Aaron Smith Levin on the Collapse of SCN in California

i think you may be missing some transcription or punctuation/capitalization error, like the difference beween '20 million members' and '68,000 IAS Members'

i could see it being sort of like in a totalitarian country, where say everyone is a communist, but there are only a limited number of Communist Party Members....
Except that you will not be allowed to go on org services unless you are an IAS member.

So they may count everyone who has ever bought a Dianetics book as "a Scientologist", but that does not mean there's enough people to keep org doors open.
 
When they promote that they have millions of members I agree it makes little difference whether the real number is 15K or 30K.

There are IMO multiple reasons why they lie about this. They want their own members to believe that Scientology is not a tiny cult, but rather has a significant presence worldwide. And just as important if not more so, when OSA interacts with governments they want the government representatives to believe that OSA is representing an organization of millions as it will impact how governments deal with the CoS.

The same ploy is utilized for "people of color" and "LGBQTIA". It gives the appearance that there's more and is a shade of the "appeal to majority" logical fallacy.

The larger number somehow grants credence to the idiocy.

Argumentum ad populum - commonly referred to as the bandwagon fallacy.
 
Why in the 1990s the COS was promoting that they had both "over 10M members" and also "68,000" members?

EXPLANATION: Because Scientology is the game where everyone wins! In fact it's the "only game in the universe where everyone wins!" Therefore, in adherence to the "Hubbard Law of Commotion":

- - If there are over 10M Scientologists that is a hugely epic win!​
​
- - If there are really only 68,000 Scientologists that is also a hugely epic win, because the cult's​
enemies were successfully prevented from discovering this strategically super-secret data!​

This Hubbardian gimmick of telling two diametrically opposite versions of the same story is manifest in anything and everything that Scientologists call an "R" factor. R for reality? No. R for ridiculous. Just for fun let's cite another one of those preposterous"always winning" assertions:

- - If Scientology's lines are completely free of entheta, lawsuits, criminal prosecutions, protests and widescale media uproar, it means that the tech is working beautifully!​
​
- - If Scientology's lines are completely overwhelmed with entheta, lawsuits, criminal prosecutions, protests and widescale media uproar, that also means that the tech is working beautifully! ​

Because (Hubbard assures): "...people only attack us when we are flourishing and prospering and our tech is working!"

PRO TIP FOR SCIENTOLOGY: You should seriously consider changing your motto from "We Come Back" to "WINNUS PERPETUALIS!" Always winning!*

..

*Hey, Ron's not really dead, it's just that he is so OT he had to kill his body which is such an amazing epic win!

..


BRAVO! The Hubbard Law of Commotion!!

Remember this?

The only thing you can be upbraided for by students or pcs is “no results”. Trouble spots occur only where there are “no results”. Attacks from governments or monopolies occur only where there are “no results” or “bad results”.​

How, then, can there be attacks because Scientology is winning? The only way I could make sense out of the "Ron says/Ron does" labyrinth was...I guess...Scientology was super duper effective and had the SPs on the run so bad that they had to gnash their teeth and attack...but that attack would only come where Scientology WAS NOT super duper effective...I guess...
 
I bought an IAS yearly membership for our first baby back in the 90's.

Then money was tight, didn't renew the kid's membership, and got a VERY nasty letter from IAS addressed to the kid over the non-renewal.

I bought a lifetime one onetime that was promoted and sold as the last IAS membership you would ever need.

I think that lasted like a year or something.

:giggle: :evillaugh: :LOL:


Sort of like the 2nd "new and improved" R&D set. They were supposed to come out every 6 months or so and roll forward and you subscribed for something like $75/volume and they did the original set and then...it just went "poof" and stopped. No one at Bridge knew anything about it.

Gone like Ron.

Now, some might suspect that that's a hat dump or a blow or doing a bunk or something but my guess is that it's a demonstration of such a magnitude of ethics and morality and sanity that us poor DBs can't duplicate it.

Always deliver what you promise.
 
Last edited:
2 of the biggest donors to Orange County "IDEAL" Org~~

Ned McCrink $1 million (suicide a few years later)

and more info on this thread

Luis Garcia $1 million
who was also conned for $40,000 for the CROSS above the Super Power Building (along with 40 others each one led to believe that the CROSS was from their donation.
 
2 of the biggest donors to Orange County "IDEAL" Org~~

Ned McCrink $1 million (suicide a few years later)

and more info on this thread

Luis Garcia $1 million who was also conned for $40,000 for the CROSS above the Super Power Building (along with 40 others each one led to believe that the CROSS was from their donation.


What a cosmic comedy.

Scientology - where the marks celebrate their own gullibility and try to outdo one another in terms of being defrauded.
 
..
BRAVO! The Hubbard Law of Commotion!! Remember this?

The only thing you can be upbraided for by students or pcs is “no results”. Trouble spots occur only where there are “no results”. Attacks from governments or monopolies occur only where there are “no results” or “bad results”.​

..
Exactly!

Ron stated (not merely said) that:

"The only thing you can be upbraided for by students or pcs is 'no results'."
​
Thus, Scientology can only be attacked when it doesn't work.

Yet, when there are attacks, Ron affirms that it only means that the tech is working so incredibly well that the SPs are "howling" because they can see that it works and they fear it is freeing mankind.


CONCLUSION: Ergo, when people criticize Scientology it's because the tech FAILED TO WORK and at the same time DID WORK!

It doesn't have to make sense, it's Scientology.

...
 
Sort of like the 2nd "new and improved" R&D set. They were supposed to come out every 6 months or so and roll forward and you subscribed for something like $75/volume and they did the original set and then...it just went "poof" and stopped. No one at Bridge knew anything about it.

Gone like Ron.

Now, some might suspect that that's a hat dump or a blow or doing a bunk or something but my guess is that it's a demonstration of such a magnitude of ethics and morality and sanity that us poor DBs can't duplicate it.

i see a lot of stuff that seems to just be due to organizational dysfunction -- like the buildings sitting rotting and racking up tax bills, while the orgs that that bought them are stuck paying rent for other space. though ultimately i think that dysfunction has some root in ruthless disregard for others, such as how international management has no concern about things like financial burdens and wastes imposed on local orgs and their members.
 
i see a lot of stuff that seems to just be due to organizational dysfunction -- like the buildings sitting rotting and racking up tax bills, while the orgs that that bought them are stuck paying rent for other space. though ultimately i think that dysfunction has some root in ruthless disregard for others, such as how international management has no concern about things like financial burdens and wastes imposed on local orgs and their members.

You're right, management doesn't care at all about the burdens they place on others. I think this is one of the reasons they are so inefficient. They can just push things off on local orgs, and they don't have to worry about labor laws. While this does allow them to exist and operate the way they do, I think this has also hurt them in the long run. There is zero importance placed on operating efficiently. Why would they worry about it? It's someone else's money and someone else's time.

I'm not sure they could exist at all if they had to start caring about those things, but maybe they could. DM seems to make a habit of lighting money on fire. If that money were funneled back into the organization maybe scientology becomes somewhat viable. Just speaking from a numbers perspective, nothing changes as far as the lack of OT powers, etc. They'd still fail long term, but who knows how long they could hang on.
 
DM seems to make a habit of lighting money on fire.
When I was on staff, there would be enormous push to get a stat before 2pm on Thursday, even if it would fall into your lap without effort on Friday.

I chose not to play that game. If my stats looked like they would be normal for the week, I would see about pushing things to count in the following week, so.i would start the week off well.
 
I'm not sure they could exist at all if they had to start caring about those things, but maybe they could.

if they started caring about things like that, they'd pay employees at least minimum wage and some benefits -- and at least health care and retirement for the sea org. but i once did the math about what that would cost, and it looks to be around $100 million a year. outlays like that would have prevented DM from building up reserves of a couple of billion, over the last couple of decades -- which i think now must be providing the money being doled out to keep the lights and heat on, and the doors open, at the majority of orgs if the report about WUS (which should be their best off region) is correct and applies elsewhere.

so if they had to, it looks to me like they'd have had to have closed half or more of their orgs by now. and that could have destroyed members' confidence in management and the myth of 'expansion' and triggered near complete collapse....

on the other hand i think that points to how DM's ruthless approach has kept things going to the extent it has.
 
if they started caring about things like that, they'd pay employees at least minimum wage and some benefits -- and at least health care and retirement for the sea org. but i once did the math about what that would cost, and it looks to be around $100 million a year. outlays like that would have prevented DM from building up reserves of a couple of billion, over the last couple of decades -- which i think now must be providing the money being doled out to keep the lights and heat on, and the doors open, at the majority of orgs if the report about WUS (which should be their best off region) is correct and applies elsewhere.

so if they had to, it looks to me like they'd have had to have closed half or more of their orgs by now. and that could have destroyed members' confidence in management and the myth of 'expansion' and triggered near complete collapse....

on the other hand i think that points to how DM's ruthless approach has kept things going to the extent it has.

Right, if they continued operating the way they are it would collapse almost instantly. I'm saying if they started doing that stuff, and wanted to survive, they would have to change the whole way the operate, give some thought to operating efficiently, etc. The SO is ridiculously bloated and inefficient, if they streamlined things and eliminated useless posts maybe they could make it work. At least fir a little bit longer.
 
Right, if they continued operating the way they are it would collapse almost instantly. I'm saying if they started doing that stuff, and wanted to survive, they would have to change the whole way the operate, give some thought to operating efficiently, etc. The SO is ridiculously bloated and inefficient, if they streamlined things and eliminated useless posts maybe they could make it work. At least fir a little bit longer.

sure -- but that would require a real sea change in how they operate. and wouldn't that essentially mean throwing a lot of LRH policy out the window?

among other things if they wanted to be more efficient and lower unnecessary costs, they'd have to turn around and sell off most of the 'ideal' buildings, and move the local orgs back into ones more the size of what they started off with -- though if the orgs then had a surplus of cash but then also owned a smaller building they didn't have to pay rent on, they'd be in better shape for at least a while....
 
sure -- but that would require a real sea change in how they operate. and wouldn't that essentially mean throwing a lot of LRH policy out the window?

among other things if they wanted to be more efficient and lower unnecessary costs, they'd have to turn around and sell off most of the 'ideal' buildings, and move the local orgs back into ones more the size of what they started off with -- though if the orgs then had a surplus of cash but then also owned a smaller building they didn't have to pay rent on, they'd be in better shape for at least a while....

Yeah, it wouldn't be Scientology anymore so it would never happen. It's just interesting to think what would Scientology look like if they followed laws, labor regulations, etc. What if IAS funds went to pay SO/org staff instead of lawyers/PIs.
 
When I was on staff, there would be enormous push to get a stat before 2pm on Thursday, even if it would fall into your lap without effort on Friday.

I chose not to play that game. If my stats looked like they would be normal for the week, I would see about pushing things to count in the following week, so.i would start the week off well.
You won't be surprised to hear that the 2pm Thursday deadline gets ignored now, or at least it did up until 2016 during the last time I was on staff. "It's not 2pm in CA yet!" was the battle cry many times. I saw GI still coming in several hours later that was reported as being in the week ended at 2pm.
 
Yeah, it wouldn't be Scientology anymore so it would never happen. It's just interesting to think what would Scientology look like if they followed laws, labor regulations, etc. What if IAS funds went to pay SO/org staff instead of lawyers/PIs.
If orgs had to pay market salaries and benefits, every org would be insolvent.

Except maybe Flag, and they would fold once they ran out of whale money.
 
You won't be surprised to hear that the 2pm Thursday deadline gets ignored now, or at least it did up until 2016 during the last time I was on staff. "It's not 2pm in CA yet!" was the battle cry many times. I saw GI still coming in several hours later that was reported as being in the week ended at 2pm.

No wonder your org crashed so quickly... Look at this out-ethics behavior. (all orgs lie about the 2pm deadline, they continually fudge when things happened)
 
sure -- but that would require a real sea change in how they operate. and wouldn't that essentially mean throwing a lot of LRH policy out the window?

among other things if they wanted to be more efficient and lower unnecessary costs, they'd have to turn around and sell off most of the 'ideal' buildings, and move the local orgs back into ones more the size of what they started off with -- though if the orgs then had a surplus of cash but then also owned a smaller building they didn't have to pay rent on, they'd be in better shape for at least a while....
They were doing better when there was a bunch of field auditors floating around.

The field auditors would work out of their homes, and have day jobs. Whatever they would get from auditing PC's (mostly friends of friends) was just extra cash, so they could keep going forever.

In a Darwinian process, the ones who produced happy PCs flourished, and the ones who didn't stopped trying after a while.

A lot of missions ran out of somebody's house or daytime business, so they would have staying power too.
 
They were doing better when there was a bunch of field auditors floating around.

The field auditors would work out of their homes, and have day jobs. Whatever they would get from auditing PC's (mostly friends of friends) was just extra cash, so they could keep going forever.

In a Darwinian process, the ones who produced happy PCs flourished, and the ones who didn't stopped trying after a while.

A lot of missions ran out of somebody's house or daytime business, so they would have staying power too.
All that has been destroyed. The madman that was hubbard had a plan. It seems that the madman that is miscavige has a different plan.
 
A bunch of scn'ists have left Atlanta as well over the past few years. Really, it's a large percentage if you consider now how few are left
It would be an accelerating trend.

Scientologists need other Scientologists to hang out with. You can hang out with non-Scn if you conceal and never talk about your Scn connection, but it is wearing after a while.

As the local community shrinks (old people die, become disaffected, or declared) , people want to go where there's others like them. Right now, there's only two viable communities left: LA and Clearwater.
 
Back
Top