What is Rhetoric?

I will ban myself.

.

Promises, promises. . .

But you didn't keep your word (again). Looks like a condition of treason. Betrayal after trust.

PRO TIP: Riddick, per Ron's senior policy, be sure to: "Always deliver what you promise".


..
 
Last edited:
You've been asking the same question for years. If you really don't understand that no one wants to discuss rhetoric with you then there must be something wrong with you.

"If not, then I will stop posting" - you keep saying this but you don't stop posting, you just keep on saying the same things you've said over and over again. Have a look at other people's posts and you will find that they post about different subjects or they have different things to say about one particular subject. They don't continue to post the same thing over and over for year after year. Only you do that and that is why it is only you who is banned occasionally.

"You've been asking the same question for years. If you really don't understand that no one wants to discuss rhetoric with you then there must be something wrong with you."

That's totally fine no one wishes to discuss rhetoric. I happen to think Dianetics and Scientology are rhetoric. I don't think it is proper to claim there is something wrong with me. I could could also say there is something wrong with people because they don't think I believe.
 
You've been asking the same question for years. If you really don't understand that no one wants to discuss rhetoric with you then there must be something wrong with you.

"If not, then I will stop posting" - you keep saying this but you don't stop posting, you just keep on saying the same things you've said over and over again. Have a look at other people's posts and you will find that they post about different subjects or they have different things to say about one particular subject. They don't continue to post the same thing over and over for year after year. Only you do that and that is why it is only you who is banned occasionally.
""If not, then I will stop posting" - you keep saying this but you don't stop posting, you just keep on saying the same things you've said over and over again. Have a look at other people's posts and you will find that they post about different subjects or they have different things to say about one particular subject. They don't continue to post the same thing over and over for year after year. Only you do that and that is why it is only you who is banned occasionally. "

Well I changed my mind, LOL.

I will now continue to post what I feel is Hubbard's rhetoric, not mine, you guys.
 
Pineapple made this comment on another thread. It's a perfect example of Hubbard's rhetoric. Well at least pineapple saw it, many did not,.

"Actually I think it begins when you're told that you don't have to accept everything in scn, "just find the parts that work for you and apply those." So you develop the habit of putting the unacceptable things aside and not examining them too closely.

For example, I thought All About Radiation was nonsense when I first skimmed it, and I certainly knew LRH wasn't a nuclear physicist. But this was several years pre-Purif, so no one was making me take it seriously and I thought I could safely ignore it.

And there was a story in Have You Lived Before This Life that bothered me, where the pc was in a space battle and his spaceship was blown up. He ejected and fell through the atmosphere of a nearby planet into the ocean, where he was eaten by a fish. Now how come he didn't burn up when falling through the atmosphere at terrific speed? But again, it didn't seem important enough to get upset about ....

And when the Volunteer Minister's Handbook came out, oh man, that was so bad. It wouldn't have been as bad if someone else had taken those amateurish photographs, but it was LRH! And people were practically swooning over how wonderful it was ....

It finally got to the point where I had a whole mental closet full of stuff like this that I'd shoved out of sight, and it was so full of this crap that I couldn't close the door on it anymore. That was when I knew I had to split."
 
.
"If not, then I will stop posting" - you keep saying this but you don't stop posting, you just keep on saying the same things you've said over and over again.

Well I changed my mind, LOL.
I will now continue to post what I feel is Hubbard's rhetoric, not mine, you guys.

..

You've added yet more proof of your degenerate trolling.

(recent examples):

example #1. ​
-- Riddick trolls boards with many new threads on "rhetoric" as well as derailing other threads by trying to make all of them about "rhetoric"​
-- Finally after much uproar, Riddick agrees and promises board members he will stop derailing all threads with his "rhetoric" trolling as well as cease starting more new identical "rhetoric" threads. He agrees to keep all his repetitive posts about "rhetoric" on his thread with that name/ subject.​
-- A few days later Riddick continues trolling the board by both starting new threads about "rhetoric" and also derailing others' discussions on threads about other subjects.​
-- When called on his continued trolling and break of his agreement, Riddick's response is: "I CHANGED MY MIND, TOUGH SHIT!"​
​
example #2 (this week)​
-- Riddick just returned from his 2nd ban, immediately starts trolling again by starting yet another new thread about "rhetoric"​
-- As usual Riddick posts about "rhetoric" on other discussion threads (more trolling)​
-- When there is more uproar about his trolling, Riddick states that if nobody wants to discuss rhetoric with him "I WILL BAN MYSELF"​
-- As expected nobody responds or wants to discuss "rhetoric" with him. So does he ban himself? No, within some hours he is back on the board with more new posts about rhetoric.​
-- And, very predictably his response is to again break his agreement (to stop trolling) by stating: "WELL I CHANGED MY MIND, LOL". Note well his triumphant laughter; because it's very funny to a troll when he can sleaze and slime other board members with his trolling deception, gimmicks and nasty repartee.​
​
​
​
Hey Riddick, I think you are going to need to pack a much bigger suitcase for your next vacation because you might not be coming back again. Good luck in finding other people and places on the internet to troll.​


..
 
Last edited:
Hoaxer, how about we start a campaign to just not reply to any of Riddick's posts anymore period ? I mean he/she/it is not listening to anything we say, anyway.


Sounds good to me—as long as he remains under house arrest inside his "RHETORIC" thread. But, if he wanders onto other discussion threads and continues trolling the whole board, I can't guarantee what one of my BTs might do, lol.

Here's an interesting anecdote entitled: "I RECENTLY LOST A BET!"

A day ago Riddick guaranteed that if nobody wanted to discuss "rhetoric" with him--he would ban himself. Nobody wanted to, so his self-ban went into full effect. Thus it got very quiet for about 12 hours and it sure looked like he really banned himself.

However, during that period I exchanged a couple PMs with a friend of mine who also posts on ESMB. I messaged this:

"I give it even 50:50 odds that he unbans himself and continues "not trolling", LOL
​
The other much wiser board member replied:

"I believe the odds are even better than 50:50 that he will be back." :D
​
The bet's winner can of course out themselves if they choose, in which case in addition to basking in the glory they can make arrangements to pick up their engraved 9 foot high bowling trophy!

.
 
Last edited:
That's totally fine no one wishes to discuss rhetoric. I happen to think Dianetics and Scientology are rhetoric. I don't think it is proper to claim there is something wrong with me. I could could also say there is something wrong with people because they don't think I believe.

Yes, you could say that.

But when you're the only person on the planet who believes that Dianetics and Scientology are ONLY rhetoric, not a single ex-Scientologist or academic with an IQ over 50 has expressed agreement with you on this point in the many years you've been writing it, and when you just ignore those who challenge your opinion because you're unable to respond with a logical argument, do you think maybe you should consider the possibility of altering your opinion about this matter? :whistle:

You wrote:
"That's totally fine no one wishes to discuss rhetoric."

You've demonstrated on multiple occasions that it is YOU who is unwilling to discuss rhetoric unless those who post in your thread are 100% in agreement with your opinion. If they are not you will either ignore them or insult them, You're not looking for a discussion. You're looking for agreement.

The claim that Scientology is ONLY rhetoric is complete unadulterated bullshit. By continuing to post that on a public message board, and passing along that misinformation to others you're doing a disservice to readers.
 
.

..
Where do I pick up my trophy? :unsure:
.
.

LOL!

Congratulations on winning the 2023 ESMB NOSTRADAMUS PROPHECY AWARD for most accurately predicting the odds on whether Riddick's fake self-ban would be reversed by him and he would return to standard trolling again.

Here it is! She's a beauty, ain't she?!


America_s_cup.jpg
​

Obviously, since this is a very advanced level trophy, we have to keep it in an extremely safe and confidential underground location until you have completed all the routing form steps and signed the legal documents so that you are are up to speed on all necessary compliances*.


​


* Your exquisite and super-shiny 9 foot high trophy is 100% absolutely free! However, before it can be released for pickup you must first evidence proof that you have purchased a 2nd "backup trophy" (for only $9,999), which it vital for you to have in case something happens to your first.


..
 
Last edited:
Hoaxer, how about we start a campaign to just not reply to any of Riddick's posts anymore period ? I mean he/she/it is not listening to anything we say, anyway.
Well thank you. That's a smart idea because all you folks do is troll my thread. I suppose you didn't see that before but now you do.
 
Hoaxer, how about we start a campaign to just not reply to any of Riddick's posts anymore period ? I mean he/she/it is not listening to anything we say, anyway.
Consider this, are you and others trolls on my thread of what is rhetoric:

An internet troll is someone who makes intentionally inflammatory, rude, or upsetting statements online to elicit strong emotional responses in people or to steer the conversation off-topic. They can come in many forms. Most trolls do this for their own amusement, but other forms of trolling are done to push a specific agenda. Trolls have existed in folklore and fantasy literature for centuries, but online trolling has been around for as long as the internet has existed.

Believe me, I know you and or others will now make comments regarding me instead of the topic of this thread.
 
I like this new post by I M Dex. It's about KSW. KSW was Hubbard's greatest rhetoric to persuade. When I was first involved, I just wanted to go clear thru Dianetics auditing, dianetics had nothing to do with a religion for which I was basically a atheist. I somehow got persuaded to read Hubbards books on The Problems of Work, A New Slant on Life, etc. And then I read KSW on my own, not on course, and I thought it was wonderful. Little did I know at the time, I was entering into a religion which I never wanted to be a part of. Later on I read it was what Hubbard called the ridge onto the bridge, that meaning the barrier to get someone to convert to scientology from dianetics, or the next step up the bridge to total freedom, or convert to scientology.

Back in the day when Jefferson Hawkins made the dianetics campaign on TV, the whole network of dianetics and scientology began again. That's when I got involved.

Anyways, this whole org board, Marketing and PR series in the OEC's, FEBC's, green and red volumes, are basically one big loop to persuade using rhetoric, to persuade one to BE a scientologist.

Thank god I am no longer one of those.
 
When you truly decide to disengage from something, you simply withdraw. You don't make a show of "this is what I'm doing because you are undeserving of engaging with", or "I give up on trying to reason with you, it can't be done"; that is merely a continuation of engaging. To make a declaration of "I will disengage from you" is a form of engaging. Both sides are employing declarations of "I will disengage from you" here, rather than withdrawing. I guess both sides continue to find value in this silliness. OK.
 
Probably, now that I think about it, the most influencer persons that got me out of dianetics and scientology. First in order was the debbie cook email sent to many member's. I never got it, my OT wife did, she actually forwarded it to me and asked me what do I think. I said I think she debbie cook is 100% right. And actually during the time of that email, I started to research the internet. And I did a lot of research during the time.

I think the second or third most persuasive research was listening to the Truth Rundown series and also the Jason Beghe interview by Mark Bunker.

I did a lot more research after those.

Say hey, no clears or OT's. Just a bunch of rhetoric to think one can go clear or OT.
 
Back
Top