upset that lead to surfing through so many spiritual technologies and tools for getting rehabbed and back out. I don't remember any bogeymen or counter intention hitting me as a result of ascensions or exteriorization by dynamics. Why the banana peel of Scientology. Why the destructive counter intention leveled at so many good beings. Why the re-enactment of implants to make you go back in or occlude all memory of your real self.

I've seen a few of the top auditors at Flag and AOLA who have managed to remain unscathed and I marvel that they were not attacked also. They're still working at the same Orgs and have not been declared. AMAZINGLY they've survived inside the organization. I wonder what their secret is.
I've had an ex-SO client who answered directly to Miscavige for years and was never treated abusively, and I recall one client who did the full Scientology "bridge" and then went his own way without further involvement, and while recognizing it didn't deliver anything like the stated "EP's" at any level, his experience was entirely satisfactory, and without incident. Some people, although not many apparently, just aren't at all invested in the abused/abuser mentality/game, at least in the context of their involvement in Scientology, and come through it unscathed. There's no doubt in my mind that it has to do with what the individual is generating at some level. As stated in quantum physics, "the observer affects the experiment". However, that being said, very few people have that experience, so I wouldn't use this as justification for walking into that snakepit.
 
realistically, someone can't prepare for something like that and memorize the exact quote and proper citation for everything they might possibly want to use, can they?

Jon Atack is frequently promoted as a Scientology historian by Tony Ortega and others - and by himself.

A true professional historian keeps meticulous records of their sources for the purpose of defending the accuracy of their claimed facts. A historian who cannot cite their sources is incompetent and not to be trusted. A historian who omits the source of a claimed quotation is a deceitful propagandist deliberately preventing fact checking.

Attack has spent decades PR positioning himself as a Scientology expert, historian, and subject expert court witness. Therefore he has an obligation to provide proper citation whenever he makes this or that factual statement about his claimed area of knowledge and expertise.

Edit Addition: @Reyne Mayer - I have a few rules of thumb (heuristic) I use when evaluating claims made by pretty much anybody - including Ron Hubbard:

Anyone who wishes to accurately inform another about claimed facts or events, provides their sources so that one may verify the claim.

Anyone who cannot provide you with the source of a claimed fact or event (an eyewitness is the source of the claim) is forwarding rumors, the truth of which they do not know.

Anyone who hides or falsifies the source of a claimed fact or event is attempting to control the thoughts or beliefs of another by inserting uninspected information into their mind.


The Scientology critic community is in the middle of an information warfare battleground. One had best learn to know which direction the information artillery shells are coming from and where they are likely to land.
 
Last edited:
I think Miscavige is a religious fanatic
and a con man
Just like Hubbard

Miscavige won’t have any ability to do a mass suicide cuz it’s not in El Ron’s Tech
David Miscavige will most likely kill himself one way or another
Covertly via smoking and drinking himself to death
Or overtly - shooting himself or some other violent death
His black heart 🖤 will get him one way or another
It’s Karma
 
I've had an ex-SO client who answered directly to Miscavige for years and was never treated abusively, and I recall one client who did the full Scientology "bridge" and then went his own way without further involvement, and while recognizing it didn't deliver anything like the stated "EP's" at any level, his experience was entirely satisfactory, and without incident. Some people, although not many apparently, just aren't at all invested in the abused/abuser mentality/game, at least in the context of their involvement in Scientology, and come through it unscathed. There's no doubt in my mind that it has to do with what the individual is generating at some level. As stated in quantum physics, "the observer affects the experiment". However, that being said, very few people have that experience, so I wouldn't use this as justification for walking into that snakepit.

Were these clients staffers?

I believe there is a fair amount of differences in the way that staff and public are treated.
 
Were these clients staffers?

I believe there is a fair amount of differences in the way that staff and public are treated.
As I said, one client was ex-SO and answered directly to Miscavige. And yes, without a doubt, in general, staff were far more vulnerable and subject to abuse.
 
Regarding Hubbard saying 'I like to catch the smart ones and reel them in' - I find it difficult to imagine who Hubbard would have said this to.
To my knowledge he was not honest with *anyone* regarding his true intentions, including even his own wife. The fact he preferred to keep his own wife and children *cult members* is quite extraordinary. If he did indeed say this, I would like to know more about what would have been a rare moment of honesty on his part.
 
TBH, I don't think Miscavige is really a Scientologist (in the spiritual sense).
He may be a fanatic about power and money and keeping those aspects of Hubbard's legacy going, but the person who has done more to undo the original "Bridge" (even though it's not really real), is certainly not a believer.
 
I've had an ex-SO client who answered directly to Miscavige for years and was never treated abusively, and I recall one client who did the full Scientology "bridge" and then went his own way without further involvement, and while recognizing it didn't deliver anything like the stated "EP's" at any level, his experience was entirely satisfactory, and without incident. Some people, although not many apparently, just aren't at all invested in the abused/abuser mentality/game, at least in the context of their involvement in Scientology, and come through it unscathed. There's no doubt in my mind that it has to do with what the individual is generating at some level. As stated in quantum physics, "the observer affects the experiment". However, that being said, very few people have that experience, so I wouldn't use this as justification for walking into that snakepit.

I went back to the 3 hour and 10 min Atack vid with Andy Nolch and gave up. The quote is either in the 2 hr one preceding or the one following it. I can't spend 4 hrs looking for the time marker at present.

Dex said
"Some people, although not many apparently, just aren't at all invested in the abused/abuser mentality/game, at least in the context of their involvement in Scientology, and come through it unscathed."

When it comes to how you were treated by higher Orgs, whether staff or public, it's a dice roll. You hope no one who was mad at you wrote any slander in the first page of your folder cover. I was unfortunate to have had affairs with 2 auditors who I then alienated. Interviewed by Frankie Freeman, Flag qual in 82, to get folders mailed to AOLA, I got his lowdown of what was placed inside my folder cover. OMG. This was done because he suspected a PTS sit with suspicious session comments.

In the FSSO, in the early 80s, it was safe to confess anything..... to have done drugs or been promiscuous or financially evil. Nobody made trouble for you as an FCCI. There were actors and musicians and recovered addicts and everyone was in a safe space to reveal anything. But, THEN, when I got my tech estimate saying to purchase 4 more intensives to even start my next program, I was in a different boat. I'd only one left. Up til that date, I'd been treated with kid gloves. I didn't really want to leave. Nicole Sims, registrar at AOLA said she could start me on my solo course immediately if I transferred the remaining funds and added a bit to it..

Huge mistake!. My world crashed like I was asking for a refund from the FSSO. I should have been alerted that it was not proper.....or something. I was no longer enjoying the 'sinners' protection I'd been privvy to, after that.

I got the written transfer papers from AOLA and gave it to Flag with my signature. I got a quick response from a very rude and NO ARC person. A young MAA, cold as ice. I backed down and said, I'd just get more money from my boyfriend. That young assertive MAA told me I could get auditing wherever I wanted to....but it would NOT be at Flag. Maybe the new 'kids' went through my folders and decided I was a DB under the new witch hunt rules. They were excavating for 'evil' that caused finances to crash all during that Spring

This crap where you are treated very well and suddenly are not treated very well depends on who's HAT is being used. You only had protection from the MAA kiddies if you got the loot in front of you. Then, the reg would slap em back down.

I was devastated. I didn't know if I was being kicked off the base because of a different eval or because I'd asked to transfer money out of the account. I'd been in the FSSO for 6 weeks straight and then another 3 on a consecutive trip. The Case Cracker Rundown ran very well. and I was not an NCG

So, no Dex, I think it's sometimes a crapshoot as to whether you find yourself in drama and stops while going up the bridge. You probably remember Chris Chrissinger. He got in trouble to saying the Happiness Rundown just used up his account when all he wanted was to do his OT levels. An upstate person at AOLA got into trouble because they balked at having the Sunshine RD added to their roster when they'd flown in from Germany on a budget. Some people are just adversarial, especially if driven by a leader like DM, looking for unclean spirits or counter intention under every rock.
 
Last edited:
A true professional historian meticulous records of their sources for the purpose of defending the accuracy of their claimed facts. A historian or who cannot cite their sources is incompetent and not to be trusted.

when do even professional historians, do that during a speech or video?

sure, i think someone like him should be well-sourced -- i asked if there have been situations where he could realistically be expected to be and hasn't, but you didn't answer that. what's his record with written material, where scholarly standards are most applicable? i couldn't lay my hands on my copy of A Piece of Blue Sky right off to see what it has in the way of footnotes, but i see online that it has has close to 20 pages of bibliography and reference summary.

and sorry, but aren't you complaining he doesn't document his claims -- but not providing documentation of that?
 
.
when do even professional historians, do that during a speech or video? i asked if there have been situations where he could realistically be expected to be and hasn't, but you didn't answer that. what's his record with written material, where scholarly standards are most applicable? i couldn't lay my hands on my copy of A Piece of Blue Sky right off to see what it has in the way of footnotes, but i see online that it has has close to 20 pages of bibliography and reference summary. and sorry, but aren't you complaining he doesn't document his claims -- but not providing documentation of that?

..
Oh no! Sneakster has been once again been busted for hypocritically complaining about lack of "scientific" or "scholarly" proof in others' statements.

He's also very worried about what academic "degrees" or "authority" people have that would allow them to criticize any of his personally cherished beliefs. The real punchline to this joke is that all of Sneakster's frenetic fanaticism about "facts" and "docs" is being done while he proudly promotes that he is a Scientologist--the 20th century's most debunked and disgraced "science", which was created by one of history's most notorious and prolific racketeers, con men, pseudo-scientific charlatans & pathological liars, L. Ron Hubbard.

Well, perhaps I am being too harshly judgmental and "besmirching the good name of L. Ron Hubbard" since he meets all of Sneakster's "professional" standards. After all, Dr. Hubbard is an acclaimed nuclear scientist with a doctoral degree and diploma from the prestigious Sequoia University! LOL


..
 
Last edited:
As I said, one client was ex-SO and answered directly to Miscavige.
I think the question was "was he SO at the time he was reporting to Miscavige? "

With bullies, a crucial evaluation they make is "how will this guy respond to my messing with him?"
 
.


..
Oh no! Sneakster has been once again been busted for hypocritically complaining about lack of "scientific" or "scholarly" proof in others' statements.

He's also very worried about what academic "degrees" or "authority" people have that would allow them to criticize any of his personally cherished beliefs. The real punchline to this joke is that all of Sneakster's frenetic fanaticism about "facts" and "docs" is being done while he proudly promotes that he is a Scientologist--the 20th century's most debunked and disgraced "science", which was created by one of history's most notorious and prolific racketeers, con men, pseudo-scientific charlatans & pathological liars, L. Ron Hubbard.

Well, perhaps I am being too harshly judgmental and "besmirching the good name of L. Ron Hubbard" since he meets all of Sneakster's "professional" standards. After all, Dr. Hubbard is an acclaimed nuclear scientist with a doctoral degree and diploma from the prestigious Sequoia University! LOL


..
Lol, have been waiting for you......
 
Back
Top