Dissecting Scientology: "Keeping Scientology Working"

I M Dex

Well-known member
From time to time, a friend or client, after listening to me share my observations and knowledge about the world and history of Scientology, has said "you should write a book", and for whatever reason, the last time I heard that, I felt like, "hey, actually, I should do that!". That was about 6 months ago, and I started making a list of subjects to write about, and began to write separate articles on each topic that seems relevant and worthwhile. I have no clear idea when I'll feel like I've covered everything I feel I should cover satisfactorily, but here's a piece of it, subject to further writing and editing. I'll share more if the interest seems to be there:

“Keeping Scientology Working”-Hubbard’s manifesto.

Every Scientologist must study and re-study “KSW” again and again, as the very first section of every Scientology course. The message hammered home from every conceivable angle is “I am the one and only source of the only workable means of making people rational, happy and well, nobody but me is capable of this, and anyone who does anything other than exactly as I instruct will ruin everything and we will all suffer for it”.

Hubbard was in a rage when he wrote this diatribe. It’s obvious enough from his tone throughout this manifesto, but besides that, a friend who was around Hubbard at that time confirmed this for me. Actually, rage came quite readily for him at least as far back as the early 1950’s. When he wrote “Keeping Scientology Working” in 1965, there was more than one thing triggering the episode that played out in “KSW”.

Firstly, there was the interview with Hubbard that was recently published in the national magazine, the Saturday Evening Post. Hubbard was certain he was charming and captivating the interviewer with his hyperbole about Scientology, only to have it result in an article that ridiculed him. And secondly, Hubbard’s increasingly heavy-handed authoritarian attitude toward all, including all of his crew that was busily contributing principles and techniques to his system, offended and disturbed many, who left the fold to form their own practices or follow those who did.

And so Hubbard sought to secure his following with this hamfisted take-no-prisoners declaration. Objectively, assertions such as “a woman died of cancer as a result of a beating” (because-get this- the man beat her as a result of getting Scientology auditing that didn’t correctly follow Hubbard’s instructions) are laughably absurd, but the Scientologist glosses over this in reading “KSW” because, very clearly, disagreement is not to be tolerated. Thus the key cult indoctrination step of inducing the programming of the individual’s self-suppression is established. And then going forward through each and every subsequent Scientology training step, the repeated force-feeding of KSW sets the follower up to be wide open to that next batch of Scientology dogma.
Hubbard goes on to insist that Scientology’s progress soars when his “technology” (“the tech”) is followed precisely and it all goes into a tailspin if not.

Interestingly, it was confided in me by a former Scientology “Sea Org” staff member that his unit did a survey that showed that when strict compliance with “KSW” was enforced on an organization, the statistics actually crashed.

Ever wonder why “KSW” was stretched out to fit exactly 10 points (“Having the technology, Knowing the technology, Knowing that it is correct, etc)? All simply being 10 ways of saying “thou shall take no other God than me”? (And let’s not forget, he also states in “KSW”, “We will not speculate here on how I came to rise above the bank”) Hubbard was seeking to create a subliminal connection to the Ten Commandments. It only becomes easier to connect those dots when you read in Nancy Many’s book, “My Billion Year Contract: Memoir of a Former Scientologist” how, later, around 1976, Hubbard ordered that a survey to be done to see if he could be successfully promoted as the new messiah. Or if you noticed his Hymn of Asia, wherein he implied that he was the next incarnation of Buddha.
 
Are you even a scientologist if you haven't M9ed KSW a few times? KSW is the most important reference in creating the hardcore scientology fanatics you hear about. It's a brilliant reference and a key part of programming scientologists, it's also something that cripples scientology by making it inflexible to a large degree.
 
Are you even a scientologist if you haven't M9ed KSW a few times? KSW is the most important reference in creating the hardcore scientology fanatics you hear about. It's a brilliant reference and a key part of programming scientologists, it's also something that cripples scientology by making it inflexible to a large degree.
Number of times over equals brainwashing.
 
Being that many of my clients have background in Scientology, I've been struck by how so much of the attitudes and ways of thinking about things remains insidiously ingrained. I wonder if any of us who have moved away are as out of the thought bubble as we might think we are. Such as in the attitudes about politics, i.e., "those who think differently just don't have a clue".
 
Being that many of my clients have background in Scientology, I've been struck by how so much of the attitudes and ways of thinking about things remains insidiously ingrained. I wonder if any of us who have moved away are as out of the thought bubble as we might think we are. Such as in the attitudes about politics, i.e., "those who think differently just don't have a clue".


When one has deeply ingrained beliefs on any subject it can negatively impact ones ability to objectively consider ideas that don't align with those preexisting beliefs. That weakness seems to be unfortunately hardwired into most if not all humans.

One of the best ways to guard against that is to test one's own beliefs while adopting the mindset of a scientist and adjusting them accordingly. I'll copy/paste excerpts of something I posted in a different thread to illustrate what I'm talking about:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

When I first got involved in Scientology I was looking through the Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health book and there was an appendix in that edition that was entitled "The Scientific Method" which was authored by John W. Campbell. Besides being a science-fiction writer, Campbell did actually have an education in science, attending MIT for some time and getting a B.S. degree in physics at Duke University. And this appendix included in the Dianetics book was very good. It's more than a bit ironic that it was included in the Dianetics book whose author was allergic to the scientific method.

There was a part of this appendix I loved though. IMO, it really describes the mindset of what a scientist should have and would be helpful for any critical thinker to adopt that same mindset. I'll excerpt a few sentences of it below. Unfortunately, science isn't always done that way these days, especially when those funding it don't have that same mindset. Instead, they have a desired outcome in mind that aligns with their preexisting beliefs or will somehow benefit their cause.

Excerpt from The Scientific Method by John W. Campbell (appendix in earlier edition of Dianetics book).

"...the Scientific Method implies zestfully, gleefully attacking, with every available weapon of logic, every possible logical loophole in - your own structure of logic and theory. It requires that a man tear into his carefully built theory with the vim, vigor and spite of his worst enemy. It implies that a scientist's best friend will review his work starting with the premise that it's all wrong and do his best to prove it's wrong."
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

^^^^^^ One doesn't need to be a scientist to adopt this mindset. Many beliefs that people have were adopted prior to turning age 7 before one possesses much in the way of critical thinking ability. Other beliefs may have come via indoctrination in public schools or via disinformation from media outlets. To test those beliefs by utilizing this type of mindset can have a hugely beneficial impact on one's life.
 
I personally try to maintain the idea that everything I think or believe is subject to change, to be superseded by views, ideas or attitudes that allow for better understandings and views. Adding the qualifier, "as it appears for now" to any conclusion, idea or view. It's been very helpful for me. I think that the need to have things solidly defined or categorized, to have a "stable datum" is driven by an anxiety about being vulnerable if you are simply present, and letting every moment be fresh, new, strange and unique, as it is without projecting some kind of framework from which to view everything.
 
It's a brilliant reference and a key part of programming scientologists, it's also something that cripples scientology by making it inflexible to a large degree.

as awful as it seems, i think it may actually be one of the things that has helped scientology stagger on as long as it has, when most of its peer groups were down for the count decades ago. if not made inflexible, it could have been likely to just fall apart rapidly (see next).

also, to me it seems that with its reference to having 'once had the idea that a group could evolve truth' marks the end of an era where he had collaborators and co-authors who were peers -- often rather capable, experienced, mature and educated -- and the ultimate handing over of the reins to a group of young and uneducated sycophants. and i think that had as much to do with his inability to work well with others, as his lack of proper methodology that left the 'subject' more like trying to nail jello to a wall and unable to work except under authoritarian control.
 
as awful as it seems, i think it may actually be one of the things that has helped scientology stagger on as long as it has, when most of its peer groups were down for the count decades ago. if not made inflexible, it could have been likely to just fall apart rapidly (see next).

also, to me it seems that with its reference to having 'once had the idea that a group could evolve truth' marks the end of an era where he had collaborators and co-authors who were peers -- often rather capable, experienced, mature and educated -- and the ultimate handing over of the reins to a group of young and uneducated sycophants. and i think that had as much to do with his inability to work well with others, as his lack of proper methodology that left the 'subject' more like trying to nail jello to a wall and unable to work except under authoritarian control.

Yeah, it probably has kept Scientology from completely dying out. I also think it does a lot to promote the authoritarian control Scientology loves so much. One of the key concepts of KSW is that groups bad, strong individual good. When individual listens to groups things go bad, groups are aberrated, the only hope for mankind is individual. Of course there are plenty of other references that also promote this ideology but KSW is the most important reference in Scientology, by a pretty wide margin.
 
I personally try to maintain the idea that everything I think or believe is subject to change, to be superseded by views, ideas or attitudes that allow for better understandings and views. Adding the qualifier, "as it appears for now" to any conclusion, idea or view. It's been very helpful for me. I think that the need to have things solidly defined or categorized, to have a "stable datum" is driven by an anxiety about being vulnerable if you are simply present, and letting every moment be fresh, new, strange and unique, as it is without projecting some kind of framework from which to view everything.
Sometimes, I get the feeling that Hubbard treated us new Scientologists like we were all on a bad acid trip. The idea of the "Stable Datum", for example was his way of "talking us down" from the trip, Either way, it gives me the feeling that he had a lot of contempt for Scientologists in general. Not that it would be a big surprise to me. :roflmao:
 
I don't think I took KSW all that seriously. I read over it and just kept on studying and auditing. My general idea and acceptance was that if a bunch of people were running their own versions of auditing sessions there would be no uniformity and no way for the Case Supervisor to know what happened in a session. If I muffed a session I welcomed a cramming order so I could get things straight.
 
....
..


Are you even a scientologist if you haven't M9ed KSW a few times? KSW is the most important reference in creating the hardcore scientology fanatics you hear about. It's a brilliant reference and a key part of programming scientologists, it's also something that cripples scientology by making it inflexible to a large degree.



Unfortunately, the original point of Dianetics and the 10 points of KEEPING SCIENTOLOGY WORKING was designed to "salvage this sector" (i.e. Hubbard's overdraft bank account)—instead of salvaging Scientologists.

It would have taken so little effort to correct that minor flaw.

Getting the correct technology applied consists of:​
​
One: Having the correct technology.​
​
Two: Knowing the technology.​
​
Three: Knowing it is correct.​
​
Four: Teaching correctly the correct technology.​
​
Five: Applying the technology.​
​
Six: Seeing that the technology is correctly applied.​
​
Seven: Hammering out of existence incorrect technology.​
​
Eight: Knocking out incorrect applications.​
​
Nine: Closing the door on any possibility of incorrect technology.​
​
Ten: Closing the door on incorrect application.​
​
Eleven: Closing the org when no paying customers attained Clear or OT. ​
​

SELECT.png
​
​
"These KSW points go up to 11."​
—Don Hubbard​
​
..​

​
​
 
Last edited:
Sometimes, I get the feeling that Hubbard treated us new Scientologists like we were all on a bad acid trip. The idea of the "Stable Datum", for example was his way of "talking us down" from the trip, Either way, it gives me the feeling that he had a lot of contempt for Scientologists in general. Not that it would be a big surprise to me. :roflmao:
Hubbard created the confusion, then threw out a stable datum which we eagerly accepted like a drowning man reaching for a life preserver.

"The Confusion Technique" by Milton Erickson

For want of a better term, one of these special procedures may be termed the "confusion technique." It has been employed extensively for the induction of specific phenomena as well as deep trances. Usually, it is best employed with highly intelligent subjects interested in the hypnotic process, or with those consciously unwilling to go into a trance despite an unconscious willingness.

In essence, it is no more than a presentation of a whole series of individually differing, contradictory suggestions, apparently all at variance with each other, differently directed, and requiring a constant shift in orientation by the subject.

 
"The Confusion Technique" by Milton Erickson

thanks for that. i discovered that at one point early on LRH set up shop in Phoenix basically just a few blocks away from where Erickson was working, so while the founder was obviously already an accomplished hypnotist, it may be no accident that at some point he picked up on more advanced and subtle manipulative techniques -- a source Keith Raniere and his NXIVM cult also had (through NLP). 'source' seems to me to have picked up a lot of stuff from the social circles he ran in, and what others in them had dabbled in or learned; so it seems likely to me that in Phoenix there must have been people working with or learning from Erickson, who also crossed paths with LRH and provided him with at least some ideas and techniques -- which of course he would always claims as his own without giving credit or citing the real source.

there's an interview with Ava Berner who along with her husband Charles was the source of several things like 'study tech' (originally intended just to help students with LRH's confusing use of neologisms they didn't understand) and 'clay demos', who says that when they were around during the Saint Hill period, it was a fertile environment with others like them who provided everything to him.
 
Hubbard created the confusion, then threw out a stable datum which we eagerly accepted like a drowning man reaching for a life preserver.

"The Confusion Technique" by Milton Erickson

For want of a better term, one of these special procedures may be termed the "confusion technique." It has been employed extensively for the induction of specific phenomena as well as deep trances. Usually, it is best employed with highly intelligent subjects interested in the hypnotic process, or with those consciously unwilling to go into a trance despite an unconscious willingness.

In essence, it is no more than a presentation of a whole series of individually differing, contradictory suggestions, apparently all at variance with each other, differently directed, and requiring a constant shift in orientation by the subject.

I never saw this data before. Thank you. I wonder what else you know that I need to know lol!!

This could explain quite a bit of my own unexplained observations of my time while in (27 years) and confusions of my own and others. While posted as supervisor, the confusions coming from students which were supposed to be handled by study tech+ (more than just the basic three barrier stuff) were quite common in many intelligent people. And since our illustrious leader had bragged about "his discoveries" of study tech now affecting how he delivered data to his followers, these actions did not alleviate the confusions that he generated from so many sources. I had many old time "experts" explain away such tech inconsistencies as "dicey tech points."

I had suspected near the end of my scn life that there was something to know about this subject. I tripped over a datum or two in some of the books and materials I read after being out.
 
While posted as supervisor, the confusions coming from students which were supposed to be handled by study tech+ (more than just the basic three barrier stuff) were quite common in many intelligent people.

for starters i realize that i should have pointed out in my last comment that LRH in typical narcissistic scapegoating fashion, took 'study tech' which was originally intended to try to solve his bad habit of confusing students with made-up terms he hadn't adequately explained or defined, and turned it into a technique in which the student is always blamed for any confusion.

he made some fairly clear references to the fundamental principles involved in confusion technique at a couple of points, though it's possible it's one of those things that he figured out in parallel with others like Erickson trying to do more with basic hypnosis.


this is some of MB's commentary inspired by that article:

 
From time to time, a friend or client, after listening to me share my observations and knowledge about the world and history of Scientology, has said "you should write a book", and for whatever reason, the last time I heard that, I felt like, "hey, actually, I should do that!". That was about 6 months ago, and I started making a list of subjects to write about, and began to write separate articles on each topic that seems relevant and worthwhile. I have no clear idea when I'll feel like I've covered everything I feel I should cover satisfactorily, but here's a piece of it, subject to further writing and editing. I'll share more if the interest seems to be there:

“Keeping Scientology Working”-Hubbard’s manifesto.

Every Scientologist must study and re-study “KSW” again and again, as the very first section of every Scientology course. The message hammered home from every conceivable angle is “I am the one and only source of the only workable means of making people rational, happy and well, nobody but me is capable of this, and anyone who does anything other than exactly as I instruct will ruin everything and we will all suffer for it”.

Hubbard was in a rage when he wrote this diatribe. It’s obvious enough from his tone throughout this manifesto, but besides that, a friend who was around Hubbard at that time confirmed this for me. Actually, rage came quite readily for him at least as far back as the early 1950’s. When he wrote “Keeping Scientology Working” in 1965, there was more than one thing triggering the episode that played out in “KSW”.

Firstly, there was the interview with Hubbard that was recently published in the national magazine, the Saturday Evening Post. Hubbard was certain he was charming and captivating the interviewer with his hyperbole about Scientology, only to have it result in an article that ridiculed him. And secondly, Hubbard’s increasingly heavy-handed authoritarian attitude toward all, including all of his crew that was busily contributing principles and techniques to his system, offended and disturbed many, who left the fold to form their own practices or follow those who did.

And so Hubbard sought to secure his following with this hamfisted take-no-prisoners declaration. Objectively, assertions such as “a woman died of cancer as a result of a beating” (because-get this- the man beat her as a result of getting Scientology auditing that didn’t correctly follow Hubbard’s instructions) are laughably absurd, but the Scientologist glosses over this in reading “KSW” because, very clearly, disagreement is not to be tolerated. Thus the key cult indoctrination step of inducing the programming of the individual’s self-suppression is established. And then going forward through each and every subsequent Scientology training step, the repeated force-feeding of KSW sets the follower up to be wide open to that next batch of Scientology dogma.
Hubbard goes on to insist that Scientology’s progress soars when his “technology” (“the tech”) is followed precisely and it all goes into a tailspin if not.

Interestingly, it was confided in me by a former Scientology “Sea Org” staff member that his unit did a survey that showed that when strict compliance with “KSW” was enforced on an organization, the statistics actually crashed.

Ever wonder why “KSW” was stretched out to fit exactly 10 points (“Having the technology, Knowing the technology, Knowing that it is correct, etc)? All simply being 10 ways of saying “thou shall take no other God than me”? (And let’s not forget, he also states in “KSW”, “We will not speculate here on how I came to rise above the bank”) Hubbard was seeking to create a subliminal connection to the Ten Commandments. It only becomes easier to connect those dots when you read in Nancy Many’s book, “My Billion Year Contract: Memoir of a Former Scientologist” how, later, around 1976, Hubbard ordered that a survey to be done to see if he could be successfully promoted as the new messiah. Or if you noticed his Hymn of Asia, wherein he implied that he was the next incarnation of Buddha.


It's KFC, really good chicken
 
Back
Top